Good point Ian. Recall when Matheson's first feeble excuse when he said he was involved in constituency work from Morocco, but nothing was ever provided as proof. All B-S
Swinney ranting on about Gray's engagements as though Neil Gravy Train was doing extra curriculum, it's his job and he is paid well for it. SNP think they are Kings and Queens.
@@vtechead1 Oh dear, In 2010/2011 financial year the cost of UK Government Ministerial Car Service was nearly £4m. That is nearly 3x more the cost 13 Years Ago than your figures for Scottish Government for 2021. I won't let the UK Government further embarrass you with their figure for 2021.
@@ScottishRoss27 not much difference between a population of 5 million that could fit into London with 3 million spare, and a population of 55 million. You really need to stop embarrassing yourself by diverting. SNP is the subject 👍
I have a friend in the civil service in Edinburgh. She informed me that her notes and paperwork for her meetings, is chauffeur driven between buildings in Edinburgh .
Shouldn't Neil Gray be saying something at some point? What specific action is being taken in the health industry specifically as a result of these "meetings"?
While not excusing their actions. The SNP are rank amateurs compared to the Tories. Didn't see this sad excuse for a newspaper geting laid into them over the previous 14 years.
And is that not his job visiting this that and the other social care is not attractive for some it’s about time people started to look after there own kith and kin and leave the social care to those that have no one to look after them but folk are greedy and won’t do without 😂
@ScottishRoss27 well Ross im guessing your a deluded snp man. The lying disgraceful snp have destroyed education, transport, NHS and economy. Scotland had before snp took power one of the worlds best education record. Under their watch we have the highest drug death rate in the whole of Europe, We have worse stats than any other uk board in regards to the NHS. And the snp has for decades failed the economy and it's people. They love using our tax payers money on themselves and think of new ways to defend there stealing habbits. They have still not delivered 2 ferry's that are now ridiculously over budget with 1 of them already needs new parts for a mechanical issue during sea tests and it's not evan carried 1 passenger!!! And iv not evan mentioned Operation Branchform yet there fraud case. All they do is blame covid and Westminster when people know snp have enough powers to change things but don't so they can use Westminster as a excuse. Snp is a cancer that is slowly killing Scotland, the only chance we have of surviving and recovering is to vote these lying disgraceful thieving scumbags out for good!!!
So Swinney “expects his ministers to have meetings with stakeholders”. What stakes do these various holders have in the government of Scotland? Why do ministers have to have meetings with them and what are they discussing? He is standing in front of the cameras and blatantly admitting to his msp’s being bought. I can’t help but feel there are many people in Scotland with different stakes to offer the snp.
Thats a lot of meetings. Couldnt have got much work done. GPs/ NHS surgeries have been in crisis since 2013!! The problems been there for 11 years. If you can't solve an 11 year old problem it's time to leave.
@@user-wf1zp2cd2e From September 2013 to June 2024, NHS Scotland's Workforce Statistics show there were 157,383 staff in September 2013 and 186,293 staff in June 2024. = An increase of just under 15,5 percent or 28,910 staff.
Same here., I strongly agree that the Bitcoin ETFs approval will be greatly life opportunity for us, with my current portfolio of $102,500 from my investments with my personal financial advisor Steve Miley I totally agree with you😊
YES!!! That's exactly his name (Steve Miley) so many people have recommended highly about him and am just starting with him from Brisbane Australia...🇦🇺
He's my family's personal Broker and also a personal Broker to many family's in the United states, he is licensed and a FINRA AGENT in the United States.
I mean the real issue is the waste of money on the utter garbage that passes for football in Haggis-land: we'd understand the spend if he'd been to see Leyton Orient or Wrexham, but a Jock team? Throw the book at the prole.
![Gunna - HIM ALL ALONG [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/w7Wf0h1Q8a4/mqdefault.jpg)
Lost count the number of times Swinney has had to stand up and defend blatant corruption within his party. Time he went as well.
How can swinney defend slease and corruption........oh it's normal🤣😂🤣😂
Clutching at straws here taxpayers taken for a ride
If it was government business, where are the minutes of this meeting?
Good point Ian. Recall when Matheson's first feeble excuse when he said he was involved in constituency work from Morocco, but nothing was ever provided as proof. All B-S
Swinney ranting on about Gray's engagements as though Neil Gravy Train was doing extra curriculum, it's his job and he is paid well for it. SNP think they are Kings and Queens.
The whole party lacks any credibility.
Swinney the Swindler. Enjoying the gravy train while they can. The SNP. Scotland’s shame.
Gray is just another SNP Minister that takes us for mugs. And Swinney, defending him, is just another.
Corrupt to the core , just more BS from John
What a crock Swinney! ps. That moustache needs to go Mr. Gray, looks like a right creep.
Its Movember
Reform 🇬🇧🏴
What's an English Nationalist Party got to do with Scotland?
@@ScottishRoss27What’s the snp doing for Scotland?
@@ScottishRoss27tell that to the Reform Party Scots that stood at the last election and those that voted for them. More dross.
@@taffyddu
No mention of Scotland in reform party election manifesto, you will know this if you read it.
@@mariannestuart4398
Lots
347 engagements, I wonder how many lasted 90 minutes plus extra time?
Cleary a case of SNOUTS IN THE TROUGH again !!!
Laughable answers yet again SNP
Swinney is an absolute disgrace and defending the indefensible as per.😢
The benefits of devolved power just shine through. What a shower of sh it
SNP corruption
In 2011 they had 24 government cars. By 2021 they had 41 cars to ferry them all around costing over £1 million a year !
What's the equivalent figures for the UK Government? presuming you have the comparative figures there?
@ do your own research
@@vtechead1
Oh dear, In 2010/2011 financial year the cost of UK Government Ministerial Car Service was nearly £4m.
That is nearly 3x more the cost 13 Years Ago than your figures for Scottish Government for 2021.
I won't let the UK Government further embarrass you with their figure for 2021.
@@ScottishRoss27 not much difference between a population of 5 million that could fit into London with 3 million spare, and a population of 55 million. You really need to stop embarrassing yourself by diverting. SNP is the subject 👍
@ and considering the SNP have only nine seats and no voice in Westminster now, makes the situation even worse. Bye bye 👍
That stupid clapping needs to stop - it’s nonsense and does not look good at all
Reform 🇬🇧🏴
English party
@ British party
@@Johnm-94315
English party
SNP give Social Care Staff a pay rise, but increase their income taxes - leaving individuals worse off.
Social care employees are paid around £900 per year more than their counterparts in England.
@@ScottishRoss27You must be very tired by now.
Me and family friends will never ever vote for this lot ever again disgusting snp
Clapping seals the lot of them
It was all Westminster’s fault.🤔🤔😜😜👍
Sack the s.n.p !
I have a friend in the civil service in Edinburgh. She informed me that her notes and paperwork for her meetings, is chauffeur driven between buildings in Edinburgh .
Shouldn't Neil Gray be saying something at some point? What specific action is being taken in the health industry specifically as a result of these "meetings"?
Just last week the health secretary settled a pay rise for consultants.
Big guilty face there, glaring back with that eyebrow that’s come down for a drink 😆
I read he was also trying to get oasis tickets whilst at a meeting about dementia
Swinney what a balloon
While not excusing their actions. The SNP are rank amateurs compared to the Tories. Didn't see this sad excuse for a newspaper geting laid into them over the previous 14 years.
What have they done to my country 😢🏴😢
And is that not his job visiting this that and the other social care is not attractive for some it’s about time people started to look after there own kith and kin and leave the social care to those that have no one to look after them but folk are greedy and won’t do without 😂
SNP are all Glasgow Celtic supporters
Eh?
Swinney is a Hibs supporter, Humza is a Celtic supporter, don't know if Nicola follows football, Salmond was a Hearts supporter.
Liars, grifters, obnoxious mps, that applies to the whole lot of you, snp Lliebor, and conservative.
He could have used the motorhome the party paid for and had 40 winks before the game.
Naaaaaa it’s still in the police pound 👍
Need these people voted out
Swinney is moribund as partridge would put it😂
He shouldn't be at the football games at taxpayers expense Swinney what don't you get about this
He who defends corruption is just as guilty
Where's Christine 😢 ?
The sooner we can vote out the snp the better off we will all be
Evidence?
@ScottishRoss27 well Ross im guessing your a deluded snp man.
The lying disgraceful snp have destroyed education, transport, NHS and economy. Scotland had before snp took power one of the worlds best education record.
Under their watch we have the highest drug death rate in the whole of Europe, We have worse stats than any other uk board in regards to the NHS.
And the snp has for decades failed the economy and it's people. They love using our tax payers money on themselves and think of new ways to defend there stealing habbits.
They have still not delivered 2 ferry's that are now ridiculously over budget with 1 of them already needs new parts for a mechanical issue during sea tests and it's not evan carried 1 passenger!!!
And iv not evan mentioned Operation Branchform yet there fraud case.
All they do is blame covid and Westminster when people know snp have enough powers to change things but don't so they can use Westminster as a excuse.
Snp is a cancer that is slowly killing Scotland, the only chance we have of surviving and recovering is to vote these lying disgraceful thieving scumbags out for good!!!
Thats a lot of limo rides
What a stupid reply by honest John 🙄
what do you expect the guy protected his mate Mathieson. When everyone with a moral compass could see Mathieson was going down.
@@keithduff8158 it's all he's got.
Obfuscation, deflection, Westminster and not forgetting his biggest strength LYING 🤥
So Swinney “expects his ministers to have meetings with stakeholders”. What stakes do these various holders have in the government of Scotland? Why do ministers have to have meetings with them and what are they discussing? He is standing in front of the cameras and blatantly admitting to his msp’s being bought. I can’t help but feel there are many people in Scotland with different stakes to offer the snp.
Out of curiosity
Has any snp msp ever been to ibrox,somehow i dont think so.
Rangers owe the Scottish Government 3 Million from covid support loan the Scottish Government provided it help with.
@ScottishRoss27 no such thing scottish assembly, the celtic way built by gdc in 2014 for the common wealth games because it was an eyesore.
@@charleslouden6600
No such thing as what?
@@ScottishRoss27 Ross ,rock,go inhabit.
@@charleslouden6600
Eh?
They could have saved money and used Kranky's motorhome to ferry them to the match. 🤣
Thats a lot of meetings. Couldnt have got much work done. GPs/ NHS surgeries have been in crisis since 2013!! The problems been there for 11 years. If you can't solve an 11 year old problem it's time to leave.
No they've not. Scotland is only Nation in the UK to have avoided any strike action.
@ScottishRoss27 Where did strike action come from?
@@user-wf1zp2cd2e
There has been no strikes in Scotland's NHS.
@@user-wf1zp2cd2e
From September 2013 to June 2024, NHS Scotland's Workforce Statistics show there were
157,383 staff in September 2013 and 186,293 staff in June 2024.
= An increase of just under 15,5 percent or 28,910 staff.
Our taxes their personal bank account?
Ministers make visits all the time promoting Scotland's health, education, culture, economy
I'm favoured financially with Bitcoin ETFs approval, Thank you buddy.$28,600 weekly profit regardless of how bad it gets on the economy.
Same here., I strongly agree that the Bitcoin ETFs approval will be greatly life opportunity for us, with my current portfolio of $102,500 from my investments with my personal financial advisor Steve Miley I totally agree with you😊
YES!!! That's exactly his name (Steve Miley) so many people have recommended highly about him and am just starting with him from Brisbane Australia...🇦🇺
He's my family's personal Broker and also a personal Broker to many family's in the United states, he is licensed and a FINRA AGENT in the United States.
The very first time we tried, we invested $1000 and after a week, we received 4500. That really helped us a lot to pay up our bills.
This sounds so good and i would like to be a party to this, is there any way i can speak with him?
Not many SNP trips to Ibrox??
Rangers owe The Scottish Government £3 Million from covid support loans.
Is Rangers doing anything for the community that would merit a Government visit?
I smell 💩
I mean the real issue is the waste of money on the utter garbage that passes for football in Haggis-land: we'd understand the spend if he'd been to see Leyton Orient or Wrexham, but a Jock team? Throw the book at the prole.
How would you know? The last time I looked the SNPs favourite football team is doing well both domestically and in Europe.
Why the racism against all Scots?
Sadly, it is believable. Shocking, this is not Government business.