Always good to reintroduce another generation to this glorious music. These performers in this video are, as others have said here, OK, but not great. They are pretty and graceful, but rather nasal and offers the usual "stage singing" necessary for Broadway. NOTHING will match the 1968 Don Francks and Petula Clark rendition of this song--fortunately captured on film for us to enjoy and here easily found on YOUTube. When I saw "Finian's Rainbow" in Santa Barbara at the State Theater in 1968, I was in junior high school and the Old Devil Moon song blew me out of my seat. Still does. The steamy, yet restrained passion and ability to "pause" at just the right moment in the song is what makes Francks' and Clark's performances so good. Don Francks has never been given appropriate credit for the excellent performance he gave in that movie. His utter focus on Petula Clark's character as "Woody" and the manner in which he played a difficult role is so memorable and professional.
You are OUT of your mind -- the Petula Clark duet in the movie STUNK to high heaven -- gave it no justice -- they were talk-singing, stalling and way off pitch and totally out of rhythym -- their version should be IL-LEGAL ...!!
You are all wrong, obviously. Even a deaf person could tell the BEST version of this song is Frank Sinatra's, nothing like the old devil to sing this song. I heard him live at the age of -25 at a small New York bar.
People obviously have their favourite version of this song. I absolutely love the Don Francks-Petula Clarke version. Coppola shot it in a very intimate manner - quiet but powerful. The way Don looks at Petula made me feel like a voyeur!
Sadly, I doubt they will ever do another Broadway revival of Finian's Rainbow, as it's not considered "politically correct", with the blackface etc., despite having an anti-bigotry message which will no doubt get lost. Surprisingly, the best versions and orchestrations of the songs are on the movie soundtrack with Petula Clark.
@@scottandrewhutchins I saw the Encores production which was what transfered to Broadway, and NO they did not do "Blackface". The actor Philip Bosco who played the racist Senator Rawkins was replaced by the actor Ruben Santiago-Hudson after the leprechaun Og changes the color of the Senator's skin. All the Black characters were played by Black actors.
It's okay. Jackson's vocals are fine but don't measure to that of Don Francks who was also sexy as hell in the film version. Kate's vocals are good and strong. But their performance is too high school quality. Lacks the passion, sultriness, and vibrancy of the film version which was epic and left me panting.
Agreed with this. “High school quality” is the perfect description. It’s, well, fine, but as another commenter wrote, “I don’t believe they are bewitched.” At least they sing Yip Harburg’s exceptional lyrics clearly.
Great performances and beautiful voices, both. But, good golly, Kate Baldwin is gorgeous. 😮
Cheyenne Jackson’s voice is absolutely amazing I could listen to him all day
His voice is absolutely perfect for this song.
@@Vitarai definitely
Voice? I am only aware of his kissable lips ❤❤❤ swoon
A very great song from the Golden Age of American song writing.
💜Pure Magic. Devine Duet!!! Sincerest gratitude for all the creative people who made this presentation possible!!!
Cheyenne jacksons voice is soooo amazing doesn't even need a microphone
way way better than the movie version.......gorgeous ---
Always good to reintroduce another generation to this glorious music. These performers in this video are, as others have said here, OK, but not great. They are pretty and graceful, but rather nasal and offers the usual "stage singing" necessary for Broadway. NOTHING will match the 1968 Don Francks and Petula Clark rendition of this song--fortunately captured on film for us to enjoy and here easily found on YOUTube. When I saw "Finian's Rainbow" in Santa Barbara at the State Theater in 1968, I was in junior high school and the Old Devil Moon song blew me out of my seat. Still does. The steamy, yet restrained passion and ability to "pause" at just the right moment in the song is what makes Francks' and Clark's performances so good. Don Francks has never been given appropriate credit for the excellent performance he gave in that movie. His utter focus on Petula Clark's character as "Woody" and the manner in which he played a difficult role is so memorable and professional.
You are OUT of your mind -- the Petula Clark duet in the movie STUNK to high heaven -- gave it no justice -- they were talk-singing, stalling and way off pitch and totally out of rhythym -- their version should be IL-LEGAL ...!!
@@mmichael216 Opinions are opinions. This version is really good--but nothing tops Ella Logan and Don Richards.
You are all wrong, obviously. Even a deaf person could tell the BEST version of this song is Frank Sinatra's, nothing like the old devil to sing this song. I heard him live at the age of -25 at a small New York bar.
People obviously have their favourite version of this song. I absolutely love the Don Francks-Petula Clarke version. Coppola shot it in a very intimate manner - quiet but powerful. The way Don looks at Petula made me feel like a voyeur!
How spectacular that was...Look at the audience loving this...How did this show disappear so fast?
I saw this movie with my father with Fred Astaire and Petula Clark and I wore out the 8track track!
Brilliantissimo🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤🎉❤❤❤
¡Realmente amo esta canción e interpretación!, no se ni cuantas veces he visto este video 💖💓💕
I was very fortunate to have attended this revival last December - flawless in every way!
Cheyenne Jackson is a god and Kate Baldwin is divine. They are both pure genius.
Her hair is so beautiful 😍😍💕💕
Ariana Vilani - Its a wig
God, they're both so gorgeous.
lucky audience!! and they have so much chemistry!! *sigh*
She's like a Disney princess
Ahhhhhh love him
Cheyene Jackson and Kate Baldwin
I think that any women who looks at him will fall instantly in love with him; I know I have! lol
Sadly, I doubt they will ever do another Broadway revival of Finian's Rainbow, as it's not considered "politically correct", with the blackface etc., despite having an anti-bigotry message which will no doubt get lost. Surprisingly, the best versions and orchestrations of the songs are on the movie soundtrack with Petula Clark.
Did they actually do this in blackface in the 2009 production? Even the movie used black actors.
@@scottandrewhutchins I saw the Encores production which was what transfered to Broadway, and NO they did not do "Blackface". The actor Philip Bosco who played the racist Senator Rawkins was replaced by the actor Ruben Santiago-Hudson after the leprechaun Og changes the color of the Senator's skin. All the Black characters were played by Black actors.
Perfect!!!!
I don't know if it's the blocking, or the actors, but I don't believe they are bewitched.
Until Whoopi walked on I thought sure this was in the actual theatre where this was performed.
Finian's Rainbows?
James Polk Finian's Rainbow's
I like Don and Petula's version better.
Absolute crap. There was no chemistry between them at all. Glad I didn’t waste my money 3:00
It's okay. Jackson's vocals are fine but don't measure to that of Don Francks who was also sexy as hell in the film version. Kate's vocals are good and strong. But their performance is too high school quality. Lacks the passion, sultriness, and vibrancy of the film version which was epic and left me panting.
Agreed with this. “High school quality” is the perfect description.
It’s, well, fine, but as another commenter wrote, “I don’t believe they are bewitched.” At least they sing Yip Harburg’s exceptional lyrics clearly.
Amen to that--you could not have said it better. Th sultry version from 1968 is ten times better.
original from the movie is better.
I liked the movie version much better.
Most definitely NOT as good as Petula Clark and Don Francks. Why can't we get talent like that any more?
They are both excellent, just different. There's no need to choose which one is better.
Not sure why these guys decided to sing with a vibrators in their throats? I'll take Sinatra over Broadway belting every time...