Видео

The problem with your Abbey Road CD creating gaps might have something to do with an unusual feature of all the Beatle 2009 STEREO CDs. They all contain an extra VIDEO track about the album. I've never found any problem ripping them and all my CD players play those albums perfectly but maybe this extra video track is affecting your car CD player. It may not be the explanation but you did mention your Sgt Pepper album played okay - but maybe that was an earlier edition which did not contain the video track. Incidentally, my son bought that very Topaz player some years ago. It took him a while to notice the gap problem. He contacted Cambridge Audio and was told it was a "design feature"!!!!!

3. Ziggy Stardust 2. Hunky Dory 1. Aladdin Sane

Sometimes you have to change the output on cd player. Think its encode of the dacs that course the gaps? Is the a gap if you use as transport

There will be people whose CDs contain only distinct songs and don't care about the gaps separating them. They probably won't even understand what this video is about. Perhaps the designers of modern, gappy, CD players are among them. For listeners to classical music, the gaps are disastrous. Many classical CDs, especially ballet and choral music, have tracks that aren't there to provide breaks in the music; they're just to indicate where you are on the disc. In the early days of the CD, some discs had index marks, separate from the track numbers and players had the ability to show them but I haven't seen either for many years. CD Text, as demonstrated on the Yamaha, seems to have been added and died out much more recently. I don't think I've ever owned a player that could do it. That Yamaha looks like a nice little system. There aren't many like that on the market now.

Heroes by far, the whole album Low Ziggy Stardust Hunky Dory Songs: Neukoln Rock 'roll Suicide Look back in Anger

Good ranking for the top 6 - I’d probably relegate Space Oddity, and put Lodger and Young Americans higher. I agree about Heathen, by the way, it restored my faith too. Heroes divides opinion these days, as an album, but at the time I recall it being viewed as stronger than Low. It’s just a very different album, and lyrically miles ahead. Sonically, though, Low is hard to beat. I’d probably put Low on the turntable before Ziggy these days, so might have Low at 1 and HD at 2.

Your accent reminds me so much of Pete Townsend. Are you from Shepherd’s Bush?

My favourite albums are at the bottom of the top. All the Let's dance-Never let me down era and Outside-Reality era, plus the Heroes album are absolute masterpieces

Watch that man is a great track and a great opener. It’s one that id like to do on karaoke sometime. I enjoyed this programme. I didn’t agree entirely but that’s never a bad thing. I don’t often subscribe to anything but I have here.

My father had some Bowie's vinyls , he wasnt the biggest fan but whatever he could get on vinyls during the dark days of Communism in Romania. But...thats how i discovered Bowie and he became my fav artist of all times. Image, voice, creativity hitting the sky, never will be another musician like him. My favs from him are Honky, Alladin, Ziggy, Low, Heroes, Station, Diamond dogs. Cant pick one, keep changing for the last 10 yrs. Great video, great ranking. I am also jealous off your Bowie's collection.

Based on people on forums and on here saying that the Marantz CD5005 (2014) and CD6007 (2020) are gapless, I've just bought a CD6004 (2011) with recently cleaned lens and recently lubricated tray mechanism, as that was what I could afford. I hope it's also gapless, and will be seeing (hearing?) if it is as soon as it arrives. (EDIT 6 days later) to my relief, yes my CD6004 does play gapless! The short is on my channel.

The top ones for me are Dark Side of the Moon, Piper at the Gates of Dawn, Animals, Meddle, Wish You Were Here and the Wall.

Watching this just reminds me how pointless ranking videos are you can pick literally any Bowie album and use it to get into his music my favourite albums changes every week

Suffragette City? Did you miss it or did I?

"Lodger" must be #1, folks 🍻🍻

I always smile when i hear about Bowies "phil collins " period. Pop music should relax you, makes you comfortable. And Bowie on Never let me down put words like chernobyl and hitler , wich are disturbing (especially hitler makes you think abou war and all its atrocities)

We are music-mates: I share your thoughts on momentary lapse (awful record), I do find the division bell mediocre. The final cut is a Waters' album but is far from being as bad as people rate it (well crafted songs even if not really inspired)and Atom Heart is a brilliant record. Only discrepancy : The wall, I liked it a lot but the fourth side is a "skip side" and there are too many fillers

Why does nobody ever include Toy in their Bowie rankings?

MARANTZ M-CR612 CD same problem. es una verguebza

My personal favourite is Scary Monsters. I also thoroughly enjoy Earthling, Station To Station, Aladdin Sane and The Next Day

Ha ha" Please show respect even if you disagree" - yes great track!

No mention of the re-recorded version of "Never Let Me Down?" I didn't like the production on the original either, but the tracks are pretty damn strong in the songwriting department. "Time Will Crawl" is up their with classic Bowie. But then again you sold Young Americans & Tin Machine 1 waaaaayyyy to short IMHO. "Middle-of-the-road hard rock?" Not even. Not with Reeves Gabrels riding shotgun 🤨 It's an unsettling Dystopian Future almost concept album like one usually expects from David Bowie, but he doesn't always deliver.

The Philips Micro Music System M4205 is gapless. It's a mini stereo, and it's perfect for my needs.

I recently purchased a 1994 Marantz CD-53 at a very reasonable price. It works a treat and is gapless, so am very happy!

You don't even mention classical music, where gapless playback is even more important. It's hard to believe that Cambridge Audio would screw up on this; they're a high-end brand. My PS Audio Transport will even play separare WAV files continuously.

I think its an important issue but please knock 8mins off the length would be good... You have pointed the problem out on a pretty old player (seems to be from around 2010) so not perhaps representative of current players. There are plenty of Hi-Fi CD players that do gapless playback but it's worth checking first as you say.

I can only imagine that this has to do ith the way the data is processed. In the olden days that data was basically streamed into a very small buffer and just decoded on the fly. You may remember the early Philips players with their voice coil driven laser pickup on a rotary arm. You could simply move that manually to any spot on the CD and as soon as the control circuit locked onto the track again the player simply continued playing. So the metadata was also decoded on the fly as a side product. So the implementation was more like a record player. You would have to do quite same extra work for such a crappy non-seamless playback implementation.

Thats why i love minidisc, all the sony portables have gapless random playback depends how the cd is mastered, all cd players should be gapless even going back to 1985, but i know of none that are gapless on random playback, simply because they dont have a buffer like minidiscs does. But just playing a disc from start to finish like for example a ministry of sound mix cd has to be gapless on all players for obvious reasons. the sony cd players have autospace feature that you can turn off.

The Arcam CD5 now plays gapless after a firmware update that's done via USB. An owner confirmed this on the What Hifi forum.

I find it very strange that there would be people denying or ignoring this as an issue. CDs are a great technology and while I love my records, I cannot deny the reliability and ease of use of CDs. Their biggest advantage at the time apart from sound quality was that you didn't need to flip the record/tape. There were no longer sides to an album, just a straight shot from beginning to end. Artists didn't need to worry about spacing their songs out in any way and could present them in the way they or the record label wanted while albums that already existed could be released in their exact form without any changes needed.

The very odd thing is that the audio file on a CD is continuous. The table of contents with the track information is a seperate thing from the audio. When I master a CD a fair bit of time is spent deciding with the artist on the gaps between tracks. Between tracks you should see a count down, as you demonstrate, from the end marker of one track to the start marker of the next. During the count down the player should be outputting digital silence if that is what is recorded in the audio file. Also, many live albums run as a continuous piece if you stsrt from the beginning with the track i.d.s carefully placed to avoid any jarring when you start a track from within the running order that does not start from silence. I can only assume that manufaturers are cutting costs by using players without the firmware needed for full Red Book playback.

As a Beatles fan, I really love Bowies version of Accross the universe… and I also love Dj. Not really sure about your “love for bowie”- some of your rankings a bit suspect to me

My favorite Bowie song is station to station, but after that song the album is just ok.

I would say my favourite music is where classical meets rock,hence my favourites..late beatles,bowie,ELO....life on mars may be the best song ever made.Ziggy is the only album with no fillers...even the masterful abbey road has one or two.

Great ranking and discussion. Here is how I rank them. 1. The Piper at the Gates of Dawn- I am a huge Syd fan and consider this album to be a masterpiece. 2. Dark Side of the Moon 3. Animals- This one got better as I got older. 4. A Saucerful of Secrets- This album is very underrated. 5. Wish You Were Here 6. The Wall- This was number one for me in high school. I really connected with it at a hard point in my life. It doesn't hit me quite the same at this age, but I still enjoy it. 7. Meddle 8. Obscured by Clouds 9. The Final Cut 10. More 11. Division Bell 12. Atom Heart Mother 13. Endless River 14. A Momentary Lapse of Reason 15. Ummagumma

Interesting list and ditto comments to each entry. I have been a big Bowie fan since the 70s. I guess each fan's list would be different, depending on ones individual taste and so would mine. E.g. some of your top 10 picks would be at the bottom of my personal list (I never quite liked Diamond Dogs) but I loved hearing your reasons for placing the albums in the particular order you have chosen. Cheers from a new subscriber from Denmark😎

As a Bowie record collector I found this video very interesting. But I do disagree with a lot of what you said. That's not me being nasty just different opinions. I personally don't think any album is a ten out of ten. That would mean liking every single track to a point where they are all classics. Now for me Heroes ( album version) is the best song ever written but I can't seriously say I love everything on the album. Same with Ziggy. Songs like moonage daydream/ Five year's are ten out of ten but sings such as Soul love and It ain't easy are very poor. The closest to perfection is ( and these comments are only my opinion) Scary Monsters album. It's absolutely brilliant. The weakest track being Scream like a baby is average but tracks like Because your young /Teenage Wildlife are brilliant and I'd give Kingdom Come another chance. I think it's one of his best ever covers along with Cactus ( Heathen album). Like I said not having a go. It's a good video and would love to hear what you guys think about my comments.

4 Station to station 3 Heroes 2 Low 1 1.Outside

'doesn't do anything for me' is over-used, mate!

Glad to see "Heroes" make your top 5, its my personal fav, side 1 is just perfection, 5 amazing krautrock style songs, I also love the ambient work on side 2, the whole album feels like a journey

Enjoyed this video, I would mostly agree with your rankings. I was lucky enough to be around for his seventies and eighties stuff, but only recently got round to catching up with his albums since then. Am enjoying them all on rotation.

I recently had to replace a faulty Oakcastle majority cd100 portable player from Amazon and so decided to do some research and eventually went with a Desobry model and although it had a nice interface and better Bluetooth connection with device memory and resume feature which they don’t all have etc etc… it wasn’t seamless play and apparently it’s something that’s now common especially devices from China who don’t understand the seamless play system like with audiobooks, live music and classical which require this feature and so don’t program it into the devices software. Like many having had many cd devices over the years I’ve never had this before so it is a modern recent issue. So i decided in the end to get another Oakcastle cd100 which is seamless and states so in its advertising a British company from Cambridge who understands our listening habits

1. Scary monsters 2. Aladdin Sane 3. Ziggy Stardust 4. Low 5. Hunky Dory 6. Station to station 7. Diamond dogs 8. Lodger 9. The man who sold the world 10. Young americans 11. Heroes 12. Black star 13. Let's dance 14. Heathen 15. Reality 16. Outside 17. Earthling 18. Hours 19. The next day 20. Pin ups 21. Space oddity 22. Tonight 23. David Bowie 24. Buddah of Suburbia 25. Black tie white noise 26. Never let me down

great video.. i made a video about how i bought a 50 dollar cd player and there is a two second gap .. so frustrating!!

Great ❤

Tonight is a right stinker, deserves a 3 or 4. I think your being a bit too hard on Reality, I'd rate it higher, ditto with Black Tie which I would rate way higher; Young Americans deserves better at least an 8 although the Glouster would rate a 9; Pin Ups deserves better, a def 9; Let's Dance needs more love in getting a 9; Bowie 1967 is a 7 at best, Toy gets a 9 in my book; Man Who Sold s/b 8.5; Scary I give a 8.5; Next Day a 9, the 2 disc deluxe version is a 9.5; Black Star is a 10; Bowie 1969 is too high, a 8; I never really understood why so many people rate Diamond Dogs so high, for me giving it a 7.5 is generous; Hereos is a 9 for me; ditto for Low

Sharp's CD-BH10 shelf system adds a gap between songs (but the CD-BH20 is gapless). There is NOTHING in the product descriptions to give you a heads-up. Ugh.

Wooow, you’re cool (Bowie made you look cool) 😉

Wow where do I start? Your lower end ranking almost looks like a classic Bowie ‘cut up’ random albums appearing in odd places Tonight album ranking higher than Tin Machine and the hours album in which you totally missed Thursday’s Child surely a classic Bowie song, honestly it’s so bizarre I am lost, you did recover towards the end. Teenage Wildlife is in fact about Bowie’s dissatisfaction of the New Romantic movement, ‘same old thing in a brand new drag….’ An interesting ranking, but only a 3.5. ⚡️⚡️⚡️

Bowie himself said Buddha was his own favourite album. I confess I really like some tracks on Never Let Me Down. Black Tie, White Noise is a masterpiece, you blathering slaphead 😅