Видео

He never quite finished it. I'm sure he was experimenting by the time he was working on it, probably finding its soul, but was unable to.

But I have to be honest and say that this version of the 3rd and 4th movements is bad, a real composer would have done it better and I know someone who did it better, there is also a video of his own version of the third movement. At the moment, a human being can still analyze music better than an AI and I won't be persuaded, yes with art, but not with music. AI understands the structure of a piece of music, but it still can't implement it properly or process it in a meaningful way like a human can. The AI simply gives random structures or themes that no longer make much sense in terms of music theory, but sometimes it sounds good by chance because it repeats, processes and develops the melodies. The AI will never become exactly like a human being, because it is not human. Nevertheless, I have to admit that it is making good and rapid progress and is moving further and further in the direction of humans, but it will never become 100% like a human. But there's no harm in experimenting with it, I don't deny that.

@@Der_Komponist Interesting. Would you say AI music is bad without knowing it was AI though? If you were to listen to AI music, but it was labeled as music written by a human, would you actually like it? You know this was written by an AI, so you were predisposed to listen to this music knowing that it might not sound good. But what if you didn't know, going in to listen to a piece of music, whether or not it was written by an AI?

​@@rahulradhakrishnan5591 I wouldn't like the music either, even if it had been written by a human being, because no effort was made.

iMMER eine Steigerung vor handen.

היצירה הראשונה של בטהובן לפני מותו.

E perchè? Cosa ne sai tu di come sarebbe dovuto essere il Requiem nelle intenzioni di Mozart?

I have always this question in my head: Why some composers died before completing their last work that they have started? 😢 Idk, but maybe there is a reason why some things remain unfinished and I don't think that their sickness and being unable to finish it is always the reason. Maybe, this reason was never true.

@@teodoragradinaru8572 Good day. But it makes sense that there is always at least one work that is never completed, because as a composer you work on several works at the same time, start different ones and finish different ones. It would have to be a very big coincidence that you die as a composer at the exact moment when you don't start or finish a new work.

Aber nicht stumm 😊

Das Ist doch keine Computer Nachahmung, die kommt erst im 3. und 4. Satz. Der 1. Satz ist von einen Musikprofessor geschrieben/ bearbeitet worden. Es sind auch richtige Orchester Aufnahmen.

He won't

Then why they didn't made that movement with chorus? I think it was better if Beethoven could've live longer to finish his 10th symphony.

Isaiah 9 New International Version 9 [a]Nevertheless, there will be no more gloom for those who were in distress. In the past he humbled the land of Zebulun and the land of Naphtali, but in the future he will honor Galilee of the nations, by the Way of the Sea, beyond the Jordan- 2 The people walking in darkness have seen a great light; on those living in the land of deep darkness a light has dawned. 3 You have enlarged the nation and increased their joy; they rejoice before you as people rejoice at the harvest, as warriors rejoice when dividing the plunder. 4 For as in the day of Midian’s defeat, you have shattered the yoke that burdens them, the bar across their shoulders, the rod of their oppressor. 5 Every warrior’s boot used in battle and every garment rolled in blood will be destined for burning, will be fuel for the fire. 6 For to us a child is born, to us a son is given, and the government will be on his shoulders. And he will be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace. 7 Of the greatness of his government and peace there will be no end. He will reign on David’s throne and over his kingdom, establishing and upholding it with justice and righteousness from that time on and forever. The zeal of the Lord Almighty will accomplish this.

This is a real orchestra.

?

I hope we will be able to listen to it.

Can I please see or listen to your version of the Scherzo?

@@LoquaciousLemonade it's not about being nice or not. It just doesn't work, in my opinion.

This is half a ai

What about the non-symphonies Beethoven finished after his ninth symphony.

This is the best work of art of all times

What was Beethoven's intention: Did he want to make a 10th Symphony? The answer is most assuredly yes. Ludwig was in conversation with leaders of the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra about a 10th Symphony, no more than a couple of months before his death. Having said that does this Symphony sound like a Beethoven's composition? Yes and no. The first movement (since split into two movements), are spot on Beethoven-ish but the following two movements are just poorly reasoned out interpretations of the sketches Beethoven left behind. Beethoven tended to repeat themes throughout his music. The third and fourth movements lack that.

They should keep refining it as these AI models continue to improve.

But I have to be honest and say that Barry Cooper's version is much more mature and better than the AI, and I know what I'm talking about because I've heard and know a lot of Beethoven's works, and therefore know, recognize, and understand his musical style. The Barry Cooper version is good, I mean, why not write a movement that starts slowly, is fast in the middle, and ends slowly again. You can't argue that Beethoven would have done that too. The movement is also more structured than the other movements. I also understand a bit about music theory and I know that it's not 100% Beethoven, but Barry Cooper did a very good job with it, it's a modern first movement in which the basic rules of sonata form are not fully adhered to, but it's nothing new with Beethoven that he often had to break the rules with his music as we know it now, and the 10th Symphony wouldn't have been as great as the 9th, but perhaps more modern than his other 9 symphonies. Every symphony by Beethoven has to be different because he wanted to make each symphony different from the other, so the 10th Symphony is something new and that's why you have to change the structure and break the rules again. The 10th would probably have been a romantic symphony.

Unfortunately, I did not mark the time intervals, because I myself had difficulty determining the movements of the so-called 10th symphony. But I advise you to search RUclips for something similar. But I can assume that, most likely, the first part (more than 20 minutes) consists of two movements, and the second part was created by artificial intelligence. You can find and listen to it. And I only compiled two parts to make a full-fledged symphony, although this is far from a work by Beethoven, but only a reconstruction. ruclips.net/video/Rvj3Oblscqw/видео.html

Best guess I can surmise is 6:00, where the Allegro begins, though that’s also counted as part of movement 1

@@dmitrysparkle2100 Barry Cooper's version is only labeled as '1st movement' and the AI version is only listed as the 3rd and 4th movement.