Making Music With The DORIAN #4 Scale On Guitar [The EVIL Scale]

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 264

  • @lukehewko260
    @lukehewko260 3 года назад +37

    The pull of the Em can actually serve a purpose as being an incredibly organic feeling way of changing keys!

  • @ishaboy5090
    @ishaboy5090 4 года назад +54

    4:41 I thought I was about to hear the forbidden song

    • @petterhouting7484
      @petterhouting7484 4 года назад +3

      Yes.... even though its just an Am arpeggio....

    • @victorbitencourt9481
      @victorbitencourt9481 4 года назад +1

      @@petterhouting7484 isnt it ab though? correct me if im wrong

    • @petterhouting7484
      @petterhouting7484 4 года назад +2

      @@victorbitencourt9481 no it is an A minor arpeggio

    • @wchen2340
      @wchen2340 4 года назад +2

      no stairway, denied!

  • @chiju
    @chiju 4 года назад +18

    I could not believe my eyes when I saw this thumbnail. I've had in mind for about a year now an arpeggiated vamp between Am and G+, with the seconds in as filler notes. At some point I figured it must be some mode of of the Harmonic Minor scale, but I didn't know then what to call it. I put the idea away for a while but now I'm in the middle of fleshing the idea out into a full track. I only figured out a few days ago that it would be called Dorian #4. I searched YT for videos about this mode but could not find anything useful. Today I look to see what Tommaso's upload for the week was and BAM! I'll be looking to apply this for sure!

  • @Bronze_Age_Sea_Person
    @Bronze_Age_Sea_Person 4 года назад +79

    I love this scale, especially when used in Turkish music where it is called Nikriz and in Klezmer.

    • @blinkforme5726
      @blinkforme5726 4 года назад

      tam olarak nikriz i karşılıyor mu?

    • @gregtees9995
      @gregtees9995 4 года назад +4

      Do you have any axamples of the turkish music/artists who play this?

    • @gregtees9995
      @gregtees9995 4 года назад

      Always looking for new tunes.

    • @cinnamonsinner4619
      @cinnamonsinner4619 4 года назад +1

      Shut up right now

    • @RavSoda
      @RavSoda 4 года назад +2

      Also Jewish, as well as Arabic music more generally. Though they are used quite differently.

  • @indubiousComrade
    @indubiousComrade 4 года назад +18

    Your tip about seeing modes as overlaid arpeggios is top notch. I made the same realization a few months ago that it's much simpler to think of Dorian as "minor 1st chord, major 4th chord, minor 5th chord" than the equivalent collection of 7 notes. Want to modulate to mixo? Easy, just make the I chord major. Easier said than done, you still have to practice the changes but that was a helpful tool that got me to grok the 'how and why' of changing modes.

  • @luapsel77
    @luapsel77 Год назад +3

    This is the first time I've ever been on your Channel and I watched the whole lesson... You not ONLY taught me all about the Dorian#4 scale, and its Usage, you made me THINK of how to use OTHER scales, and to be able to write MUSIC!..You are an Excellent teacher, one of the BEST I've ever seen!

  • @sonorstudio1
    @sonorstudio1 4 года назад +2

    One of the best teachers in the world ! No riff raff and neither waisting time or moving to fast. Just perfect

  • @pyrotas
    @pyrotas 4 года назад +34

    One of Satie's favourites. Actually, listening to the Gnossienes is a very good introduction to the kind of eerie atmospheres one can get out of this and similar modes in a not-metal-centric context.

    • @michaeldejong2700
      @michaeldejong2700 3 года назад +4

      Most metalheads dont have the imagination to compose something like this

    • @TheBaconWizard
      @TheBaconWizard 3 года назад +5

      @@michaeldejong2700 As a metalhead, I see you are the kind of person that is capable of thinking in terms of "most " are X. Hypocritical much? The channel-owner is a metalhead btw. Do better.

    • @sunkintree
      @sunkintree Год назад +1

      @@TheBaconWizard unironically saying do better is so lame

    • @mariusirgens5555
      @mariusirgens5555 Год назад +1

      Thanks for the tip ❤ I love how he changes between dorian #4 and normal minor.

    • @josephperkins-z7n
      @josephperkins-z7n Месяц назад

      @@sunkintree unironically demeaning constructive criticism is not good.

  • @mikeythemaestro
    @mikeythemaestro 4 года назад +23

    Holy Crapoloni, a theory video that doesn't make me feel like I'm taking a class on calculus or physics
    >..>
    Thank you

  • @mickaelkyrlis1702
    @mickaelkyrlis1702 4 года назад +4

    One of my favorite scales in greek folk music also, it's called "Nikriz" ! In greek "modes", often the V- chord (Em) is becoming E (dominant), if the melody needs it, and you get an Ab in the scale instead of G.

  • @richarddelaney8257
    @richarddelaney8257 4 года назад +27

    Im a beginner in the theory side, I think you're about to change that

  • @efstratiosanagnostopoulos6636
    @efstratiosanagnostopoulos6636 4 года назад +15

    It is used in Greek traditional music. Ποιμενικος is the mode's name (or Nikriz in Turkish). An example, search for έμαθα πως είσαι μάγκας song. Or in greeklish "ematha pws eisai magkas". Enjoy

    • @BlueArpeggio.PoDoDan
      @BlueArpeggio.PoDoDan 2 года назад

      Now that makes me wanna go take a listen to Greek traditional pieces.
      Thanks for the info!!
      Have a great day

    • @hglundahl
      @hglundahl Год назад

      Isn't there also a scale in traditional Cretan music, that has three doric tetrachords instead of two?

    • @efstratiosanagnostopoulos6636
      @efstratiosanagnostopoulos6636 Год назад

      @@hglundahl Sorry, I don't know that. But can you impose 3 dorian tetracords one on top of the other? That would go beyond one octave

    • @hglundahl
      @hglundahl Год назад

      @@efstratiosanagnostopoulos6636 It _does_ go beyond the octave.
      A B C D
      E F#G A
      B C# D E
      For authentic.
      For plagal:
      A B C D
      D E F G
      G A Bb C

  • @TedBoyRomarino
    @TedBoyRomarino 4 года назад +18

    Hey Tommaso, this Am B/A progression are the first two chords of Piazolla's Libertango! 😉
    And Genesis' Ripples uses Dm E/D in the part "for an hour a man may change". I think it's D dorian #11 too

    • @MusicTheoryForGuitar
      @MusicTheoryForGuitar  4 года назад +5

      Libertango is such a good song... I love Piazzolla.

    • @aylbdrmadison1051
      @aylbdrmadison1051 4 года назад +2

      @ TedBoyRomarino : Gotta say, I really love your eclectic musical tastes.

  • @jasentra
    @jasentra 4 года назад +18

    Me: On edge thinking he's playing the song that shall not be named...
    Him: Stairway Denied!

  • @jessemontano6399
    @jessemontano6399 4 года назад +4

    This is such a great channel. Not only information but immediate real world application for me... Thanks, man...

  • @joeldcanfield_spinhead
    @joeldcanfield_spinhead 3 месяца назад

    I love these little bits where I can go off and do something with the info without having to go learn something else FIRST before I understand what it's about.

  • @RaulMannolaX
    @RaulMannolaX 3 года назад +8

    If you want to hear this scale used in Flamenco, check the piece Mezquita by Manolo Salùcar. Sounds fantastic!

  • @UseTheSupeRsonic
    @UseTheSupeRsonic 7 месяцев назад +1

    This is my favorite scale because it reminds me both of playing Castlevania Symphony of the Night when I was just entering my teenage years, but it also reminds me of Gabor Szabo's "Dreams" album.

  • @EclecticEssentric
    @EclecticEssentric 4 года назад +2

    Thanks for the Dorian Sharp 4 breakdown. Your shared knowledge is appreciated!

  • @OptimusPruim
    @OptimusPruim 4 года назад +3

    This YT channel is by far the best one to boost my theory knowledge 👏
    Thank u Sir🤗

  • @zummo61
    @zummo61 4 года назад +2

    Reducing the scale to the two triads is key for me. Easy, fun, and leads to the most creative practicing and songwriting.

  • @EddieMetal68
    @EddieMetal68 2 года назад +5

    This scale (mode of the harmonic minor) makes me feel like "Arabian nights at the Oasis", while the phrigian dominant mode also created by the harmonic minor makes me feel like the "Egyptian mysterious darkness of the pyramids mortuary rooms"

    • @anirudhsilai5790
      @anirudhsilai5790 2 года назад

      Arabian Nights uses the chromatic mediant Am - Cm which is possible because D# is the same as Eb

  • @nickjones5641
    @nickjones5641 4 года назад +5

    I was successful with the Em chord by placing a C or A bass note underneath. It still felt like A was the center.

  • @TedBoyRomarino
    @TedBoyRomarino 4 года назад +7

    Hi Tommaso. Good subject of discussion. All modes with a sharp fourth have some magic in them. This one brings us some Spanish magic.

    • @wulfenii64
      @wulfenii64 4 года назад +3

      That was the first thing that came to my mind as well.

    • @aylbdrmadison1051
      @aylbdrmadison1051 4 года назад +2

      Definitely a Spanish sound in there, and Turkish, and it seems I've heard this in some form of mediterranean music as well. Something I heard as a kid from my parents records probably.

    • @TedBoyRomarino
      @TedBoyRomarino 4 года назад

      @@aylbdrmadison1051 Spain has strong links to arab culture.

  • @bartwisse8197
    @bartwisse8197 3 года назад +2

    Mr.Frenchie,no dis i ntended, is an exelent teacher indeed.Merci!

  • @chris6160
    @chris6160 Год назад +1

    The is the scale Slash plays on the run in the solo to Sweet Child of Mine . Over the A chord.

  • @dominikglockner7170
    @dominikglockner7170 4 года назад +1

    Another great lesson from the harmony master including instantly usable chord progressions, thank you and keep up the good work !!

  • @swmoblues
    @swmoblues 4 года назад +6

    The first two chords sounded like Siouxsie and the Banshees song Night Shift.

  • @fingerzfrienemy2226
    @fingerzfrienemy2226 4 года назад +2

    This guy always helps me break my musical ruts.

  • @guitarmemoir
    @guitarmemoir 4 года назад +1

    You are a wealth of knowledge Tomasso. Thanks again Maestro.

  • @farnaztabatabaee
    @farnaztabatabaee 4 года назад +1

    Amaziiing!please make more videos of these exotic scales😱😱😱😱😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

  • @JohanTillgren
    @JohanTillgren 4 года назад +6

    The only way I can describe how much I love this scale is by dialing in my best lead sound, and shredding this scale non-stop for 5 minutes along with the most expressive bends from #4 to 5 I can muster. It’s hard to prove my point otherwise :)

  • @carbonmonoxide5052
    @carbonmonoxide5052 4 года назад +3

    I think it’s worth noting that when this mode is used in Klezmer, G#s are used to cadence to Am, typically with E7 chords, despite the D# in the melody that clashes with that harmony.

    • @carbonmonoxide5052
      @carbonmonoxide5052 4 года назад

      @FU 50cent Using E7 in the harmony to cadence to Am doesn’t make the pieces in different modes, it’s just how Klezmer music handles modes. It’s similar to how “minor” in classical music includes the natural minor scale, but also the major 6, major 7, and (arguably) b2 for the sake of specific cadences/melodic contours. Most modal music written by people that don’t have formal training in modes doesn’t actually follow the modes perfectly because they weren’t interested in following them for the sake of following them.

  • @dougshankle7946
    @dougshankle7946 4 года назад +1

    This is a really good lesson and one that I will come back to again for sure.

  • @sciexp
    @sciexp 4 года назад +1

    Thanks for sharing. Very moody...
    And the thumb up in the key of G is brilliant... 🙂😉🎶👍

  • @artisinventable
    @artisinventable 4 года назад +1

    Your channel really helps me not staying trite in my playing. Thank you!

  • @faizalahamed1541
    @faizalahamed1541 4 года назад +2

    Love your style and teaching, superb

  • @speedhead
    @speedhead 2 года назад +1

    what a superb, enlightening video. thank you mr instructor man!

  • @lupo10
    @lupo10 4 года назад +2

    So I’m 1:52 in, and I’m lost thinking how can I understand this! But I was loving your voice so carried on. Now 3:47 in and so thankful for the way you not only made me understand, but also created the tabs for me. That’s a great sound. 👍

  • @aylbdrmadison1051
    @aylbdrmadison1051 4 года назад +3

    Awesome! Our power was shut down for the last few days here so I missed this video. But yesterday I was experimenting with mixing this with the lydian mode. There is the commonality of the sharp 4, but they are very different sounds otherwise. One distinctly Major, and the other distinctly minor.

  • @liquidsolids9415
    @liquidsolids9415 4 года назад

    Another cool lesson. Thanks for the simple explanations, and composition ideas. Looking forward to the next one!

  • @DrRonaldSIpock
    @DrRonaldSIpock 4 года назад

    Thanks for all the ideas. I often play this chord (Although I've always called it Dorian #11) but these new perspectives will lead to a fresh vista or two

  • @Gwens42
    @Gwens42 4 года назад +2

    It's funny,
    the french rapper Uzi in his song "à la fête" use a chord progression which starts with I-min II-Maj
    Showing that the sound of dorian #4 is not restricted to cinematic or metal styles but can be applied even in more pop contexts

  • @YashpriyaEntertainments
    @YashpriyaEntertainments 4 года назад +2

    Wow...superb chord progressions in this scale... actually this Dorian #4 scale is very near to Raaga 'Saraswati' in north Indian music..any way... these chord progressions gives unique feel... thanks for sharing.👍👌🙂

  • @stuartthorne4872
    @stuartthorne4872 4 года назад +3

    “Danger, Will Robinson” almost made me spray green tea all over my iPad screen. 🤣🤣🦁🌞

    • @MusicTheoryForGuitar
      @MusicTheoryForGuitar  4 года назад

      HEHEHE, I disclaim every responsibility for water damage or any other kind of hardware, software, or wetware issues ;-)

  • @felipeachter9485
    @felipeachter9485 4 года назад +1

    Your chanel is one off the things there I looking for, at time

  • @neilmarsh7437
    @neilmarsh7437 4 года назад +1

    love the two triads way of thinking about this very useful

  • @jobent3436
    @jobent3436 4 года назад +3

    and for me the sound feels is about worry and curiosity at the same time

  • @guitashamilele
    @guitashamilele 4 года назад +1

    Hello Tommaso! So nice to see you!

  • @firasmaaroufi9809
    @firasmaaroufi9809 4 года назад +5

    Thank you very much. This is one of my favorite scales, I've always felt it has an "evil" sound. Here is a beautiful song in C# dorian#4 :
    " Bab Darek / Mohamed-Ali Kammoun feat. Eya Daghnouj "
    you can find it here on youtube.

    • @sotiriskaraoulanis2014
      @sotiriskaraoulanis2014 4 года назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/5J6CjNc8Njo/видео.html

    • @giovi.0
      @giovi.0 8 месяцев назад +1

      Thank you so much for making me discover this wonderful song.

  • @phutureproof
    @phutureproof 4 года назад +2

    Man, I love this channel!

  • @krassawatmakul6753
    @krassawatmakul6753 3 года назад

    That's very interested scale. About chord progression of this - at the 3rd chord it can use Major or Minor chord
    you can see in the mode of Harmonic Minor - the 7th note = b8 then: 6 - 1 - b3 or 6 - b1/b8 - b3
    Try this progression:
    Dm - Fm
    Dm - E - Fm

  • @JojoJere
    @JojoJere 5 месяцев назад +1

    I like to make an i diminished with the I bIII and #IV of the scale. And I love to use line cliches starting from the diminished tonic chord as the highest note goes up

  • @stevet.4974
    @stevet.4974 4 года назад +1

    AWesome lesson man, I really got into the sound and vibe of what you were putting across a man does this sound have a lot to offer!! Using this in hard rock style seems to work very well. Im going to experiment with it... thanks a lot. Killer lesson.

  • @girthbrooks1708
    @girthbrooks1708 4 года назад +1

    Thank you for your videos!! You are appreciated my man

  • @sieni221
    @sieni221 4 года назад +1

    Dorian is by far my most used scale

  • @R_G_S
    @R_G_S 4 года назад +2

    This reminds me of the band Opeth, they use this type of chord progressions, sounds great..

    • @TheCrazyDog1234
      @TheCrazyDog1234 4 года назад +1

      I thought exactly of this! A Fair Judgement from Deliverance is a perfect example.

  • @frenchiesfrankieandhenry
    @frenchiesfrankieandhenry 4 года назад +13

    I have a few thoughts.
    1. I think you should turn on the RUclips join section. I've been watching your videos for over a year, and while I can't necessarily swing the 50 to a $100 a month just now to get your course, I would like to be able to support you monetarily in some sort of way; or even a Patreon, PayPal, etc.
    2. Perhaps, when you do specific scale lessons, such as this one, or lydian dominant, etc maybe a friendly competition for your faithful community. Like a 30 second composition using that weeks scale, or monthly, however you prefer, really. I just think that will inspire more interaction with your core audience, and even expand the base.
    Then you can pick a few of the compositions and break down what people got right, and where they may have went wrong. For instance, if they shifted the tonal center to e harmonic minor, when it's supposed to be A dorian #6, as you explained in this video.
    I've been on the Beato and Signals channels for about 3 years and I've learned and internalized more from you in the past year, than I've ever retained in 20+ years of playing.
    I'm gonna play around with this scale tonight, as always, thanks so much for rhe inspiration, Tommaso!

    • @d.e.dmzunguking644
      @d.e.dmzunguking644 4 года назад +2

      Great ideas, I agree with your suggestions!
      If you compose something with this scale I'd be happy to hear it, I'm gonna try it myself

    • @frenchiesfrankieandhenry
      @frenchiesfrankieandhenry 4 года назад +1

      @@d.e.dmzunguking644 check out bandlab if you like collaboration. I'll put a link to my page and the latest track I wrote learning to use my recording gear.
      www.bandlab.com/post/3bcbdb2f-c5d9-ea11-8b03-501ac51fd70d

    • @aylbdrmadison1051
      @aylbdrmadison1051 4 года назад

      @@frenchiesfrankieandhenry: Wow, well two things: one is my ears are bleeding that was so loud. Anyone else who is wearing head phones or earbuds be warned, your ears will be damaged.
      Other than that, once I held mine a half a foot away from my ears, what I could hear sounds really good actually. No joke, I'd like to be able to actually hear it some day. lols

    • @frenchiesfrankieandhenry
      @frenchiesfrankieandhenry 4 года назад

      @@aylbdrmadison1051 yeah, that app "masters" your tune. In other words, makes it loud as hell to compete with other loud ass music. Lol
      The original track is better, imo.

  • @randEveScrub
    @randEveScrub 2 года назад +1

    SOO good! Thank you for these vids

  • @gregtees9995
    @gregtees9995 4 года назад +1

    Brilliant lesson.

  • @Beastintheomlet
    @Beastintheomlet 4 года назад +2

    It’s amazing how much my brain keeps trying to go to Em when listening to the examples. After playing around with it a bit you definitely should be careful adding the b7 to the top of a B chord as well, it becomes over whelming wanting to go to Em for my ear.

    • @fingerzfrienemy2226
      @fingerzfrienemy2226 4 года назад

      Me too. I forced myself to use Cminmaj7 and Ebdim7. It resolves to B real well to my ears.
      Just a thought.

  • @AJPMUSIC_OFFICIAL
    @AJPMUSIC_OFFICIAL 3 года назад +1

    Love the videos excellent as always.

  • @GabePerson
    @GabePerson 4 года назад +3

    That augmented section gives me heavy Opeth vibes

    • @emilpysenisoncrack420
      @emilpysenisoncrack420 4 года назад +1

      I think that is exactly what is used in the ghost house in some mario games

    • @marcusking8507
      @marcusking8507 3 года назад +1

      Well, Opeth normally like to use Hungarian Minor (which is pretty similar) during acoustic sections, so that's probably why.

  • @appolinaireyapo1190
    @appolinaireyapo1190 3 года назад +2

    Minor roumanian scale. The 4th degree of harmonic monor

  • @BlueMoonFuzz
    @BlueMoonFuzz 2 года назад +1

    Super helpful 👌 thank you!!

  • @MrHarrygames
    @MrHarrygames 4 года назад +1

    quite ironic you made this . I was working on donna lee and 4 bars before the head finishes this lick is done

  • @Xplora213
    @Xplora213 4 года назад +2

    Welcome to Slayer 101. Excellent examination of the scale melodies involved with those sounds.

    • @michaeldejong2700
      @michaeldejong2700 3 года назад

      Sounds nothing like slayer and other metal stuff

    • @Xplora213
      @Xplora213 3 года назад

      @@michaeldejong2700 you didn’t watch the video, did you? Pedal tone “drone” chord structures is how Slayer and a lot of metal bands create melody and harmony. Clean sections from Sanitarium and Seasons In The Abyss or 213 are easy examples.

    • @michaeldejong2700
      @michaeldejong2700 3 года назад

      @@Xplora213 In an intelligent discussion about music theory its absolutely forbidden to start talking about metal bands

    • @Xplora213
      @Xplora213 3 года назад

      @@michaeldejong2700 in any intelligent discussion, it is forbidden to be a high school age try hard gate keeping the subject.
      This is the first genuine explanation of the theory behind the methods. It got a heart from the creator. He’s probably shaking his head right now “why can’t I blow up like pewdiepie... oh wait, too many of my viewers are jazz douche bags who push away new viewers.” 😂

  • @cactusowo1835
    @cactusowo1835 4 года назад +1

    I love hoy I came exactly from practicing on my keyboarda and trying weird things like taking a scale and changing a grade, well I just came across dorian with #4 and then, I find this video lol, everything is magic

  • @VoidloniXaarii
    @VoidloniXaarii 4 года назад +1

    Thank you very much yet again. You are mega awesomely awesomeness

  • @aleonyohan6745
    @aleonyohan6745 22 дня назад

    Maestro, your lessons are priceless. Where are you from in Italy? And do you have any videos about your life story? I know you said you had a PhD in physics. It would be fabulously interesting to know some of the people, places and things that have inspired you.

  • @SonicArchives
    @SonicArchives 4 года назад +2

    Nice lesson

  • @MS-iq4eo
    @MS-iq4eo Год назад +1

    Great great great!

  • @tonyjones1560
    @tonyjones1560 4 года назад +1

    For a while now, I've been looking for something that, used right, will cause people to run out of the room (other than the quality of my playing, I know some wise-acre was gonna go there, LOL). This could be it... thanks!

  • @MohamadBHadun
    @MohamadBHadun 3 года назад +1

    Wooou...this nice , I like this....

  • @KireyAz
    @KireyAz 4 года назад

    Its very hard to avoid Em,... but i'll try,, thanks for very good lesson

  • @cesiupro123
    @cesiupro123 4 года назад +6

    3:48 is't like Stairway to heaven but jazz

  • @archinsoni1254
    @archinsoni1254 2 года назад +1

    I newly found your channel
    Love your videos

  • @wulfenii64
    @wulfenii64 4 года назад +1

    Very nice.

  • @hasanhammoud8016
    @hasanhammoud8016 4 года назад

    Can u make a video about half notes and their ysages ?? I really enjoy watching ur videos thank you so much☺

  • @pfkmsandiego
    @pfkmsandiego 4 года назад +1

    great vid!

  • @RickMason-yj7pv
    @RickMason-yj7pv 4 года назад

    Reminescent of "Bell, Book and Candle" closing theme.

  • @samueljacobson470
    @samueljacobson470 4 года назад +6

    Ukranian Dorian! One of my favorite examples is the beginning of Egyptian Danza by Al Di Meola. Also a lot of John Zorn

  • @oguzkaan5235
    @oguzkaan5235 4 года назад +1

    thank you

  • @walterdebbarma561
    @walterdebbarma561 4 года назад +1

    The best teacher

  • @ionageman
    @ionageman 4 года назад +2

    My dream of being an advanced guitar player continues to shatter .. how does anybody learn this .

    • @MusicTheoryForGuitar
      @MusicTheoryForGuitar  4 года назад +2

      You just need to learn things in the right order. Watch this playlist first, and take it slowly :). ruclips.net/video/V7wGIxpW5rM/видео.html

  • @malahamavet
    @malahamavet 3 года назад

    so, I have a Romanian Kaval and wanted to know what's this scale name. I just realized that many Romanian kaval music is either in this dorian #4 or regular dorian mode 😁 I wanted to know because the Romanian kaval always sounded a bit exotic but not stereotypical middle eastern, the old dances were played in a scale that was strange and mysterious. sounded minor but with just a tiny eastern sparkle that made it unique compared to the more famous oriental scales. now I know, it's called dorian #4 and I love it

  • @N0THlNG-2-C-H3R3
    @N0THlNG-2-C-H3R3 4 года назад

    According to my notes Dorian is the second mode of major and the scale that you show is Roumanian minor also the 4th mode of harmonic minor
    Never mind, I didn't catch the sharp fourth of Dorian but I still think that's a bad way to represent it. I could just call it A minor with a sharp fourth + a sharp sixth. We really need to represent scales in binary and it would end all this confusion.

  • @Shareef2610
    @Shareef2610 4 года назад

    Very beautiful and amazing explanation. But why you don’t add music notes so other not guitar player can understand

  • @maciejjanoszko1214
    @maciejjanoszko1214 2 года назад

    Isn't the "First prayer" by Deathspell Omega built just in this scale (but in the key of E) and the same progression?

  • @noorerishan7910
    @noorerishan7910 3 года назад

    pls do a lesson on Lydian #2 or #11 the 6th mode of harmonic minor...

  • @aztlangrooverecordz
    @aztlangrooverecordz 4 года назад +1

    thank you for the info brooo!!! ... :)

  • @mattgilbert7347
    @mattgilbert7347 4 года назад

    I got lost halfway through. Back to regular Dorian and pentatonic for me!

  • @intervalkid
    @intervalkid 4 года назад

    The Em (vi) doesn’t have a pull per se it is just centuries of classical music have conditioned our ears expectation to seem that way. To prevent this pull from superseding your tonal center (mode) you will need to write the progression in such a manner to overcome it, use proper voice leading, and you may need secondary scales which will reinforce the tonal center and primary mode. The diatonic variant modes are sometimes more difficult to compose progressions from that include the chord representing the scales origin tonal center (harmonic minor in this case) since the scale was built to define it as the tonal center in the first place. All the more useful a role secondary secondary scales might play to perform this.

  • @howardanderson3061
    @howardanderson3061 4 года назад +1

    Nice tutorial,,,another good one..."danger Will Robinson" haha
    Did you watch American TV shows growing up?

    • @MusicTheoryForGuitar
      @MusicTheoryForGuitar  4 года назад +1

      That joke is literally the only thing I know about the show ;-) It just popped out in my mind while I was recording.

  • @ramrod924
    @ramrod924 4 года назад +1

    You explained this better than my teacher

  • @inFAMOUSgagimeister
    @inFAMOUSgagimeister 4 года назад

    Most klezmer music uses this scale and it does not sound evil at all. in arabic music this scale/maqam is called Nikriz and is used a lot in Turky, Also used a lot in slavic music and is often called romanian minor. I personaly would rather call it the bombastic scale! It is actually a very versitile scale that packs a lot of personality. It is the minor version of the overtone scale

  • @JojoJere
    @JojoJere 5 месяцев назад +2

    Try this chord progression.
    idim -> i -> bVI/I -> VIdim/I
    It sounds like creepy footsteps

  • @chandlermoss103
    @chandlermoss103 4 года назад +2

    You play the devils music with your diminished 5th interval sir

  • @jeffbrown1366
    @jeffbrown1366 4 года назад +1

    Cool thanks, a mode of a harmonic minor....

  • @fivetimesyo
    @fivetimesyo 4 года назад

    There's an great blues tune by Hard Swimmin' Fish called Blind Love that, uses something like this in the solo. It's a minor scale with a #4 but then the top is really strange with an aug6 and a maj7. I kinda wonder if they thought it through our if it just happened because it falls nicely under the fingers (if you avoid the weird 6).

    • @alsatusmd1A13
      @alsatusmd1A13 4 года назад

      ##6? Isn’t that normally the same semitone as the major 7?

    • @fivetimesyo
      @fivetimesyo 4 года назад

      @@alsatusmd1A13 you're right. I was thinking (wrongly) of the major 6 as #6 by comparison with the b6 of aeolian, so I didn't know what to call the next semitone up. Its proper name is aug6, which is the same as the b7. So the scale ends up having a "b7", then a maj7, then the tonic. It's still really weird...
      Thanks for the heads up. I'll correct it now.