Видео

That sounds great. I hope you`re still on it?

Thats right. I started with Shotokan Karate, later i learned, that Funkakoshi sensei took the "pinan" kata and changed it into "heian".

Hi resta, can you plz explain your question? There are two things i take into consideration. a) you mean the spelling. and i checked, both spellings can be found. b) the difference between the meaning of "uchi uke" and "sote uke" in different karate stiles.

Hallo, Ich meinte den von dir erwähnten Punkt 2. Ich sehe da einen uchi uke, wenn du soto uke ankündigst. Von innen nach außen ist m. W. Immer 'uchi'....? Oder liegt es wirklich daran, dass bei mir im shotokan die Begriffe anders verwendet werden? 🤔 Vg👋🙂

So ist es. :D Ich habe es im Shotokan damals so kennengelernt wie du anscheinend auch. Dann kamm die große Verwirrung im Shukokai. Grundlegend bedeutet sote/ soto lediglich "außen/ äußere". Je nach Stil (und sogar manchmal Meister) besteht dann der Unterschied, ob gemeint ist, von wo der Block kommt, oder wohin er gezogen wird.

@@KarateBuchin ah interessant! Danke für die gute Erläuterung! Vg P.s. gute, anschauliche Darstellung und auch Erklärungen der Techniken. Ist ein Abo u. Like wert 👍🙂

@@restaresta1630 :D es freut mich helfen und damit wachen zu können!

It`s a pleasure to be of help.

Daaaas stimmt. Das Video ist schon ein wenig in die Jahre gekommen und wird ersetzt. :D

Sounds good. I think both of them are close to roots. There do you teach?

@@KarateBuchin Ich bin Kanadier. And yes, Shito and Wado are solid traditional forms.

So sollte man dies wohl nicht verallgemeinern. Denn es gibt genud Richtungswechsel/ Drehungen, die dem Blocken dienen und nicht dem Wurf. Zweiterem stimme ich dir aber gerne zu :D

Hope, both will never happen!

I can understand that, i tried it a few times. I like how both (jujjitsu and karate) can be combined.

@@KarateBuchin Yeah i agree, in my jujitsu class im pretty sure ive seen people try to use karate against me

Und wie man hörte: sie wurden unterhalten 😁

Great that i could help you, i hope you`ve seen our newer video to the pinan nidan? And, coming tonight, we will show a few bunkai for this kata!

Dear Armand, thank you for your thoughts. Kata is in constant flow, and some Sensei prefer small changes, so that the kata match with the bunkai. In regard to the eye contact i have different ideas. First, your horizontal facial field/ eyesight lays between 180-200°, so that you can recognize an attacker easily before you turn your head. Second, the bunkai part starts AFTER you turn your body to your partner/ attacker, so that the turning of the head is no part of the application itself. My roots lay in Shotokan, but even there (with clearly more headmovement) you won`t wait till the attacker stand by your side and starts attacking you, you turn your whole body to your partner and THEN start the bunkai. What are your thoughts to this? Do you train in a spezial stile of karate?

Thank you! I hope i can help with our new videos too.

@@KarateBuchin thanks although I'm not good at foreign languages lol

Even if my reply is a bit late, it`s a pleasure to be off help!

Thank you very much for your detailed comment, i will intensify my background research and adapt the video. Where does your knowledge come from?

@@KarateBuchin ...you're welcome I can speak, write and read japanese. I'm also a student of Tsukada sensei in France and i know pretty well Kamohara sensei.

Thank you for the advice. It might be a difference in the stile, that it`s not so good to be seen. I`ve started karate with shotokan, in wich we always turned our heads straight to the side. In Shito ryu shukokai we want it to be more in sync with the whole body. Which style do you study?

@@KarateBuchin good points. I've been studying Shorinkan and Shorin-ryu, and we're generally told to look where we're going briefly first, but it's not always strict and of course the newbies don't remember. It's mainly for tournaments, imo

Thank you! I hope i can be of help!

🤣 Will keep the idea in my mind.

Glad to hear that!

I`ll go over it again, but i want to mention, that this vid is already a little bit older ;) Which stile do you study, maybe there lies the difference?

@@KarateBuchin cool! I study a Shorinkan/ Shorin-ryu style, slightly different.

Hallo Stefan, danke für die Info, leider kommt meine Antwort erst ein Jahr später... Aber es wird überarbeitet :D