- Видео 246
- Просмотров 117 007
Reflecting History
Добавлен 2 окт 2016
Reflecting History is an educational history podcast that explores significant historical events and themes without losing track of the ordinary people involved. Covering a wide variety of topics, it explores the connection between history, psychology, and philosophy on a personal level.
Episode 150: Aztec Memories Part IV-The Chontal Gift
While the Aztec Empire peaked in central Mexico, a different empire was spreading it's tenticles across the Atlantic Ocean. The Spanish were in the early phases of setting up a global superpower powered by colonialism. In early 1519, the Spanish arrived in force on the shores of the Yucatan Peninsula. After crushing the Chontal Maya city states, Hernando Cortez and his Spanish conquistadors set their sights on the Aztec Empire. But would the ensuing conquest have been possible without Malintzin? Her real name forever lost to history, a nameless slave girl possessed a weapon that would change the course of history forever.
This is Part IV in a series on the rise, fall, and enduring legacy...
This is Part IV in a series on the rise, fall, and enduring legacy...
Просмотров: 152
Видео
No Time To Die - A Deeper Meaning
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.12 часов назад
How should we deal with the reality of death? "No Time To Die" and James Bond's character through the years offer a potential solution. Free will, nihilism, and cycles of violence are all themes explored in the movie and this video essay. Musical jingle inspired by "Vesper" by David Arnold. Listen to the podcast here: www.reflectinghistory.com For more video essays, James Bond stuff, and other ...
Episode 149: Aztec Memories Part III-The City on the Lake
Просмотров 11821 день назад
The Aztec Empire at its height in the 1400's was a flourishing civilization that had a rich social and cultural tradition. In addition to the political realities of statebuilding-war, tribute, human sacrifice, and slavery, the Mexica people took care of their families, tended to gardens, ate rich foods, listened to music, participated in religious ceremonies, bought and sold goods in markets, a...
Episode 148: Aztec Memories Part II-A Memory Called Empire
Просмотров 294Месяц назад
From their new base in Tenochtitlan, the Mexica people slowly built the Aztec Empire over the course of the 1300's. While the "myth of the Aztec" ascribes this accomplishment to the barbarism of human sacrifice and brutality, the Mexica both lived in a particular context and shaped their own unique political environment. Demystifying what the Spanish referred to as superstition and barbarism, t...
Episode 147: Aztec Memories Part I-A Rose Not a Rose
Просмотров 2802 месяца назад
The story of the Aztec Empire is a story unlike any other. From it's origins as a nomadic underdog, to it's ascendance at the rich and powerful city of Tenochtitlan, to it's clash of civilizations with the mighty Spanish Empire, this is a historical story that will never happen again. If you think you know the story, think again. For hundreds of years myths and half-truths about the Spanish con...
BONUS: Arcane
Просмотров 1662 месяца назад
This bonus episode is the first episode of a nine part podcast series on the Netflix show “Arcane.” I recap season 1 of the show and delve into the history, psychology, and philosophy underpinning the story-discussing why it is relevant for the real world problems that we all face. In Episode 1, we introduce some of the characters and their overarching themes and motivations, discuss the confli...
Episode 146: Prehistory and Posthistory
Просмотров 2783 месяца назад
Episode 146: Prehistory and Posthistory
Episode 145: Daughters of Shandong with Eve Chung
Просмотров 2054 месяца назад
Episode 145: Daughters of Shandong with Eve Chung
Episode 143: The Unseen Leader with Martin Gutmann
Просмотров 3155 месяцев назад
Episode 143: The Unseen Leader with Martin Gutmann
Episode 139: Vagabond Princess with Ruby Lal
Просмотров 1648 месяцев назад
Episode 139: Vagabond Princess with Ruby Lal
Episode 138: The Metamorphosis Part III
Просмотров 1289 месяцев назад
Episode 138: The Metamorphosis Part III
Episode 137: The Metamorphosis Part II
Просмотров 1059 месяцев назад
Episode 137: The Metamorphosis Part II
Episode 136: The Metamorphosis Part I
Просмотров 17210 месяцев назад
Episode 136: The Metamorphosis Part I
Episode 132: The Mexican Dirty War Part VI-Spaces of Memory
Просмотров 73Год назад
Episode 132: The Mexican Dirty War Part VI-Spaces of Memory
Episode 131: The Mexican Dirty War Part V-Massacres and Memories
Просмотров 107Год назад
Episode 131: The Mexican Dirty War Part V-Massacres and Memories
Episode 130: The Mexican Dirty War Part IV-Violence and Change
Просмотров 112Год назад
Episode 130: The Mexican Dirty War Part IV-Violence and Change
Episode 129: The Mexican Dirty War Part III-Revolution of the Mundane
Просмотров 175Год назад
Episode 129: The Mexican Dirty War Part III-Revolution of the Mundane
Episode 127: The Mexican Dirty War Part I-The Politics of Memory
Просмотров 254Год назад
Episode 127: The Mexican Dirty War Part I-The Politics of Memory
Episode 126: Reconstructing Emotion in History
Просмотров 126Год назад
Episode 126: Reconstructing Emotion in History
Episode 124: W.E.B. Du Bois and the Wounded World with Chad Williams
Просмотров 137Год назад
Episode 124: W.E.B. Du Bois and the Wounded World with Chad Williams
This is an interesting analysis, unfortunately I disagree with you in the end. The reason why this movie exists can be summed in 3 words: Kill James Bond. Craig always wanted to end his tenure with Bond dying and the filmmakers started with their ending and worked backwards (hence the many plot holes and anti-climatic moments in the final product). Spectre ended with Bond learning his lesson about living the best life he could by sparing Blofeld and quitting MI6. Bond leaving Madeline in NTTD was more of a plot convenience so we can get the surprise that he has a daughter later and less of a genuine emotional moment. The themes in the movie aren't supported by substance but forced via plot holes and we end up with the most pointlessly depressing Bond film ever.
Appreciate the comment, I can see this side as well!
The initial impression of Tenochtitlan from the Spanish in context was some of them have seen the great European cities of the time,the closest comparison being Venice..and still were in awe of the majestic beauty of Tenochtitlan. From my reading during Cortezs intense battles with Tlaxcaltec, the Spanish held up in an old Aztec? build structure on the high ground outside of Tlaxcaltec, forming a 360 deg permerinator and were under seige at times but this forced Tlaxcaltec into frontal attacks against their superior weaponry causing high casualties, interesting bit about the Spanish roaming around at night burning down surrounding villages during this time.
Thanks for adding your thoughts, always appreciate your commentary! The bit about the villages comes from Cortés’ second letter from Mexico.
Who is here after Elon mentioned this on Christmas Eve on X?
This was really good. Appreciate the thoughts shared here.
Thanks for watching!
I did not especially like No Time To Die when I first saw it but upon seeing it again, I found it inspiring and yours is the first analysis I’ve seen that goes into the depths of what I, too, saw in this movie. For me it was the themes of trust and loss, loss of innocence, loss of love, of living a worthwhile life. Your analysis opened up other themes I had not considered, connecting mythology and poetry. I am new to your channel and it’s quite a coincidence that you published this just as I was inspired to go looking for it. Well done. Thank you.
I appreciate the kind words! Well said, trust is one I wish I thought of.
Thank you for this because I have been angry about this movie ever since I saw it. I couldn't help but think they "didn't understand the assignment" because . . . At the time, we watched Covid-19 shut the world down and death was all around us. Just when we could go back to movie theaters, we really needed our 'annual action injection' of the incredible death defying things James Bond does and the impossible fun of him coming through every danger to pump us up. What we got instead was more death. After nearly two years of waiting and death, it was just too much! They killed off Iron Man, John Wick, and they'll be killing off Ethan Hunt no doubt in M:I 8. It felt like such a betrayal. I had too much invested in Bond to be able to handle this inevitability at that time. With a few years' passing, I could maybe watch it again. Maybe, after watching this, with a new appreciation. But it feels like Titanic (I can never watch that again). At least I can stop hating it. LOL I really do love the Daniel Craig Bond series and have watched them all so many times. Quantum of Solace is criminally underrated. They are all excellent movies and well written, IMO, visually stunning and full of exciting action scenes. I think the QoS scaffolding fight is particularly genius!
Thanks for watching and leaving the thoughtful comment! Strangely enough I wanted to upload my Quantum of Solace video too but couldn’t get it past the guard rails, so right now that one lives on my page with the other ones in this series. I agree Quantum is really underrated and deeper than it gets credit for!
Amazing book
10^4677 books
Currently half way into the book!
Hope you’re enjoying it!
This is amazing! You should be very proud of your work 🌟
As far as the ongoing war between the Aztec and Tlaxcaltec, there were 3 major Aztec offensives(i don't think calling the large Aztec march on them a flower war fit the definition)on Tlaxcaltec territory. All of them with heavy casualties but the last one breaking through Tlaxcaltec forces leaving their city exposed. However, the fighting was so heavy the Aztecs turned back. Cholula, nominally allied with the Tlaxcaltec, located smack in the middle of the fighting, decided to flip to the Aztec side afterward. Tlaxcaltec people pre Cortez were fending off the Aztec but they were definitely under heavy pressure and probably felt betrayed by Cholula changing sides and also what happens to be Cortezs first major massacre. Coincidence, yea, you do the math.
Yeh and ruins the pace of the series
The book was disappointing. It was short but repetitive, and the main character-a young child-came off as whiny and irritating. Toward the end, the author seems to abandon the dark tone, abruptly shifting to a forced happy ending. I was bored throughout, and the lack of commitment to a consistent tone made it even harder to stay engaged.
okay lil bro im not gonna waste my time writing five paragraphs
@ it’s trash man, ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@@Knightlife07 thsats your opininon but all ill say is that your opinion is ass
and theoretically, if it contains everything ever made, could answers to questions that haven’t been thought of exist?
Probably Cormac's happiest book.
This, but unironically. The point of the story is the love of the father and son and how they refuse to not only not give up, but also not give into the worst impulses of desperate people. In the worst of circumstances, the darkest of times, the light shines brightest.
@@OldWestGunslinger-vs9mx Yeah I agree. Accidental sarcasm.
do you know of any other similar shipwreck/mutiny books? I have Madhouse at the End of the Earth, and Endurance on my to read list already. Looking for something closer to The Wager though.
Usually not my wheelhouse, but one I’ve read and can recommend is “The Amistad Rebellion” by Marcus Rediker. I based a podcast series on it a few years ago. More of a “history” type book and written a little more dry than something like The Wager, but still a fascinating book and topic.
@@reflectinghistory Thank you very much, I will be adding this one to the list. A good history book never disappoints. Keep up the good content 👍
Commenting again, a year to the day after you posted this short. I just finished this book last week. I think your comment regarding “the end of the frontier” is seen perfectly in the Epilogue with Billy. Great book, loving your channel :)
Thanks for the support it means a lot! Such a great trilogy I’m looking forward to rereading it soon.
As an older brother, this one has stuck with me for months since I finished it. Incredible, incredible book. The blind man’s story and the description of his eyes being sucked out still haunts me. Might have to pick it up again
It’s funny you say that, the blind man’s story is one of my favorite sections in any book ever. I’ve always wanted to do a podcast on that part, if not the crossing or the trilogy as a whole, but it’s a daunting task.
@@reflectinghistory extremely daunting, and I wish you luck in that endeavor if you ever get around to it. I’d give it a listen! I’m so happy this short came up on my algorithm :) reminded me of such a great book
I appreciate that, thanks for the kind words!
Thanks for the episode! this was so interesting and tragic.
Thank you for listening!
I am actually reading it right now, I love how it is written
there's a show being filmed for this right now
Good read
This was a fun read
i have read this and it was beyond amazing! though so so sad. this book will forever remain in my memorys to always love everything big and small, and enjoy every moment of life...
Diogenes is reflected in the lives of John the Baptist and Jesus of Nazareth and Desert Fathers and Mothers - challenging worldly conventions and promoting authentic living.
Thanks for sharing. We're big fans of Martin Gutmann's take on effective leadership - hoping there's more Amundsen in us than Shackleton!
People don't like it when they first read it, like me. But when I reread it a couple of times it has become my favorite ASOIAF book
Agreed. The combined reading with Dance was pretty cool too.
This my ranking of the 5 books: 1. Storm 2. Dance 3. Game 4. Clash 5. Feast
“War is a racket,” as Smedley of House Butler once said.
The library of babel is something that is not infinite just unimaginably massive. And it is something that actually exists today.
Blame those three old farts for all of it one wanted half of the country second one the other half then third emerged with a brand new idea then the previous two decided zo shit on him destroyed zhe north amd the south
Absolutely incredible work
O think what I get the most from thos section is the need to advocate and adjust for your own well being as we age. It's great to have empathy and compassion for others just not at the point of neglecting one self also. To show all how fast others can abandon empathy and compassion, this Hregor was handoxa and he was neglected. I don't struggle with it, he should do SOMETHING about his anxiety. Great points on how we got through changes at different times of life.
Great points, thank you!
Love it
The movie is a master piece, i need the novel, they always are way better than the theatre version, thanks for the light on the novel
Agreed! For me, this is one of the few cases where the movie is right there with the book.
One of the worst books I've ever read. All they do is walk in ash. Nothing is well explained, dialogue is poorly written, and nothing happens. Oh no there's cannibals again 😱 lets completely avoid them, again 😱😱😱😱 It is a very bad "novel". It's very much a emperor has no clothes kind of book. Don't waste your time on it.
I don’t agree with this assessment, but not everything is for everybody. Thanks for your input!
Can you elaborate on what is poor with the dialogue?
@@bobjenkins5867 I found the book overly written and pretentious. The language was filled with words I’ve rarely heard, yet the story itself felt like it could’ve been written by a 14-year-old. For most of the book, the author spends endless pages describing ash on the ground in the fanciest way possible. Then, after all that buildup, they didn’t seem to know how to end it and just threw in a happy ending for the kid-who, realistically, should’ve met death instantly given his weak character. Looking at how it wraps up, I was left thinking, What? How?
@@Knightlife07 What aspects ,other than the " thrown in" ending, made the book sound like it was written by a 14 year old?
@@Knightlife07 Did you read the book? Its is some of the most simplistic writing I've ever read. Also probably Cormac's least descriptive and most accessible novel. If you find it overwritten then I don't think you've read that many books.
I've been wanting to read this myself. I have an audiobook reading of it that has been difficult to listen to due to a poor narrator & /or sound editing.
That’s a bummer. I’ve never tried an audiobook for one of his books, but yea I can imagine McCarthy’s writing style would be difficult to pull off in that format.
I can't imagine it's the narrators fault. The book is very poorly written. Look up an excerpt online and try to read it.
@@KP_Uravity i thought the rambling and choppy prose really contributed to the overall vibe! i might be an optimist tho
@@jadedpotato1574 if you feel that way thats fine, i wont fault you for it. but i genuinely believe that its just poor writing. it conveys the information poorly and makes it difficult to flow through the text. i also think the story is terrible but thats neither here nor there
“Crows are all liars,” GRRM agreed, from the chair where he sat doing his typing. “I know a story about a crow.” “I don’t want anymore Samwell Tarly or Arianne Martell chapters,” Bran snapped, his voice petulant. He had liked GRRM and his stories once. Before. But it was different now. “I hate your stupid stories.” “I know a story about a boy who hated stories,” GRRM said with his stupid little smile, his keystrokes moving all the while, click click click, until Bran was ready to scream at him. “I could tell you the story about Brienne The Beauty,” GRRM said. “That was always your favorite.” “That’s not my favorite,” Bran said. “My favorites were the scary ones around The Wall.”
This is an underrated ass comment
One of my all-time, favorite books.
I love this book the most in the series because it feels like each chapter is so much more detailed and the characters feel alot more “human”. Like I got sucked into Cerseis and Aerons delusion filled povs and almost believed half the nonsense they spouted
I agree, that is a great way of putting it.
I was an extra in the tv show. Really great story
There’s a tv show??
Those who give a strange look must never read the books Jamie povs are top tier
The broken man speech was the best it’s not a bad book just hard to get through for me at least
thats why i listened davidreadsasoiaf reading it.
I had that phone lmao
Yes! That chapter really stood out to me. This is my second re-listen, having first read them, and I'm catching a lot more. Can't wait to finally break open A Dance With Dragons.
Always something new to catch on the reread relisten. Thank you for watching!
I'll be honest, I can see why it's fairly disliked among the fan base. When I read it I found it really boring and it crawls along at a snails pace. With that said, I'm half way through rereading AGOT and I'm looking forward to rereading it with a fresh perspective to enjoy it on its own terms rather than to continue the plot of the overall narrative
Fair points. I think it’s a lot more interesting on the reread. Let me know what you think!
Reading it right now, it’s probably set to be one of my favorite McCarthy books. I’m excited for the crossing.
Incredible book. I’m looking forward to re-reading it soon. The Crossing is my favorite of the trilogy. Thanks for watching!
Pol Pot = Political Potential
I'm about to finish it 😄 . Just 4 chapters more to go
How was the book ?
@@Harrishmen starting and ending was good. but normally story moves with very slow pace.
I’m currently reading it now( ok we can be honest I’m listening to it at work) but it the one I personally like the least so far I’m praying literally praying A Dance of Dragons is better.
Makes sense! It can definitely seem a bit slow compared to a storm of swords. Slow and atmospheric works for me and the reread is great as well.
ADWD is definitely more exciting and probably my favourite by Feast is my second fav for the worldbuilding