Видео

good amazing video! definetly informative for anyone else wanting to make an ms paint fan adventure!!

Cool video, but I don't think the FNaF videos are exactly a good example of your point because a good chunk of the mysteries _were_ intended and _were_ solvable, just not all of the ones that people thought they saw. FNaF gained its popularity _from_ that dig for clues and secrets, and actively engages with the fandom through it, so I feel like your highlighting it as people digging too deep and missing the author's point comes as a sort of bad-faith argument. Tangentially, I don't think The [Media] Theorists switching to lore theories was necessarily malicious or disingenuous, it was just a result of the sheer numbers their early lore videos like FNaF did, so they were chasing the success that came with that. RUclips has been their job now for the better part of a decade, so they have to follow what brings in an audience if they want to sustain that livelihood. I have some other issues with how you handled certain topics, like you yourself glossing over critical things in the same way Game Theory does or some math wonkiness, but I think other commenters put it into words better than I ever could. I see the intent with the whole diatribe about media analysis and you make a lot of good points, but some of the ways you did it were a bit hypocritical or self-contradictory. FUCK cinemasins, I can't believe I ever watched their shit.

Would the scratch here be like resetting a run? Ah shit we got stuck time to end the planet

I assume time is required as that's where the disc spawns for THE SCRATCH in case things go wrong. Plus, a player skilled with time makes sense for the game, given that the players will have to engage in a number of self fulfilling time shenanigans

nicew

Actually, Homestuck is good. Like, unironically. It is straight up good, regardless of the "generic white guy" or "ableism."

this video is fucking awesome HELL YEAH HOMESTUCK SEMI-SPRITES!!!!!

I enjoyed John Egbert talking at me about homestuck semi-sprites. Good luck on your project, the premise got me hooked

Semi-sprite is definitely the artsyle I associate most with Homestuck. I like the "newer" and HS2 styles but it doesn't help hold the same charm to me.

Oh shit i have that lime sign in the thumbnail lmao

You voice sounds like you could voice john

NEEEERRRRRDDD AAALLEEERRRRRTTTT (awesome video)

ho homestuck isn isnt good......? (YOU HAVE JUST CRUSHED THE DREAMS OF A THIRTEEN YEAR OLD BOY)

i hear everywhere: "what is homestuck" homestuck is not a "what," its a feeling an experience, you arent going to understand it if someone explains it

this is just insufferably long droning, a very tedious and meticulous description of literally every minutiae in the game, not an analysis. learn from the game and be more concise - it's a sign of a sharp mind.

Actually Homestuck is Good.

12:16 Look, in general I think the art in Act 6 is pretty good, especially when Andrew Hussie really shows a good effort in some panels that are more polished. However, something I would say that I think is kind of bad is some panels where you can clearly see that he was too lazy to reuse an asset or to really put effort into the art, which is strange because he had a lot of time. An example of a panel that I would say that I noticed this is in some panels in the final stretch where some characters are very, very pixelated. Example: page 7461 and page 7465 Which in themselves are literally the same page, but the problem is not that they are the same page it is the fact of the lack of explicit effort in the art. There are several examples of pages that contain questionable quality, sometimes even in the background where it looks like it needed more effort. Sometimes some backgrounds that use more realistic things end up looking very strange next to some of the characters they are drawing.

I love the “right door” joke. I always understood it as “will taking the right (correct) door lead us to our destination? Yes! So the door on the right must be the correct one.”

The unintentional comedy of a SBURB speedrun without a time player. They literally have no Time, they gotta do it ASAP.

I mean when I played the very first ending I got was the Freedom Ending, I guess I’m different from a lot of gamers cos my instinct is to start by following the rules of a game to see what experience the developers intended before starting to fuck around and push the boundaries

NOOO CRIMP :CCCC

potato rose is precious yall bfr

Did the music actually play forever in the original game? I ask, because in the Ultra Deluxe Version, the music keeps playing for about 1 minute 46 seconds, before stopping, as if the motor of a record player stopped working. If the music really doesn’t stop in the original version of the game, we really have a difference, how the endings are viewed between the two versions of this game.

i imagine hussie just had a giant pin board in his room crafted together before he decided to actually make the story

this vids old i know but whats the program being used as your explaining how the rose panel is put together

4:44 rocket shields can surf

30:32 Tally Hall jumpscare

I was listening to Tally Hall in the background while watching this so when Spring and a Storm started playing I was seriously wondering why my playlist was suddenly out of order. Anyway, the spriting process and analysis of why fan adventures fail was really interesting and I'm probably gonna check out the comic now.

11:55 Thank you for making me vqlue it so much more!

I agree with a lot of your ideas relating to this comic, but I have to disagree with the opinion that act 1 is boring (and therefore should be skipped). It's not that it's my favorite part, but I still like the process of getting to know the characters. The context of how these people act before the game changes them is important; for a *spoilery* example, watching Delire make their way up the RNG tower was a huge moment of character development, but seeing them in the intro behaving normally can do a lot to set up that impact and deepen its effect. The real reason I have to disagree with it, though-- the assumption of disinterest. I think I am safe in assuming that there are many mspfa readers who enjoyed homestuck, and are here specifically because they have interest in how someone else might take the prompt and rewrite or reinterpret it, with new characters and new ideas, just with a familiar prompt. I'm not saying it's wrong to dislike certain parts, and to choose to spend more time on the parts you liked; ultimately, you still worked it into a unique prompt as a sort of wordless quip on the slow pacing of act 1. But it's not like it was unenjoyable or unnecessary. I understand the structural reasons to try and get the project running before it can fall flat, but I feel like it's a bad mindset to assume the reader wouldn't enjoy what you might write there, even if it's mostly a re-tread. I don't know if that makes sense. Or if even made a correct interpretation on what you were saying. But it just sort of struck a sour note in me to hear someone dislike their writing before they even got a chance to write it.

Yo!, 413th like here

23:30 is so real holy shiiiiiii

holy crap, i feel like i'm almost woefully undeserving to watch this video. all the amazing advice and information you've given in here is AMAZING, this feels like it should be the documentary feature hidden behind purchasing the whole comic on DVD or something!! EXCELLENT video, I'm gonna go out and read your comic now!! you explain your decisions so transparently and honestly that it's extremely refreshing, really showing just how doable yet difficult it is to make something like Homestuck. i loved your breakdown of the Rose panel in the middle section, going to save that for my own use one day haha you are an excellent person and you deserve the world; putting your own comic out for the wide world to read entirely for free is already doing an incredible service, but being so helpful alongside is just... seriously. SO far above the pay grade. thank you so much <3 YOUR DAD IS THE OG BTW

I felt like semi-sprites in act 6 had the same amount of badness as before it,m in a different way though. I also don't mind hero mode being used less sparingly. Yes, it became less special to see a panel with it, but to me that's okay since it just symbolises a gradual shift in the comic's vibe, which I don't fault it for good video still, i like people exploring niche stuff like this

nice video!

yo,,, where is that groovin synthwave savior of the waking world remix from,,, i need that actually all of this background music is a boogie can you share the links

10:38 there is no missing dialogue there, the game just disregards your feedback there on purpose

I had so much more fun reading your comic than I had reading homestuck^2. It made me feel such joy that I felt reading since the epilogue. Genuinely well made and interesting, looks fantastic, all the gifs and sound pages were a treat. I would have loved to see a finished version just to see more of the characters I grew to adore, but this was good enough at least.

🤓

Do you play Minecraft?

Why is there an avatar ad in hebrew in 11:21 😭

7:47 the reason time and space players are needed is because time players planets have the scratch, in case anything goes wrong, I suppose not applicable here where they’re destined to win. Space players are needed because their planet contains the forge, necessary for breeding the genesis frog.

imagine being so woke you hate homestuck for being "ableist" Homestuck is bad cause it's woke, but i guess not woke enough for you

I love the music for this so much

This is an excellent video and I really agree with everything you're saying. I fused stuff to my shields, sure, but it was really only the Zonai stuff. And only *then* did they even start breaking at what feels like should be the normal, actual rate. Anyway, yeah. Re: UI stuff -- wonder what your pitch would be w/r/t the Sage powers. Would you add another menu, or do you like it being in the open?

I was origionally going to disagree with most of what was said here, but you actully made many very solid a good points that I feel as though would make really good additions to the game. One issue I sould see here is by adding more ways to "fuse" it could make the game a little more complex than it needs to be for newer players, I personally belive that the game in it's current state is in a really good spot for new and old players alike to discover and learn new things too. Additionally id like to add that your ideas were likely thought of during development of tears but due to time constrains they may have been cut which would be a shame if true. Either way man this was a really good video, keep it up! and try to improve little by little I could see you being super big one day lol.

Glad to see you back! I kind of agree but at the same time there's already interesting shield fusions (most zonai devices, bombs, the elemental gemstones, frozen meat, heck the spiky armor bits from the armored lynels...) and bow fusions aren't a thing because there's already a lot of arrow fusions and bows already have a few standout things like the zoom, multishot, faster draw speed, max hearts damage bonus... But yeah the pausing during combat thing is dumb and while I don't want the thing to be in real-time like Dark Souls I still need an excuse not to eat a meal after every big enemy attack.

I've been looking for good, long homestuck media essays to consume along with a sopor slime pie using the recipe from the requiem event. This is gonna be good.

About time players. They have a lil something in their planet called "scratch construct" which basically can hard reset the universe in case things go south which happened in homestuck