I agree that economics is very underrepresented in the Great Books. I find it especially odd there’s a volume devoted to Mill but excludes Principles of Political Economy, one of the most impactful economics works of all time. Carl Menger’s Principles of Economics is an obvious glaring omission considering its importance with laying out marginal utility correctly, possibly the most important concept in economics. And Bohm-Bawerk’s Capital and Interest would be the other classic economics work that is a must read.
Great suggestions, both of which I'm unfamiliar with but will look into. I figure if Keynes is represented (in the 1990 update I believe), then the opposing Austrian school should be represented as well.
@@ThinkingWest My original comment was referring to the 1952 Great Books. But Mises’s magnum opus Human Action would be the obvious selection then if it’s to counterbalance Keynes. No work is greater in the history of economics in my opinion (though I would recommend Man, Economy, and State more to a beginner since it essentially is a more accessible Human Action).
@@jakelm4256 Great. I'll look for the second work by Mises as I've certainly heard it recommended before. I'm certainly no expert in economics, but have read some of Hayek and other works for the layman like myself.
@@christiannstephaniebottenf1041 by the way, speaking of Carl Menger, he had one of the greatest personal libraries possibly of all time. The economics, philosophy, and ethnography works comprised around 20,000 volumes. He spent much of his time tending to the library, as well as inviting students and colleagues to use it. Hayek catalogued and appraised it, and it now mostly sits in the archives of a university in Japan.
I've been making my way through the Great Ideas Program by Adler which uses the older version of the Great Western Books. It has proven to be highly rewarding thus far.
@@ThinkingWest I'm on the 14th reading of book number 2 that deals with government. So far so good. Lots of good ideas and insights I hadn't considered before.
Hey thinking west, i was wondering if you can make a video on how to read difficult books. I was trying to go through adler's list but i just couldnt read or understand alot of the books. For example : spinoza ethics, aristotle ethics, saint augestine confessions. I can read the words obviously and know their meaning but the sentence just dont make sense. If you can maybe share how you go through these that would be of great help thank you.
Should you read karl Marx? Yes. Should you follow Marx's philosophy? Upto you. You'll learn something for sure. It doesn't have to have an influence on your values and principles. Everyone has the freedom to assert their own meaning into this meaningless absurd life. Perhaps you'll learn what are the things you should never follow from reading Marx🤷🏻♂️
😠 I downvoted this video because of the highly intrusive music. Either it is a concert being interrupted by talking, or a talk interrupted by music. Neither is acceptable listening or viewing.
I agree that economics is very underrepresented in the Great Books. I find it especially odd there’s a volume devoted to Mill but excludes Principles of Political Economy, one of the most impactful economics works of all time. Carl Menger’s Principles of Economics is an obvious glaring omission considering its importance with laying out marginal utility correctly, possibly the most important concept in economics. And Bohm-Bawerk’s Capital and Interest would be the other classic economics work that is a must read.
Great suggestions, both of which I'm unfamiliar with but will look into. I figure if Keynes is represented (in the 1990 update I believe), then the opposing Austrian school should be represented as well.
@@ThinkingWest My original comment was referring to the 1952 Great Books. But Mises’s magnum opus Human Action would be the obvious selection then if it’s to counterbalance Keynes. No work is greater in the history of economics in my opinion (though I would recommend Man, Economy, and State more to a beginner since it essentially is a more accessible Human Action).
@@jakelm4256 Great. I'll look for the second work by Mises as I've certainly heard it recommended before. I'm certainly no expert in economics, but have read some of Hayek and other works for the layman like myself.
Oops. Replied from a personal account. Oh well.
@@christiannstephaniebottenf1041 by the way, speaking of Carl Menger, he had one of the greatest personal libraries possibly of all time. The economics, philosophy, and ethnography works comprised around 20,000 volumes. He spent much of his time tending to the library, as well as inviting students and colleagues to use it. Hayek catalogued and appraised it, and it now mostly sits in the archives of a university in Japan.
Excellent presentation.
I've been making my way through the Great Ideas Program by Adler which uses the older version of the Great Western Books. It has proven to be highly rewarding thus far.
I bought The Great Ideas recently....also excited to go through it.
@@ThinkingWest I'm on the 14th reading of book number 2 that deals with government. So far so good. Lots of good ideas and insights I hadn't considered before.
Awesome and very insightful analysis!
Much appreciated!
I enjoyed this. The pursuit of wisdom.
Thanks!
Hey thinking west, i was wondering if you can make a video on how to read difficult books. I was trying to go through adler's list but i just couldnt read or understand alot of the books. For example : spinoza ethics, aristotle ethics, saint augestine confessions. I can read the words obviously and know their meaning but the sentence just dont make sense. If you can maybe share how you go through these that would be of great help thank you.
Great suggestion for a common problem. Thanks.
those volumes surely required improviing reading skills
Yes they can definitely be a challenge. Slow and steady win the race.
@@ThinkingWest forced me to take notes and repeat by myself, turned out to be great
What are the Great Books?
Generally, those books that generation after generation have kept saying is worth reading.
Is that a Les Paul?
Yes! A Gibson Les Paul Studio.
@@ThinkingWest And do you like it?
Absolutely.@@hanskung3278
@@ThinkingWest Play much?
Karl Marx? Do you really recommend reading Karl Marx??
Should you read karl Marx? Yes. Should you follow Marx's philosophy? Upto you. You'll learn something for sure. It doesn't have to have an influence on your values and principles. Everyone has the freedom to assert their own meaning into this meaningless absurd life. Perhaps you'll learn what are the things you should never follow from reading Marx🤷🏻♂️
😠 I downvoted this video because of the highly intrusive music. Either it is a concert being interrupted by talking, or a talk interrupted by music. Neither is acceptable listening or viewing.
I've upvoted to counteract this.
Thanks for the feedback.