From Ape to God: Sapiens Book Review (Urdu/ Hindi)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- From Ape to God: Sapiens Book Review (Urdu/ Hindi
Sapiens is one of the greatest books ever written on evolutionary history of humans. It contains utmost significance in the world when it comes to history and its understanding.
Yuval Noah Harari has written this book in 2014 from then onwards the book has earned much reverence throughout the world for its comprehensive account of humans.
The book carries four chapters which majorly revolve around three phenomenal revolutions in humans history: Cognitive Revolution 70000 years ago, Agricultural Revolution around 12000 years ago and Scientific Revolution which is very recent 500 years ago.
I have attempted to explain and review the book in detail. Every chapter is separately reviewed so that you could get a thorough and even minute understanding of the book.
Watch it to understand and know your own history: of Homo Sapiens.
Links:
Harari’ book “21 lesson for 21 century”
• 21 Lessons for the 21s...
Facebook: m.facebook.com...
#sapiens #sapiensbookreview #yuvalnoahharari #homosapiens #cognitiverevolution #scientificrevilution #inshanattaspeaks #reading #bookreviews #inshanattabooks #bookreviewinurdu #bookreviewinhindi #sapiensexplained
#inshanattaspeaks
This is the first time I've watched someone with a Sindhi accent speak so bravely, rationally, and unbiased about a book like this...
There are so many Sindhis who speak and work on books greatly.
Thanks for your kind words dear❤️
Dhruv Rathee ko copy na karo
@extraorchidinary6347
Dear Kitab mene parhi, uspe research krke review mene banaya editing mene ki present krke upload mene keya
Aur ap kahe rahe ho Dhuruv rathe ko copy kr raha ho
Wesy agr even if learns and copies Dhruv rathee’s way there should be no issue in learning.
@@Inshanattaspeaks bro don't waste your energy on such people. They will always have to say something negative. Woh hum Punjabi main kehte hain naa.. Aata gundhi hildi.... bas in logo ka wohi hisaab hai.
Mashallah ❤️ keep it up
I read this book few months ago, but didn't understand it completely. May be my mental capacity wasn't enough to digest this master peace. The way you defined it compelled me to read it again. Very well elaborated SAIN
♥
Thanks dear.
But there is nothing like short or insufficient mental capacity.
Read it once more and hopefully u will enjoy reading it. ❤️
Your lines show Ur humbled nature ..really v much inspired by u
@@InshanattaspeaksWhat a thought !❤
@sibghatmangii2210 thanks dear ❤️
Thanks for your kind words ❤️
Science is secular.
Brilliant review ❤
Thanks ❤️
Very unusual style… I’m enjoying the book… It’s too dense to take it in one gulp however. But your review so good about that book watching From Russia
Thanks dear ❤️
Finally my long wait of this book summary is finished.thanks dear
Thanks dear ❤️
Better discussion to understand book ,
@abukhas73 thanks ❤️
I read this book very keen .The Apes of God is a fine cynical lacework... The novel is an intricate rococo of words… And its title cleverly joints the origin of species with divinity… However in his wicked tale Wyndham Lewis sneers at the sham artistic beings who apishly attempt to imitate creative acts of God…
Great Efforts Sain❤
Thanks ❤️
u have lots of potential to be the one of the top youtubers of Pakistan in intellect category. I need your introduction please made a video about you
Lots of thanks! ❤️
واھ ❤
ايترا ڏينھن توهان ڪٿي ھئا.!
نيڪ خواهشون
اتي ئي پيارا.
قرب اوهان جا❤️
Well explained bhai ❤
Thank u dear ❤️
Good video chat and it's spontaneous❤
Thank u ❤️
Bro background music finish ar full low kr du... Serious discussion aisy sae smj ni ati
Sure dear.
Wesy Music is not the part of entire video. It is just in beginning.
harari is more powerful than God who present in myths
Humans are the most powerful things in today’s world. Harari argues this that there were a time when gods and religious scriptures were powerfull, but now all power lies in humans.
Sir! That is very well explained❤
Shuqrya ❤️
Tawhan khe natho lage ta evolution jo concept God and coming of Adam from heavens khe khatam tho kare??? In khe saheeh kian tha chaee saghaun?? We don't know with surity about any of human like species which existed before Us? It completely opposes Islamic beliefs.....
Dear, science and religion are two different and entirely separate things. I don’t say or implore you consider this book or science true or perfect. I have just reviewed the book and have tried to convey the idea of the book. It is now up to you and on every individual to follow the path they want. However, one thing I can say is that everyone should not follow anything so blindly whether that is science or religion or any other thing. One must investigate and interrogate things by the lieu of the capacity of one’s faculties. If one begin to use his/ her mind and begin to question things, he then I thing can drain better conclusions.
@@InshanattaspeaksA great reply🙏❤️ Very well said,, Tawhan khe Fb te message kayo atham.. Thanks a lot and more power to you💙
buhat hi achi explaination hai good work keep it up
Thanks❤️
Thanx brother for info and pehla paksitani banda mila jo rationaly baat kar raha
Buht shuqrya dear ❤️
Well Explained
Thanks ❤️
Theory of evolution is fact ?
Yes it is an established scientific fact and theory both
Yes. You can gauge its authenticity from the fact that 97%of world’s scientists agree on evolution of humans.
@@InshanattaspeaksNo there is fact like thing in science in modern scientific world. There are new theories which take position of previous.
there have been instances in history where a scientific consensus was later proven wrong. Science is a process of discovery, and as new evidence emerges, previous theories or beliefs can be revised or even overturned.
Here are a couple of notable examples:
1. **Geocentrism vs. Heliocentrism**: For centuries, the prevailing belief was that the Earth was the center of the universe (geocentrism). This view was widely accepted by scientists and philosophers until the 16th century, when Copernicus proposed that the Sun was at the center of the solar system (heliocentrism). Later, Galileo and others provided evidence supporting this model, fundamentally changing our understanding of the cosmos.
2. **Phlogiston Theory**: In the 17th and 18th centuries, the phlogiston theory was widely accepted. It posited that a fire-like element called phlogiston was released during combustion. This theory was later debunked by the discovery of oxygen and the modern understanding of chemical reactions.
These examples highlight the self-correcting nature of science. As new evidence comes to light, scientific theories are tested and updated, which can lead to significant shifts in our understanding.
Latest time 100% authentic researches proven be wrong.
Recent examples of scientific consensus being revised or challenged include:
1. **Stomach Ulcers and Bacteria (Helicobacter pylori)**:
- **Past Consensus**: For a long time, it was believed that stomach ulcers were primarily caused by stress, spicy foods, or excessive acid production.
- **New Understanding**: In the 1980s, Australian scientists Barry Marshall and Robin Warren discovered that a bacterium called *Helicobacter pylori* (H. pylori) was the main cause of most stomach ulcers. Their work was initially met with skepticism but eventually revolutionized the treatment of ulcers, leading to the use of antibiotics instead of just acid-reducing drugs.
2. **Pluto's Status as a Planet**:
- **Past Consensus**: Pluto was discovered in 1930 and was considered the ninth planet of the solar system.
- **New Understanding**: In 2006, the International Astronomical Union (IAU) redefined the criteria for planet status, leading to the reclassification of Pluto as a "dwarf planet." This decision was based on new understanding of the characteristics of celestial bodies in our solar system, particularly in the Kuiper Belt.
3. **The Role of Cholesterol in Heart Disease**:
- **Past Consensus**: For decades, dietary cholesterol was believed to be a major contributor to heart disease. Foods high in cholesterol, like eggs, were often avoided.
- **New Understanding**: More recent research has shown that dietary cholesterol has a much smaller impact on blood cholesterol levels and heart disease risk than previously thought. The focus has shifted more toward the types of fats consumed (saturated vs. unsaturated) rather than cholesterol itself. This has led to changes in dietary guidelines in many countries.
4. **Impact of Saturated Fats**:
- **Past Consensus**: Saturated fats were universally considered harmful and directly linked to heart disease. Many dietary guidelines recommended minimizing their intake.
- **New Understanding**: Recent studies have questioned the strength of the link between saturated fats and heart disease. Some research suggests that the relationship is more complex, and other factors, like the overall diet and the type of saturated fat, play a role. This has led to some revisions in dietary advice, though the topic remains debated among scientists.
These examples demonstrate that science evolves with new evidence, and what was once considered true can be reassessed as our understanding deepens.
So, by many researches there are many loopholes in evolution theory. And by the way it is such a theory you presenting
Best review all of one🙏
Gratitude ❤️
Halo very good explained...hamare sochne kee takat kee wajha se ham insan hai..hamare sochne kee wajha se sare mazhab hai... question ye hai sochne kee takat insano k hi paas kyu hai?? Iske peeche hi khuda hai...phir next question paida hota hai kiska wala khuda kyunki sabki aapni apni dhapli hai or apna apna raag 😊
True everyone has his own god and own constructed stories.
Baqi This question that Why only Homo sapiens has thinking capacity is answered in the video.
Harari is the most nonsense person on earth,go read ur Torah and quran..all reason and talk with logic ull find if u believe God.. otherwise go astray
Love from a Pashtoon brother. ❤❤❤
Thanks and lot’s of love❤️
I listened and subscribed as I can get new videos
You will get more such videos❤️
Sindhi me vedio thayo,
Zaror ❤️
Wah sardar❤
Thanks ❤️
Well explain ❤🎉
Thanks dear ❤️
Very well explained,,,good work
Thanks dear ❤️
Well explain ❤
Thanks dear ❤️
Science 🔭🧪🔭🧪 zindabaad
Science ❤️
subscribed ! ..... by exmuslim atheist
Shuqrya ❤️
Great sahab
Thanks ❤️
Science believes imperfectness
True. Because perfection is death.
@@Doz997 who is abusing science?
❤
Very informative Sir❤
Thanks dear ❤️
Well Explained ❤
Thanks ❤️
Well Described ❤️
Thanks dear ❤️
Its been my topic in Pakistan. But people around opposed badly talking variou belives. Finally, i stopped talking about.
Don’t stop. Keep talking.
@@Inshanattaspeaks ok...I will send you my video soon....right now I am in Canada....late night here
Theories only!
Okayy!
Even then scientific theories are much more solid than religious stories.
@@Inshanattaspeaks No comparison of scientific theories with socialogical/anthropological stories. Science is based on concrete facts/evidences. Others based on inferences.
Abhi tak ka behtreen review
Thanks ❤️
He is openly gay His book Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind is an effort in the genre of universal history. Like many such efforts, it does not contain much actual history. Rather, it is a speculative reconstruction of human evolution, supplemented by the author's thoughts on recorded history and the human condition
Ya to theory of evolution shi hai ya fir islam ki aadam ki theory… you have brain so think accordingly 💯👍
It is very debatable thing dear. We can’t draw conclusion so easily. However, I personally believe in scientific things. Religious dogmas and stories don’t appeal me..
Islam doesn't say adam was first person he was first chosen person and was a prophet
If there were nit humans before adam so to whom he was sent to
And according to quran when Allah created adam the angels said he will.make disturbance why are you making him
So my question is taht how the angels got to know he will make disturbance ? Because they knew it he will do as same things as humans did it before him
@Sam-isra
Islam does say that the first human was Adam, and probably the first prophet not sent for any nation to reform it but sent due to his mistake .
And dear this is question that most atheists asks and reject Islamic idea of Adam that Adam was not the first human. Humans evolved a lot earlier than Adam arrival in earth..
@Inshanattaspeaks OK bro can you please give the verse that says Adam was first human and no humans exist before him
I can prove that he was a chosen person and before him no body van speaks but he could and via history he came almost 10000 years ago and surprisingly we found sigh of language in that time not before
And according to quran the final testament Angels bow down to Adam
Tell me on the base of what????
What he got that Angels make to knee before him
That was the knowledge
And when you come to old testament you will find why Angels boe down to Adam that was knowledge that he gave name to everyone thing(knowledge of language) that never existed before Adam
Beautiful
Thanks ❤️
😮
Very informative video
Thanks dear.
❤
What a review!❤❤
Thanks dear
Keep sharing it with ur friends ❤️
😮😮😮😮😮😮good
copy of khan sir
Thanks for well explaination
یہ آخر میں جو سوال آپ نے سامنے رکھے ہیں یہ واقعی قابلِ غور ہیں. سچائی یہ بے کہ آج کا انسان پریشان اور بے سکون ہے.
Bilkul! They are thought provoking questions which compel us to think why exactly humans are suffering so greatly despite so much scientific growth.
Acha lga ki pakistan me bhi rational thinking rkhne wale log hai
Thanks ❤️
I am agnostic
This is middle path which carries weight in its place.
Well illustrated! लेकिन अाप बुक के च्याप्टरवाइज करते ताे अाैर अच्छा रहता!
Thank u ❤️
Bhai….Adam Seeker, Zafar Heretics and Sachwala pe videos banaye…Plzzzz..
Will make dear ❤️
I'm Agnostic
Mujhe nahi pata k duniya k religions books 📚 Sach hai ya jhoot..... isliye main Agnostic hu
Being Agnostic is a good approach as one is still unable to prove or deny the existence of God.
3:57 yahan aap ghalti kar diye ... pahli life species 3.8 billion years ago ... insan nahi thay toh insani tarikh kaise hui? haan earth ki tarikh bol sakte ho
It is true that when life appeared on earth, that was not humans. But this books talks about human specie in specific. It tells us as how the only human species has made wonders and wonders.
🥰🥰
How homesepion s know good and bad things
Biologically there is no good and bad. Good and bad things belong to our society. It is morality humans have created over the ages. The reason why humans created idea of good and bad because they were beginning to live as a larger group, community and society. So, there was also need of certain moral and psychological restrictions on what to do and what to avoid.
I'm going to read this book after listening your review. Very well explained 👍🏻✨
Thanks dear ❤️🌹
Ensab batoon pe kease yaqeen kar loon.
Since humans have their mind and logic to use, It is human nature that they believe things that have some basis or logic. They require evidences for things to be true.
Hence , this idea has overwhelming scientific as well as observational proofs, so it becomes quite compelling to accept this.
Excellent work 👏👏👏
Thank u sir ❤️
Only speculations
Okay!
Good sindhi accent
Thank u ❤️
Simple We have many proof for evolution and not for supernatural creation
True.
When saw your thumbnail i thought its should not be done to misguide people ... but u did well to attract religious people who think Evolution is just joke
Thanks for such kind remarks ❤️
Watching From India Vit, great review. I've had The Apes of God on my book shelf for a few years. I started reading it, the Prologue and Part 1. I am already one third into Proust's Vol.1. The Way by Swann's, of In Search of Lost Time. A lucky coincidence to start The Apes of God. I realise that the Prologue and Part 1, about Lady Fredigonde and Co. has to be a send-up satire of Proust's elderly Aunt and household.
Thanks dear
❤
Thank u ❤️
Brilliant brother (Y)
Keep it up!!
Just amazed to see your intellectual level.
Thanks dear.
Keep watching ❤️
Muslim hone ke bad bhi apake himmat ko dad dena padea
I have just tried to explain and convey the ideas writer has written in the book. ❤️
we are not muslims... we are exmuslim atheist
@@abdulmoizniaziPakistan mein?!! 😮😮
Loving the informative content! Happy to see educational videos like this coming out of Pakistan, especially from Sindh! Keep up the great work! 💞
One more thing, take inspiration from creators like Dhruv Rathee, but maintain your old unique style, it's what suits you! 🌷✨️
Buht shuqrya apki comment ka ❤️
I read physically this book .Amazing this one
This is great book❤️
Let me suggest you Qaisar Ahmad Raja or Prof Ahmad Rafique Akhtar
Well explain ❤❤
Thanks dear ❤️
Love you so much from India 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
Lots of love for such love ❤️
واھ ❤
ايترا ڏينھن توهان ڪٿي ھئا.!
نيڪ خواهشون
Superb lecture jani..
Thanks dear ❤️
Your channel will definitely grow faster ❤
Hope so.
Thank u for well wishes. ❤️
Excellent review .....Very good job. Highly recommended . Thank you Mr Inshan
Thank u so much ❤️
بہت ہی اچھا چینل ہے آپ کا اور آپ کے بولنے کا انداز بھی بہت اچھا ہے. دعا ہے کہ آپ کا چینل دھروو راٹھی سے بھی زیادہ آگے جائے. سبسکرائبڈ.
Buht shukrya for ur love and kindness ❤️
This book is Really fruitful Lewis: A really interesting man....I think I prefer his art....but his work is keen to explore
He has wonderfully written this ❤️
Best dear
Best review of book till now
Thanks Shahabaz ❤️
My question is that's " how man realize their is any God who made us ?
By using power of thinking and imagining.
❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ acchj malumat
Shuqrya ❤️
Boht ache bhai...lage raho acha kaam kar rhe ho
Shuqrya ❤️
Hello can you tell me what software u use to to edit your video
Different applications for different purposes.
CapCut
Vita
Filmora
Agr religion myth ha to genes ko program kisny kia bta?
It is a natural phenomenon, and the nature is not necessarily religion or god.
Keep it up bro,
Great Work ❤❤
Thanks dear
The book was published more than a decade ago, and the citizens of advanced, developed, and cultured nations have long since read and moved on from it. But here we are, with Pakistan-a struggling Third World country that survives on handouts from the World Bank, IMF, the U.S., and China-finally getting around to reviewing it over 10 years later. This is precisely why Pakistan remains mired in poverty, dependency, and begging. Stay in your place, my friend, because that’s all you’ll ever be-a nation that lags behind, always chasing the world’s leftovers.
Keep it up, ❤❤❤
Thanks ❤️
Love watching you grow bro Ma Shaa Allah, you doin greatttt❤
Thanks ❤️
There is no allah
Good wark❤❤❤❤❤
Indebted ❤️
Nice video informative
Thanks dear
Well explained dear
Thanks dear
So amazing bro
Thanks ❤️
Well explained
Thanks dear
Good❤
Thanks dear
just remember, harari is the same guy who referred to humans as controllable animals
True. Humans can be controlled.
Thus, harari says the stories humans have created are actually controlling them. Stories of different kind that they generated are now working as a check on their freedom.
However, Harari also seems to be saying that in foreseeable future things will change. Such stories will no longer be relevant to humans. They won’t appeal humans any more. Humans could get to the heights of freedom and animalism then. And to control humans again, another set of stories and myths created by very humans is important. They will do what they want unless construct another fascinating stories which indirectly controls them.
@@Inshanattaspeaks those stories he is speaking about is referring to religion... that idea you are referring to is taking humanity to atheism by erasing religion. now i am not suggesting atheism is bad and religion is good. and his idea of controlling is like how animals are controlled in a zoo or a farm... also installing chips in humans in the future when that technology is available to control them like robots.
this book is older, things have changed a lot since then. not everything that glitters is gold.
@childrenofadam4 true things have changed over time. And the ideas to grow old as humans. But the things he has delved into in the book are relevant even today. I don’t find anything Harari has talked in the book has gone irrelevant. If u have anything such in mind, share it?
@@Inshanattaspeaks i just did share it above.. also you can do your own research what is he upto now, who is he working for and what is the agenda of who he is working for...
as i said, this book is old, and the ideology of the writer has changed a lot since then.... and i will also say it again, all that glitters is not gold
@childrenofadam4
Okay!
Wawo ❤ Amazing
Thanks dear ❤️