The Shocking Drop of West Air Flight 294 is Hard to Explain 😲Air Disasters | Smithsonian Channel

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 фев 2021
  • Investigators looking at the January 8, 2016 crash of West Air 294 know the plane’s IRU was faulty. But it doesn’t explain how a plane goes from level flying at 33,000 feet to a 600 mile/hour impact in just 80 seconds.
    From Air Disasters: bit.ly/3ppP92T
    #AirDisasters #PlaneCrash #SmithsonianChannel
    Subscribe to The Smithsonian Aviation Channel: bit.ly/2UNavJO
    Twitter: bit.ly/33lH712
    Instagram: bit.ly/3iw9Iay
    Facebook: bit.ly/3kkVOZp
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 290

  • @ryanmanoghan5136
    @ryanmanoghan5136 3 года назад +138

    To the ppl who's never seen this series. If you watch it, it's gonna become an addiction.

    • @Maniacguy2777
      @Maniacguy2777 3 года назад +3

      Really very addicted.

    • @shockgaming1002
      @shockgaming1002 3 года назад

      Name of the channel for full episodes.

    • @velorp5412
      @velorp5412 3 года назад

      It already is

    • @cyrusjosef
      @cyrusjosef 3 года назад

      idk why we like seing people die from crashes

    • @lindenPRZ
      @lindenPRZ Год назад

      just got hooked, need help

  • @teabag9050
    @teabag9050 3 года назад +772

    No lie but they could seriously have a million subscribers if they uploaded whole episodes.

    • @kevinbosma4047
      @kevinbosma4047 3 года назад +2

      fr

    • @user-zf5bw3mi5g
      @user-zf5bw3mi5g 3 года назад +51

      bruh they litterally own the show if they did what's the point of buying the episode they wont make enough money and therefore the show would be closed due to failure

    • @user-zf5bw3mi5g
      @user-zf5bw3mi5g 3 года назад +11

      @@teabag9050 they earn more money from airing shows

    • @jmceditions6719
      @jmceditions6719 3 года назад

      W

    • @unbekannterkanal7318
      @unbekannterkanal7318 3 года назад +11

      they have a second channel with 3 million subscribers

  • @theshermantanker7043
    @theshermantanker7043 3 года назад +210

    Ironic that the aviator's golden rule of don't trust your senses trust the instruments was what ended up killing everyone this time :/

    • @kirilmihaylov1934
      @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад +6

      @Marc Chew different situations . This crash was really a bad one . Big time mechanical failure

    • @miguelsalami
      @miguelsalami 2 года назад

      That was back in the day when the instruments were Made in the U.S.A. 🇺🇸

    • @lruy360ng
      @lruy360ng 2 года назад +1

      i wouldve thought gravity would be enough to tell them that they're about to plummet into the ground.

    • @notme9049
      @notme9049 2 года назад +1

      @@lruy360ng if they sense that theyre falling they would think its a stall due to the nose being up.

    • @DiegoTheGreat89
      @DiegoTheGreat89 2 года назад +4

      There's also a rule to crosschek your instruments before making a decision. If only he had done that

  • @Mar.lxqmzzz
    @Mar.lxqmzzz 3 года назад +219

    I'm finally not 6 years late

  • @HypeMaster080
    @HypeMaster080 3 года назад +78

    Crazy how this happened.
    Prayers go out to them

  • @Rushmore222
    @Rushmore222 3 года назад +97

    Wouldn't the simple cockpit addition of a small globe filled halfway with easily visible liquid help pilots determine pitch and roll accurately?

    • @Kromaatikse
      @Kromaatikse 3 года назад +45

      No, because that doesn't actually indicate pitch and roll in a moving reference frame. A very similar device is used in small aircraft to indicate *slip*.
      If you look carefully, however, you can see a backup vacuum-driven attitude indicator (with its own gyros) in the middle of the instrument panel, between the two pilots. It's shown with an almost completely brown aspect - ie. a steep dive. This is indeed what the aircraft was actually doing. It's intended for use when the "glass" instruments fail, perhaps due to an electric fault. If the pilots had cross-checked the "glass" instruments with the vacuum one, they'd have realised they were getting a false indication on the Captain's side and switched to the FO's.

    • @kirilmihaylov1934
      @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад +3

      @@Kromaatikse they didn't do it though. This was big time mechanical failure. It is possible that the second IRU was also faulty. But more likely the captain didn't understand what was going on and crashed the plane at high speed. Unfortunately that's the truth.

    • @vmsh9810
      @vmsh9810 2 года назад

      Physics arent so easy, Momentum and G force would make the water always look leveled, but honestly i dont know how to explain myself so i'll just show this video
      ruclips.net/video/g99ho_ExApU/видео.html

  • @kcnairnair7299
    @kcnairnair7299 3 года назад +74

    Don’t put questions to us. The reason we see your videos are for answers!

  • @gaithrislife
    @gaithrislife 3 года назад +32

    Was surprised to see a stock image of my beautiful city before clicking on the video. R.I.P to the pilots

    • @kylein9869
      @kylein9869 3 года назад +1

      Sweden has the most beautiful women

    • @gaithrislife
      @gaithrislife 3 года назад +1

      @@kylein9869 yes we do 🥰

    • @kirilmihaylov1934
      @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад +1

      @@gaithrislife I am coming

    • @badgerden7080
      @badgerden7080 2 года назад

      Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

  • @agungtriharyadi9689
    @agungtriharyadi9689 3 года назад +58

    "Hit the ground with 600miles/hour" even if superman sits in that plane he will die

  • @bennetto5872
    @bennetto5872 3 года назад +78

    Noone:
    *SMITHSONIAN AFTER A PLANE CRASHES AND EVERYONE DIES* : Its brighter here

  • @mozartpiano23
    @mozartpiano23 3 года назад +8

    I remember dad told me that machines don’t make mistakes after I told him it’s the computer cause he seen my grades

  • @mrrolex1364
    @mrrolex1364 3 года назад +7

    I love aviation and this channel

  • @limeeirfan6896
    @limeeirfan6896 3 года назад +3

    I watched it on TV just now, and Smithsonian already uploaded it

  • @karlzen86
    @karlzen86 2 года назад +8

    I have been on that plane many times and met both of the pilots multiple times since I work at the postalservice loading the plane with mail and parcels. It was sureal when we got the news the next morning that It had crashed and both pilots lost their lives.

    • @ramblingaly2364
      @ramblingaly2364 2 года назад

      Same here ! I used to work for westair and knew the co-pilot quite well. I couldn't believe it when I got the call 😔

  • @chewybuoyeel
    @chewybuoyeel 3 года назад +14

    Trust your instruments, until you shouldn’t

  • @gtaretard
    @gtaretard 3 года назад +12

    I'm Early and I'm from Sweden myself. I Love this channel!

    • @lucassteen4050
      @lucassteen4050 3 года назад +2

      Hände detta i Sverige?

    • @daze2op435
      @daze2op435 3 года назад +2

      Me too❤️

    • @reyker1144
      @reyker1144 3 года назад +2

      Hi sweden I'm from finland

    • @gtaretard
      @gtaretard 3 года назад

      @@lucassteen4050 Jag tror att det hände i Sverige...

  • @shinchanindia6306
    @shinchanindia6306 3 года назад +8

    rest in peace for both of the pilots may there soul go to heaven and there familese move on and live a happy life

  • @wanamirwantafkir3597
    @wanamirwantafkir3597 3 года назад +20

    How do you go from level at 33,000 feet to 1,000km per hour impact in 1 minute 20 second ? 😱

  • @king_kalo
    @king_kalo 2 года назад

    this clips are addictive cant stop watching😊

  • @danielfairfield1255
    @danielfairfield1255 3 года назад +6

    Such a sad crash, the aircraft failed both the crew

  • @slvr.2ur
    @slvr.2ur 3 года назад +18

    Wouldnt you feel that you’re literally going straight down and then inverted?

    • @aussiesam01
      @aussiesam01 3 года назад +7

      Not necessarily, in theory it would be possible to maintain 1g for the most part, but I'm not saying that is what happened. However, you would notice the pitch and airspeed information telling you that maybe your other instruments were wrong, but then the entire thing happened so fast you would hardly have time to thunk about it and figure out what was wrong.

    • @boeing-ys7wr
      @boeing-ys7wr 3 года назад +8

      Not necessarily, it’s quite possible for planes to “feel” like they’re flying normally, while in reality, the could be inverted, banked, pitching up, etc. This is why instruments are so important for flying in clouds and at night

    • @slvr.2ur
      @slvr.2ur 3 года назад +2

      @@boeing-ys7wr oh ok thx

  • @pr3yal0l
    @pr3yal0l 3 года назад +2

    If I was an Investigator, I'd be confused too

  • @Sevisstillalive
    @Sevisstillalive 3 года назад +5

    reminded me of flight 93 when it hit .

  • @ghosttgirl9805
    @ghosttgirl9805 2 года назад +1

    Please have full episode's

  • @jeffreygosselin1143
    @jeffreygosselin1143 3 года назад +5

    This is getting scary with computers taking over. Bring back dial gauges!!!

    • @StickandGlider
      @StickandGlider 3 года назад +2

      All airliners have backup analog gauges. If there’s a power failure, or a disagreement, the pilots can revert to the old-fashioned way.

    • @kirilmihaylov1934
      @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад

      @@StickandGlider but this wasn't computer failure but an instrument failure. It was major one though

  • @spd_bird
    @spd_bird 3 года назад +3

    1:34 That backup attitude indicator must not have helped lol

  • @kabeertheavgeek
    @kabeertheavgeek 3 года назад +31

    youtube logic:
    0 views
    38 likes

    • @alexwatt19
      @alexwatt19 3 года назад

      That is weird.

    • @alexwatt19
      @alexwatt19 3 года назад

      That happened to me

    • @Velehokala
      @Velehokala 3 года назад +1

      ​@@alexwatt19 stop begin idiots please. its know thing from beginning of youtube. it always shows that when video is released if it have enough watchers

    • @captainbossman1016
      @captainbossman1016 3 года назад

      Kowalski analysis

    • @ArnBrickJeff
      @ArnBrickJeff 3 года назад

      @@alexwatt19 Idiots youtube cant load views but can load likes

  • @devingraves8044
    @devingraves8044 3 года назад +4

    They really putting emojis in titles about videos where people died lmao

  • @racingalienhcr2
    @racingalienhcr2 3 года назад +2

    What I don't get is how the FDR is able to record the actual pitch but the instruments failed to record the actual pitch. Shouldn't the FDR and the instruments record the same pitch? Both use the same IRU.

  • @WillDoesTransport
    @WillDoesTransport 3 года назад

    Plane: Crashes
    Smithsonian Channel:(Happy Music) It's brighter here.

  • @zahidurrahman6422
    @zahidurrahman6422 3 года назад

    Where can I see the full episode??

  • @latasha3472
    @latasha3472 2 года назад +1

    Damn 600 mph😯

  • @sharonhaywood2818
    @sharonhaywood2818 2 года назад +1

    They have to remember that humans put those aircraft together and whatever human put together is subject to fail

  • @TheSuperPsychoKiller
    @TheSuperPsychoKiller 3 года назад +26

    Pilots need to stop being heavily dependent on flight instruments and more reliant on common sense.

    • @yebosuwa
      @yebosuwa 3 года назад +3

      True but their taught to always trust their flight instruments. So when in trouble such as this, what does one do?

    • @isaacwoohoo318
      @isaacwoohoo318 3 года назад +1

      They weren’t aware of a faulty IRU. They did what they should have done, pushing the he nose down.

    • @Leo-pu2nw
      @Leo-pu2nw 3 года назад +6

      They're trained to rely on their flight instruments. There are hundreds of crashes where the pilot relies on their common sense and disregards their instruments, as well as vice versa. John F Kennedy Jr died this way. Didn't trust his altimeter and virtual horizon and crashed his plane.

    • @kirilmihaylov1934
      @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад

      @@Leo-pu2nw I thought the pilots did what they should . This was major failure

  • @Powerranger-le4up
    @Powerranger-le4up 3 года назад +23

    I’ve seen this episode and this is not the first accident I’ve watched that not only resulted from pilot error, but from the drawbacks of continual advances in technology in aviation. Technology may help prevent a lot of accidents, but some of the drawbacks is the failure rate. It fails so rarely that pilots sometimes become mystified and some airlines have become complacent and are relying too much on the technology to fly the plane instead of the pilots whom they are supposed to train for all potential situations. And with all the knobs, gauges, and technology onboard, it is also becoming more difficult for pilots to find and solve problems in the cockpit.

    • @spacemarinechaplain9367
      @spacemarinechaplain9367 3 года назад +5

      Yeah, it might be prudent to reintroduce a third crew member in the cockpit because like you said, it’s getting to the point where it’s getting too much for two people to handle especially in a stressful situation.

    • @Salamander-Jones
      @Salamander-Jones 3 года назад +5

      @@spacemarinechaplain9367 Some planes have a Pilot, Co-Pilot and an Engineer in the cockpit. It may be time to bring that back into widespread practice.

    • @boeingdriver29
      @boeingdriver29 3 года назад +2

      The only part of your comment that is accurate is that airlines have over the last 20 years encouraged pilots to use more automation rather than hand flying which has to a degree de skilled them. There is no evidence that improvements in technology has led to increased systems or indication failures, in fact its the opposite. The amount of knobs, switches, buttons has vastly decreased over the past 2 decades due to glass cockpits and automated systems. In my 35 years as a B737, 767, 747 captain the only failure of note was having to shut down an engine because of a high oil temperature indication which turned out to be a thermocouple error/failure not an overheating engine oil scenario.

    • @kirilmihaylov1934
      @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад

      @@spacemarinechaplain9367 this crash was hardly a pilot error. The captain got major instrument failure . It was hard for him to know what to do in this situation. No pilot error here

    • @bayouflier6641
      @bayouflier6641 2 года назад

      @@kirilmihaylov1934 You and the Chaplain are both wrong. They had 3 ADIs in the cockpit. One took a shit, and had they crosschecked the two that agreed, this would have been a non-event. Totally pilot error and NOTHING to do with automation.

  • @737tech
    @737tech 3 года назад +3

    The resent Amazon 767 crash is the opposite of this. The pilot felt like the plane was pitching up and drove the plane into the ground.

    • @kirilmihaylov1934
      @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад +2

      It is called somograhic illusion or something like that . In 2016 there was another crash because of this in Russia.Basically the pilot thinks he is pitching up and pushes the plane in a dive . In fact he is flying straight .

    • @kirilmihaylov1934
      @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад +1

      It is not opposite . Both pilots crashed the planes in a dive. But while that was pilot mistake here it wasn't .

  • @minetubequest
    @minetubequest 2 года назад +2

    After watching the video I see that the pilots follow only gyroscope. But for some reason my mind says if they dive at that rate they would feel a very high g-force. For that reason they should have been able to realize they are diving!

  • @user-rc2bd2zd3q
    @user-rc2bd2zd3q 3 года назад

    I would like to see the New York midair collision as a future episode

  • @soniashammiakter4588
    @soniashammiakter4588 3 года назад +1

    Last time a airplane was upside down 😂

  • @idknils2920
    @idknils2920 3 года назад +3

    No one
    Smithsonian : 😲

  • @especiallyninety_751
    @especiallyninety_751 2 года назад +1

    Hits the ground 600mph
    “It’s brighter here”

  • @heyy_itzsneaky5755
    @heyy_itzsneaky5755 3 года назад

    What's the Season and Episode?

  • @coolguy13333
    @coolguy13333 3 года назад +3

    The plane hit the ground so hard that every pice just tuned into shards after it hit

    • @bletrick3352
      @bletrick3352 Год назад

      The most instant death in the history of instant deaths. Most passengers never knew it happened.

  • @adityatiwary2221
    @adityatiwary2221 3 года назад

    How to watch the whole episode?

  • @fluffy-fluffy5996
    @fluffy-fluffy5996 3 года назад +1

    That first picture of Stockholm makes me miss it so much 🤐

    • @Hittlinho
      @Hittlinho 2 года назад

      Where you from? 🙂

  • @kas8887
    @kas8887 3 года назад +1

    It's shocking these planes actually do crash

  • @elirovowskiThela
    @elirovowskiThela 2 года назад

    Mans literally said looks like im going for a swim

  • @goodccvoid
    @goodccvoid 3 года назад +3

    The air crash investigation episodes always get more views than the astronomy ones

    • @alexchristopher221
      @alexchristopher221 Год назад

      Wait until we reach the age of interstellar space travel.

    • @WingNuts2010
      @WingNuts2010 Год назад

      Only from those interested in plane crashes.

  • @ponloksne2644
    @ponloksne2644 3 года назад

    Wow it was great

  • @CosmoLuminesce
    @CosmoLuminesce 3 года назад +1

    The altitude indicator shower it was descending

  • @Meghnaaad
    @Meghnaaad 2 года назад +1

    When you are falling you feel it right?

  • @MOLDOVIAMAPS
    @MOLDOVIAMAPS 3 года назад

    I have a question did it happen 3 days ago?

  • @abdulrahimify
    @abdulrahimify 3 года назад

    Reminds me of KAL8509 except in the air.

  • @ArnBrickJeff
    @ArnBrickJeff 3 года назад

    Pls do SJ182

  • @cleansoap628
    @cleansoap628 3 года назад +2

    Bruh how only 85 k subs

  • @felixsephiroth4174
    @felixsephiroth4174 3 года назад +1

    Upload the trigana air crash

  • @mariosantiago2088
    @mariosantiago2088 Год назад

    You don’t feel it going which side up or down?

  • @bandiswa1592
    @bandiswa1592 3 года назад

    RIP 😔😔😔

  • @shinchanindia6306
    @shinchanindia6306 3 года назад +1

    moral of incident sometimes machines can also be wrong and it can cause you really bad

  • @ajelceballos1267
    @ajelceballos1267 2 года назад +1

    How come the first officer wasn't reacting to anything?

  • @ChrisC1946
    @ChrisC1946 2 года назад +2

    How do they mistake that do you not feel the G force and the feeling of free falling

    • @alexchristopher221
      @alexchristopher221 Год назад

      It's almost like the pilot intentionally nosedived to the bitter end.

  • @kirilmihaylov1934
    @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад

    That was a bad one. The captain had no way of knowing what was going on

  • @lambokr3497
    @lambokr3497 2 года назад

    this could be a movie...

  • @michaeljosephdimaano2802
    @michaeljosephdimaano2802 3 года назад +1

    Yeah, so they didn't felt that they're nose diving?

  • @Mushiiiii
    @Mushiiiii 3 года назад +1

    the callibration system was not working simple

  • @PlayBarbie
    @PlayBarbie 2 года назад +1

    i think pilots should also get a training and also pay attention to viberation also

  • @dsmp_bee6238
    @dsmp_bee6238 3 года назад

    Placing 2 levels in the cockpit would have avoided this

  • @donnaking7439
    @donnaking7439 3 года назад

    It cut off before we heard the mystery explained.

  • @rhushsnr
    @rhushsnr Год назад

    Now I think I can fly a airplane by watching all episodes 😅

  • @djpep_sea6893
    @djpep_sea6893 3 года назад

    🔥🔥

  • @xi8roblox
    @xi8roblox Год назад

    2:11 maybe he's thoughts his IRU was a faulty IRU (Maybe)

  • @ellenroux5748
    @ellenroux5748 Год назад

    I’m not a pilot but can’t the pilots feel In momentum if the planes nose is up or low? Ya know when you are driving car? In a car when you feel your going to tip in one direction or the other you try to correct it.

  • @alisonstewart6077
    @alisonstewart6077 3 года назад +1

    Dose any one know what happened to it

  • @SG_aviation_traveller
    @SG_aviation_traveller 3 года назад +1

    Big crash there....

  • @ZeDestroyer262
    @ZeDestroyer262 Год назад

    i think the sensors were kaboosed and the co pilot's IRU maybe faulty idk but if the sensor was showing false readings wouldn't the pilots know that they are level by looking at the horizon? let me know in the comments.

  • @IrfanKhan-sx1it
    @IrfanKhan-sx1it 2 года назад

    @3.25: to the 5th grade investigator : plane goes 33,000 ft at 1000 km/hr in 1 second because it reaches Mach speed. Probably Mach 3.0

  • @koushikborah2081
    @koushikborah2081 2 года назад +4

    Investigators in stockholm talking in american accent.keep going 🤭

  • @pistachiocracker4477
    @pistachiocracker4477 3 года назад

    What do you mean it’s brighter here?!?! Stop it with that jingle

  • @godsaveve
    @godsaveve 3 года назад

    I wont fight any more

  • @ChrisC1946
    @ChrisC1946 2 года назад

    How could a pilot mistake that

  • @paulretsas66
    @paulretsas66 4 месяца назад

    All the captain needed was a visible spirit level mounted to a flat surface… no second guessing.

  • @ouiiouliukuykuykuy8451
    @ouiiouliukuykuykuy8451 3 года назад

    united 232 plssss

  • @shobhakiran5699
    @shobhakiran5699 3 года назад +8

    FULL VIDEO PLEASE

    • @i6r468
      @i6r468 3 года назад +1

      We need some movie about that

    • @orvinkent7600
      @orvinkent7600 3 года назад

      Facebook

  • @warszawianek
    @warszawianek 3 года назад

    Similar to Qantas 72 but it's a bad ending

  • @southpark4151
    @southpark4151 3 года назад +1

    Is it true that the software programmers and software design team are the ones that should be jailed or sacked over that amateur software system? When critical flight data is detected to have discrepancies between the two or more sets of measuring systems, then a very loud computer voice should have said on the cabin loudspeakers ------ 'warning - mismatch in pitch measurements ----- IRU1 likely to be in error, IRU2 likely to be functioning correctly - due to two out of three agreement condition'. And also have big red flashing lights to draw attention. And also - the little yellow 'PIT' indication on the screen should definitely have been programmed to remain on the screen. It should never have disappeared in any case. But also - one must admit that it's pretty stupid to have the little yellow 'PIT' light come up (even if if it did stay on permanently). It's better to have a big flashing PIT symbol (along with a loud but calm computer voice warning) - that also shows more information about which display panel or instrument had likely developed an issue. So basic common sense programming would have easily saved those two pilots.

  • @erumzehra01
    @erumzehra01 3 года назад +1

    Edit it to its nightmare here

  • @dennismitchell1934
    @dennismitchell1934 2 года назад

    It appears a cabin leak caused the loss of oxygen putting both pilots asleep and fell forward (limp) on the yoke. Down it went to the ground up-side down lickity split
    KA-BOOM !

  • @hillbilly4555
    @hillbilly4555 2 года назад

    Aviation, Not a single video about September 11, nice going RUclips

  • @arkfn912
    @arkfn912 2 года назад

    Have a flight today

  • @dank1518
    @dank1518 Год назад

    After much reflection have decided not to fly….especially if Smithsonian film crew is hanging around the airport.

  • @8346324970712
    @8346324970712 Год назад

    Don't always trust your instruments.

  • @U_Iz_COOL
    @U_Iz_COOL 3 года назад +1

    if this happened to me I would of called MayDay because this is making you have a high risk of confusion causing the plane to crash even if you rely on sight you still get confused and not firmly know if the plane is banking left or right if you are gain altitude or losing it

  • @xinadado9780
    @xinadado9780 3 года назад

    I already watched this as my first episode

  • @kashifuddinahmed8383
    @kashifuddinahmed8383 3 года назад

    If you're steeping down at that speed wouldn't you realise something is wrong ?

  • @miguelsalami
    @miguelsalami 2 года назад

    Never Trust your instruments or your planes computer!

  • @djmorry8748
    @djmorry8748 2 года назад

    Is it silly of me to ask you people who are tech minded , why the main flight computer did not immediately warn that he pitch of aircraft was critical nose down and cut in with over ride pull up and audio warning to get back to leve lflight at the same time?

  • @erichred2858
    @erichred2858 3 года назад

    Nope. Dont see a plane. Another shanksville...

  • @draco2xx
    @draco2xx 3 года назад

    But I thought they say, always trust your instruments😩

    • @ndeso94vlogrider41
      @ndeso94vlogrider41 3 года назад

      Thats right. But of the instrument failure,,,, you know what happen next....

    • @kirilmihaylov1934
      @kirilmihaylov1934 3 года назад

      @@ndeso94vlogrider41 this was major failure

  • @IamNotIntelligent
    @IamNotIntelligent 3 года назад

    Finally

  • @Interdictiondeltawing
    @Interdictiondeltawing 3 года назад +2

    The IRU Faulty caused the accident