I’ll never understand why judges get so up in arms that people don’t still have receipts for things they purchased 10 years ago. People aren’t thinking down the road they MAY one day be in a lawsuit over this stereo I bought
Ya know I'm a little nuts, aside from my everyday thing's needed I take a picture & email it from my cell phone to myself, i've been doing this for years, before that I had a cabinet that I would throw my receipts in.... IDK really if he took her ring even though he has a history of thefts, when JM it could be buried under her socks & it might show up the plaintiff laughed/giggled about it & said yeah maybe.... That's just my opinion though.
I just bought a pair of pants online and right after I received it and checked if I like to keep them I tossed the receipt and exactly you're right WTH! 🤦🏻♂ , 🙅🏽 , 🙄
He stole her belongings. He thought he could get away with it because now she is a woman on her own. Such a scumbag. He says he changed but he is still a dishonest stealer.
The junk is just that - junk. Even the female admitted the diamond ring will show up. It so easy to say it's the principle of the thing. Nobody turns the other cheek?
I don’t know why the judge is confused. The defendant came in took stuff from the garage and sold it, plus has a history of robberies, why wouldn’t the plaintiff think of him as the one who took her ring? Anyone who’s ever had thieving relatives are not confused by this scenario at all.
In instances of death, it often amplifies existing negative feelings among survivors, especially when they had strained relationships or minimal interaction. Funerals can then become the reconnection point, overlaying grief with renewed contact and potentially exacerbating those negative sentiments.
A low life and a thief. what made him think the wife never needed those items. He is so money hungry that he had to sell his stepmother's item. What a shame.
Hearing all the cases just like this one makes me so glad my family handled things so much better. We didn't have the perfect family. But we had respect for one another.
He went over there and stole his stuffs d if his dad meant that much, he wouldn’t have sold those items. Just sad. When my dad died people who never bought a thing, nor visited him on all of his sickness were grabbing at straws. Just sick
Watching the defendant walk in I already distrust him. He's flinging rage all over the room through his eyes, and had a scary look in his eye when he verbally reacted to the end of the intro. It sounded to me like he said "she's not my step-mom" or "I stole from stepmom" in a derisive, sarcastic manner. Either way, that level of anger from the jump is frightening.
She always tries to award the least amount possible bc she knows it’s coming out of her own pocket and her shows budget. She mentions about if she mentioned it in the police report the day of n the second she sees she did that was instantly never spoken of again but if she hadn’t she would have used that as the excuse as to why she can’t be repaid for the ring!
She should not give him the truck as it really isn't his anyway, she should sell it to compensate herself for the ring he stole. He looks deceitful and certainly not remorseful. The judge wanted to check that she had mentioned the ring in the police report, yet then doesn't give her anything even though it was mentioned, so what was the point of that question?...
@arianefr78 A police report doesn't necessarily serve as evidence that the defendant stole her ring. She may have listed it as she felt it was stolen. Beyond that for someone who has a non-profile picture that's a low thing to write about the defendant's looks when you are hiding behind a keyboard and we can't point out your physical features, grow up dear.
"My rough justice is different from your rough justice." Yeah. I suspect the plaintiff puts more emphasis on the "rough" than she does on the "justice."
Funny, he wants to take his Dad's things yet he's entitled to none. His wife owns everything they purchased during the marriage. He better be glad she's willing to give up a truck and boat. I wouldn't after dealing with his thievery.
Me either. I don't blame her at all for holding the truck and boat. This guy gets a truck and a boat but it's not enough for him; he's got to steal big-ticket items from her garage & sell them real quick so the cops can't make him give the items back. Scummy. He was clearly in the wrong yet he was angry and stomped off in the end! She needs to install some cameras because new locks or not, that guy is going to be back to steal some more. He feels entitled. What I can't make sense of is why the plaintiff's husband made a convicted thief executor of his will, especially when his wife didn't get along with him.
I spend as much time with my parents as possible. My dad is my best friend in the world. That said, my sister has told my mom, to her face, that she can’t wait for her to die so she can have her money. She’s also told our father he’s “dead to her” because he wouldn’t take her side in a family dispute. It’s absolutely abhorrent. Some people really think only of themselves.
@@LoveThinkLaugh My parents are my best friends! I wouldn't know what to do without them! I'm so thankful I have a close knit family, sadly a lot of people don't! Treasure all the time you can with the one's you love ♡
@@dunkinjunkie5868there you have your answer: Your parents are your best friends Some of us were beaten as kids. Yeah there's shitty people in the world and shitty adult children, but - "usually" they're assholes because their parents weren't the greatest
@@VladmirPoopN I know you weren’t responding to me, but I just want you to know that staying away from toxicity is critical, even when it’s family. I’m so sorry your parents were the source of that toxicity for you, and you ought to be very proud of yourself for taking care of your well-being. Much love. ❤
I was thinking that, too. If she'd reported it to the police, as they said she did, pawn shops usually get notifications. Unfortunately, with all the online sales options these days, he could have taken a different route.
When my father passed away years ago, there was not a single moment that I thought to myself that I should try and acquire any of his belongings. If he wanted to leave something to me he would have put it in his will. But other than that everything he left behind remains with his wife. If I did not ask to have anything when he was alive, I am certainly not going to ask for it after he passes away. It is beyond shameful that people like to defendant think that they are entitled to certain items. I do not care if the stepmom did not like him. I imagine she may have good reason to not like him. But even if she did not like him for no real reason, that does not entitle him to steal his dead stuff from her.
I don't understand how the judge can't see how he would steal the ring. What do you mean why do you think he would? Because he stole other items and sold them for money. Are we not listening to the same case. He didn't even steal the items for sentimental reasons.
I bet he wouldn’t have gone over there and stolen that stuff if his dad was still alive. I know it wasn’t proven that he stole the ring but I’d bet on the fact that he did.
So? I don't call my mother's husband my "stepdad" because I was an adult when they married. He's "my mother's husband". And we have an excellent relationship, but he isn't my "step father".
@@mnschoen same, my dad married his wife when I was in my mid 20's. I typically only refer to her as my step mom to people who don't know us to simplify. We get along great.
I've waited to see a litiga do that for so long...I would too, speak twice for what? I usually turn it off at that part, repeating what's already been said why
I find it weird that the plaintiff realized right a way a hidden ring was missing? Especially when the defendant only took items that were outside of the house🤔.
When she realized he stoled the items in the garage, she ran in to look for the expensive ring his father gave her. The son knew about it and how to get into the house. He was desperate for money. I definitely would have looked right away too.
@@cameronbolden5064 She was willing to give him the tools, a boat and a car. All she wanted was what was hers. He admitted he walked in and stole those items. Claiming she was ok with it. So like a friend borrowing money then claiming it was a gift.
Where is she buying space heaters for $7.88?.....i can't stand her pettiness! If it's only $10, give her the $10!!!..... it's like that other case, the lady whose towels were ruined because of the landlord's neglect, and the landlord lost but instead of giving the litigant $50 for new towels, JM told her to wash them. I guess that's the law. Towels can be washed. But a $7.88 space heater (that actually costs $36.17 plus tax) - let the lady present her case! And quit grabbing every chance to poor shame with your ignorant dismissal of a $40 item because you know that space heaters are cheap (as in - $35, not $10 - big difference to minimum wage workers).
@@janets9179 she has a serious chip on her shoulder. She saw her father go from penniless immigrant to successful business man and he programmed to function in his footsteps. Not everyone has a good father. Over half of the women out there come from broken homes, absent/abusive fathers. So we keep putting our best foot forward while the little clique of 7th grade daddy's girls sit at their little mean girl table in the cafeteria. She's just flipping her - I'm one of the popular girls! - hair (literally - look at her perfectly gorgeous hair) at whoever dares approach her bench. I get it. She's the judge and it's a TV show for the sake of entertainment. So I'm entertained, judging the judge for always trifling the women who are less fortunate than her because her daddy was a construction contractor blah blah. My father was a construction engineer as well. And we lived in a nice house in Saudi Arabia while both my parents worked for ARAMCO, making six figures back in the 1980s. But I never sat at the popular girl table because I had no interest in being a cut throat judge or business person or jerk. I'm an artist first. And then I work minimum wage jobs to pay the bills. And people like me and never post negative stuff about me on the internet.
It sounds like this is not the first time he's stolen from her and probably his father too. Now his dad is gone, he can't hide behind his daddy anymore.
He looks like he's tweaking in the court room. He definitely took that stuff... he had all the gall to take things that he didn't ask for so why wouldn't he take her ring as well???
If the plaintiff was so nasty, she would have let it go to probate and the defendant would have been the big loser. Unless every item was specifically spelled out in the will, his widow gets everything by default. He admitted he took everything else and sold it to pay his rent, why not the ring. Stepson was shady as hell.
You don't know what her husbands kids may or may not have done to that woman, or how they treated her. Clearly, she was right about her stepson... Being a stepparent doesn't mean kissing your partners kids behinds when they're showing it to you.
She bought the house before she married his dad. She had every right to avoid the defendant (in her own home). He served 3 years in prison for multiple robberies (violent crimes).
I don't think he stole the ring. Nothing else in the house was missing. Also he does not seem to want anything to do with her. That's a shame all those years lost...
He probably did steal it, figuring if he just took the ring and nothing else in the house that she might not even notice it. He probably sold it with the other items.
I don’t think he took it either. He didn’t know the ring was in the sock drawer so the only way he would be able to find it would be to look for it. If he was looking for it something would have been out of place in the plaintiff’s bedroom.
She never had any intention of the defendant reimbursing the plaintiff for the ring. She just wanted to hear the defendants past misdeeds. She’s so nosy. Plus, the defendant is greedy! He gets the truck and boat and a bunch of other stuff and he still needs to steal!?
Guess the stepson proved that once you're a lying POS thief; always a lying POS thief. I always hate how they just replace the depreciated value of an item. The victim is still going to have to spend full price to replace the items, which they would never have had to do if their items hadn't been stolen. Absolutely, no punishment to the thief for taking what wasn't theirs and a big inconvenience to the victim. It's BS.
People and families fight over money and property because their just plain selfish and greedy and he just proved it by walking out without saying a word, Pathetic 🤨
true! addicts will sell any and everything that makes them money for their next hit of drugs! my dad used to do drugs and would sell my moms things to buy drugs.
Its too bad that the plaintiff was so nasty to her husband's son and grandchildren while he was alive. No wonder their relationship is so testy now. But i dont believe he stole her ring.
I agree that he didn't steal the ring but he served 3 years for multiple robberies which are violent crimes. She wasn't nasty to him but she did avoid him and so would any lady. Trust is earned and he proved he isn't worthy of it stealing $800 of her stuff in a house she bought before she married his dad.
He stole the ring, unfortunately in court, proof is needed. However, a drug addict is a thief! When they enter your house, it isn’t pleasantries, their eyes are scanning left and right looking for valuables and the first chance to steal the second your head is turned. This is a known fact from everyone who has had a thief in their life. Too bad that isn’t enough for the judge to be convinced because he did steal the ring.
I can’t stand when people say they didn’t want to come to court. You have a choice, if you don’t want to bring it to court then don’t. None of the stuff he took was anything of value. If the snow blower is 20 years old it probably doesn’t even work.
He looks like a criminal. He stole stuff out of the garage knowing she needed them so why wouldn’t he take her rings. As a last resort he might have to get a job to pay his rent now.
And you can tell by the way he was answering the judge's question, he was lying about taking those things that were not tools. And the police do not call you on the phone, they come to your home.
I thought he said he called and spoke to the police himself. Not that they called him. I could be wrong,but I thought he called them a few days later and was asking them something about the ring.
![[Judy Justice] Judge Judy [Episode 5559] Best Amazing Cases Season 2024 Full Episodes HD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3pybf0P-B4Y/mqdefault.jpg)
How in the heck did he think he had the right to go in and take that stuff… Then sell it???!!!
I wonder if there was some male ego going on there. Everything that went missing, other than the ring, was "guy-stuff."
@@BobBlumenfeldor maybe because it was his daddy’s shit 🙄
@@cantgetbettathanthisAND?
Have you lived in this world very long 😂 sadly this happens way too often!
@@cantgetbettathanthisThat still would not entitle him to those belongings unless they were left to him in his fathers will.
I’ll never understand why judges get so up in arms that people don’t still have receipts for things they purchased 10 years ago. People aren’t thinking down the road they MAY one day be in a lawsuit over this stereo I bought
Not her fault. If you want to sue someone for something , you need evidence. Could’ve even been saved in an email
@@yakira33310 years ago babe. Get with the program you dense turkey 😂
Ya know I'm a little nuts, aside from my everyday thing's needed I take a picture & email it from my cell phone to myself, i've been doing this for years, before that I had a cabinet that I would throw my receipts in....
IDK really if he took her ring even though he has a history of thefts, when JM it could be buried under her socks & it might show up the plaintiff laughed/giggled about it & said yeah maybe....
That's just my opinion though.
I just bought a pair of pants online and right after I received it and checked if I like to keep them I tossed the receipt and exactly you're right WTH! 🤦🏻♂ , 🙅🏽 , 🙄
Unreasonable, right?
The Defendant had no right to sell items that did not belong to him. This case was sad. Especially after the death of her husband.
He stole her belongings. He thought he could get away with it because now she is a woman on her own. Such a scumbag. He says he changed but he is still a dishonest stealer.
You hit the nail on the head 👍
The junk is just that - junk. Even the female admitted the diamond ring will show up. It so easy to say it's the principle of the thing. Nobody turns the other cheek?
No my dad is not
Addicts have no problem finding things of value. He ABSOLUTELY took that ring.
He stole her stuff... all her stuff. If he needed money that bad to sell all he could get and he knew the ring was there, he took it.
I don’t know why the judge is confused. The defendant came in took stuff from the garage and sold it, plus has a history of robberies, why wouldn’t the plaintiff think of him as the one who took her ring? Anyone who’s ever had thieving relatives are not confused by this scenario at all.
He is a major Hustler.
He took that stuff for drugs
I’m definitely not confused!! If the ring was under the socks all he had to do is move the damn socks and put them back..
So true...
JM being biased
You've got to have proof. Not just your mythical intuition.
I have always said.....Divorce and death bring out the worst in people.
In instances of death, it often amplifies existing negative feelings among survivors, especially when they had strained relationships or minimal interaction. Funerals can then become the reconnection point, overlaying grief with renewed contact and potentially exacerbating those negative sentiments.
And money
U r being too compassionate..terrible ppl SHOP for moments they think ur weak
He pounced cuz he saw she was in a weakened state
That's not rough justice, That's cheap justice.
A low life and a thief. what made him think the wife never needed those items. He is so money hungry that he had to sell his stepmother's item. What a shame.
That’s the same thing that I said, she still needs the generator and snowblower so he clearly took stuff that she didn’t allow
Drugs are definitely involved.
My dad is not money hungry thank you very much
@@charlottegeary8541do you have proof 😂
He definitely gave off addict vibes ...
He stole the ring too
He is actively still a drug user, a thief, a liar, and let's add elder abuser also! Who does he think he is kidding!??!
ikr
Doug still had to get in a dig at the end lmao “he’s the stepson” 😂😂😂
He was probably careful enough to not make it look like anyone when through her drawers so she would not notice it was missing right away.
Hearing all the cases just like this one makes me so glad my family handled things so much better. We didn't have the perfect family. But we had respect for one another.
Oh my goodness, REALLY JM
KEEP ASKING THE GUY
DO YOU REALLY THINK HE TOOK YOUR RING DUH🤔😳🤷
WHY NOT HE TOOK EVERYTHING ELSE!!!!!
He went over there and stole his stuffs d if his dad meant that much, he wouldn’t have sold those items. Just sad. When my dad died people who never bought a thing, nor visited him on all of his sickness were grabbing at straws. Just sick
It wasn’t his dad stuff it was hers as they both say early on
This actually happens far too often. The vultures reveal themselves.
Watching the defendant walk in I already distrust him. He's flinging rage all over the room through his eyes, and had a scary look in his eye when he verbally reacted to the end of the intro. It sounded to me like he said "she's not my step-mom" or "I stole from stepmom" in a derisive, sarcastic manner. Either way, that level of anger from the jump is frightening.
She always tries to award the least amount possible bc she knows it’s coming out of her own pocket and her shows budget. She mentions about if she mentioned it in the police report the day of n the second she sees she did that was instantly never spoken of again but if she hadn’t she would have used that as the excuse as to why she can’t be repaid for the ring!
She should not give him the truck as it really isn't his anyway, she should sell it to compensate herself for the ring he stole. He looks deceitful and certainly not remorseful. The judge wanted to check that she had mentioned the ring in the police report, yet then doesn't give her anything even though it was mentioned, so what was the point of that question?...
@arianefr78 A police report doesn't necessarily serve as evidence that the defendant stole her ring. She may have listed it as she felt it was stolen. Beyond that for someone who has a non-profile picture that's a low thing to write about the defendant's looks when you are hiding behind a keyboard and we can't point out your physical features, grow up dear.
The truck was supposed to go my dad anyways
I ABSOLUTELY BELIEVE HE TOOK THAT RIING!!!
Me too! Which is messed up! 😕
ABSOLUTELY. Once a drug head always a drug head.
I agree. he took it all - INCLUDING the ring. He is still a criminal. and a pig.
"My rough justice is different from your rough justice." Yeah. I suspect the plaintiff puts more emphasis on the "rough" than she does on the "justice."
Now he’s gonna have to steal something from someone else to pay for this.
😂
The show pays for the verdict
The defendant acts like he is still on drugs
This guy is such a lair! He said his “boss” needs it then he says he sold these “tools” for rent? Dude has issues. So sad.
Funny, he wants to take his Dad's things yet he's entitled to none. His wife owns everything they purchased during the marriage. He better be glad she's willing to give up a truck and boat. I wouldn't after dealing with his thievery.
Me either. I don't blame her at all for holding the truck and boat.
This guy gets a truck and a boat but it's not enough for him; he's got to steal big-ticket items from her garage & sell them real quick so the cops can't make him give the items back. Scummy. He was clearly in the wrong yet he was angry and stomped off in the end!
She needs to install some cameras because new locks or not, that guy is going to be back to steal some more. He feels entitled.
What I can't make sense of is why the plaintiff's husband made a convicted thief executor of his will, especially when his wife didn't get along with him.
Such a sad situation. Kids can't wait for their parents to die so they can take their belongings,yet they can't come by and visit while their living 😢
I spend as much time with my parents as possible. My dad is my best friend in the world.
That said, my sister has told my mom, to her face, that she can’t wait for her to die so she can have her money. She’s also told our father he’s “dead to her” because he wouldn’t take her side in a family dispute.
It’s absolutely abhorrent. Some people really think only of themselves.
@@LoveThinkLaugh My parents are my best friends! I wouldn't know what to do without them! I'm so thankful I have a close knit family, sadly a lot of people don't! Treasure all the time you can with the one's you love ♡
@@dunkinjunkie5868there you have your answer: Your parents are your best friends
Some of us were beaten as kids.
Yeah there's shitty people in the world and shitty adult children, but - "usually" they're assholes because their parents weren't the greatest
Not kids with parents that don't have any belongings
@@VladmirPoopN
I know you weren’t responding to me, but I just want you to know that staying away from toxicity is critical, even when it’s family. I’m so sorry your parents were the source of that toxicity for you, and you ought to be very proud of yourself for taking care of your well-being. Much love. ❤
I wonder if the plaintiff checked local pawn shops for her ring?🤔 . 🕵♀️
good idea.
I was thinking that, too. If she'd reported it to the police, as they said she did, pawn shops usually get notifications. Unfortunately, with all the online sales options these days, he could have taken a different route.
She had a bunch of folders of supposed proof yet didn't even print out what she found online. What "proof" did she have??
When my father passed away years ago, there was not a single moment that I thought to myself that I should try and acquire any of his belongings. If he wanted to leave something to me he would have put it in his will. But other than that everything he left behind remains with his wife. If I did not ask to have anything when he was alive, I am certainly not going to ask for it after he passes away. It is beyond shameful that people like to defendant think that they are entitled to certain items. I do not care if the stepmom did not like him. I imagine she may have good reason to not like him. But even if she did not like him for no real reason, that does not entitle him to steal his dead stuff from her.
I don't understand how the judge can't see how he would steal the ring. What do you mean why do you think he would? Because he stole other items and sold them for money. Are we not listening to the same case. He didn't even steal the items for sentimental reasons.
I’m thinking it’s drugs, because he said he sold it for rent.
Stealing a snowblower etc from family and selling it to pay bills is high-key junkie behavior😊
That guy looks like he'd steal anything and sell it.
It appears that her dislike of him is justified.
When parents die there is usually always one child that is greedy and sneaky. Not being rude .
So true!!
💯
Your not being rude, your just speaking the truth, don't ever apologize for the telling the truth
That's not true for every family.
He stole the ring.
Of course he did. He went straight to the drawer she got the coins out of.
Lemme see he can't pay his rent, but there's lots of bling in the left ear. Wonder where the money came from?
I absolutely believe he took her ring
I bet he wouldn’t have gone over there and stolen that stuff if his dad was still alive. I know it wasn’t proven that he stole the ring but I’d bet on the fact that he did.
Death brings out the worse in the living
He took his dads stuff just to sell it. He a tweaker 🤷♀️
This is beyond sad. It just goes to show that you can't help people sometimes especially family. Smh😔
He mouthed the words she's not my stepmom
Twice!
So? I don't call my mother's husband my "stepdad" because I was an adult when they married. He's "my mother's husband". And we have an excellent relationship, but he isn't my "step father".
@@mnschoen same, my dad married his wife when I was in my mid 20's. I typically only refer to her as my step mom to people who don't know us to simplify. We get along great.
I don't know why but this comment tickled me
Scott walked past Doug like I would whether I won or lost.
I've waited to see a litiga do that for so long...I would too, speak twice for what? I usually turn it off at that part, repeating what's already been said why
Moral of the story if people are shitty before the passing of relative they tend to be so afterwards.
No one ever wants to talk to Doug lol
Wow! That’s so low to literally go in there, and straight up steal the high dollar items to pay his rent! How was he not arrested?!
The judge almost always depreciates items leaving no one enough money to purchase a replacement.
I don't think the ring is missing. 💍
I find it weird that the plaintiff realized right a way a hidden ring was missing? Especially when the defendant only took items that were outside of the house🤔.
When she realized he stoled the items in the garage, she ran in to look for the expensive ring his father gave her. The son knew about it and how to get into the house. He was desperate for money. I definitely would have looked right away too.
Or they are bith greedy
@@cameronbolden5064 She was willing to give him the tools, a boat and a car. All she wanted was what was hers. He admitted he walked in and stole those items. Claiming she was ok with it. So like a friend borrowing money then claiming it was a gift.
Where is she buying space heaters for $7.88?.....i can't stand her pettiness! If it's only $10, give her the $10!!!..... it's like that other case, the lady whose towels were ruined because of the landlord's neglect, and the landlord lost but instead of giving the litigant $50 for new towels, JM told her to wash them. I guess that's the law. Towels can be washed. But a $7.88 space heater (that actually costs $36.17 plus tax) - let the lady present her case! And quit grabbing every chance to poor shame with your ignorant dismissal of a $40 item because you know that space heaters are cheap (as in - $35, not $10 - big difference to minimum wage workers).
I've noticed that too. It's unusual for an extremely rich person to count every penny like she does.
@@janets9179 she has a serious chip on her shoulder. She saw her father go from penniless immigrant to successful business man and he programmed to function in his footsteps. Not everyone has a good father. Over half of the women out there come from broken homes, absent/abusive fathers. So we keep putting our best foot forward while the little clique of 7th grade daddy's girls sit at their little mean girl table in the cafeteria. She's just flipping her - I'm one of the popular girls! - hair (literally - look at her perfectly gorgeous hair) at whoever dares approach her bench. I get it. She's the judge and it's a TV show for the sake of entertainment. So I'm entertained, judging the judge for always trifling the women who are less fortunate than her because her daddy was a construction contractor blah blah. My father was a construction engineer as well. And we lived in a nice house in Saudi Arabia while both my parents worked for ARAMCO, making six figures back in the 1980s. But I never sat at the popular girl table because I had no interest in being a cut throat judge or business person or jerk. I'm an artist first. And then I work minimum wage jobs to pay the bills. And people like me and never post negative stuff about me on the internet.
It sounds like this is not the first time he's stolen from her and probably his father too. Now his dad is gone, he can't hide behind his daddy anymore.
He looks like he's tweaking in the court room. He definitely took that stuff... he had all the gall to take things that he didn't ask for so why wouldn't he take her ring as well???
Just sad...
Sad! That lady seems simple but a sweet lady
If the plaintiff was so nasty, she would have let it go to probate and the defendant would have been the big loser. Unless every item was specifically spelled out in the will, his widow gets everything by default. He admitted he took everything else and sold it to pay his rent, why not the ring. Stepson was shady as hell.
Defendant is a thug👎🏾he stole that RING‼️
Douche was just waiting for his step dad to die so he could swipe things to sell and make a quick easy buck.
Smh I feel bad for her, I hope she gets protection cause he seems dangerous smh
The defendant is still in denial about the ring.
Kinda have the feeling that she didn't like her husband's kids. She doesn't seem very nice.
You don't know what her husbands kids may or may not have done to that woman, or how they treated her. Clearly, she was right about her stepson... Being a stepparent doesn't mean kissing your partners kids behinds when they're showing it to you.
She bought the house before she married his dad. She had every right to avoid the defendant (in her own home). He served 3 years in prison for multiple robberies (violent crimes).
I don't think he stole the ring. Nothing else in the house was missing. Also he does not seem to want anything to do with her. That's a shame all those years lost...
He probably did steal it, figuring if he just took the ring and nothing else in the house that she might not even notice it. He probably sold it with the other items.
100 agreed
I hope she just misplaced the ring. Sometime ppl hides thing and forgot precisely where it was hidden. Just saying
Sorry! Nope! In fact quite the opposite! If there was one thing it would have been that ring. @@Azkika1
I don’t think he took it either. He didn’t know the ring was in the sock drawer so the only way he would be able to find it would be to look for it. If he was looking for it something would have been out of place in the plaintiff’s bedroom.
Is this the guy from men and black at the beginning where he tells will smith on the rooftop that our world is about to end.
Harvey saying motive and opportunity doesn’t mean you did it!?!? Tell that to 99 percent of the people incarcerated 😂😂
Dougs nickname should be Salt. lol. (Salt/wound)
All that over 800 bucks lol.
She never had any intention of the defendant reimbursing the plaintiff for the ring. She just wanted to hear the defendants past misdeeds. She’s so nosy. Plus, the defendant is greedy! He gets the truck and boat and a bunch of other stuff and he still needs to steal!?
Guess the stepson proved that once you're a lying POS thief; always a lying POS thief. I always hate how they just replace the depreciated value of an item. The victim is still going to have to spend full price to replace the items, which they would never have had to do if their items hadn't been stolen. Absolutely, no punishment to the thief for taking what wasn't theirs and a big inconvenience to the victim. It's BS.
This comment is everything I feel when it comes to depreciated value. Thanks
Good verdict!
People and families fight over money and property because their just plain selfish and greedy and he just proved it by walking out without saying a word, Pathetic 🤨
The plaintiff was pleased as heck to be there. She was having a good time. I don't agree with the defendant's decisions, but I get it. Shame.
Once a thief always a thief.
He had already sold it before she asked for it back
Yea he already had it sold when he asked to get tools
Not trying to be that judgemental but he seems like an addict of some sort
true! addicts will sell any and everything that makes them money for their next hit of drugs! my dad used to do drugs and would sell my moms things to buy drugs.
It must’ve been a small generator for that amount it’s valued at.
Of course he stole that ring!
I hope she went to pawn shoppes and checked them out for her ring
Milan 🙄 c'mon stop giving her such a hard time!!
Its too bad that the plaintiff was so nasty to her husband's son and grandchildren while he was alive. No wonder their relationship is so testy now. But i dont believe he stole her ring.
I agree that he didn't steal the ring but he served 3 years for multiple robberies which are violent crimes. She wasn't nasty to him but she did avoid him and so would any lady. Trust is earned and he proved he isn't worthy of it stealing $800 of her stuff in a house she bought before she married his dad.
Not surprised that the defendant stormed out.
A new big generator costs FAR more than $300.
Just because somebody has a past doesn't mean they can't change....yall need to realize that..
I can't IMAGINE why she didn't like him!!!
The Judge is a smart ass .
He stole the ring, unfortunately in court, proof is needed. However, a drug addict is a thief! When they enter your house, it isn’t pleasantries, their eyes are scanning left and right looking for valuables and the first chance to steal the second your head is turned.
This is a known fact from everyone who has had a thief in their life. Too bad that isn’t enough for the judge to be convinced because he did steal the ring.
I can’t stand when people say they didn’t want to come to court. You have a choice, if you don’t want to bring it to court then don’t. None of the stuff he took was anything of value. If the snow blower is 20 years old it probably doesn’t even work.
Some people will walk you down into the ground if you let them, that's what he was going to do to her had she never put the laws in it
He stole the ring!
Yep
he looks and acts like trouble
She should have checked the local pawn shops
That thief didnt talk at the end because Doug was going to grill him about the ring.
He looks like a criminal. He stole stuff out of the garage knowing she needed them so why wouldn’t he take her rings. As a last resort he might have to get a job to pay his rent now.
Harverys wrong at the end. If they have motive and a chase of course that’s enough for a judge to rule in a civil court!
Drugs have fried the defendant’s brain.
You can accuse anyone of anything, without evidence your not going anywhere.
And you can tell by the way he was answering the judge's question, he was lying about taking those things that were not tools. And the police do not call you on the phone, they come to your home.
I thought he said he called and spoke to the police himself. Not that they called him. I could be wrong,but I thought he called them a few days later and was asking them something about the ring.
$250 generator.
$50 old snowblower.
$100 two used weed wackers.
That’s $400…….how did she get $820 ?
How would he have paid his rent if those items had not been available?
Scott can’t make his rent, so idk how he’s going to pay her. That’s for him to worry about though.
He stole that ring and sold it like he did the rest of the items and probably bought drugs