The HHKB Layout: Revisited
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- Last time, I was pretty harsh on the HHKB's layout without actually putting in the effort to try it out. I went back for it for about a month, and I've changed my mind
Things shown in the video:
HHKB Professional 2 Type-S with BKE Redux Light domes
KBD66: 65g Zealios + GMK Nautilus
KBD661: Kailh Pro Purples + GMK Pristine
Aluminum Clueboard R1: Lubed Gateron Yellow + GMK SoWaRe
Weaven: Kailh Box Royal
GH60 in Revo One: Lubed 67g Zealios
B.Face x2: Mod-H + OG Cherry Doubleshot
High Profile Planck: Gateron Yellow in Zeal housing + GMK Mondrian
Pok3r: Cherry MX Blue
Some maple syrup
Instagram: / jymvideos
Reddit: / jymv
Join my Discord: / discord
Vim keybinds can help with a lot of your gripes with the hhkb layout
As a linux and vim user, this layout is perfect. a lot of smaller boards force the tilda and esc to the same key, which bothers me. Another change that a lot make is replacing or dropping the right super key, which makes window manager hotkeys harder to press; one-handed operations can become two-handed due to the overreliance on the left super key.
the only thing i don't like is the arrow keys on hhkb. I thought it makes way more sense to have it mapped to Secondary layer on HJKL (so mimicing vim movement keys). That's I ended up doing and i almost instantly got used to it because of so much muscle memory for using HJKL for movement in vim already. I suppose the position they're on in hhkb is a little more ergonomic and easier to press while holding down Fn on the right side, but still, hjkl is not that much worse.
The best review on the HHKB layout for programmers I've ever since! Thanks a lot!
Thank you. The perspective for vim users might be a little different but I've heard good things about that too.
vim would solve a lot of the problems you have with this layout. once you get used to it, i think you'll prefer it
indeed. I use nvim and have used this keyboard (and predecessors) for about 15 years it's a wonderful programming keyboard
@@programmer1356 did you do any remapping ? what do you have in the bottom row next to spacb. ?
@@hanazuki333 I'm not sure I know what you mean by re-mapping. I have neovim remappings if that is what you mean. On the keyboard itself the keys next to the space bar are alt and fn.
I liked the HHKB Lite2 arrows more than the HHKB Pro2 ones, as on the HHKB Lite2 there are not only actual arrow keys, but a function key on the left which is great for ergonomically operating the function-operated arrow keys.
you don't need arrow keys when you use Vim, the superior text editor (i guess).
btw i would use a 60% only if it is a HHKB or a layout inspired by it. I like your blue and grey keyboard! The real reason i want the keyboard is because of some parts of the layout, specially the backspace that makes the grave and tilde accent in a dedicated key. The control and caps lock swaped is useful but my main reason is the dedicated tilde key
You may like the Tokyo60 in aluminum. Same layout as HHKB in an aluminum case. It takes a bit of work to make it sound good but I love it.
Can you make a review for hhkb lite? Because it has dedicated directional/navigation keys and a second function key to the left. It would be great to hear your opinions
That would be pretty interesting. I'll look into it for sure!
what's your opinion on the board and layout now? do you still use it?
I'm pretty comfortable with it but I still prefer poker style 60 layouts. For the most part, I've regressed to just using 65% where I don't even need to use layers.
Guess I got lazy
box.. royals.. on the table.. and you're talking about the HHKB.. sheesh xD
NICE VIDEO!
vim please
Can you please PLEASE assemble your hhkb properly?
What is the board called that has the FC660C layout?
I featured these three: kbd66, kbd661, aluminum Clueboard
Most keyboards with 66 keys usually have that layout.
I buy the HHKB for the bluetooth
7018 Maddison Spurs
then i am here with iso De..................
the only good hhkb is the JIS version with hasu LOL
Vim rocks. Till you debug in something like Pycharm or Visual Studio. And then you look like a hipster who's shoes got puked on by some homeless dude on the subway.
Vimspector is an amazing Debugging Plugin for Vim
Use Vim or Emacs and you never have to worry about arrow keys again.
I confirm. Since i use VIM, i use my keyboards as a 60% (i have a Model M and a Rantopad MXX with red switches).
I plan to buy an HHKB when i will have moneys
I don't know...I use vim without the arrow keys but why omit the arrow keys still? I mean it does not take a lot of extra space to include them. The whole argument to leave out the arrow keys sounds a bit fanboyish to show I am so cool I don't need them.
I use vim but at the end, still have to scroll in excel / web browsers / logs over a webui in Kibana... so arrow keys are still useful to me.
BIG FACTS
I have to use a VIM to accommodate a keyboard?
I used to program C++ in VIM and had an HHKB. It was fine if you use and only use VIM for everything, but that is not the case in the modern-day workflow for pretty much anyone. I need to use a web browser, IDE like IntelliJ, spreadsheet, and all those other tools. I'm pretty glad I gave my HHKb to a friend before I moved to a different country so now I can use a standard tkl keyboard to perform my tasks and not have to pretend the it's a cool keyboard.
The real problem with the HHKB is the price.
Absolutely not. Made in Japan, superior quality, extremely good QA, fantastic layout, best caps money can buy. And all that out of the box. The price is more than justified.
@@PaladinJenkis not actuay superior, layout depends, caps are pbt but thin, shitty abs spacebar
the typing feel wont be able to be mimicked by other boards but it's obvious that the price is ridiculous
By what standards is the price ridiculous? By yours? Thankfully not!
I repeat, it's made in Japan, has a fantastic QA, capacitive switch design that is basically going to last forever, best caps money can buy, no wobble, no scratchyness, brilliant layout and all that "out of the box" since 2003!
How is the price ridiculous considering all that? Come on man, have some common sense.
@@PaladinJenkis have you ever even read my comment? all the strengths of hhkb you suggest are actually overrated as fuck
also ive customized/build my several custom boards and hhkb's price does not look that big
however i'm saying the price doesn't fit the actual product
Don't argue about worth vs cost ever. No two people will land on the same judgement.
My experience with the HHKB changed drastically once I found the proper DIP switch settings. I have 2,3,4, and 6 all set to 1. This keeps the keyboard in Mac mode, switches backspace and delete, and sets the left meta key to Fn. This makes for the optimal setup in my opinion.
Btw if you set left meta key to fn, does the fn swapped to meta key or you have 2 fn?
@@slowtyper95 I don’t have the pro 2 anymore, but I’m pretty sure you then have 2 fn keys
@@CoreyStock i see. I do lot of text selection like ctrl shift home/end. So left fn should helps a lot
As a Vim user, I cannot see myself having Ctrl where I use Esc everyday constantly.
The HHKB layout is based on the Sun type 5 US/Unix layout. It makes sense to any unix user, especially anyone that used unix workstations in the 80s & 90s.
It’s if you use vim/emacs, then hhkb. Not if hhkb, then use vim/emacs.
Curious question, do you find any wobble on your right shift key with the HKKB's that you've tried?
VVHAT? NO Cursor Keys? How is that supposed to work? Did Steve Jobs have to approve this? I know, in the OLD days we had WordStar Ctrl-E/S/D/X for cursor movement out of the home row, but nowadays on a IBM Model M keyboard, that feel ARKANE. It IS TWO keypresses, just for 1 line up. That might have been good on an Apple II keyboard, but NOT on an IBM Model M.
All the vim cult users in the comment section...we get it, you are cool
60% keyboards are made for vim
May in hacker's world hacking is nothing but under cli
Can you have IJKL work as arrow keys by layering it with ctrl instead of fn?
There is no way to program the board in the stock form
@@JYMV what about with hasu controller?
Yes it should be totally possible with hasu. Though I found it a little weird to move Ctrl on it. I ended up just learning regular hhkb layout
What is the keyboard on 1:40? looks like Clueboard but has a different layout..?? Thank you!
KBD66, he also has a video on that one.
Pure maple syrup
2:46 Map FN to Alt.
hello can we be friands 🌹
cant seem to get the caps lock combination (fn + control) working is there any specific way Im meant to press them?
I believe caps lock is typically fn+tab
@@JYMV cheers man haha I figured it out apparently it has to be in mac or windows mode for the caps lock to work.
what is the name of the 660 layout board
Three here
The pointy one is Clueboard 66
The one that looks like an Enter key is KBD661
And the boring one is KBD66
What color did you get with the m60-a? I joined the GB too.
I joined that black one. Kuro I think? I'm not sure what set will look the best on it though.
I ordered black one too !!!
I still think Pok3r layout is better
I think your first analysis was not done from the point of view of the actual target user of the HHKB. As its name so proudly states: hackers, i.e. people passionate about computer programming. It is well known that the de-facto “hacker” system is *NIX, in any of its forms. Be it Linux, BSD or macOS. Many of the HHKB’s layout choices accommodate very well to this kind of user. Control where Caps Lock typically is is great for navigating in a terminal. If you’re on the Mac, the HHKB’s GUI and Alt positions is the default one. No need to swap them via software. The backspace’s position is easier to reach and a good decision. In the Mac most shortcuts are done via Command+, so Control is not as important as on Windows.
I’ve found that most people who complain about the HHKB’s layout are not *nix users. They are simply not the target for this board and should go find something else.
as a macOS user(unix w/ a nice UI), I disagree. If I have to use VIM or Emacs when I type on HHKB, that should be in the buyer's warning.
I used to have HHKB and it works OK in VIM, and only in VIM. The lack of arrow key makes it pretty much useless. That secondary layer for arrow key is freaking weird and unnatural. The only thing that makes sense on this keyboard is that ctrl is placed next to little finger.
5204 Hickle Avenue
23458 Wilkinson Union