She is one of the best super talented singers in Asia. If you like her music, you should pick any of the songs. You will know the reason why she is that famous in ASIA. Now, she has new 14 MV's from story one to story 14 MV and those 14 MV's relative to one long story. Those 14 MV's are completely created on her own, she is so talented. You can think about if she went into the world market, she will give a big impact on the music world. Due to her own musical talent, She did that in ASIA. I hope you can share her music with the talented musicians in the world. We would like to know the feedback from them also. Her music starts today. G.E.M. 鄧紫棋《GLORIA》 | 啓示錄 REVELATION Enjoy it! Thanks!
Joe's analysis & breakdown of the song truly gave it a new life. The Chinese lyrics were beautifully translated. They can be considered as modern poetry.
Thanks for another review. 🙏 do one for 时光音乐会 's songs. The old version and new rendition from singers. Maybe 凤凰传奇和张杰的月亮之上。 I think the music arrangements can have alot to talk about. Esp. 张杰 always have very creative way of remaking a song.
I like GEM's singing, but not for this song. To me, unfortunately, only reminds me of Beyond. Perhaps Joe felt her singing is mostly a deliverance of Western style into Chinese tune, that can't raise his further interest. Well, after all it's still good to learn from his analysis with his might. Also thank you for your efforts on this episode, Sander!
Beyond唱出的是：風中殘燭般的抑鬱和滄桑
而紫棋 唱出的是：滿天星空下的憧憬和回憶
Beyond的歌真的可以流傳百年，今天還在聽，還在唱，激勵人心。
这也是我最喜欢邓紫棋翻唱的一首，她翻唱中最有活力和能量的一首，可以说在这场比赛中不能忽视的一首。敬Beyond
這首歌由鄧紫琪翻唱非常好聽~!!...有她自己的味道..很精采~!!
強烈推荐卢冠廷的”一生所爱” 👍🏻👍🏻
好聽 但是跳的我不知所措
She is one of the best super talented singers in Asia. If you like her music, you should pick any of the songs. You will know the reason why she is that famous in ASIA. Now, she has new 14 MV's from story one to story 14 MV and those 14 MV's relative to one long story. Those 14 MV's are completely created on her own, she is so talented. You can think about if she went into the world market, she will give a big impact on the music world. Due to her own musical talent, She did that in ASIA. I hope you can share her music with the talented musicians in the world. We would like to know the feedback from them also. Her music starts today. G.E.M. 鄧紫棋《GLORIA》 | 啓示錄 REVELATION Enjoy it! Thanks!
好想听九爷评价邓紫棋的“孤独”呀
91分 , 歌声和音乐都有升华的感觉, 结尾也完美, Perfect,,👍
邓紫棋真不错。致以最高的敬意to Beyond❤
太喜欢这个系列了，好多乐理的东西Joe一讲才觉得，哇，真的是这么回事诶
一定要继续下去鸭！！
想看Joe review 张淇、白举纲和霍尊唱的《悟空》
顶起来！！！！
這曲是Beyond原創的, Beyond唱的也與鄧紫琪唱的意境不同, 試試給Beyond的版本來評, 應該他感受的會不一樣
在结尾有提到
对不起了哈，两首我都喜欢，但还是更喜欢Beyond的版本，它是永远都听不腻的那种，黄家驹真的是天才，不只是唱功顶级，作曲也是天才
音乐🎶人都会respect的黄家驹 介绍给这位音乐人 香港曾经有一位伟大的音乐家
鄧紫棋可能是這一代流行歌曲女歌手現場唱功前十。推薦資深的天才搖滾歌手－羅琦
GEM同輩同年代（90後）去計，GEM唱功、實力、才華，絕對係top one ，而且係拋離第二位！
Joe's analysis & breakdown of the song truly gave it a new life.
The Chinese lyrics were beautifully translated. They can be considered as modern poetry.
你和九爷都很可爱😉，喜欢你们俩💕💗💕。当九爷听到“喜欢你…”这几句歌词时，他的面部表情马上就显现柔光…。可见一首好的歌，一句好的歌词，真的能让人发自内心的表现出当下的感觉😄😀😊
Of course Beyond
awesome！！
G.E.M和BEYOND给我的感觉就映衬了那句话：男追女隔层山，女追男隔层纱
想聽久爺評論鄧紫棋的If I were a boy, 該首歌裡，GEM對唱功發揮之處遠多於這首喜歡你，不過我知道If I were a boy若是今天情人節來播會不應景。😅
Please really let Joe to hear the Beyond version, let him know how a song from 1988 like and became a classic Canton song
相比起更有流行色彩的版本~~其实喜欢原版本的青涩和内敛~窈窕淑女，寤寐求之。
求之不得，寤寐思服。悠哉悠哉，辗转反侧~~那种暗恋的感觉~
react more gem please,I love her very much💜💜💜
不如評一下反差大的兩首歌 G.E.M. "偶爾" [HD] - LIVE PIANO SESSION and 存在 (我是歌手), 還有是Falling and 差不多姑娘?
hi @不是柯桑德
可以做一集林志炫的講評
他很特別, 他是從傳統聲樂跳到流行音樂的, 但做了很好的mix
這首歌聲好聽 但是無法表現出鄧紫棋的超強唱功
確實
唱功的使用不能太過，傳達好內容、帶動好情緒就足夠了，所謂過猶不及。實際上這個版本最吸引我的地方是她所使用的語感，既清脆又軟糯，非常動聽而且有種乾淨利落的感覺。人人都說紫棋“很會唱”，能對細節把控得很完美才會一直給路人這個印象。
他評了樂器，評了編曲，評了合唱，就是沒有評歌手本人(除了 "經典動作")😅
鄧妹！too much skill
他好似呃飯食
😂
哈哈哈 确实 弦乐很喜欢 伴奏很棒 和声好厉害 歌手动作不错哦
我也发现了
非常中肯的评语~🤙
邓紫棋 我要我们在一起
黑鳳梨是beyond 😰推薦”光輝歲月”
Beyond的音樂和詞放到那個年代都不會覺得落伍。。家駒逝世的同時Beyond也跟隨他一同離去。。。
我是邓紫棋的粉丝，超兴奋的🤯
Thanks for another review. 🙏 do one for 时光音乐会 's songs. The old version and new rendition from singers. Maybe 凤凰传奇和张杰的月亮之上。 I think the music arrangements can have alot to talk about. Esp. 张杰 always have very creative way of remaking a song.
Beyond ✌️
Beyond 才是永远的神🤟
She'd like to give a salute to Beyond who is her favourite. Btw, I like both
喜欢Joe
Noice...Joe again~!
與其說是評價歌唱人~不如說是在評價音樂本身~都在分析樂器~對歌手本身的音質歌唱技巧反而很少講評到...
這樣來講~說外國人評價某某歌手來說根本沒意義~他只是在分析樂隊而已....誰唱都沒差....
I would like to hear the comments on Gem Sleeping beauty tks
GEM sang Beyond song😍😍😍
beyond 的歌只有beyond他們自己唱才有那種感覺，聽過很多很多其他的cover,但始終有種對不上號的感覺。
黄家驱的唱腔真的好
毕竟是黄家驹自己的故事创造的歌曲。在感情上肯定是独一无二。
@@danteli9105 现在安逸的时代很难出这么好的歌词了
@@justinliang2443 全世界还有很多地方值得创作出类似beyond 那首AMANI 反对战争的作品的。
香港的歌手都很棒👍🏻
For the lyrics translation, instead of ‘love you’. Would ‘Loving you’ be better?
希望可以让Joe 评论 陈力 87 红楼梦版里的 葬花吟、还有红楼梦引子，枉凝眉。 但那些必须先了解一下红楼梦的背景故事和宝钗黛的情感纠葛。 真的是太美了。 这些近年的歌曲多少很容易搜到，但是像红楼梦歌曲外国人都不知道。 不推荐他们自己永远发现不了。 包括西游记歌曲，三国演义等。
I found GEM used too much nasal sounds in her performance. It is a little annoying to my taste. I definitely vote for Beyond’s version.
Likewise here. I change station every time the radio announcers play her songs.
存在！！！存在！！！想看看九爷是否也会对向生命呐喊的歌震撼到
你唱的我起雞皮疙瘩了，哈哈哈
從頭到尾我還是沒聽到九爺對鄧紫棋的評價
原版「喜歡你」是分手後的傷情歌吧
please react more songs of Gem eg. Fly away
希望你给JOE听听《歌手》里面也是一首经典的歌曲《给所有知道我名字的人》罗琦，重点是讲一讲罗琦老师演唱这首歌之前的人物背景，为什么来到歌手，以及为什么要唱这首歌……
This song just reminds me of ktv, Thai disco, smoke, alcohol, perfume, dim light, dizzying lights
你們倆都十分棒棒，超喜歡你們。
這標題下錯了吧~~~應該是~~国外专业音乐人如何评价邓紫棋.....的樂隊？
今日は520ですね☺️、もう一度聴いてみ~
I love both of them.
Recommend G.E.M 倒数 countdown
想看評論鄧紫棋的光年之外
I like GEM's singing, but not for this song.
To me, unfortunately, only reminds me of Beyond.
Perhaps Joe felt her singing is mostly a deliverance of Western style into Chinese tune, that can't raise his further interest.
Well, after all it's still good to learn from his analysis with his might.
Also thank you for your efforts on this episode, Sander!
beyond是无可取代的.
我来看你的 头发的，既然又戴帽子😥😥😥
Wish you can comment on Tan Jing 谭晶 （让苍天变了心、赤玲、一样的月光等等）
誠摯推薦歌手袁婭維版本的《愛》。
請你評論一下央吉瑪的愛你的三百六十五天 及部落的信天游 Thanks
看到了韩磊，叫九爷评个韩磊的《向天再借五百年》吧！同意的举手！
她好多歌都是先抑后扬，这样效果很好，但吃个人能力，容易驾驭不了。
想聽黃妃的追追追
有点听明白了。背后的是强大的。台前的是一般的。
為什麼你不做 张靓颖邓紫棋合唱《雨蝶》, 存在, 狐獨的reaction? 這個樂評人，好像比上次嗰個差一皮播. 無乜料播. 上次嗰個去左邊呀？你好像每次做G.E.M. REACTION都有小小問題, 選歌同標提兩個都好重要. 樂評都重要.
Beyond 喜欢你
植发效果如何
希望下次可以评价二手玫瑰的仙儿。
沒啥好評的，詞曲結構一樣，全是beyond創造，這視頻只需評論唱功吧。
但鄧紫棋本就是很會唱的實力歌手😁
this song will always belong to the canton legend “ beyond”
Beyond的歌我較喜歡真的爱你同海闊天空。原版喜歡你感覺節奏有点慢不太喜歡，gem的版本反而聽起來很正能量很爽。
想听九爷评价一下邓紫棋的存在
邓紫棋的台风真的拿捏了
從頭到尾只有紫棋在唱，哪來的合聲啊？
唯一能接受的翻唱版本
你好，推薦你聽一下屠洪剛＜你＞，很好聽的
听不了听不了，听到beyond的歌就想哭
雖然歌名叫喜歡你，但實在是一首失戀歌，所以Beyond 版本的編曲比Gem版本更貼合歌曲原來的意境，始終都係鍾情Beyond 版本
如果 九爷听，
约瑟翰·庞麦郎 《我的滑板鞋》。
不知会有怎么样的评价？
👍👍👍👋👋👋👋
see you next time & like you this time
邓紫棋的歌里面这首歌恰恰是我不太喜欢的。最重要的原因是因为翻唱别人的歌而且不是那么的出彩。至少我没感觉除了声调以外有什么可以值得让人疯狂的感觉。相比其他的她自己的原创歌差多了。至少没有光年之外好听。看看光年之外的点击率就看到明显的差别了。
4:56 这段真是笑死我了哈哈哈哈
Why no introducing Anita Mui?? 🤔🤔🤔
强烈推荐林子祥的“数字人生”！！！
我以為會撥放 GEM 翻唱的 龍捲風 GEM真得更激昂呀 很推
當然選Beyond啦
想聽九爺分析中國第一網紅唐藝,她的表演很精采
Gem covering BEYONDS song. Sanders, can you do a Dave Wang/Kit Wong song?
不必*
@@user-tp3wk1kh6g who you?
一般中国人想表达“我喜欢你“时会说”在吗?“
下次可以让九爷听听韩磊版的《花房姑娘》
喜歡gem 的版本 輕快又歡樂 beyond的版本節奏太慢
知道黄家駒為什麼作這首歌嗎？這首歌原本就不是輕快歡樂的歌曲，分手後懷念前女友所作的歌！
什么时候听华晨宇呀？期待
各有各千秋 各有各喜欢
邓紫棋怎么能不听ainy这首？