Ex-Muslim Questions Determinism and Free Will - Toronto Dawah

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 янв 2025

Комментарии • 71

  • @sydanas7564
    @sydanas7564 5 лет назад +349

    You know when I was young like 12-13 I asked my parents that if everything is written and predetermined how come a robber is held accountable for robbing they could not answer but Alhamdulillah I have had some great friends who explained to me how free will works and how qadr works in Islam and for that I am really thankful, Islam answers every single question u could ever have relating to faith and our scholars have already explained to us such questions We just have to search for it and learn from it. I hope Allah Increases me and you and our Imaan. Ameen.

  • @AliDawah
    @AliDawah 5 лет назад +692

    This brother basically has tawakul (trust) in quantum mechanic mysteries, but doesn’t have tawakul in Allah swt when it comes to free will & pre-destiny. And as usually it goes back to the issue of lack of tawheed.

  • @saqibalvi9440
    @saqibalvi9440 5 лет назад +556

    Pray for your brothers and sisters in Indian Occupied Kashmir. #66Days and counting.

  • @30251
    @30251 5 лет назад +183

    From what I just watched, he seems like a decent guy with a genuine desire to reconcile these issues. You spoke to him very well, Mohammed. Keep up the good work.

  • @Knighttus
    @Knighttus 5 лет назад +761

    These kids leave Islam cause they think it restricts their life and that’s sad because Islam is doing them more good than harm, humans are selfish by nature they would rather go drink and commit adultery then die of a disease and end up losing both worlds this world and the hereafter, you have an expiration date on you life and everything has an end so make it count, you will stand in front of Allah one day and regret every sec you wasted chasing this life.

  • @aneni
    @aneni 5 лет назад +175

    being given free will, we blame god for not making us pious enough.
    if god had made us all pious, people would blame him for not giving us free will.

  • @Wiiforsale
    @Wiiforsale 5 лет назад +87

    Brother Hijab is trying to get into the mukbang scene...good thinking.

  • @0779
    @0779 5 лет назад +113

    How I understand free will is the same as writing code or programming a game. We are all programmed to a certain degree, God created the code language and the programmer(the pen), God can always intervene and change the direction of the program or the structure of the code anywhere he wants, so overall God knows everything. By the way, I recommend anyone to learn to code, it will change how you think.

  • @Alexir.
    @Alexir. 5 лет назад +116

    Studying philosophy in depth can be dangerous and is ultimately pointless. Wondering if you exist or not is like trying to imagine what God looks like. You'll drive yourself insane.

  • @Walidbouguelouz055
    @Walidbouguelouz055 5 лет назад +111

    i passiolny want to understand and watch but the noises are tackling my ears

  • @syafiatulkhusnah2903
    @syafiatulkhusnah2903 5 лет назад +142

    Oh Allah i want my future kids will be like him ( Muhammad Hijab) and hopefully more than him 😢

  • @User-4517
    @User-4517 5 лет назад +43

    We don’t have “free will”... what we have is freedom of choice..

  • @watermelon7867
    @watermelon7867 5 лет назад +110

    Mohammed Hijab's voice is lower than the ex-Muslims's. They should be the same. Try using a microphone next time.

  • @BeLiiinDaaa
    @BeLiiinDaaa 5 лет назад +64

    May Allah reward you Brother Hijab
    Such a good idea to sit with the 'ex-muslim' and explain to them islam , something they maybe didnt understand and are doubting islam.
    We all should treet nice this 'ex-muslims' , and explain them calm what they are doubting. And not fighting with them or bring them down.

  • @zio__e
    @zio__e 5 лет назад +44

    Finally you're back

  • @BadranLyrics
    @BadranLyrics 5 лет назад +32

    Why didn't he announce that's he's gonna be in Toronto?😤😤😤

  • @souadburghan5313
    @souadburghan5313 5 лет назад +23

    Bro Hijab please do a podcast with Andalusian Project, another intellectual giant masha'Allah.

  • @owliealim745
    @owliealim745 5 лет назад +43

    I really really really love Mohamed hijab and i would love for him to have brother Asadullah Ali Al andalusi on his show.....he's highly intellectual and has a degree in philosophy...please invite him to your channel

  • @Walidbouguelouz055
    @Walidbouguelouz055 5 лет назад +23

    the editor of this video please captions next time...and try to eliminate the surrounding noises so the speakers sounds pure and clean

  • @abdulrashid2143
    @abdulrashid2143 5 лет назад +6

    MashAllah you become one of my top RUclipsrs
    Found your channel a few days ago thanks

  • @pure4901
    @pure4901 5 лет назад +27

    You'll find ex-muslims choose to disbelieve the moment they can't find a definitive answer to a complicated question. Instead of searching for the answers whilst still believing, they use that doubt to justify shedding the "limitations" Islam enforces in order to not feel the guilt associated with breaking Islamic law. It's much easier to drink alcohol and perform zina when there's no looming guilt...

  • @hassaambaig8000
    @hassaambaig8000 5 лет назад +12

    Salaam brother hijab, is it possible if u can do a meet up in Toronto, cuz i live here and im eager to meet u

  • @nabeel8194
    @nabeel8194 5 лет назад +4

    JazakumAllah Khair for tackling these issues

  • @FreakishlyTrue
    @FreakishlyTrue 5 лет назад +13

    Great. Im hungry now.

  • @Abdullahin1
    @Abdullahin1 5 лет назад +14

    What Hijab should have said was "Call me when you're ready to listen"....... 🤷🏾‍♀️

  • @StockInvestingCad
    @StockInvestingCad 5 лет назад +8

    Ma man is in Toronto. Brother Hijab I would like to get in touch with you. How would I be able to do so?

  • @fiazmultani
    @fiazmultani 5 лет назад +44

    First. Bismillah. But Allah was always present. So i'm last.

  • @AyubKhan-md4km
    @AyubKhan-md4km 5 лет назад +8

    Just like how a teacher can predict whether a student will do well or not, the Almighty can see far far far more intently, deeply and into the past present and future and determine where you will head

  • @LadyNoor22
    @LadyNoor22 5 лет назад +14

    Mohammed Hijabs back! Just about heard you though, you should’ve put subtitles. Still enjoyed the convo 💙
    Also made me feel hungry, I’m eating at Subway tmrw 🙊

  • @sofiemran7638
    @sofiemran7638 5 лет назад +5

    Brother use microphone next time in public.. Voice quality is very poor.

  • @mabdullahsari
    @mabdullahsari 5 лет назад +11

    ma shaa Allah bro Hijab, may Allah bless you

  • @Selektur
    @Selektur 5 лет назад +11

    are you in toronto currently?

  • @zwedenish
    @zwedenish 5 лет назад +4

    I am the first one bro. Follow u now 6 months. Doing great job with huge knowledge.

  • @shel_shel
    @shel_shel 5 лет назад +2

    Brother can you do a detailed video on free will and predestination please in Islamic context?

  • @SeNniN06
    @SeNniN06 5 лет назад +2

    Hi brother hijab are you going for any debates in Toronto?

  • @muslimman7143
    @muslimman7143 5 лет назад +4

    May Allah guide us all

  • @masterace1150
    @masterace1150 5 лет назад +2

    Hijab is like, "this guy is fucked up, I will just enjoy this amazing shawarma, ummmmmm."

  • @AliSheikh
    @AliSheikh 5 лет назад +9

    Hijab I need to meet you, I’m from Toronto and literally frequent Eaton Centre on the daily and I would love to have a conversation with you.

  • @gtrroman5823
    @gtrroman5823 5 лет назад +2

    Jzk. Could you make a video concisely and clearly detailing your contingency argument so it's easily accessible.

  • @raheemali6438
    @raheemali6438 5 лет назад +2

    Can someone break down quantum mechanics i really don't understand it ?

  • @AK-kv2fl
    @AK-kv2fl 5 лет назад +4

    Granny has given the most suitable name
    Hijab = Barrier

  • @lavishlyenigmatic
    @lavishlyenigmatic 5 лет назад +2

    I'm trying hard to get my head around what Hijab is digging out of determinism ,but the noise in the background woefully and constantly distrupting my understanding ! Too bad !!

  • @uponsunnah6986
    @uponsunnah6986 5 лет назад +2

    Bro you're in Toronto??¿??

  • @trix514
    @trix514 5 лет назад +3

    @mohamed hijab
    Come to Montreal you'll love it... I'm guessing you might come since tristar gym is here .. but hey let us know if you coming brother !

  • @olgu6877
    @olgu6877 5 лет назад +9

    Whatever u eating makes me hungry. Is it doner

  • @zain-elabideen2689
    @zain-elabideen2689 5 лет назад

    ASA, whats the deal? Your in Toronto? Where you be speaking? #quran #haqq

  • @mohsinraza3712
    @mohsinraza3712 5 лет назад +2

    So much noise in back ground.

  • @優さん-n7m
    @優さん-n7m 5 лет назад +6

    this guy is basically wasting time, he has no intention to change his mind.

  • @vukcvijovic9180
    @vukcvijovic9180 5 лет назад +3

    Silly question , was the sandwich halal ?

  • @sm-yo6pt
    @sm-yo6pt 5 лет назад +3

    why only apostate from Islam call themselves (Ex Muslim ) but all people from other beliefs don't call themselves (Ex+ previous faith)?
    from now on we must call them (apostate) only.
    (Ex Muslim) term using by haters Islam only

  • @nishiayad
    @nishiayad 5 лет назад +4

    Made me hungry :p

  • @2manyusernamestaken548
    @2manyusernamestaken548 5 лет назад +2

    Al hamdu lillah. Another Hijab video!

  • @Siwahib
    @Siwahib 5 лет назад +5

    Thanks, Mohammed, but it's too noisy!

  • @MrAliasgarshah
    @MrAliasgarshah 5 лет назад +3

    MashAllah brother Hijab Is an inspiration indeed.

  • @Boss-gk8kc
    @Boss-gk8kc 5 лет назад +6

    Dawa Mukbang

  • @rosslysamad2779
    @rosslysamad2779 5 лет назад

    nice

  • @KevinChantal
    @KevinChantal 5 лет назад +1

    I challenge Mr Hijab to a debate!

  • @suhailhabibzadah8634
    @suhailhabibzadah8634 5 лет назад

    Yorkdale mall

  • @usmanbarak2615
    @usmanbarak2615 5 лет назад +2

    Lol Hijab in my city

  • @zaidahaziz
    @zaidahaziz 5 лет назад

    Can regulate your own heart beat?

  • @faqirahabdullah1364
    @faqirahabdullah1364 5 лет назад +2

    this young guy if he has the strong knowledge about the deen..he wont be asking that 'silly' question

  • @tutorialsaspect5548
    @tutorialsaspect5548 5 лет назад +2

    1st salam

  • @beehivepattern5695
    @beehivepattern5695 5 лет назад

    You guys missing the Important point, wihtin the Qur'an Salah & vasting is the best way to controll freewill, more calm cool with no second thought.
    Freewill is base on the brain capability to reason anything on our action, brain has two major purpose which is emotion and instinct, theese factor determine the entire DNA in our body to be enhanced and full fill the desire, meanwhile in islam there there is no words of freewill but may consider as "Nafs" meaybe in english called as "self accomplishment" or ego which is also contain opposite factor which is Good Ego and bad Ego.
    God knows if the entire Humanity is in bad or good freewill, he will send a savior or ultimate punishment through anomaly of Natural disaster, it also has historical record for it even in the last decade.
    Owh...one more thing, Global thought is real ;)

  • @lacameyangarsenal8157
    @lacameyangarsenal8157 5 лет назад +2

    First

  • @danishanwar6757
    @danishanwar6757 5 лет назад +1

    Why can u not rationally prove that you exist.
    Thank you

  • @DmxAng
    @DmxAng 5 лет назад +1

    First