Carb vs EFI On The DYNO!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
  • Here's a look aback at a test we did a little while ago. So cool to watch the gas flow.

Комментарии • 175

  • @junkyardjimmyriversiderecy6722
    @junkyardjimmyriversiderecy6722 Год назад +38

    Nick is top shelf material for sure 😊

  • @Ang3lUki
    @Ang3lUki 4 месяца назад +56

    One of these starts without a fuss in the cold

    • @chopperking007
      @chopperking007 3 месяца назад +10

      That's what the choke is for

    • @matthewhattia7091
      @matthewhattia7091 Месяц назад +2

      ​@chopperking007 that's basically the fuss😭

    • @Ang3lUki
      @Ang3lUki Месяц назад +2

      @@matthewhattia7091 Meanwhile the injected engine is making MORE power with denser air charges.

    • @matthewhattia7091
      @matthewhattia7091 Месяц назад +2

      @SoylentGamer The only upside is, flipping the emergency switch while rolling in gear, then flipping it back, to shoot flames. (Yeah, I know it's bad for the engine)

    • @mooosestang
      @mooosestang 29 дней назад

      The carb with the electric choke?

  • @ManderscheidMedia
    @ManderscheidMedia Год назад +14

    I love the top down view in the barrels! Watching the fuel flow!! Awesome!

  • @Adam-nv9zo
    @Adam-nv9zo Год назад +164

    I would love to know the hp numbers.

    • @Adam-nv9zo
      @Adam-nv9zo Год назад +5

      @@michaelmays9292 cool. Thank you.

    • @markt9438
      @markt9438 Год назад +13

      I watch this test run and Nick adjusted that carburetor almost as close as the EFI so it can be done old school for a lot less money just depends on what you want

    • @Steven-y9q
      @Steven-y9q Год назад +16

      Carb usually gives 15 to 35 more horsepower that what everyone thinks is it

    • @rickybailey7123
      @rickybailey7123 2 месяца назад +4

      All the Dyno test runs the carb wins by ten to fifteen horsepower every time the carb is the winner every time

  • @MrJosephfunk
    @MrJosephfunk Год назад +117

    I'm a big fan of keeping it simple. Carburetor with mechanical fuel pump leaves so little to go wrong.

    • @JimmyCasket02
      @JimmyCasket02 Год назад +18

      There’s really not much to go wrong with efi either

    • @MrJosephfunk
      @MrJosephfunk Год назад +10

      @JimmyCasket02 self learning systems are nice since some of us cave men still don't understand fuel table and other such things yet but we're learning.

    • @Cherokee93
      @Cherokee93 Год назад +11

      Carbs get dirty really quick compared to efi rarely getting dirty

    • @MrJosephfunk
      @MrJosephfunk Год назад +6

      @Cherokee93 really? Because I've ran them my whole life of 40 plus years and other than ones that have sat on a shelf I've not had one that didn't do what it's supposed to. I still daily drive carbed vehicles and the only thing I don't like is the ethanol fuel evaporates if left for days and you have yo let it pump up fuel.

    • @efanclublolsmaforlife2501
      @efanclublolsmaforlife2501 Год назад

      One to bet

  • @natelorimer8567
    @natelorimer8567 Год назад +33

    "Let's put a six pack" hahah his Dodge devious spirit jumps out on the SBC.

    • @mikatamminen2786
      @mikatamminen2786 Год назад +2

      Or in GM terms a tripower.

    • @natelorimer8567
      @natelorimer8567 Год назад +3

      @Mika Tamminen yes GM called it that. First was the 348 tri power , then was made bigger by the 409 which was available with two 4 barrels carbs.

  • @crazyhorse3275
    @crazyhorse3275 Год назад +13

    I prefer carburetor and mechanical fuel pump it’s simple no headaches on the long run. My 77 el Camino with a 540 gives me 700 hp just like that no worries.

  • @anthonypesqueira7540
    @anthonypesqueira7540 Год назад +13

    I took my EFI off and went to carb. The engine sounds happier and the power is waaaaayy better. I can tune it on the spot. If you know how carbs work, you'll never want to use EFI on a race engine or classic car

  • @markt9438
    @markt9438 Год назад +9

    Nick said it simple ! Carb can be adjusted to do the same !

  • @ericball6000
    @ericball6000 Год назад +6

    Dr. Nick, the King of the dyno.

  • @richardstump4582
    @richardstump4582 Год назад +2

    Sounds Fantastic!!

  • @douglasb9105
    @douglasb9105 Год назад +16

    Old school meets new school!👍👍

  • @derekbowbrick6233
    @derekbowbrick6233 Год назад +5

    If you are miffed because there are no numbers, tough. We fans already know from watching the original video with Piss Cutter.

  • @gillesanglehart5300
    @gillesanglehart5300 Год назад +11

    Carb for me regardless of the numbers.

  • @alltheboost5363
    @alltheboost5363 Год назад +12

    Efi for the win... better throttle response, more tunability, better mpg, and better cold starts. Oh and more power at any throttle position. Lol

    • @bartschwartz9233
      @bartschwartz9233 Год назад +2

      If yr a driver not stock point judging EFI and no warm period for engine to warm
      Up. Turn key and go

    • @bartschwartz9233
      @bartschwartz9233 Год назад +2

      EFI is more power on demand and 000 vapor lock up and more reliability if u do a lot of Sumer and high summer temperatures

    • @anthonypesqueira7540
      @anthonypesqueira7540 Год назад +6

      False, if you know carbs and how to pick the right one, is out performs EFI. The Carb is an atomizer. You can't get better fuel air mixture than that.

    • @KingJT80
      @KingJT80 11 месяцев назад +1

      until you get a mechanical secondary with annular boosters....way better than down leg and dog legged booster...they are just a better carb and faster and will keep up with EFI no problem.

    • @0rvelazqu
      @0rvelazqu 10 месяцев назад +4

      EFI over carburetor, especially up here in the Rocky mountains

  • @burt1758
    @burt1758 Год назад +1

    He's a good guy. Knows his sh*t.

  • @rickybailey7123
    @rickybailey7123 2 месяца назад +1

    All the
    Dyno runs, I've seen the carb wins. Buy 10 to 15 horsepower every time I've seen it Done 3 different times carb, one every time !! In my opinion thats the only place the carb wins is wide open every where else the Fuel injection burns cleaner, run smoother at colder, starts.Even hot starts fuel injections better

  • @chrisbryant6408
    @chrisbryant6408 Год назад +2

    The technology is better performance but if you want the old school feeling you have to have old school parts. Example late 70s olds 403 with a 4barrel quadro jet if you know you know that sound when the secondaries open up

  • @mickangio16
    @mickangio16 6 месяцев назад +1

    Looking down the throats of each the EFI sure looks like bigger venturies. EFI SHOULD make more power in that case. I'm a carburetor fan so I feel cheated😠

  • @czechmate6916
    @czechmate6916 Год назад +1

    Damn I love that sound 👍👍

  • @jefferywdonald
    @jefferywdonald Год назад +9

    I watched the full length episode this short was made from. Very interesting. You should add the final numbers of each setup at the end of the short though.

    • @NicksGarage
      @NicksGarage  Год назад +8

      That would be a bit of a spoiler for our own video, no?

    • @ronaldcallaway3139
      @ronaldcallaway3139 Год назад

      I watched the full episode too that this short version was made of sometimes I think when people bring him a build they built he's always asking what rpm you looking to get after he or they achieve it keeps asking want to see if it'll do better get them some more rpms as if he's trying wanting it to blow Nick is a super smart nice guy

    • @ercost60
      @ercost60 Год назад +11

      425HP Carb, 434HP EFI

  • @matthewgorski3101
    @matthewgorski3101 Год назад +9

    The spray pattern on the EFI is mesmerizing

  • @paulhetherington3854
    @paulhetherington3854 10 месяцев назад +1

    Carb = coolest it - may seem! They don't design it!
    Hence; under law - wouldn't know - any answer.

  • @robertorhymes
    @robertorhymes Год назад +5

    This was from a superb episode Nick's Garage'll get it fit for the road

  • @harryweldon9543
    @harryweldon9543 11 месяцев назад +2

    I'd love to know the numbers as I'm going to build an SBC and go with sniper.

  • @minnesotatomcat
    @minnesotatomcat Год назад +9

    Oh you tease! We need numbers Nick!!

    • @NicksGarage
      @NicksGarage  Год назад +4

      Watch the full video. It’s on our channel now.

    • @GorVala
      @GorVala 5 месяцев назад

      Don't be like that 😢 sharing is caring😊

  • @hippiemiller
    @hippiemiller Год назад +3

    I would depend on the carb more to get me there

  • @theredwedge9446
    @theredwedge9446 Год назад +1

    throw on an edlebrock and you wont need to worry about a crappy efi system. c:

  • @blinkie1523
    @blinkie1523 Год назад +6

    Nick and the dyno, they are made for each other, way cool!!!

  • @Mrbhogarty
    @Mrbhogarty Год назад +2

    On my stock 79 TA so wish EFI versify rottenchester with that stove pipe choke assy..
    Anybody else…pls??
    10-15 min warn up emparssing???

  • @donaldburgess757
    @donaldburgess757 11 месяцев назад +1

    old school carbs if you can keep em clean from soot and rust or carbon burn or plain old dust particles old carbs like the 4 barrel holly or the old Rochester carbs will make a engine purr like a kitten

  • @nickolasedmunds
    @nickolasedmunds 10 месяцев назад +3

    Looks like the carburetor runs pretty lean.

  • @autonomous_collective
    @autonomous_collective Год назад +21

    Show the Dynos.... Carb for me everytime.

    • @ercost60
      @ercost60 Год назад +1

      EFI only adds 9 HP

    • @Projects5309
      @Projects5309 Год назад +1

      @@ercost60
      I wonder if the EFI gets rid of all this stupidness that carburetors cause and create. I would hope so. I absolutely love carburetors and have a quirky preference for old technology but this EFI thing seems to hold water most of the time.

    • @girthquake9655
      @girthquake9655 Год назад

      ​@@Projects5309What "stupidness" do carbs create?

    • @Projects5309
      @Projects5309 Год назад +1

      @@girthquake9655 Hmm, let's see...worn /Leaking throttle shafts, accelerator pump that stops working, accelerator pump that boil the fuel out of the circuit, vapor locking/ hard hot starts..etc...etc. all of that nonsense went on with three different brand new Holley's which I sent them all back to Chinatown where they came from. I've been running a couple Edelbrock AVS2's and all of those problems have gone away for now so EFI is on the back burner.

  • @dougcorwin3090
    @dougcorwin3090 Год назад +2

    Why after a pull instantly shut off the engine let it idle to move the oil off hot surfaces

  • @wayneoakley1832
    @wayneoakley1832 Год назад +2

    Let's do a 6 pack efi😂 that would be something different. Plenty of fuel

  • @59kuy
    @59kuy 11 месяцев назад +2

    Cool

  • @ChefLaRue
    @ChefLaRue Год назад +2

    Where are the numbers Nick?

  • @tannerschneider8492
    @tannerschneider8492 Год назад +5

    Witch made more power?

  • @henrybourdon6712
    @henrybourdon6712 Год назад +1

    Since i do not own the tools to tune a carb(S) i think i will try a 6 BBL EFI. Checked prices and they are about 200.00 up or down depending where you buy each one.

  • @1607rosie
    @1607rosie Год назад +2

    Did you guys see the distributor move when he revd up first time .

  • @Yokomohoyo69
    @Yokomohoyo69 4 месяца назад +2

    Which one did better?

  • @billyhernandez7540
    @billyhernandez7540 9 месяцев назад +1

    Carbs are great just hate the cold starts

  • @josephverdone7099
    @josephverdone7099 Год назад +15

    I have learned something from your video. A carburetor is as good if not better then the EFI unit I just installed. Going back to my Carburetor.

  • @Project-gr6zy
    @Project-gr6zy 3 месяца назад +1

    Efi by my definition is injecting directly into the ports
    Not TBI or basically a carb where the jets were replaced with fuel injectors basically doing the same job with electronic control instead of mechanical means

  • @1607rosie
    @1607rosie Год назад +1

    Mn that dist moved twice watch the video! It probably moved four degrees

  • @largos7289
    @largos7289 2 месяца назад +1

    LOL so which one was better? or was this not the point of the video?

  • @20alphabet
    @20alphabet Год назад +2

    No results included? Disappointment ensues.

  • @UFO-047
    @UFO-047 Год назад +1

    Thats not a Holley Sniper running on the engine on the dyno as was shown in the box at the start. Did you run multiple efi units?
    Ill have to try to find the original vid.

  • @Jim-sz2be
    @Jim-sz2be 9 месяцев назад +1

    Six pack indeed

  • @zachwebb6879
    @zachwebb6879 Год назад +2

    Nick i think we need the six pack

  • @Zulebmwe007
    @Zulebmwe007 Год назад +1

    OlD school 😊😊

  • @sportsmansparadice42
    @sportsmansparadice42 Месяц назад +1

    Where are the dyno numbers for each set up?

  • @lateefcarrere1649
    @lateefcarrere1649 Год назад +1

    I love my carbs... whether it's steak or six-pack. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

  • @jeffreyrue4569
    @jeffreyrue4569 8 месяцев назад +1

    So now for a daily driver, carb or EFI (Holley sniper?)

  • @Boeing__747
    @Boeing__747 Год назад +1

    im new to car stuff so correct me if im wrong. one above is the carburator right? whereas the one below is a fuel injection with throttle body on top? carburators and throttle body always confuse me.

  • @michelswerissen6544
    @michelswerissen6544 Год назад +2

    Video approved,click.

  • @pete1003
    @pete1003 Год назад +2

    So what's the verdict? I didn't see the dyno results

    • @NicksGarage
      @NicksGarage  Год назад

      Check out the full episode for the full results.👍

  • @johngowetski1582
    @johngowetski1582 Год назад +1

    Why don't you ever use a velocity stack on the dyno?

  • @rayarthur586
    @rayarthur586 Год назад +1

    cute, but numbers speak louder. we know they both work

  • @Bodeezl7305
    @Bodeezl7305 Год назад +1

    What are the numbers???…thanks a lot

    • @NicksGarage
      @NicksGarage  Год назад

      Check out the full video. You're welcome.

  • @f.chrisliuzzo7889
    @f.chrisliuzzo7889 Год назад +2

    The efi looks to have waaayyyy more fuel atomization then the carb!!?

    • @KingJT80
      @KingJT80 11 месяцев назад

      thats because the carb is down legged boosters.
      you put annular booster in it and bam! now its gonna look about the same and be quicker than down legged or straight legged booster carbs

  • @bruceallen6016
    @bruceallen6016 4 месяца назад +1

    I want to know which made more HP?

  • @petedelavega6094
    @petedelavega6094 Год назад +1

    NICK IS GREAT WHAT AUTOMOTIVE KNOWLEDGE. GENIUS.

  • @DavidDubois-dr1sq
    @DavidDubois-dr1sq Год назад +2

    numbers please.

  • @Valkyrie271
    @Valkyrie271 7 месяцев назад +1

    Where's the numbers?

  • @SoundsLegit71
    @SoundsLegit71 Год назад +1

    I think the carb can always equal the EFI at a given temperature its when temp changes alot the EFI wins.

    • @KingJT80
      @KingJT80 11 месяцев назад

      EFI isnt' that much of a winner over carbs at temperature changes (electric choke fixes that) but ALTITUDE changes

  • @MichaelJohnson-lx8ft
    @MichaelJohnson-lx8ft Год назад +1

    More better fuel atomization =more better

  • @4ondflor
    @4ondflor Год назад +1

    EFI is neat but you can’t beat a 4150

  • @RichardMLowe
    @RichardMLowe Год назад +1

    Nick
    EFI 6-pack vs Carb 6-pack

  • @moparnut6286
    @moparnut6286 11 месяцев назад +1

    Nick is right six pak!!!!

  • @Op1zilla
    @Op1zilla Год назад +2

    😁👽👍

  • @javonbrandon
    @javonbrandon 9 месяцев назад

    Would this work on a 90s sportster

  • @calvincosby921
    @calvincosby921 Год назад +1

    Well 🤔 what's the result?

  • @willkincaid5841
    @willkincaid5841 Год назад +1

    What is the point if you don't see the results? It's always cool to watch!

  • @roybrennen5557
    @roybrennen5557 Год назад +1

    No data??? Should show the numbers so we can see what is what???

    • @NicksGarage
      @NicksGarage  Год назад

      Check out the full video on our channel.

  • @johnjaco5544
    @johnjaco5544 Год назад +2

    Yep the carb is better.

  • @ls1_cammeroh
    @ls1_cammeroh 4 месяца назад

    Looks like the efi uses more fuel.

  • @STSwhisperer
    @STSwhisperer 6 месяцев назад +1

    What was the result?

  • @mohamadsuleimankhamis4627
    @mohamadsuleimankhamis4627 Год назад +1

    Nice

  • @cmte.brazinazzo2061
    @cmte.brazinazzo2061 Год назад +1

    And the results are secret, Nick? I saw,EFI got to redline and cut first but ...

    • @NicksGarage
      @NicksGarage  Год назад

      Watch the full video for the results.

  • @moto_rad
    @moto_rad Год назад +1

    Carb > efi

  • @wht240sxka
    @wht240sxka 9 месяцев назад +1

    Results?

  • @59kuy
    @59kuy 11 месяцев назад +1

    Good work

  • @davidortiz173
    @davidortiz173 Год назад +1

    Nick is cool as hell!

  • @richardbrowne3641
    @richardbrowne3641 Год назад +1

    Which one won? Carb. or E.F.I.?

    • @NicksGarage
      @NicksGarage  Год назад

      Watch the full episode, and find out! 👍

  • @gradertrk
    @gradertrk Год назад

    Thumbs down....compare wiyh no numbers....

  • @tanvirchowdry897
    @tanvirchowdry897 7 месяцев назад

    EFI best

  • @kevinkirkconnell5892
    @kevinkirkconnell5892 Год назад +1

    I'm going to watch the full video !

  • @bunnyheng1384
    @bunnyheng1384 Год назад +1

    We need to know the results !

  • @Gordonseries385
    @Gordonseries385 Год назад +1

    👍

  • @edsoncaires5974
    @edsoncaires5974 Год назад

    Eu torço pelo quadrijet. Se o motor tiver "platinado" melhor ainda!!!!

  • @daviddelgado556
    @daviddelgado556 Год назад

    Efi sistem is shet

  • @PeterHatch-mx7zc
    @PeterHatch-mx7zc Год назад +1

    After watching run a engine rubbing on valve cover just bad workmanship very poor

  • @BigDipperAK
    @BigDipperAK 9 месяцев назад +1

    That’s not really fuel injection. That’s a throttle body style. It’s same as carburetor just controlled by a computer. Fuel injection has single port into each cylinder. This is a lie.

  • @donaldburgess757
    @donaldburgess757 11 месяцев назад +1

    do a tunnel ram with two 780 double pumpers on a 350 block 4 bolt mains 375 horse heads off a corvette with dome pistons or shave the heads thousands of a itch with roller rockers stainless steel crankshaft polished to specs

  • @nerome619
    @nerome619 9 месяцев назад +1

    The 'EFI' added is no more than another type of carb - very poor efi.

  • @Tgtouh-oe9ld
    @Tgtouh-oe9ld 3 месяца назад +1

    I'll stick to my carburetor that way I don't have to worry about sensors and computers and all the other crap that you have to put on your engine