Fender Stratocaster Shootout - American Vintage ii 1961 vs. American Original 60's. Which is Better?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 239

  • @bluwng
    @bluwng 7 месяцев назад +16

    The Clay dot inlays on the red one looks really good.

  • @alexhaworth9855
    @alexhaworth9855 6 месяцев назад +4

    My American vintage ii came flawless out of the box. Such a beautiful guitar! Couldn’t be more happy!

  • @kazimustafizurrahman2122
    @kazimustafizurrahman2122 Год назад +12

    Good decision on the 61. I have the exact same one and absolutely agree with you on the color and on that ‘something about it’ mojo… enjoy your new guitar! 🙂

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +4

      Thanks! Yes, the American Original was the exact opposite. It was a perfect instrument, but for some reason it just kind of fell a little flat in the character department. I’m on the hunt now for an AV 65’ which is supposedly the neck profile they used for the American original, which was my favorite aspect of that guitar.

  • @tinpanalleybluesman
    @tinpanalleybluesman Год назад +4

    First of all, thank you for this video. Second of all - forgive me if there is some gramatical & typing mistakes, clearly english is not my first language. As owner of American Vintage II 1961 olympic white Fender Stratocaster, I have to say that I had exactly the same issue with neck pocket and crooked neck like yourself. Also I have seen a lot of videos in which people were complaining about the same issue. Also, I have to admit, that from what I hear in this video, I like more how does the Fender American Original sounds like. It has that almost pre CBS - bell like deeper tone than american vintage II ... Thank you and God bless you !

  • @4jrbirdman
    @4jrbirdman 11 месяцев назад +4

    My '61 came out of the box set up perfectly and was flawless. Can't put it down, light weight and love the neck.

  • @ryangunwitch-black
    @ryangunwitch-black Год назад +17

    The Fiesta Red finish on the one I played at the store was dead on. It was so pretty. It had that pale red with a touch of salmon. And the 7.25" board is the real selling point for me. I've been looking at all of these Custom Shop Strats that are really appealing until I get to the specs and find out they have a 9.5" board. Such a sticking point for me because I really love that vintage Fender radius.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +6

      I’m the exact same. I prefer the 7.25 over 9.5

    • @danielferrera8773
      @danielferrera8773 Год назад +3

      ​@@NickHandleyCreativesame for me. I'm not a shredder at all but more of a rhythm player so it suits my playing much better, chords and so on...

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +3

      @@danielferrera8773 indeed. I’d play faster if I could 😆

    • @danielferrera8773
      @danielferrera8773 Год назад +1

      @@NickHandleyCreative hahah

  • @acousdeek
    @acousdeek Год назад +8

    Thank you for putting this video together! I'm so surprised that there aren't more comparison videos between the AO and AVii out there! I bought one of each and ended up keeping the American Original. They're both perfect and it is just preference. I preferred the beefier neck and '65 pickup voicing, but no matter how hard of a decision it was, there really was no -wrong- one to make!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Yes I preferred the beefier neck profile on the AO as well. Something about the AVii just spoke to me on a deeper level, but both are pretty amazing!

    • @vyvynylification
      @vyvynylification Год назад

      are the pv65's warm sounding and good for cleans? :-)))

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      @@vyvynylification Both guitars had pretty amazing clean tones. The AO was definitely a slight bit fuller/warmer my ears, but the AVii had more articulation

  • @blindsidedka
    @blindsidedka Год назад +4

    You don't have to take the neck off to adjust it in the neck pocket, just loosen the screws a few turns and gently push it in place. Not sure why you'd want to take the entire neck off. It can even be done while the strings are at full tension.

  • @nalukeko
    @nalukeko Год назад +3

    2:14 mine had that too, you don't have to take the neck off. just loosen the screws very little, move in place, and tighten screws while maintaining pressure/position.
    I sold the AO60. Mainly for cosmetic reasons (clay dots and spaghetti logo), but I do love the neck on the AVII61.

  • @sponto25752
    @sponto25752 Год назад +13

    Funny I was in the exact same situation and I ended up keeping both but I have to say my AVII 61 is so sweet I cannot put it down. Something very special about it.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +4

      In retrospect I probably should have just kept both. The AO had something special about it that I talked myself out of based on financial reasons, but now that I don’t have it anymore I do miss it.

    • @bluwng
      @bluwng 7 месяцев назад

      Is the neck on the AV II as thin as a Classic Vibe?

    • @sponto25752
      @sponto25752 7 месяцев назад

      @@bluwng yes it is. The American Original 60s neck is quite a bit chunkier than the AVR2.

  • @rylieriley
    @rylieriley Год назад +8

    The American Vintage II definitely has a more aggressive tone that I think would be suitable for more styles of music. I do like the sound of the American Original as well, though, and I personally prefer a beefier neck. Both guitars are also very cool colors. A tough choice for someone to have to make for sure.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Agreed. I prefer the beefier necks too. Love the AVii but I do with the neck was a slight bit thicker like the AO.

    • @joehenry9787
      @joehenry9787 9 месяцев назад +1

      Is this not just the pups?

  • @giulioluzzardi7632
    @giulioluzzardi7632 Год назад +3

    If you use the Trem arm the Original stays in tune and that fatter neck resonates with the body perfectly. In any case we all know "You only miss them when they've gone" and they don't even make those "Originals" anymore. I bet they become sought after just for the neck. Awesome viddy, you basically had 2 many Guitars and that can happen to all Guitar players. When I was playing full time I would use anything thst I could get my mitts on and tried my best to get it to work. With all the choice available now we split hairs. Your dilemma is rampant amongst all musos now. Thanks.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Great synopsis. Yeah I love the AO neck. I’ll grab another some day. Lately I’ve been on a quest to collect all the strats in the AVi and ii line, so I think that was part of the reason for keeping the 61.’ Like you, way back in my 20’s when I played for a living, my guitar (American standard strat) fell out of the back of my pickup and I was too poor to buy another nice one so I finished out my career with a hw1 strat that was donated to me. Never liked it. Now I’m grabbing all the stuff I wanted back then. The irony being that I only play in the bedroom now 😆

    • @giulioluzzardi7632
      @giulioluzzardi7632 2 месяца назад

      That's alright as long as you keep playing Guitar and enjoying yourself! I am going to try one of those AV2s though, the pickups might be where that "Mojo" lives? I might get the pickguard with those 59 pickups and stick it in the AO . Mine is Olympic white and after almost 5 years the paint is showing those fine hairline cracks so I have really have played the Fudge out of it and made it my own. It aint perfect but it has "Character".

  • @michaelharrington9966
    @michaelharrington9966 Год назад +3

    Loving the video's you are putting out Nick. Must admit, I have spent a lot of time looking at the Custom Shop options, but the AVII 1961 Start, has all the spec's I'm after (except, maybe different Fret's). Anyway, after watching your video's and several other youtuber's covering the AVII '61 Start, I have decided to give it a go, and have one on it's way (of course in Fiesta Red). My concern was the -'ve comments I have seen about QC, but I can get the AVII at less then half the cost of a CS in Australia, so nothing a bit of work cannot solve. Anyway, keep up the awesome content.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +2

      Ahh man, thank you!!
      About your AVii…. I wouldn’t worry about it. In my humble opinion 99% of all the internet noise about the QC issues is just that… Noise. I have 3 AVii’s with a fourth on the way, and the only real QC item I’ve noticed was the misalignment of the neck on the 61, but that was so, so minor, and I’m pretty sure the one I got was a returned floor model, so who knows what happened to that thing before it came to me. I think I’ve had maybe 2 or 3 guitars in my entire life be perfect right out of the box. Congratulations on the 61’ !! I can confidently say that if you like vintage spec guitars you’re going to love this one.

  • @HamHavoc
    @HamHavoc 11 месяцев назад +2

    One thing that people don't realize is how often will a shell pink nitro finish come along from fender? I feel like the shell pink strats are going to be worth a lot in the future.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  11 месяцев назад +2

      I’m really hoping they do a FSR AVii in shell pink.

    • @GundogJake
      @GundogJake 9 месяцев назад

      I’ve owned my 60 CS Shell Pink Strat for at least ten years, I’ll have to keep an eye for the peeling nitro finish. Nothing so far though!

  • @scripteaze
    @scripteaze Год назад +24

    The best guitar is the one that feels great in your hands, period.

    • @jamiemorgan4146
      @jamiemorgan4146 Год назад +1

      And sounds best!

    • @scripteaze
      @scripteaze Год назад +1

      @@jamiemorgan4146 and looks the best. I mean, you need to "want" to pick it up

    • @kennethchambers9949
      @kennethchambers9949 11 месяцев назад +1

      Couldn't have said it better. I'm waiting on mine. The red one. Saved five hundred bucks on a demo,black Friday and Christmas sale all rolled in one. A couple more days.

    • @profile2047
      @profile2047 9 месяцев назад

      Yep. It doesn’t matter if it’s warped, has dead/wolf notes etc. it’s allll about how it feels in your hands. Period.

  • @sixbladeknife44
    @sixbladeknife44 Год назад +3

    I have the same pink Ame. Original, it’s a great guitar and I particularly enjoy the neck. I’m pretty sure mine has a high fret because it will fret out on big bends past the 15th fret (high E) unless I keep the action a little higher than I’d prefer. It does sound great though, the neck pup position sounds superb. That said, my older ‘62 Ame. Hot Rod is still my #1. Big fat neck, bigger than the Ame. Original and is def. the best sounding Strat I’ve ever owned. In fact, I’ve owned two of them over the years. I grew up playing the 7.25 radius also on an old MIJ 80’s ‘57 Reissue, so I know where you’re coming from…some players hate the vintage radius, but it still feels like home to me too when I pick one up, although sometimes they can be a bit tougher to bend on.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Hey I think I have that same guitar! Are you talking about a AVRI 62’ hot rod? I have that one too and I totally agree. BIG fat neck and very articulate sounding.

    • @sixbladeknife44
      @sixbladeknife44 Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreative Yup, I’ve owned two sherwood green ones…not letting go of the second one ever!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      @@sixbladeknife44 I’m jealous. What makes the one you’re keeping better than the other?

    • @sixbladeknife44
      @sixbladeknife44 Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreative I actually sold the other one years ago when I was going through my divorce, I absolutely did not want to sell it. But I always promised myself I’d find another nice condition one, it took a few years…it just sounds bigger, more open and more dynamic than the other one. Fender should reissue them, I really believe those were the best production line Strats ever built outside of the custom shop.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      I find pickup position 4 to be absolutely delectable on my 62’ hot rod. I don’t see those pop up very often for sale

  • @markc2761
    @markc2761 11 месяцев назад

    Great video, I enjoyed how you described the difference’s between the two and cool playing too. Thanks very much 😃🎸

  • @mikec3454
    @mikec3454 Год назад

    I have the shell pink AO 1960s Strat. I love the colour - it really evokes the 1960s design and flair to me.
    The neck profile is frickin’ amazing. I have it set perfectly and it just sounds amazing.

  • @tjchad1
    @tjchad1 Год назад +1

    I like the 7.25 radius also. My guitar is one of the earlier Road Work 50s and I LIKE the 7.25 radius with the soft V. Has the nice dark amber tint also. Kinda liking the looks of the AVii 61 slab though...

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      I’ve had a couple of the road worn series. They are indeed nice. Great value in those too seeing as how the next jump is straight to the custom shop if you want relicing

  • @arnolddealiii4259
    @arnolddealiii4259 Год назад +3

    Personally it’s splitting hairs but here’s my opinions.
    1. Fiesta red kills! End of contest!
    2. Why would I want a warmer sound I have a tone knob, you can’t add back bite if it’s warm to start with.
    3. I prefer a skinny neck over a fat neck
    4. 9.5” feels better to me. So egg shell pink for the sun here.
    5. Vintage 2 finger board I think looks a little darker but I could be wrong.
    Overall I think you kept the nicer guitar. I’m sure you’re thrilled either way!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Great points. Yeah couldn’t go wrong either way. It was the best problem to have !

    • @arnolddealiii4259
      @arnolddealiii4259 Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreative Absolutely!

  • @trusty1987
    @trusty1987 Год назад +1

    Can you do a comparison between the AV59 and the AVII61? I have the old one and love it....but didn't have the chance to play the new one yet :)

  • @deanallen927
    @deanallen927 Год назад +1

    Very well done comparison, though I like the pink one on every difference you pointed out. Keep that one, the 9 1/2" radius. I was raised on 7 1/4'" but in the '70s realized the 12" on a few friends' Gibsons was the deal, why they were so much easier to rip on a solo with. And a bit more meaty neck is nice. The pink isn't my cup of tea, but it just seems like a better guitar on several points, and I come from the old days when you'd go to a shop after a sunburst and leave with Olympic White because it was an extraordinary guitar. Prefer the more subtle tint of the pink one too. NICE JOB!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      I loved the pink color too! I'm sure I'll end up with another AO at some point

    • @deanallen927
      @deanallen927 Год назад +1

      @@NickHandleyCreative Actually it wasn't the color I liked, but you just made it sound like a better guitar to me, spec-wise.

  • @SwanSycorax
    @SwanSycorax Год назад

    I haven't listened to your conclusion / decision yet, but from the playing comparisons, I preferred the Vintage II (the red guitar) from what I could hear from your video recordings. Soundwise, that would get my vote. Now I will play on and see what you decided.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Correctomundo! AVii for the win in this particular case. I’m working on my long-windedness 😆😆😆

  • @iagobroxado
    @iagobroxado 11 месяцев назад

    Fiesta red is a fun color, like the name implies: it looks really bright red under certain lights, or pinkish-red under natural light to me... or even coral-ish (little more orange) at times.

  • @IDriveAnAudi
    @IDriveAnAudi Год назад +2

    I like the American Original better between the two and like the vintage tone. But I agree on the 7.25 radius and I also love Fiesta Red (just bought a fiesta red custom shop Jazzmaster). I know you’ve decided and it’s too late, but I would keep both. I still want a shell pink Fender!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Congratulations on the CS Jazzmaster. I’ll bet that’s absolutely incredible! Is it a 9.5” or 7.25” ?

    • @IDriveAnAudi
      @IDriveAnAudi Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreative It’s a 7.25 radius roasted maple neck and ebony fretboard.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      @@IDriveAnAudi oh my gosh. That’s next level! I was recently researching the idea of getting a custom made CS Strat to my specs, but apparently there’s about a 2 year wait for those 🤷🏻‍♂️, so I came off that idea.

    • @IDriveAnAudi
      @IDriveAnAudi Год назад +1

      @@NickHandleyCreative I went to a local shop last week that’s a custom shop dealer that ordered a run of 1962 vintage Stratocasters, Telecasters, Esquires, Jazzmaster and Jaguars for the store 65th anniversary in heavy relic vintage white and sapphire blue. So I went to try out a Jazzmaster for fun and was digging the vintage white one. Then he told me that they had a Fiesta Red one in the storeroom that wasn’t on the website, so of course I said I wanted to check it out. For some reason it was the only one of the three with the roasted maple neck and ebony fretboard, and it also clearly had a different shaped neck that fit my hand like a glove. So I bought it within minutes and had the shop check the setup and put on new strings. It’s a joy to play. Love your Stratocaster!!!

    • @giulioluzzardi7632
      @giulioluzzardi7632 Год назад +1

      I agree with you, that fat neck on the American Original" adds to bouncy sustain, I won't part with mine.

  • @GuitarShack
    @GuitarShack Год назад

    Just when I think I have a problem I watch your videos and realize that I do have a problem, but I’m not alone 😂
    Both look and sound great. A bad choice can’t be made. If the AVii is speaking to you then you made the right choice. Plus it’s part of your AVii collection. Just return the AO and walk away. You can do it Nick!

  • @peterlindsay3800
    @peterlindsay3800 7 месяцев назад

    I just brought one the USA original in white great guitar took it out from the case , all setup great guitar love it.

  • @reverb508
    @reverb508 9 месяцев назад

    The American Original series was really special. I love most things about vintage Fenders, but the small frets are a no-go. I can live with the 7.5" radius if it has bigger frets, but man is it awkward for me to play small frets on a vintage radius fretboard. I have a 57 AVRI Strat from 2012 and I love it to death, but man, playing that thing after my Gibsons is ROUGH. Probably gonna get it refretted soon with medium jumbo or 6105 fret wire.

  • @starshineraiser6729
    @starshineraiser6729 6 месяцев назад +1

    My AV2 Strat neck is unbelievable. I love fat necks but it feels as good as my Custom Shop 63 neck, and much better than the AO 60’s that I owned. My AO 60’s Strat was not fun to play and the tone was lifeless. I felt guilty for selling it.
    My point is, go to GC and and play one. I’ve also got an AV2 Jazzmaster that is equally incredible.

  • @Lasaration
    @Lasaration Год назад +1

    I would go for the pink one because its pink! Great vid by the way!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      The pink was awesome! I loved how it looked with the mint pickguard and aged pickups too.

  • @vepex7305
    @vepex7305 Год назад +1

    dude how do I play like you xD Im new to guitar, only been playing for a year, not really learning music theory because I don't know where to start but I love what you played when trying out the vintage 2. What pentatonic was that on and what style is that phrasing?

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Right on! Nice of you to say. If I was teaching a person who’s been playing a year I’d say Dive into the major and minor pentatonics as these scales make up 95% of all guitar licks / riffs / noodling. I’d also say to pair the ‘lick learning’ with a deep dive into bar chords. IMO you can build an entire career out of these two things

  • @RubenStuveling
    @RubenStuveling Год назад

    Hey man, the AO is basically a 1965 Strat. It has the right logo, veneer board and pearl dots with the right spacing. I don’t know why Fender didn’t call it American Original 65 Strat, but my guess is the 9,5” radius.

  • @adammartin7007
    @adammartin7007 Год назад +1

    I briefly had both guitars too. I kept the American Vintage ii 1961. I love the neck profile. I also found it to be a lighter weight and the pickups were mellower.
    I didn't know they have quality control issues with the Vintage reissues.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      It’s hard to say, but personally I don’t think it’s as much of a quality control issue as a setup issue and/or minor imperfections. I have 2 strats in the AVii line and they are both pretty amazing.

    • @vyvynylification
      @vyvynylification Год назад

      You say the PV61's are mellower than the PV65's? If so, that'd be exactly what I'd look for. Something inbetween PV59 and PV65

  • @Foe1971
    @Foe1971 Год назад +1

    I now have a newfound appreciation of my Fender CS with its compound 7.25 to 9.5 inch fretboard. We shouldn’t have to choose, lol. Anyway, out of curiosity, what audio/video setup are you using? I could definitely hear the tonal difference through my 6th generation iPad mini. Kudos from a fellow GenXer.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Wow that’s intriguing. For some reason I’ve always written off the notion of a compound radius, but I guess it’s because I always assumed it would start pretty flat and get flatter. Had not ever even considered a 7.25 to 9.5…. I will surely have to try one. As for the audio video, on this one I think was just using my iPhone 13 Pro Max. The amp is a 65 reissue princeton reverb with a 12” speaker. Be well GenXer!!

  • @beestew79
    @beestew79 Год назад

    Cool video! I have the AO in Shell Pink and I love it, but those Fiesta Red Strats keep tempting me.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +2

      Yeah they’re both sweet. They still have the AO that I returned in stock. I’m seriously considering grabbing it again

    • @beestew79
      @beestew79 Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreative do it! Lol.

  • @freeed2722
    @freeed2722 Год назад

    Nice guitars! Just wanted to mention, that the am original 60s is not a hybrid of 60 specs but a 65 with flatter fretboard radius.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Oh gotcha. That makes sense. Its because of this AO ‘60’s that I grabbed a AVii 65. Love the fat neck!

  • @comicsrcool5483
    @comicsrcool5483 Год назад +2

    I had the same dilemma. Kept them both. They may both be trying to be Vintage guitars but the AO is more Vintage Modern and the AVII is Vintage Classic. Whatever way you go I hope it works out. Sad to say but someone would have to pry them out of my hands!!

  • @Annunaki_0517
    @Annunaki_0517 9 месяцев назад

    Damn I wish I had seen this earlier. I would have bought the shell pink strat in a heartbeat. Looking for one exactly like that.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  9 месяцев назад

      At the time of writing this reply they have one for sale on the guitar center website for $1599

  • @Pegasus4213
    @Pegasus4213 5 месяцев назад

    The vintage 61 two just has some magic the 60s doesn't have. My trouble is I hate red guitars! 🙂 Nice demo!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  5 месяцев назад +2

      @@Pegasus4213 I generally have the same sentiment toward red guitars. The fiesta red, though, just has something cool about it. I honestly don’t even see red when I look at it.

  • @vaibanez17
    @vaibanez17 Месяц назад

    I played a AV2 61 at Guitar Center and the high E kept slipping if I went up high and tried to bend.

  • @CraigFlowersMusic
    @CraigFlowersMusic 8 месяцев назад

    I had the exact misaligned neck issue on my Vintage ii, only my high E was even farther off the fretboard. Same exact guitar, same color and everything. My hypothesis, since I got it from Sweetwater and could see the neck was seated fine in the photos, is that since they come in a vintage case, it must have shipped handle-down. Have a look, and you'll see there's no support for the bass-side cutaway bout if it's facing down in a truck. So technically, I don't think that's a QC issue -- but just when we're talking vintage cases. It's just a theory, but if I look at the neck support pad bevel in the case, it's been smashed leftward a bit by the stress. Have a look and let me know if your case shows the same stresses, and I'll bet that's what went wrong.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  8 месяцев назад +1

      Real talk - my case is buried and mixed in with a bunch of other cases in my garage, so I don’t have the will to go dig it out, but I will say that I had the same thing happen with a used Strat I got on reverb. The pictures specifically showed a tight neck pocket, but when the guitar arrived the high E string was hanging off the board and there was a huge gap in the neck pocket. I blame shipping

  • @gregkuper1387
    @gregkuper1387 Год назад

    Started the video rooting for the Shell Pink ‘60’s, but when you played them, there was an audible mojo in the AVII that I could feel even from here. Both sweet guitars, but that Dakota Red one seems special.

    • @gregkuper1387
      @gregkuper1387 Год назад

      Oops-Fiesta Red! Of course it’s Fiesta!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      It was a tough choice for sure. 2 weeks later I’m feeling like a made the right decision, but I’m still thinking about pinky a bit.

    • @RideAcrossTheRiver
      @RideAcrossTheRiver Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreative The AO had fatter tone. Extra wood and those pickups.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      @@RideAcrossTheRiver 3 months later now and I am missing pinky!

    • @RideAcrossTheRiver
      @RideAcrossTheRiver Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreative I really want a white AO Strat. They're around but never close enough!

  • @TH-pq3ly
    @TH-pq3ly 10 месяцев назад

    The pink one sounds the best of the two, based just on this audio.
    I also, REALLY want a shell pink fender, have for years.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  10 месяцев назад

      At the time I preferred the AVii, but man I sure do wish I just kept the pink one too. It was really nice

  • @JoseCanihuante
    @JoseCanihuante 2 месяца назад

    I just went to a store to try it out, and it had 3 issues: 1st, the E string kept choking from the 12th fret when bending it, 2nd the tip of the pickup switch kept falling, which never happened with my previous strata and 3rd, I found the rosewood to be pale (though it was very dry, so maybe it was because of that)
    I would like to know where are your thoughts on this and if you had any of these issues? Thanks

  • @erickmo1188
    @erickmo1188 Год назад +1

    I’d have to say keep both. Return the AO and put it on a gear card, financing it for 24 months. And then you could keep both without too much of a hit. I think the AO is closer to a custom shop spec and is also essentially a John Mayer signature spec other than big dippers pickups. Same neck profile, vintage spec, 9.5 radius. Once people catch on to that, these AOs will continue to climb in price on the used market.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Yeah in retrospect I probably should have just kept it. The gear card trick is pretty maxed out at this point otherwise I would have absolutely gone that route

    • @erickmo1188
      @erickmo1188 Год назад +1

      @@NickHandleyCreative in the end, it’s all about what ultimately makes you lick up the guitar and play it more. Whether it’s the 7.25 radius or the neck shape, if you’re happy then you picked the right one. I have several of the AO models and they’re bangers. I too had a few QC things on my AVRIii tele but fixed it myself.

  • @turnsufficient4971
    @turnsufficient4971 Год назад +2

    I liked the pink one, but it's just my liking.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      I loved the pink one too. In retrospect I should have just not eaten for a few weeks so I could have kept them both 😂

  • @nickpatsios407
    @nickpatsios407 Год назад

    I went through a period where I stayed away from the 7 1/4 radius next, but I find myself playing my Strat with the 7 1/4 radius neck more. It just feels more broken in or something once it’s set up right works fantastic. That’s the thing you can have a crappy set up on a 9 1/2 and I’ll still play OK but if you have a crappy set up on the 7 1/4 ouch.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Totally agree. Whenever I get a guitar with a 7.25 I find myself fiddling with the setup for quite a while before I find the sweet spot. I do love them though. Something very satisfying about the rounded board.

  • @joemichielli1908
    @joemichielli1908 Месяц назад

    great review

  • @tonybrown7847
    @tonybrown7847 Год назад +1

    That’s a tough choice but to me the pink one just sounds better but it’s more than just tone. It’s up to the playability in the end

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Yeah that pink AO was awesome. I basically ended up splitting the difference. Returned the AO and found an. AVi 65 which feels almost the same but has the 7.25” that I like

  • @rockdanger
    @rockdanger Год назад

    Can't believe all the love for the 7.25 radius... every one I ever played was unusable... fretting out whenever you go for some big bends at the 12th fret or higher. There's a reason why they don't make 'em like that anymore.

  • @TG-vg3qe
    @TG-vg3qe 2 месяца назад

    I've tried both in GC and prefered the 61. I like a round neck no matter the thickness and the 60's just had too much shoulder. The 60's also seemed heavier and darker sounding whereas the 61 is more resonate.

  • @llwonder
    @llwonder Год назад +1

    I think I'd choose the '60s in candy apple. But they basically don't exist anymore. I can't find them on used market. The AVII sounds ok but I'd much rather have different truss rod location + 9.5 in radius is my preference. I really love that fiesta red color though, it looks perfect.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      The pictures and videos don’t do the fiesta red justice imo. It has nuances in person that don’t translate to images.

    • @hideawayblues
      @hideawayblues Год назад +1

      Check the gear page. There is a 60's in candy apple there.

    • @giulioluzzardi7632
      @giulioluzzardi7632 Год назад +1

      You'll find one. There are alredy loads of AV2 for sale used and little or no AO 60s, that must say something.

  • @charleshettich7396
    @charleshettich7396 Год назад +1

    The avii just has an addictive sound

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Agreed. Something so very quintessential ‘Strat’ sound with the AVii

  • @Harrisabd
    @Harrisabd 3 месяца назад

    Interesting colours, my AO has no where near as much yellowing on the maple parts, and the red on the vintage ii looks candy apple rather than fiesta red.

    • @bruceman9581
      @bruceman9581 Месяц назад +1

      It's actually different in different lightning. On the video it's captured like a darker red.

  • @f100strato2
    @f100strato2 5 месяцев назад

    Nick, you looked more at home and sounded better/smoother on the Original 60's. I get it you chose the vintage if you like the 7.25 neck. Everyone should have one 7.25 Strat.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  5 месяцев назад +1

      Now that it’s a year later, I really wish I had kept both guitars. That pink AO was really quite amazing.

  • @brycewaddingham3266
    @brycewaddingham3266 Год назад

    Love my original 60s bought the telecaster as well personal choice great video 🤘

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      I have the AO 60’s telecaster and when I die they will have to pry that thing out of my cold dead hands because i absolutely love that thing.

    • @carpetcrawler79
      @carpetcrawler79 Год назад

      ​@@NickHandleyCreativeI bought one of the very last one made. Love that Tele so much.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      @@carpetcrawler79 yep. That one is one of my lifer guitars for sure. Love the double-bound body. Surprised they didn’t do that on the AVii’s

  • @calvinevans6347
    @calvinevans6347 Год назад

    I'd keep the pink one if i were you, bro. I enjoyed the sound of it a little more than the other.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Sound advice. 3 months later I kinda wish I would have just kept them both

  • @jamesmcgrath6938
    @jamesmcgrath6938 10 месяцев назад

    How is it that the original 60’s in the US have a tinted finish? I found the Original 60’s is pretty much a 65’ Strat. I’m yet to try the 61.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  10 месяцев назад

      Yeah it is pretty similar to the ‘65 AVi. The AO is also pretty similar to the older AVRI ‘62 Hot Rod.

  • @marknielson2099
    @marknielson2099 Год назад

    Like you, love the 7.25 radius which all my Strats have with the exception of one. My problem is I keep them ! Oh well….

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      There’s got to be worse problems than guitar collecting, right? …. At least that’s what I try to tell my wife 😆

  • @craigthomson3621
    @craigthomson3621 Год назад

    If you like thick necks I hope you have an AO ‘50s Strat - it’s a baseball bat! I have both the AO ‘60s and the AVII’61. The QC issue on the AVII’61 was a neck pocket crack in the lacquer. I took the neck off and there is no crack in the wood so it is just a minor cosmetic flaw. BTW why do Fender Strats sound better acoustically once you have removed and refitted the neck? I’m a lefty so the AO’60s Strat came in just one boring colour so the AV11’61 in Fiesta Red certainly wins in the looks department - but they are both great guitars.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Yes! I’ve tried the AO 50’s neck. It was the profile I was hoping the AVii 57 had, which it didn’t, but then I grabbed a 56 in the AVi series and it has the big fat AO neck. I love it !

  • @mule71
    @mule71 Год назад +1

    Great video! I see from other comments that you also have an AV 59 Strat. Do you prefer the AVii 61 over the AV 59?

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      They’re so different it’s hard to say. The 59 is definitely a little edgier and it’s also a little slinkier on the strings, but the 61 has some type of unexplainable character that I haven’t quite been able to put my finger on yet. Considering I paid way more than I should have for the 59’ I’d probably pick that one overall if for no other reason than to justify the cost.

  • @mikebarnard2689
    @mikebarnard2689 Месяц назад

    He didn’t remove the neck… he said “ just the seating “ which means loosened off… but I agree he did say he took it off… but he didn’t !!😀

  • @ramonm387
    @ramonm387 Год назад +1

    Tengo una original 60 y una vintage ii 57, son tan distintas que se quedan ambas en casa, pero no me compraré la '61. Gracias por el vídeo!

  • @markeyhendrix
    @markeyhendrix Год назад

    I prefer the neck size on the 60s vintage but that red vintage 2 is gorgeous, quite a dilemma haha

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Yeah I loved the neck of the 60’s AO. Nice and fat like the 65

  • @gnoogie
    @gnoogie Год назад

    7.25 always made more sense on a fender guitar to me. Like, for a gibson, you get a wider (i know its flatter technically but it feels wider at the same time) radius but also shorter overall distance, then for fender you get a skinny-er radius at the cost of a longer fretboard so you have to stretch more.
    Having both a longer fretboard AND a wider radius makes the guitar needlessly harder to play IMO.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      I haven’t picked up any of my gibsons for a while now, but I have a feeling it’s gonna be a bit of an adjustment period to get used to the 12” radius again after being on a 7.25” kick over the last 6 months

    • @gnoogie
      @gnoogie Год назад

      ​@@NickHandleyCreative Gibson style fretboards are pretty comfy. it's what I started on. definitely it's own thing.
      Like you, I definitely feel more at home on 7.25 in recent memory. 9.5 feels way too big in my tiny lil baby hands.
      Also fiesta red is such a sick color LOL. I know exactly what you mean when you say it's more coral in person. Might be my favorite strat color.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      @@gnoogie yeah I love the fiesta. I have a AVi 65 in Dakota red , which is also nice, but the fiesta with the clay dots is so so beautiful

  • @alexgarnett5373
    @alexgarnett5373 Год назад +1

    I would honestly think about getting the previous American vintage (pure vintage ) that fender discontinued to make way for the original series .. either a 59 or a 65.. I have a 65 it’s the closest I’ve played to a vintage one. Plus they hold value really well

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Yeah I have the 59 thin skin in sonic blue and I love it. I’m on the hunt for the 65 too. Is the neck on the 65 pretty chunky?

    • @alexgarnett5373
      @alexgarnett5373 Год назад +1

      @@NickHandleyCreative yes but only as you go higher up the neck as it as the vintage taper. It’s the sound of the 65 that’s great think Hendrix at Monterey very punchy. good luck with the hunt you’ll find one as right handed I’m a lefty and it took ages to find mine

  • @TREVORJB101
    @TREVORJB101 Год назад +18

    Keep the '61

  • @EdVanMeyer
    @EdVanMeyer 11 месяцев назад

    The 61 has the best pre-CBS neck, I had a real 61 some years back. Also the 61 is a slab board the 65 type in pink has a 'veneer board' you'll see it is curved more at the nut.

  • @frankswildyear
    @frankswildyear Год назад

    I agree with you, the red one sounded much better!

  • @scottreynolds6317
    @scottreynolds6317 Год назад +1

    I LOVE my American Vintage II ‘61 Strat!!!! I got the Olympic White one and it has MOJO!!!!!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      They are sweet! I have the 57’ as well and that one is awesome too.

  • @brucerichard2904
    @brucerichard2904 Год назад

    They both sound great, but the VII gets my vote for sound.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Yeah I think that’s what did it for me too. To my ears the AVii had a little more sparkle and the AO had a little more warmth.

  • @denbodg9311
    @denbodg9311 Год назад

    Ha, good choice, you’ve bonded with the ‘61 immediately. That speaks volumes.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Yes I love it for sure!

    • @denbodg9311
      @denbodg9311 2 месяца назад

      @@NickHandleyCreativeI’ve come back to you after a year, because I didn’t mention that I also have Fiesta Red Vii, which came perfect straight from the box with no issues. Also, I’ve since acquired a 2012 ‘62 AVRI in Olympic White, which is the predecessor of the Vintage 60’s. That is the 1998-2012 version of the AVRI’s, so one of the last. I can compare it to my ‘61 Vintage 2 like yours, & strangely the pickups sound the opposite to your comparison. The ‘62 definitely sounds snappier, slightly more aggressive. Otherwise the feel & quality is almost identical, It’s a great guitar, but my ‘61 Vii is still my go to. Incidentally, I’m lucky to have owned a 1982, ‘57 2 Tone Sunburst AVRI since 2008, which is a fantastic guitar, first year Fullerton made Vintage Reissue. The pickups on that sound very like the ‘62, but with the Fullerton contours & well worn nitro feels like the proper vintage guitar that it is. That said, I won’t be selling any of them. 👍🎸

  • @markellis8621
    @markellis8621 Год назад +1

    Definitely 100% keep the Vintage 61 it sounds nicer.

  • @GerryBlue
    @GerryBlue Год назад +2

    Red Strats all the way!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      Indeed. I liked the pink too, but the fiesta red has its own thing going on that is hard to resist!

  • @RideAcrossTheRiver
    @RideAcrossTheRiver Год назад

    How does the Pro II compare to the American Original 60s?

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      I couldn’t speak to the pro ii but i do own a pro i. I like the AO better. I’m not a fan of those V-Mod pickups in the AM pro series. So incredibly bright!

    • @RideAcrossTheRiver
      @RideAcrossTheRiver Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreative I have a Pro I Tele I got used. I have a Duncan Hot Rhythm I put in it and will put in Hot Stack bridge soon! Excellent neck!

  • @chrisfain3612
    @chrisfain3612 8 месяцев назад

    I feel completely the opposite. I felt like my American original had more of the custom feel to it. Pinning the strings was easier. I do have a couple of guitars with 7 1/4 inch but there’s just something about the American originals Mojo for me.

  • @charleshettich7396
    @charleshettich7396 Год назад

    My American pro ii just got sold on reverb. After getting the avii it’s just sounded terrible to me. The American pro ii has some nice modern features that I liked and I miss, but I just came to hate the sound of it

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      I think I know what you mean. I have an an American Pro i that I’m trying to sell (I actually have a video up of me demoing it) and it’s pretty bright. It’s a surf green limited edition strat that looks so cool, but I’ve just never been able to fully bond with it.

  • @OdinHammersmith
    @OdinHammersmith Год назад

    Tough choice but I would pick the pink for me, red for you. Enjoy 🎸🎶🎶🎶🎶

  • @STF_YVR
    @STF_YVR Год назад

    I have an AVII ‘61 and I like it but I will never sell my AO 60s in shell pink … there is something about these ‘65 pickups

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Yeah my resolution to myself was that I was going to return the AO and search out a 65’ in the 2012-2017 American vintage line. I think the 60’s AO used the 65 pickups and neck profile (don’t quote me on that).

  • @Daniel-j4z4v
    @Daniel-j4z4v 3 месяца назад

    I LOVE MY FENDER STRATOCASTER AMERICAN ORIGINAL 60S... BEST GUITAR EVER MADE,,,

  • @PuttinOnTheRiffs
    @PuttinOnTheRiffs Год назад

    The red one is the winner for sure. Pink one sounds lifeless in comparison

  •  15 дней назад

    Got the AV2 pretty nice for 2 grand. Like my ultras better but both have their place.

  • @CristianGarcia-vz9sm
    @CristianGarcia-vz9sm Год назад +1

    AMERICAN ORIGINAL 60´S!!! The best guitar ever.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Yeah I kind of regret bringing that one back. Only returned it because I was feeling a bit of a financial pinch at the time due to a flare up in gear purchasing.

  • @marfg12345
    @marfg12345 Год назад +1

    The neck of the AVII is way too tinted, it's literally bright orange. In 10 - 20 years it will be red after it naturally yellows some more.

  • @kdrake777
    @kdrake777 Год назад +1

    60’s Original for the win.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      No doubt that was one of the harder decisions I’ve had to make in my life of guitar. The American original was indeed sweet.

  • @mmatthewias280
    @mmatthewias280 Год назад

    Everybody on here talking about radius, for me fret size has always been a bigger issue. If you give me any guitar with 6105 (narrow tall) frets I’m just gonna give it back to you. Medium jumbo is my favorite but Fender is using them less and less. I can “get along” with any except the 6105s, feel like railroad tie/speed bumps moving around the neck. Why they used the CBS transition logo on AO 60s is just a bone headed and out of touch move from Fender for people who want “vintage style” strats.

  • @guitarandotherthings6090
    @guitarandotherthings6090 Год назад

    You can always take neck off and sell it and buy an AO 60s neck, even today the necks sell new.

  • @kurtlonde5892
    @kurtlonde5892 Год назад

    only the red.....!!
    sounds really good
    the pink didn t have this good ton...

  • @GrahamMylett
    @GrahamMylett 9 месяцев назад

    My AO 60's Stratocaster is the best Strat I've ever played.

  • @aRRRaiS
    @aRRRaiS Год назад +2

    Good choice ! 1961 all the way American Original sounds more like a modern strat. By the way 9.5” radius is awful to handle :P

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      I did really like the AO, but imo the AVii just has more personality. And yes I definitely do prefer the 7.25” radius over the 9.5”

    • @aRRRaiS
      @aRRRaiS Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreativeHi Nick i have a one specific question about `61 can i hit You on priv somewhere ?

  • @elducko1951
    @elducko1951 Год назад

    Personally, I'd keep the red Strat.
    It just looks better to me.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Yep me too, although I like the pink too. Did end up keeping the red one

  • @josepharnone6842
    @josepharnone6842 Год назад

    Keep the fiesta red, it sounds better and you might appreciate the skinnier neck as you get older

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      Good call. It's nice to have some variety too. Most of my guitars have huge necks and the more I play this one the more I like the slightly thinner shape

  • @mikelundquist4596
    @mikelundquist4596 4 месяца назад +1

    I've had a lot of guitars... red ones sound better.

  • @jap5451
    @jap5451 Год назад

    I had the same 2 guitars. I sold the V2. I didn't like the neck.

  • @stevenkimsey7039
    @stevenkimsey7039 7 месяцев назад

    Keep both of them. A year later you won't even think about the money

  • @vyvynylification
    @vyvynylification Год назад +1

    American original is the one for me. Spec wise, it's basically a custom shop. Sadly, the AO60s doesn't exist in a color I like and the AVII 7.25 radius is... Not my cup of tea let's say.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад +1

      I never would have gravitated toward a pink guitar, but when I saw it in person it was really cool. You’re right. Basically custom shop specs. Actually, if I was blindfolded and someone put this AO in my hands and told me it was a custom shop strat I would have 100% believed it. Thing was sweet

    • @vyvynylification
      @vyvynylification Год назад

      @@NickHandleyCreative Is it still for sale? And where exactly is it for sale then because I can't find it anywhere? And yeah, I'm kinda hoping it's one of these colors you have to see in person, like fiesta red or texas tea.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      @@vyvynylification I just looked on the guitar center website and unfortunately it looks like it finally sold. There’s definitely a few on reverb though.

    • @vyvynylification
      @vyvynylification Год назад

      ​@@NickHandleyCreativesad... None to be found at all. I've been scouting reverb for about 10 months and never saw one. I'm from EU though

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      @@vyvynylification a couple sunburst on the guitar center website at the moment. They look pretty reasonable in terms of price. Good luck!

  • @bobpedone6168
    @bobpedone6168 4 месяца назад

    Looks like the High E is still hanging off that V-II Really pisses me off I have a 5K Custom shop strat with the same issue....I guess that really is period correct!

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  4 месяца назад

      @@bobpedone6168 this particular issue didn’t bother me. Could have just gotten bumped or loose screw or something. That said, I too have had issues 2 custom shop strats that I bought. This bothered me

  • @guokai275
    @guokai275 10 месяцев назад +2

    like AO60 better

  • @julestielens6988
    @julestielens6988 Год назад

    I have a 62. So much better than a modern one. I hear that here also

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      A real 62, or an American vintage reissue ?

    • @Musicsports
      @Musicsports Год назад

      I have the AVRI 62' as well. Nice guitar. 7.25 Radius and 3 way switch.

    • @NickHandleyCreative
      @NickHandleyCreative  Год назад

      @@Musicsports I got to hold one of those the other day. It was awesome! I have the AVRI 62’ hot rod which has a big fat neck but a 9.5” radius. I wish it had the 7.25 because I’ve grown to love that

  • @tabularasa7775
    @tabularasa7775 9 месяцев назад

    AND taking a neck off a strat with a nitro finish