Let 13n - 1 = c² for some c in N. The only way c² = -1 (mod 13) is for c = +/-5 (mod 13). So let c = 13u +/- 5 for some u in N. 13 n = c² + 1 13 n = 13.13 u² +/- 13.10 +25 + 1 n = 13 u² +/- 10 u + 2 Discriminant = 100 - 104 < 0 -> no solutions for u, nor for n. Done.
1. n must be odd, substitute n=2m+1 2. multiply all 3 numbers, you'll get polynomial in m, with constant term equal 38 and all other terms divisible by 4 3. 38 is 2 mod 4, all other terms will always be 0 mod 4, i.e. the product is always 2 mod 4 4. the product itself should be perfect square, so it must not be 2 mod 4 done
Let 13n - 1 = c² for some c in N. The only way c² = -1 (mod 13) is for c = +/-5 (mod 13). So let c = 13u +/- 5 for some u in N.
13 n = c² + 1
13 n = 13.13 u² +/- 13.10 +25 + 1
n = 13 u² +/- 10 u + 2
Discriminant = 100 - 104 < 0 -> no solutions for u, nor for n. Done.
Discriminant is 100 - 52(2 - n) for which solutions could exist. It is unreasonable to assume n = 0
@@moonlightcocktail You are right. I messed up.
Thanks
Thanks a lot!
Please explain the second proof again please.....
1. n must be odd, substitute n=2m+1
2. multiply all 3 numbers, you'll get polynomial in m, with constant term equal 38 and all other terms divisible by 4
3. 38 is 2 mod 4, all other terms will always be 0 mod 4, i.e. the product is always 2 mod 4
4. the product itself should be perfect square, so it must not be 2 mod 4
done
Isn't the coefficient 48? After all, multiplying all numbers for n=1 gives 48 which is divisible by 4.
Take n = 13 2 2 resptly
Crisp
Bring some animation video
First