Видео

I think the Rutles got Yoko spot on in their parady of the Beatles.

Why would they keep the "jane asher" character going for so long?

It was going so well until just after the three quarter an hour mark when you made the ridiculous statement that The Beatles didn't play the instruments themselves on their early albums! Complete rubbish. The first four albums contained a total of 18 cover versions plus the 3 on the Long Tall Sally EP. Most of which they had been performing for years in Hamburg and Liverpool etc plus BBC sessions. By your logic how did the Beatles perform these songs live or on the BBC recordings (I take it that you've listened to those?) if they hadn't learned how to play them? The remaining 46 songs were their own compositions so who would know how to play them better than they did? I think what many people today fail to appreciate was just how prolific the Beatles were and how impressive their work rate was.

Years ago in the early 90s I was playing with a Blues Band , we did at least three to four gigs a week .after being with them year and a half we went in the studio to make a recording that we could give to fans We booked a four hour session in a local Studio set up and played a 45 minute set straight through which became the album The mixing took up the rest of the session , I’ve read that the Beatles did much more than this in the 3 years before getting a recording contract , why is it so unrealistic that they could achieve this

What about Geoffrey Emerick ‘s book

I think Kesey was a raving psychopath. I read Electric Kool-aid Acid Test and it was one long run-on sentence of insanity. They'd fry some poor novice's mind with too many drugs and then just dump them into the ditch along the road.

Hey Cat. Thanks for all of this. Amazing work. It actually resonated with me when I got to the end. On another point, just seen the variant Band On The Run album covers. Are you a aware of these? Blew my mind again!

So now you're doubting Carol King wrote Chains. Did anyone write anything? This is getting crazy.

What about PRINCE. He wrote a TON of music over 10 years time. Where did he get his songs from? Some ideas came from others but still, He wrote and arranged it. Recorded it. Why him, one guy?

Why do people want to believe Paul was killed. Its so easy to prove this wrong. It's the dumbest thing I've ever heard. You can't pull off that plastic surgery today never less in the 60s. and wouldn't it have gone bad like everyone eles's ? Your proof is a fictional book. Writen by WHO????? And who was that in the 80s? Was BILLY in WINGS.

I find now after looking at past concerts like end of summer how they switched pauls in middle of a concet the real paul is more humble on stage the faul paul is more lead with george and john he goes out first on stage john second original paul let john go first. I also been wathing billys hair seems like a wig in so many shots not real hair. stays pretty solid no movement like natural hair. any way u got me thinking

Could they have replaced Jane because she was in love with the real Paul and didn't want to play along with his sacrifice so they had to replace her?

I am not mad! I questioned this over the past year after watching the Masque of Red Death. Looking at pics over time of Jane, I easily concluded that I am not looking at the same person. The trauma of Paul’s death, being forced to go along with the ruse after his replacement, and her father’s own demise, plus what she knew … there would be ample reason to replace her. Had news of her passing just been published, the negative publicity for Billy would have drawn more scrutiny, versus the scrutiny they desired (PID) to convince people that it was a marketing ploy. I appreciate this presentation so much .. The Deep End speculation; anything is possible at this point.

As well as relaying all the electrical cables and other equipment the roof as had to be reinforced to sustain all the the weight etc, giving way to the myth that it was an impromptu performance.

I must say every time it shows them rehearsing all they seem to be doing is is just messing about and not actually being serious or dedicated to what they are doing.

I am six foot and my two sons are of a similar height and we all take an eight shoe size, so not really unusual.

The PID belief, to me, is totally unconvincing. The idea that the Beatles did not write their own songs (particularly the Rubber Soul era stuff) is convincing as I see no way of McCartney and Lennon having developed such an ability in such a short period of time and being able to basically have nothing going into the studio and then everything they tried in a two week window turned into gold with no duds left on the cutting room floor. But I have to admit, I listen to your channel because of that very sexy voice! LOL

It’s weird my dad is 6’2 and he’s size 8 feet I’m shorter but still a 9 most the time, less hormones in the milk I think

I'm interested In Fred Seamans account of his time with John & Yoko, but this is bit like listening to two gossiping, giggling women. I lost interest once I heard you refer to Paul as 'Billy'. Deluded to say the least.

Bonkers but slightly entertaining 😅

Obsessed with the unreal.

Le Bouvier Can lou bouyè ben de laoura, Planto soun agulhado, **A.E.I.O.U.** Planto soun agulhado. "Catharpiller"

What a load of rubbish.

The movie 'Help' is a statement against religious cults, not in favor of them.

Great presentation. Just one point - look at Janes legs, the shape of the calves and ankles are distinctive in photos through most of the 60s, seemingly being fairly 'shapeless'. See if you can find pictures of her legs from '69 on. My recollection is that there is a clear difference.

Jane doesn't seem to age, up to 10 or so years ago at least. The best looking female pensioner I've ever seen.

John and Yoko remained together because they are TWINFLAMES. Very highly gifted people on a Spiritual Journey. When one is on a spiritual journey, it is difficult to relate to “normal” people as everything is chaos. What humans do not understand was understood by John and Yoko. They kept private for a reason. The world is in chaos and John’s belief in a Superior Being is accurate. The Divine Feminine is your answer… The Savior, The Creator, God… prophesied by Edgar Cayce, “in the blink of an eye”, SHE will Rise. She is the Holy Mother Mary. Her Divine consort is Archangel Gabriel, also a God. Any day now is THE SHIFT. The entire reason humans are on this planet is to raise the consciousness for this shift. The spiritual path leads to this enlightenment.

The fans were encouraged to scream.....so the lack of musical skill wouldn't be noticed.

I also find the number of takes anomalous . If we consider the studio protocol was one run-through and one take { as explained by Steve lukather in the rick beato interview } the takes must be vocal or complete fiction

Can't understand what the American lady is saying.

The Beatles weren’t experienced musicians? I’m sorry I must’ve dreamed the 10,000 meth fueled hours they played in Hamburg etc. Not saying they were virtuosos but some rock numbers aren’t exactly rocket science. I’m not even 10 minutes into this video and I’m already getting Mike Williams vibes. Again, don’t get mad at me just pointing out flaws as I go I want the truth too

I’m seeing a lot of “probably nots” in here, always a red flag. I’m searching for the truth like everyone else don’t get mad at me!

Missed this one so just listened and enjoyed.Another though piece of work sounds like a lot of coincidence was involved 😂😢😅 yep fairy story ❤

Your listeners may want to read Tina Foster's book, The Splitting Image: Exposing the Secret World of Doubles, Decoys, and Impostor- Replacements.

Seeing these 'Janes' stay the same whilst the husband ages makes me get Stepford Wives vibes! (The original film, not the awful remake.)

Are these doubles intelligence operatives who have been told to play the role of someone for the next ten years in a matter concerning national security? This would not be strange. Double agents, moles, and operatives overseas under deep cover do this all the time.

It is interesting to see the early Jane's Adam's apple. Look at Linda McCartney in early pictures with Bill Shepherd. She too has a very prominent Adam's apple.

"She said she'd [she had] always been a dancer" is reported speech. To me, "She said she's [she has] always been a dancer" sounds odd. It would have to be "She SAYS she's [she has] always been a dancer."

The slide at 14:06 says 1916, not 2016!

Jane Asher's mother was George Martin's music teacher........What a web! 🕸️

This is fantastic! Great work Cat! Without a doubt the most comprehensive and valuable analysis of Beatles music I’ve ever seen 👏 Learning about this apparently vast music conspiracy has led me to listen with a more skeptical ear. One of the bands that has peaked my interest recently is Metallica. Similar to the Beatles they were not learned in music theory and lived a raucous party lifestyle whilst crafting music that sounds far beyond their capabilities. In particular the albums “Ride the Lightning”, “Master of Puppets” and “And Justice for All”, bear the unmistakable stench of ghost writer/composers, session players and sophisticated social engineering techniques. I’m curious if anyone else finds Metallica’s official narrative questionable?

1:00:14. Best part of the video.

Outstanding organization and musical analysis!