A huge THANK YOU from the heart. I believe, this is a time-changer effort and we owe a lot to Prof. Zangger. Hoping to find college initiatives to widen your resaearch and hoping that you get permission to scan the 500 höyüks as soon as possible. Looking forward to new developments.
When we put the works of our esteemed scientist Prof. Fahri Işık and Prof. Eberhard Zangger, who defend the thesis that civilization was born in Anatolia and that the Luwis and Hittites played the biggest role in this in the light of all archaeological research, we can say very clearly that civilization was born in Anatolia and later created the Greek civilization...
A big Thank youuu to Dr.Eberhard Zangger for opening new horizons for those who are interested in the real versions of humanity's journey in Asia Minor present-day Türkiye. It is not surprising to know how these so-called scientists could bend the realities of archeology in favor of "certain" neighborhoods. And a big Thank you to Regber Akademisi for organizing this seminar. Hope to see this information in world textbooks in the near future. 💯💗👏
A Veritable Tour de Force by Dr Zangger! Undoubtedly a stepping stone toward grasping the history of Anatolia. I m impressed by the map of the W Mediterranean with the names in 'Luwian'.
Cok kiymeyli bir paylasim, EMEGINIZ ICIN SONSUZ TESEKKURLER!... Turkce altyazi secenegi olmasi ingilizcesini anlamayan ve konuya heyecanla ilgi duyan herkesi cekecektir. videonun cok daha buyk ilgi gorecegi kesin.
Gabriel Germain scholar of Homeric studies wrote that the hexameter rhythm of syllables in the Iliad is an unusual rhythm for Greek and he believed that the original epic was composed in an indo-european language that was spoken around the Aegean...maybe that is WHY there are so many beautiful praises for the Trojan confederacy// allies...the epic may have been translated by the Greeks...(??)
Such an amazing lecture, I was trying to find some information on the Luwian civilization and as the Prof. Zanggerd mentioned there is almost nothing. I was hugely disappointed, from what i read online, i hugely felt that there is an ongoing effort in order 'Greekify' the western part of Anatolia, for instance when they talk about the philosophers, mathematicians, historians they always put an exclamation sign " But that part of Turkey was Greece then !! ". What is with that quick remark all the time? without even letting a small pause happen? It feels strange. The ideological aspect is definitely obvious. What are your thoughts on Ionia? According to Greek myth and todays consensus, Greeks came and colonized these empty(?!) lands. Is it correct to establish a perspective based on myths ? Anyway thank you so much for this lecture, both to the Prof. Zangger and the channel administration.
That was an evening well spent. It seems a sad reflection on scholarship that such a huge gap in research should have continued so long. More strength to your organisation and its supporters.
I have feeling something is missing. Where and how would you place Vinca script ,used within the Vinca civilisation from 7500 to 2500 BC.BTW,Etruscun script was decifered,using Vinca script .Todays Cyrillic script is widely used within the Danube civilisation .There is an interesting recent book on Danube civilisation , by Harald Haarmann a well-established paleo linguist from Germany. Should it be correct ,it would mean, than The Ancient Greek was taken from the Greeks predecessors in the islands which going a bit further back we will see that Vinca is always missing. Strange? Any response and counter idea most welcome.
Very strange story about James Melaart...I m wondering about the implications of his forgeries. Are all of his forgeries known? What may have been Melaart s reasons, only financial??
Can we say, science carried from western anatolia (from luwians) to europe? Today's science must be built on something. It is clear that the Mycenaeans could not develop science and philosophy while fighting among themselves. In the cities they captured when they attacked Western Anatolia; It doesn't make sense to me that they build their non-existent sciences and philosophies. In this case, they may not have just captured the cities. But could it have also taken over Luwian antiquity science in western Anatolia and thus moved to Europe?
Also, is there any clear evidence of how the Luwians ruled the cities? If no royal documents or evidence has been found; I wonder if they developed some sort of urban democracy or something? Or should we just think that they live like peasants?
Many words which "they" identify as Luwian are not even Luwian, for example: 1-"Luvian theonym 'immarn(a)/i is derived from Luv.*immara-'open country'...." immara is Akkadian of etymology and we use it in Turkish as Imar! 2-Or "Atta", "Anna" are not Luvian! 3-"Tarhunt", "Trqqas" also not Luvian!... Atta/Ata (father, ancestor), Anna/Ana (mother), Trqqas/Tark-kas/Tark-As, Tarhunt/Tarhan/Tarkan ('tittle, male name' in Turkish, or as Tar/Taru in Chuvash Turkish meaning 'god').... Research better and be honest!
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you all for this great lecture, Dr. Eberhard Zangger does a phenomenal work there!
A huge THANK YOU from the heart. I believe, this is a time-changer effort and we owe a lot to Prof. Zangger. Hoping to find college initiatives to widen your resaearch and hoping that you get permission to scan the 500 höyüks as soon as possible. Looking forward to new developments.
We thank to Dr. Zangger for this great presentation. Hope to meet again soon...
When we put the works of our esteemed scientist Prof. Fahri Işık and Prof. Eberhard Zangger, who defend the thesis that civilization was born in Anatolia and that the Luwis and Hittites played the biggest role in this in the light of all archaeological research, we can say very clearly that civilization was born in Anatolia and later created the Greek civilization...
A big Thank youuu to Dr.Eberhard Zangger for opening new horizons for those who are interested in the real versions of humanity's journey in Asia Minor present-day Türkiye. It is not surprising to know how these so-called scientists could bend the realities of archeology in favor of "certain" neighborhoods. And a big Thank you to Regber Akademisi for organizing this seminar. Hope to see this information in world textbooks in the near future. 💯💗👏
A Veritable Tour de Force by Dr Zangger! Undoubtedly a stepping stone toward grasping the history of Anatolia. I m impressed by the map of the W Mediterranean with the names in 'Luwian'.
Wonderful! It is so interesting to hear all the Indo-Europoean Kurdish history of Anatolia !!! VIELEN DANK, Herr Dr. Zangger!
Kurds are iranized assyrians lol
Liar kurds
Absolutely outstanding. Thanks so much.
Çevirisi de olsaydı keşke
Semra hanım merhabalar, Yakın bir zamanda çevirisini yaptırıp yüklemeyi planlıyoruz. Sevgiler
Heyecanla bekliyorum bende
Cok kiymeyli bir paylasim, EMEGINIZ ICIN SONSUZ TESEKKURLER!... Turkce altyazi secenegi olmasi ingilizcesini anlamayan ve konuya heyecanla ilgi duyan herkesi cekecektir. videonun cok daha buyk ilgi gorecegi kesin.
This is Great,Dr.Zangger is a Luwian expert.
Gabriel Germain scholar of Homeric studies wrote that the hexameter rhythm of syllables in the Iliad is an unusual rhythm for Greek and he believed that the original epic was composed in an indo-european language that was spoken around the Aegean...maybe that is WHY there are so many beautiful praises for the Trojan confederacy// allies...the epic may have been translated by the Greeks...(??)
Such an amazing lecture, I was trying to find some information on the Luwian civilization and as the Prof. Zanggerd mentioned there is almost nothing. I was hugely disappointed, from what i read online, i hugely felt that there is an ongoing effort in order 'Greekify' the western part of Anatolia, for instance when they talk about the philosophers, mathematicians, historians they always put an exclamation sign " But that part of Turkey was Greece then !! ". What is with that quick remark all the time? without even letting a small pause happen? It feels strange. The ideological aspect is definitely obvious. What are your thoughts on Ionia? According to Greek myth and todays consensus, Greeks came and colonized these empty(?!) lands. Is it correct to establish a perspective based on myths ? Anyway thank you so much for this lecture, both to the Prof. Zangger and the channel administration.
TÜRKÇE ALT YAZI YADA ÇEVİRİLMİŞ HALİ DE OLMASI GEREK MİYOR MU ?
That was an evening well spent. It seems a sad reflection on scholarship that such a huge gap in research should have continued so long. More strength to your organisation and its supporters.
I have feeling something is missing.
Where and how would you place Vinca script ,used within the Vinca civilisation from 7500 to 2500 BC.BTW,Etruscun script was decifered,using Vinca script .Todays Cyrillic script is widely used within the Danube civilisation .There is an interesting recent book on Danube civilisation , by Harald Haarmann a well-established paleo linguist from Germany.
Should it be correct ,it would mean, than The Ancient Greek was taken from the Greeks predecessors in the islands which going a bit further back we will see that Vinca is always missing. Strange? Any response and counter idea most welcome.
iyi demiş
Very strange story about James Melaart...I m wondering about the implications of his forgeries. Are all of his forgeries known? What may have been Melaart s reasons, only financial??
Gabriel Germain author of 'Homer' an Evergreen Profile Book 1960 London. See my comment below.
Can we say, science carried from western anatolia (from luwians) to europe? Today's science must be built on something. It is clear that the Mycenaeans could not develop science and philosophy while fighting among themselves. In the cities they captured when they attacked Western Anatolia; It doesn't make sense to me that they build their non-existent sciences and philosophies. In this case, they may not have just captured the cities. But could it have also taken over Luwian antiquity science in western Anatolia and thus moved to Europe?
Also, is there any clear evidence of how the Luwians ruled the cities? If no royal documents or evidence has been found; I wonder if they developed some sort of urban democracy or something? Or should we just think that they live like peasants?
The Troian WAR was an European War. Troia was in Europe and not in Turkey.
Many words which "they" identify as Luwian are not even Luwian, for example: 1-"Luvian theonym 'immarn(a)/i is derived from Luv.*immara-'open country'...." immara is Akkadian of etymology and we use it in Turkish as Imar! 2-Or "Atta", "Anna" are not Luvian! 3-"Tarhunt", "Trqqas" also not Luvian!... Atta/Ata (father, ancestor), Anna/Ana (mother), Trqqas/Tark-kas/Tark-As, Tarhunt/Tarhan/Tarkan ('tittle, male name' in Turkish, or as Tar/Taru in Chuvash Turkish meaning 'god').... Research better and be honest!