fun fact but gidle do have official colors. cube rarely uses them anymore but it’s miyeon - black minnie - blue soojin - red soyeon - pink yuqi - green shuhua - yellow they previously used them for their first two mini album covers as well as photocard backs. I believe the last time we saw them officially acknowledged and used by cube was on the logo on each member’s individual dumdi dumdi teasers
Most ld channels already use their official colors, this channel though doesn’t use official colors for any group, so don’t expect them to use it anytime soon
But as far as I know, Shuhua really wants to get a few lines, because most of g-idle's songs contain English too and Shuhua is not very fluent in English, so that's why she doesn't want to take a lot of lines
Honestly, this line distribution isn't absolute accurate reflected cause Minnie wrote many songs, and in her own songs, she will usually sing more instead of title. Actually in Super lady Queencard Klaxon those title, she doesn't have lots part if you observed clearly. Btw, Those people who are saying Miyeon should sing more parts, the parts she sing always the chorus, it's memorable and attracting, sadly, chorus are always short. Anyway, Minnie is also a main vocalist, she totally deserved
Shuhua has a lovely voice but lacks confidence and stability. Soyeon gives her just enough lines for her to be confortable in the songs. People need to understand that idols are different, and as much as unfair line distributions exist Soyeon does the best she can for her members.
please stop saying this 💀 idk why y'all still believe in this. Like, Shuhua's korean pronunciation improved so much since 2020 but people still spreading this lie
100's Miyeon: Maze Minnie: Maze Soyeon: Don't Text Me Soojin: What's In Your House Yuqi: What's In Your House Shuhua: Relay 200's Miyeon: Hear Me Minnie: Hear Me Soyeon: Hann Soojin: Hann Yuqi: What's Your Name Shuhua: Lion 300's Miyeon: Put It Straight Minnie: Relay Soyeon: What's Your Name Soojin: Put It Straight Yuqi: Light My Fire Shuhua: Hwaa 400's Miyeon: Help Me Minnie: Put It Straight Soyeon: Give Me Your Soojin: Uh-Oh Yuqi: I'm The Trend Shuhua: Tomboy 500's Miyeon: Light My Fire Minnie: Uh-Oh Soyeon: Light My Fire Soojin: Lion Yuqi: Moon Shuhua: Escape 600's Miyeon: Luv U Minnie: For You Soyeon: Lion Soojin: I'm The Trend Yuqi: Last Dance Shuhua: Change 700's Miyeon: Tung Tung Minnie: Luv U Soyeon: Luv U Soojin: Hwaa Yuqi: Polaroid Shuhua: Queencard 800's Miyeon: Moon Minnie: Tung Tung Soyeon: Tung Tung Yuqi: Liar Shuhua: Peter Pan 900's Miyeon: Last Dance Minnie: Moon Soyeon: Lost Yuqi: Change Shuhua: Tall Trees 1000's Miyeon: Already Minnie: Dahlia Soyeon: Tomboy Yuqi: Dark (X-File) Shuhua: 7Days 2000's Minnie: Doll Soyeon: Rollie
1. Minnie = Producer & Main Vocalist 2. Soyeon = Producer , Center , Main Rapper 3. Yuqi = Producer , Lead Vocalist 4. Miyeon = Main Vocalist 5. Shuhua = Sub Vocalist 6. Soojin 🕊️= Former Member (Main Dancer)
Don't take this as a hate comment,but when you use "🕊" it's like Soojin p@ssed away or something and it will probably confuse many baby Neverlands, so please delete the emoji!❤️
minnie: producer & main vocalist soyeon: producer, leader, center, main rapper & sub vocalist yuqi: producer, fotg, main dancer, sub vocalist & sub rapper miyeon: lyricist, main vocal & visual shuhua: sub vocalist, visual & maknae soojin: main dancer, sub vocalist & sub rapper
None of the members care about the line distribution and had always put trust on whoever fits the line will always get it. I don't get people when they say they deserve better than another member. I would not like to see members like Miyeon and Minnie straining themselves go do something like Super Lady, or Yuqi getting high pitched lines and even Shuhua as well. They're all placed perfectly based on how good they sound and I'm glad that as a group they're happy with that.
The ot5 distribution is hilarious, like seriously??? One of the main vocal at the top and the other main vocal who is th group's best Vocalist at bottom 2???
Honestly it's not that ridiculous since there are only 5 members and Idle has a lot of raps so it makes sense that the main rapper is also part of top 3 and Yuqi has a pretty standout voice they've been incorporating a lot in their more recent songs - obviosly it'd make more sense if Miyeon was part of top3 but it's also not that horrible either
I wish someone would made one of these but including the OT5 version of OT6 songs and their covers live Abracadabra and That Thart + their add songs like Ninety Nine. I feel like the results would be way more even (I dont think its on purpose but I find it treally interesting how Shuhua actually gets many lines in songs that aren't idles. She is one of the tops in both the mentioned covers AND Ninety Nine).
Well, g idle used to have cute/normal concepts, but when Soojin left the group got more bold. Miyeon suits the cute/normal concepts so that’s why she has less lines ot5
That's not an excuse for miyeon having less lines if that's the reason Than shuhua who has a voice tone similar to miyeon is often getting more lines than her in some songs and yuqi who has a deep voice and lead vocalist is also getting more than her @@asho2645
@@asho2645not really, they had cute concepts like dumdi dumdi a few times but they had mostly dark concepts, they do cute concepts post soojin as well, arguably more often (allergy, klaxon) plus songs like nxde fit Miyeons voice perfectly
Average Line Distribution per song Minnie: 32 | 20.4% (-2.2% all members; -4.2% current members only) Soyeon: 30.3 | 19.3% (-2.1% all members; -3.9% current members only) Miyeon: 27.9 | 17.8% (-1.9% all members; -3.6% current members only) Soojin (+2): 26.5 | 16.9% (+9% all members) Yuqi (-1): 24.4 | 15.5% (-1.7% all members; -3.2% current members only) Shuhua (-1): 15.9 | 10.1% (-1% all members; -1.9% current members only) Variation: 21.9% (-13.6% all members; -3% current members only) Color of Zone: Green (Used to be Yellow for all members)
I think she has been getting treated a main vocalist a lot more recently like in heat and I sway I would say those albums and maybe I made and I am and 2 are the ones were she is treated as the best vocal in the group
@@DifanMIYA7 because in the past comebacks she's the least member who fitted the concept. And you know how well (G)I-DLE makes use of their concept. In tomboy, nxde, and queencard era miyeon had the second least lines. In Heat album, 2, and I sway, she had most of the lines, why? Because she's the one who fitted the most. And wdym by she's not main vocalist anymore, she's still the best vocalist in the group, and she already proved it with her solo album.
Ya’ll calm your tits its almost perfect in ot5 and ot6 is literally not the biggest difference but mostly yuqi and minnie getting more lines and they write songs too! + shushu got more lines as well. And Miyeon has been treated decently well in 2-3 albums so fair
Miyeon, the main vocalist, having just 9 first places in their whole discography, being 4th in the OT5 distribution is EMBARRASSING. C'mon Cube, treat your artists better than this
Do realize that Miyeon usually loses the ranks by a few seconds in most of the OT5 comebacks. It's not as unfair as the rankings may make it seem like. Plus, (G)I-DLE loves cool delivery spoken/rap parts in their songs, especially as of late. Soyeon clearly prefers Miyeon's singing tone to her speaking/rapping tone most of the time, which limits Soyeon's use cases for her. Not to say her spoken parts don't come to play! She just tends to have a much cuter tone, and Soyeon has to work extra hard to get bad girl energy from Miyeon, and that's okay!! Her cute tone worked so well on Queencard, and she pulled off some of those bad girl mannerisms in Super Lady! It also has to do with Soyeon wanting to make her members shine equally, and it's objective that each member has different skills in different amounts, so Soyeon incorporates the members according to those skills. Miyeon is an INCREDIBLE vocalist and would outshine all the other members if she had more parts, imo. Her "slightly shorter" sung parts tend to make her shine plenty without outshining other members.
Why? Soyeon is main rapper, which is a vocal main position just like main vocalist + she's the center and best performer - she shouldn't be that far down. It's fair as it is.
Why should the main rapper and center have less than one of two main vocalists? Both are equally important main vocal roles and all three mains are in the top three. Why only complain about Soyeon?
@@avut2001 Bruh, she is good, and yh you are obviously a hater and idc, I will support my shuhua cuz she is super talented, ofc nobody can be talented like her, for example like u , you are a bad person that makes you bad in everything ugly hater, idc about your opinion shuhua is pretty, talented, good person and more, things like u don’t have LMAO…😂😂😂
@@avut2001Yh she is good, better than u, and she have visuals, she can sing,rap and she is also a good person, not like you!! All haters are bad which make you bad at everything, you use your “time” you hate in yt or any other platform, like bro, if your fav singer receive that hate what you will do? Get mad? Sad? Or maybe you don’t even have feeling sense…
1) No one in music academia is using that stupid ranking and none of the RUclips vocal "experts" knows what they are talking about (otherwise, they'd been busy making money by coaching instead of having to rely on fan biased RUclips videos). 2) Vocal technique and musicality really are not important for Kpop - no one in Gidle is a skilled technical vocalist. The lines distributions are based on tone and versatility: Miyeon is not a worse singer than Minnie, but she has a less distinct and genre versatile tone than Minnie and Yuqi. She also doesn't compose and probably has less interest in singing/music than the producer line. I'm sure no one in Gidle gives a fuck about line distribution and who has millisecond more in one song
fun fact but gidle do have official colors. cube rarely uses them anymore but it’s
miyeon - black
minnie - blue
soojin - red
soyeon - pink
yuqi - green
shuhua - yellow
they previously used them for their first two mini album covers as well as photocard backs. I believe the last time we saw them officially acknowledged and used by cube was on the logo on each member’s individual dumdi dumdi teasers
Most ld channels already use their official colors, this channel though doesn’t use official colors for any group, so don’t expect them to use it anytime soon
So you mean I can do the rainbow with them?
Soojin
Shuhua
Yuqi
Minnie
Soyeon
Miyeon
@@yanlynnie wdym this channel literally uses twice, red velvet, and even ive colors all the time 😭
@@yanlynnie I also don’t care if they use them or not I just wanted to point it out since they weren’t used and most people don’t know they exist
@@statesofgracie that’s only two groups out of idk amount of groups they’ve done (they’ve used misamo official colors but not twice)
Other members: ↗↗↘↘
Meanwhile Shuhua: ➡➡
=))))
Yall sitting here crying about this seem to forget that a lot of the time they have a say on what lines they want
So trueee
soojin bar turns gray in the first half of the video 😢
I'm gonna cry 💔
Shuhua is not so bad in the OT5 line distribution, hope she get more lines in the future❤️
But as far as I know, Shuhua really wants to get a few lines, because most of g-idle's songs contain English too and Shuhua is not very fluent in English, so that's why she doesn't want to take a lot of lines
disband : hi
@@blackyblacky8417 Oh yeah, I see
end of contract: hii
@@yeviii wait what?
Honestly, this line distribution isn't absolute accurate reflected cause Minnie wrote many songs, and in her own songs, she will usually sing more instead of title. Actually in Super lady Queencard Klaxon those title, she doesn't have lots part if you observed clearly.
Btw, Those people who are saying Miyeon should sing more parts, the parts she sing always the chorus, it's memorable and attracting, sadly, chorus are always short.
Anyway, Minnie is also a main vocalist, she totally deserved
counting that now shuhua have most of soojin line is pretty fair
People is so dumb, Shuhua asked for less lines because she is insecure about her korean pronunciation
People are so dumb 😉
@@Joe_Kpop THANKS FOR CORRECTION
Shuhua has a lovely voice but lacks confidence and stability. Soyeon gives her just enough lines for her to be confortable in the songs. People need to understand that idols are different, and as much as unfair line distributions exist Soyeon does the best she can for her members.
please stop saying this 💀 idk why y'all still believe in this. Like, Shuhua's korean pronunciation improved so much since 2020 but people still spreading this lie
@@0ayeri1 The Shuhua bestie:
So proud of my queen Minnie 🥰🥰🥰🥰
100's
Miyeon: Maze
Minnie: Maze
Soyeon: Don't Text Me
Soojin: What's In Your House
Yuqi: What's In Your House
Shuhua: Relay
200's
Miyeon: Hear Me
Minnie: Hear Me
Soyeon: Hann
Soojin: Hann
Yuqi: What's Your Name
Shuhua: Lion
300's
Miyeon: Put It Straight
Minnie: Relay
Soyeon: What's Your Name
Soojin: Put It Straight
Yuqi: Light My Fire
Shuhua: Hwaa
400's
Miyeon: Help Me
Minnie: Put It Straight
Soyeon: Give Me Your
Soojin: Uh-Oh
Yuqi: I'm The Trend
Shuhua: Tomboy
500's
Miyeon: Light My Fire
Minnie: Uh-Oh
Soyeon: Light My Fire
Soojin: Lion
Yuqi: Moon
Shuhua: Escape
600's
Miyeon: Luv U
Minnie: For You
Soyeon: Lion
Soojin: I'm The Trend
Yuqi: Last Dance
Shuhua: Change
700's
Miyeon: Tung Tung
Minnie: Luv U
Soyeon: Luv U
Soojin: Hwaa
Yuqi: Polaroid
Shuhua: Queencard
800's
Miyeon: Moon
Minnie: Tung Tung
Soyeon: Tung Tung
Yuqi: Liar
Shuhua: Peter Pan
900's
Miyeon: Last Dance
Minnie: Moon
Soyeon: Lost
Yuqi: Change
Shuhua: Tall Trees
1000's
Miyeon: Already
Minnie: Dahlia
Soyeon: Tomboy
Yuqi: Dark (X-File)
Shuhua: 7Days
2000's
Minnie: Doll
Soyeon: Rollie
1. Minnie = Producer & Main Vocalist
2. Soyeon = Producer , Center , Main Rapper
3. Yuqi = Producer , Lead Vocalist
4. Miyeon = Main Vocalist
5. Shuhua = Sub Vocalist
6. Soojin 🕊️= Former Member (Main Dancer)
Don't take this as a hate comment,but when you use "🕊" it's like Soojin p@ssed away or something and it will probably confuse many baby Neverlands, so please delete the emoji!❤️
Ta literalmente escrito que ela é ex membra, ninguém vai confundir@@mariqilieva6650
Yuqi is also lead dancer
minnie: producer & main vocalist
soyeon: producer, leader, center, main rapper & sub vocalist
yuqi: producer, fotg, main dancer, sub vocalist & sub rapper
miyeon: lyricist, main vocal & visual
shuhua: sub vocalist, visual & maknae
soojin: main dancer, sub vocalist & sub rapper
Just because someone is a producer or a songwriter it doesn't mean they can take all the lines.
Yall miyeon tends to get the chrouses, it is fair if you look at a memorable stand point
Not miyeon having 9 - 1st places and 9 last places ☠️
Some of the 5th places could be from OT6, but idk
@@zachyzxchzachonly 1
None of the members care about the line distribution and had always put trust on whoever fits the line will always get it. I don't get people when they say they deserve better than another member. I would not like to see members like Miyeon and Minnie straining themselves go do something like Super Lady, or Yuqi getting high pitched lines and even Shuhua as well. They're all placed perfectly based on how good they sound and I'm glad that as a group they're happy with that.
Minnie❤❤❤❤
The ot5 distribution is hilarious, like seriously???
One of the main vocal at the top and the other main vocal who is th group's best Vocalist at bottom 2???
Yes, I agree
Honestly it's not that ridiculous since there are only 5 members and Idle has a lot of raps so it makes sense that the main rapper is also part of top 3 and Yuqi has a pretty standout voice they've been incorporating a lot in their more recent songs - obviosly it'd make more sense if Miyeon was part of top3 but it's also not that horrible either
as it should be 😊
soyeon, minnie and yuqi compose song so obviously in their song they have more line, also gidle have a lot of rap, so what’s the problem?
yuqi is a better vocalist than miyeon but pop off queen
Slayyyyyy ATEEEEE PERIOD ❤😊
I wish someone would made one of these but including the OT5 version of OT6 songs and their covers live Abracadabra and That Thart + their add songs like Ninety Nine. I feel like the results would be way more even (I dont think its on purpose but I find it treally interesting how Shuhua actually gets many lines in songs that aren't idles. She is one of the tops in both the mentioned covers AND Ninety Nine).
The ot5 distribution 💀💀
Basically Miyeon used to get more lines
what
Well, g idle used to have cute/normal concepts, but when Soojin left the group got more bold.
Miyeon suits the cute/normal concepts so that’s why she has less lines ot5
That's not an excuse for miyeon having less lines if that's the reason Than shuhua who has a voice tone similar to miyeon is often getting more lines than her in some songs and yuqi who has a deep voice and lead vocalist is also getting more than her
@@asho2645
@@asho2645not really, they had cute concepts like dumdi dumdi a few times but they had mostly dark concepts, they do cute concepts post soojin as well, arguably more often (allergy, klaxon) plus songs like nxde fit Miyeons voice perfectly
my sub vocal queen Miyeon
She's main vocal
@@serpentwqIt's ironic she's main vocal with less lines than sub vocals, that's why the OG commented that.
And the other main vocal is first so what's the problem
@@Skzgidle the main vocal is first and the two sub vocals are last in ot5 distribution so what's the problem
@@serpentwq i know. it's sarcasm i love her
miyeon desserved better she's an amazing main vocalist
Miyeon, Minnie and Soyeon fighting for the top and Soojin, Yuqi and Shuhua just chilling😂😂
Miyeon is the main vocalist and she has least lines than yuqi in the ot5 total
Average Line Distribution per song
Minnie: 32 | 20.4% (-2.2% all members; -4.2% current members only)
Soyeon: 30.3 | 19.3% (-2.1% all members; -3.9% current members only)
Miyeon: 27.9 | 17.8% (-1.9% all members; -3.6% current members only)
Soojin (+2): 26.5 | 16.9% (+9% all members)
Yuqi (-1): 24.4 | 15.5% (-1.7% all members; -3.2% current members only)
Shuhua (-1): 15.9 | 10.1% (-1% all members; -1.9% current members only)
Variation: 21.9% (-13.6% all members; -3% current members only)
Color of Zone: Green (Used to be Yellow for all members)
Oh, and for the idea where I exclude former members when calculating the variation, that idea has discontinued.
Yaaass minnie the queen❤
my bias, miyeon isn't main vocalist anymore😢
She was 1st in the new album, also in the English Debut.
she’s slowly getting more lines but the first two ot5 eras and señorita-oh my god were awful
@@mathhenri-xy5fh yeah, but idk why yuqi and minnie treated more than miyeon
I think she has been getting treated a main vocalist a lot more recently like in heat and I sway I would say those albums and maybe I made and I am and 2 are the ones were she is treated as the best vocal in the group
@@DifanMIYA7 because in the past comebacks she's the least member who fitted the concept. And you know how well (G)I-DLE makes use of their concept. In tomboy, nxde, and queencard era miyeon had the second least lines. In Heat album, 2, and I sway, she had most of the lines, why? Because she's the one who fitted the most. And wdym by she's not main vocalist anymore, she's still the best vocalist in the group, and she already proved it with her solo album.
Ya’ll calm your tits its almost perfect in ot5 and ot6 is literally not the biggest difference but mostly yuqi and minnie getting more lines and they write songs too! + shushu got more lines as well. And Miyeon has been treated decently well in 2-3 albums so fair
3 seconds ago ❤😊
Why you didn’t count the wo-o-oh of shuhua in help me she would has more than 30 seconds
Miyeon is first in Klaxon
Love Yuqi voice so muchh
Minnie!!!!❤
Miyeon, the main vocalist, having just 9 first places in their whole discography, being 4th in the OT5 distribution is EMBARRASSING.
C'mon Cube, treat your artists better than this
Miyeon deserves better
YESSS
True but shuhua didn’t pass soojin until Peter Pan, and she got more lines and Yuqi too in ot6. In ot5 Yuqi only got 4 seconds more than Miyeon
Shuhua!
@@Its_neverland she can’t sing as well as Miyeon tho
@@Yunjin___ now that’s just rude they both have amazing vocals
Let's go in first W video
Imagine if soojin is still in gidle she would slay klaxon, super lady, nxde, queencard, tomboy, and my bag 😢
9:50 when "number of 5th places" comes
shuhua: 🤫🧏
Miyeon gets less lines than Minnie but she gets most of the catchy chorus that require the main vocalist
MIYEON NUMBER 1 KLAXON!!!!!!!!!!
Soyeonnn❤
Soojin....
Let’s not compare and love everyone. Does ranking matter?
Soojin did not deserve it 😢💔
I know there are other lead singers in the group
But I bet there are many people want to hear more of yuqi’s voice😭
Then they can listen to her solo album
Plss Cube give Miyeon a chance to show rapping or Yuqi she literally the Lead rapper plss
Why, when they have one of the best rappers in the industry in the group?
we love the ot5 songs distribution
por qué la amarías cuando la MEJOR VOCALISTA del grupo es penúltima? 💀
Who is "we" here
It was hurting when Shuhua sum line became more than Soojin :(
I love Shuhua, she's my bias, I just mean than she usually has not so much lines.
Can the domino be animated?
Miyeon is 1st in Klaxon =)
shuhua need more confidence 😢
Do realize that Miyeon usually loses the ranks by a few seconds in most of the OT5 comebacks. It's not as unfair as the rankings may make it seem like. Plus, (G)I-DLE loves cool delivery spoken/rap parts in their songs, especially as of late. Soyeon clearly prefers Miyeon's singing tone to her speaking/rapping tone most of the time, which limits Soyeon's use cases for her. Not to say her spoken parts don't come to play! She just tends to have a much cuter tone, and Soyeon has to work extra hard to get bad girl energy from Miyeon, and that's okay!! Her cute tone worked so well on Queencard, and she pulled off some of those bad girl mannerisms in Super Lady!
It also has to do with Soyeon wanting to make her members shine equally, and it's objective that each member has different skills in different amounts, so Soyeon incorporates the members according to those skills. Miyeon is an INCREDIBLE vocalist and would outshine all the other members if she had more parts, imo. Her "slightly shorter" sung parts tend to make her shine plenty without outshining other members.
in klaxon miyeon is first!
Soojin going gray… 😭
shuhua bro
Yuqi deserves better ❤
Sorry but shuhua ?!!!!!!!!😭
She's the only sub vocalist and their worst performer, of course she is last
Minnie ❤
Ot5 distribution is sooo "perfect"😊🔪
Abracadabra? 😕
it is cover
Abracadabra is a cover
@@hhjghhfbut it was released officially, no?
@@lizzie5046yeah it's in their discography on Spotify. I would guess so then
@@lizzie5046its not their song though 😭
where is the TOMBOY
2nd
지금 나온걸로 따지면 민니-소연-미연-우기-슈화 순이라고 생각했는데 진짠가보네
the pop stars？
what is the point of this video?
to give nevies a thing to complain about.
Discovering in a fast way the discography of groups :D
To give Shuhua/Miyeon pity and solo fans a chance to make much ado about nothing and hate on Soyeon, as always
How think it should be:
1. Miyeon
2. Minnie
3. Yuqi
4. Soyeon
5. Shuha
Why? Soyeon is main rapper, which is a vocal main position just like main vocalist + she's the center and best performer - she shouldn't be that far down. It's fair as it is.
why tf did they skip Shuhua in This Time Around, she's also a member of gidle??
Соен лучше всех
Now who will say that Soyeon gets most line?
They'll find something else to blame her for and justify their boycott of her fancams, pictures and bashing her
Internally screams at the insane amount of 5th places shuhua has
Shuhua now has more lines than soojin😭 oh it’s been so long 😭
yuqi having more 1st places than miyeon 💀
Ever since ot5 Yuqis lines have shot up tbh
@@TheCottonCandy707 cause she always gives herself more lines
@@tzuyu1989no it’s because she has a unique voice they’ve been incorporating into their songs
@@tzuyu1989no
@@tzuyu1989wdym💀 she has 2nd best vocals, unique voice, stability, ofc she's gonna be appealing to incorporate into the songs
5:17 SHUHUA barely surpassed SOOJIN even after a long time had passed since she left the group 💀💔
why soyeon more lines than miyeon....our main vocalist deserves better
Why should the main rapper and center have less than one of two main vocalists? Both are equally important main vocal roles and all three mains are in the top three. Why only complain about Soyeon?
you forgot abracadabra
abracadabra was a cover, not an official song
Actually, OT5's line distribution isn't bad. They just need to give MIYEON her main vocalist position and give SHUHUA a few more lines 🙌🏻.
shuhua deserve more lines!
No, she has way more than she deserves already
@@avut2001 no, she have a good vocal and also rap, she deserve more lines
@@IcyKai14 Good? Maybe in an alternate reality, lol. She's also no rapper
@@avut2001 Bruh, she is good, and yh you are obviously a hater and idc, I will support my shuhua cuz she is super talented, ofc nobody can be talented like her, for example like u , you are a bad person that makes you bad in everything ugly hater, idc about your opinion shuhua is pretty, talented, good person and more, things like u don’t have LMAO…😂😂😂
@@avut2001Yh she is good, better than u, and she have visuals, she can sing,rap and she is also a good person, not like you!! All haters are bad which make you bad at everything, you use your “time” you hate in yt or any other platform, like bro, if your fav singer receive that hate what you will do? Get mad? Sad? Or maybe you don’t even have feeling sense…
Minnie shouldn't have so much Line! she is not better than Miyeon and Yuqi 💀 (Miyeon D, Yuqi E+ & Minnie E-)
bla bla bla...
@@fdelys1141 🤣🤣
@@Im.hyunieAnd I think she should left (G)-IDLE and let them be ot4 forever 😒🙄🙄
@@Winterossy Yuqi or Minnie ?
1) No one in music academia is using that stupid ranking and none of the RUclips vocal "experts" knows what they are talking about (otherwise, they'd been busy making money by coaching instead of having to rely on fan biased RUclips videos). 2) Vocal technique and musicality really are not important for Kpop - no one in Gidle is a skilled technical vocalist. The lines distributions are based on tone and versatility: Miyeon is not a worse singer than Minnie, but she has a less distinct and genre versatile tone than Minnie and Yuqi. She also doesn't compose and probably has less interest in singing/music than the producer line. I'm sure no one in Gidle gives a fuck about line distribution and who has millisecond more in one song
6:27 ПОСХАЛКО