- Видео 4
- Просмотров 37 160
Jonathan Wright
Добавлен 23 сен 2011
Disc golf backhand Two Form Theory - Getting started
This is a video created for a student I am coaching. It introduces the main mechanism of the two forms people use to throw a disc, the "beginner" throw and the "pro" throw. Each form has its own set of features, but the theory states that you can't simply change the peripheral features without changing the primary feature. And features such as bracing and the power pocket are peripheral features of the "pro" throw. This is precisely why people struggle so much - they try to change the peripheral features without changing the primary feature. Ultimately, pick the throw you want to do, but don't expect to be able to brace, "hit the power pocket", or get over 300 if you are not choosing to d...
Просмотров: 998
Видео
Shoulder Stretches for Disc Golf
Просмотров 215Месяц назад
Shoulder stretches for disc golf that you can do in a house with a door frame or on the course with a pole. These were developed by my physical therapist and I am simply sharing what they shared with me. I am not a medical professional, so as with all exercise routines, consult a medical professional before using and use at your own risk. Be aware that there are several potential causes of shou...
Why you struggle to brace in disc golf - Part 2 - The run up
Просмотров 17 тыс.Год назад
Here I provide an answer to the question of why most people struggle to brace in disc golf. In your run up you are doing something naturally that keeps you from being able to brace. I provide examples of the problem and solutions. With this information, everyone should now be able to brace well and add easy power and distance to their throw.
Why you struggle to brace in disc golf - Part 1 - The plant foot
Просмотров 19 тыс.Год назад
Why people struggle in their disc golf backhand form. Why it is difficult for you to brace well. As a scientist, I studied this question carefully and found the answer. And it is simple. With this information anyone can brace well and can quickly improve their throw. This helps make all the other information out there make sense.
Thank you for making this video. I feel like your demonstrations really helped me think about my row in a different way
You're welcome! I'm glad it helped.
I think it would have been helpful to describe exactly what the “lats” are.
Very interesting! I'm gonna take a look at my past throws and try to see if I do this or not. Maybe this will get me to hit 70+ reliably? If i do, I'll update this thread after i recover from this pesky finger injury Thanks for posting your thoughts!
One follow-up question I have is, how are you loading the lats in the backswing? Anything you focus on particularly other than stretching them out?
@@michelgleeson708 This could explain the idea of leaving the disc in place and walking around it. That can work if you do it until you feel the stretch of the last and then use that as a cue to begin your pull.
Do you think to Lat Pull protects the torque on the lower back better vs core-arm model?
@@johnhall1232 Yes. You can get much greater distance with less effort. With core-arm form people add a lot of effort to get more distance. When I was doing that early on, I hurt myself several ways. Also, the rotating on the heel with a straight leg in the lat model stops the forward momentum, protecting the lower back better than the bent knee of the core-arm model.
Good stuff Jonathan! This goes well with my "Truth About the Arm - Pulling vs Slinging" vid.
Thank you!
@@seabas22 you're right, these two vids compliment eachother well and I find build a compelling model
Thanks for the video. It seems that you are attempting to create a full motion throwing technique rather than just tips to make a better throw. One question I have is when do you start to feel engagement of your lats. Is it at the very beginning of your throw at the time of reach back or is it later when you start to bring the disc forward? If it is later when you start to bring the disc forward, does the intensity of the lats contraction vary throughout the throw, being more intense in the "power pocket" phase of the throw than when you just start moving the disc forward. One last question, what part does the hip rotation play in generating velocity? Are you contracting the abs to help with the hip rotation? Do you consider the hip rotation to be an active part of generating velocity or does the hip rotation in your model occur more as a result of the lats work in other words more of a passive movement?
Good questions! I am creating a new theory, that there are two distinct forms and you can't just change features because each form has its own separate set of features. So, everything can be explained through a good theory, and I think this one does a far better job of explaining things than the current default theory. For example, people find it beneficial to walk around the disc in their runup. This can be beneficial if you allow that to stretch out your lats to where you feel the tension and then use that as a cue to begin contraction of the lats (the foot must be completely down though). So, the lats contract at full reach back, while the disc is still completely back. When that contraction happens and the force of it has caused the front hip to move backwards (this is what people mistakenly call hip rotation) and the force goes down into the heel, then the disc can come forward. This happens almost simultaneously with the off hand coming in, which allows for an increase in tension across the back, perhaps double or triple the amount. So, in this theory, there is no hip rotation. The hip moving back is simply a byproduct of pulling with the lats. Just try it yourself and you will see. That is the thing about a good theory, it can and should be testable and obviously should hold up under the testing. If it doesn't, that is okay, as long as we move on to a better theory that better accounts for the evidence. Overall, for right now, I am certain that this one better accounts for the evidence than the default theory that people work from, that there is one form and you can tweak features to make it better and eventually get to that pro style form. This theory says you can't - some people are just lucky enough to start using their lats along the way. BTW, Will Schusterick highlights the importance of pulling with the lats in his video. He just never developed it into a theory.
Glad to hear it. I'll try to get out a video more fully explaining the theory soon.
Thank you for this video. This unlocked some doors in my mind in such a good way. This form looks exactly like the pros. I'm going to practice this every day.
Thank yoy
Welcome 😊
Thanks for this compelling video! So glad it popped into my feed; I think you're really on to something, especially w/ the launch step. Could you clarify some terms, perhaps in a future video, especially where you mention "the weight" and "it goes up" and "it goes down"? I have an intuitive sense of what you mean based on what my eyes see, but these terms feel somewhat overloaded. I think a breakdown in terms of bodily mechanics would really help this stuff land. Again, excellent video. Thank you for the insights!
Ya, in order for me to throw straight on time I need a hop step like feldberg
very informative video! appreciate it.
“Launch Step” is an amazing observation! Thank you!
I’m late to this video, but I had a thought while watching that you could weigh in on. Do you think that a slightly longer extension on the brace leg will naturally keep the upper body behind it? It seems intuitive to me that it would. This might help with rotating on the heel as opposed to the ball of the brace foot which might cause the upper body to be over the brace as opposed to behind it.
Good question. Owen at Trebuchet addresses this with his short leg long leg concept. My question is, how do you actually implement that concept? I have a video coming up that will shed some light on it, but feel free to share your thoughts on implementation.
This is really a helpful video, and I will be incorporating this technique beginning with tomorrow's warmup. I do have an interesting topic. Thrpughout my life, I have been affidextrous. All sports I've played (tennis, baseball, football, basketball, ping pong, raquetball, pool, etc.) have been right-handed. However, I write, eat, and do most precision tasks left-handed. I did break my right wrist earlier in my life and found I was able to retrain myself to play ping pong and pool to about an equivalent level of proficiency left-handed during the six weeks that I had a cast. That said, I have been playing disc golf for about two uears and play almost exclusively RHBH. I have dabbled with throwing RHFH, but have only limited it to short flick shots because I really feel that my shots suffer when I put power to them. The thought has crossed my mind to learn to thtow LHBH to give myself a right-fading shot for holes for which it would be prefferred. Given my situation, would you recommend that I concentrate on developing the LHBH, or should I try to fix the RHFH, since my right arm in naturally stronger. This came to mind when I saw you practicing the left foot heel pivot.
I have known people that were in a similar situation in deciding whether to do RHFH or LHBH. Those that go with LHBH improve pretty quickly and are happy just doing that. Forehand can take more effort and time. In the end you may end up doing both but you will probably improve faster doing LHBH.
All you do is plant on the edge of your foot its like a baseball swing watching the pros in MLB. Being on the balls of your feet and plant down on the inside of you foot will keep your weight back, and center.
Failing to extend the plant leg so it is completely straight just as the the disc is ejected is failing to brace. Extending too quickly causes your plant foot to leave the ground. Extending correctly allows your body to rotate in place, on top of the straightened leg. It also prevents pole-vaulting over the top. Extending (bracing) correctly increases hip rotation and torso rotation speed, and hence disc air speed, because torso rotation rate is the single deciding factor in distance throwing. Additionally, extending your plant leg increases pressure on the ground, increasing both grip and traction (they are not the same thing) exactly and precisely when you need it most. If you front leg is not straight before the disc is ejected, then you are not bracing. Period. On top of this, extending allows you to easily move upwards into static balance (as you have done since you learned to walk) at the end of the throw. It's very difficult to end balanced on just your plant leg if that leg remains bent. AND... by timing your leg extension so that it finishes just as the disc is ejected, pressure on the ground is then radically reduced, which automatically allows your plant foot to rotate on the heel.
I think Aaron Gossage has the tightest and shortest form . It’s so quick.
What insightful content, unique and different analysis from what other pros are saying. Kudos to doing your research and thanks for sharing. Eager to go test this out!
Thanks. I try to only share what hasn't been shared or to highlight important points that have only been glossed over. And just to be clear, I'm not a pro. Just a scientist who likes to figure things out.
I have a hunch as to why it’s so difficult in general for the average player. I have no data here but I believe most RH dominant athletes are also Right Foot dominant. This means for a RHBH you are bracing with your dominant foot instead of using it to generate the power. I come from a Skateboarding background and the friend that introduced me to DG was really surprised how much I struggled. He assumed the brace and weight transfer would come naturally due to my skateboarding experience. The problem is I skate “regular” stance, or left foot forward. The motion for RHBH, specifically the footwork and brace, is the exact opposite of what’s naturally comfortable for me. My hunch is that if we polled the top 100 players, I’d bet a higher percentage of the RH/RF dominate players would skateboard/snowboard “goofy” footed, leading naturally with their right foot. Maybe I’m just trying to justify why I’m still so bad at all of this hahaha. Either way, great videos!! Thank you for taking the time to break it down.
I've had some similar thoughts from my experience with snowboarding with a regular stance. I've played around with using my muscle memory from going down goofy and turning the board uphill - that can map onto the x step and plant foot. I'm always looking for muscle memory cues that may be helpful. Bracing is tough though. I think for most people it will require building new muscle memory.
Great video, but could be better with fewer pauses in the videos 😉
Thanks. I will work on making them better in the future.
I think a big error that people make (eg.: me) is moving 'over the brace' instead of into the brace, because we try to push off with the left leg (RHBH)
Great stuff. When you do the single step are you reaching and torquing from your waist and following through with a delayed pull? I am finding it difficult to generate the power doing the standstill single step. I do feel the brace though. Great stuff
Good question. That is definitely one thing that stood out to me when I first started doing the side step. When I get my weight onto my heel, I can then do what you are saying, and the side step throw really helped with that timing. I need to do a follow up video where I go into more detail about it. Thanks.
That would be great! Looking forward to seeing that.. Your techniques are really helping me improve. It will be interesting when one of the more viewed online instructors catches wind of your explanations and techniques. I truly think it will be a game changer for peoples learning curves. I’ve shared your content with friends and I can see they are implementing your techniques and improving. Cheer!
I have a small timeframe between toes hitting and heel hitting in the plant, sometimes it looks like I plant my entire foot at once. I always rotate out on my heel and I know how to brace. I see pro's have a much more pronounced separation in time of their toe/ball of foot hitting before the heel hits when they reach for the ground in the plant. Can players benefit from a longer timeline between toe touching to heel touching or is a smaller timeframe of "rolling" from toe to heel just as effective?
I focused on this issue a lot at first. And I'm not sure. I'm not sure that it matters. It will change depending on the type of shot you are doing and perhaps the speed of your forward movement. I can see that when I do an upshot it is simultaneous, but with a drive there is more separation. Right now I'm at a point where I don't think it matters because it will be a byproduct. The important thing is to be able to rotate on the heel and for timing, to not start the pull until the weight has shifted to the heel...this might be why timing on upshots is easier. People often struggle because hitting the toe/ball triggers them to start the pull. That was my problem with timing for quite a while.
Launch Step is the "Brinster Hop"
Not exactly, but thank you for pointing out Brinster's form. The launch step is more generic in that it refers to any form that sends the weight in an arc over the x step, and that would include a hop like Brinster's and also forms like Calvin's and Tamm's.
After playing "seriously" for a year or so starting at basically 0 skill ive been able to get out to 260ish when im lucky. after recently paying attention to my bracing foot, ive noticed i naturally kind of hop on that last step and have felt alot more snap and power out of my throws. I tend to rotate on the balls of my feet, but im going to try paying attention to my heel instead, as just playing around in my house it feels alot nicer, and i notice the weight staying a little further behind me
Threw my farthest drive thanks to the launch step. Great video
Glad to hear it!
I would love to see a breakdown of Sai Ananda's drives like this. She barely has any run up and crushes the disc.
It is a good example of what I am talking about - Sai's run up is a low impact yet highly efficient example of how a person can incorporate a launch step with a hop in the run up. It does not have to be as dynamic as Calvin or Kristin to be effective. The key is to use it to brace, stopping the forward momentum abruptly so that force can go into the throw, which she does well.
@@jon51901 I'm 43, smaller guy like Emerson Keith and have definitely found myself hitting that wall. I'm 300' on a good drive, 270' consistently. I am looking forward to putting some focus into this. Thanks for the video.
Thanks for sharing ❤
Hello sir, how do I throw flat? I always throw hyzer sir i tilt the disc sir
There are too many variables to say without seeing the throw. I'd recommend joining the Facebook group Disc Golf Form Check and post a video and ask there.
@@jon51901 yes sir, problem is i have no answer even if i used the forums
Thanks for these couple videos. I really appreciate the thought of the weight going up and then down into the brace, rather than all linear towards the target. I would say Eagle McMahon and Gannon Buhr don't really have a crow hop or short x-step, but obviously they're doing everything right as far as timing. I think for the rest of us, adapting Kristin Tattar's form will help us see results faster. I agree on term "launch step" being illuminating. Perhaps most of us have focusing on the wrong step.
Nice summary
Great information! I hope more is coming in future as well, so time for some "critique" about the video it self. A bit of pre planning on what you're about to talk, and pre record the movements and then use those videos while talking (like you showed video from Simon earlier) that would help making the video and communication about the concepts bit more fluid.
Thank you. I am very grateful for advice on content delivery. I will work on that.
@@jon51901 great! As I really like the content you have, it is informative and both are to the point and does not have too much information at once but a nice actionable step anyone can take.
Bro cracked the code. I just went from 300ft max to 700ft max in this one video!
Great observations and breakdown, really helped me stop pushing my weight forward on the plant which I was struggling with. Would really like to see your breakdown on the sidearm.
Thanks. I will work on that.
Very different video but lots of great concepts! Definetly going to try this!
Lovely getting to see this from a scientific perspective
This is a great vid. I was hopping up and landing down on my brace with so much downward force i couldn't pivot well and my ankle is jacked up from it. It clicks when i move it now. Brace correctly, my friends! Helps your game and keeps you injury-free.
I have injured myself as well. For a low impact but effective form, Sai Ananda is a pretty good example.
@@jon51901 I wish I had seen this video series before I damaged myself- And so does my ankle! Keep fighting the good fight out here. Edit: Sai is becoming one of my favorite pros.
This seems intuitively ok, but I can't help thinking of Eagle's form. He does neither "launch" nor the extra short x-step. His weight almost seems to smoothly ride in a perfect horizontal plane.
He does show us another way to do it. Niklas also does this. I couldn't capture every method, but the basic idea holds...we need to be aware that the natural tendency is to push our weight up onto the plant foot. Eagle achieves it by not pushing like a normal step combined with reaching out more laterally with the plant foot. My guess is that this would be one of the most difficult methods for normal disc golfers to try to follow because it is so subtle. It will be much easier for the majority of players to use something like the crow hop. That is just a hypothesis though.
You make a lot of good observations and points, many I've made before and some are not totally correct. Not sure if you have seen my, GG/Vertical vs Eagle/Horizontal analysis vid, or Swivel Stairs, Crush the Can part 2.1, Elephant Walk, Hammer Toss, Door Frame Drills, and many others.
Thanks. Your videos are great. They have certainly helped me. My main purpose is to point to the primary issue, which in this video is that people unknowingly push their weight up onto the plant foot, and to explore ways people address that issue. By doing this I hope to direct the conversation in that direction rather than offer a definitive rule or method. I expect the ideas to be taken and used and better defined. This is how scientific knowledge improves, and I hope we can do the same with our understanding of throwing mechanics.
@@jon51901 Cool! So here's couple notes to hopefully help further discussion, understanding, and vocabulary... 1. I wouldn't call any of those examples a "Crow Hop", but either a "Side Shuffle Hop, or X-Hop". Here's a baseball video on difference between Crow Hop and Side Shuffle: ruclips.net/video/UkepJA-3rEo/видео.html Here's a Paul Ulibarri true Crow Hop example: ruclips.net/video/Z6ZKhZpdiIQ/видео.html 2. I would phrase differently, that people are pushing their weight upward off or from the rear foot/leg, rather than pushing their weight up onto the plant foot. The plant foot/leg does have to push your weight up onto it into the finish. Typically it is the extension of the rear knee that tips the upper body over top the lower body or brace/plant leg. 3. Technically the rear leg/foot does change the vertical/parabolic trajectory compared to a ball. Any rear foot pressure on the ground would do this. 4. Technically you can brace/pivot on the ball of the foot, McBeth often does this. I do agree that learning to pivot on the heel is best way to practice, and best to practice on concrete rather than turf. 5. Describing tee pad or rather throw trajectory directions I prefer to use a compass, North is targetward, East is right, West is left.
@@seabas22 Thank you for taking the time to explain those details. It is always nice to learn new things!
Get a brace on your front foot by thinking about your rear foot and arm being an anchor. Try to not let your leg and back arm rotate through the shot until after the disc has left.
this might be the only thing im overlooking i felt i was doing it by looking at my form not so much im leaning over my knee vs me bracing on my thigh behind my knee..
ive been using chatgpt to ask very specific questions about disc golf movements and what would be stronger and faster etc etc
I've done that as well. It didn't seem to know how to brace very well...
thanks for breaking the heel rotation thing down, your gona save a lot of people knee pain.
cool, lookforward to working with this idea/observation. TY
Big brains appreciate the thought and time for the analysis
Are you saying the final momentum coming from the run up (RHBH) should come from the right foot more than pushing off the left foot during the xstep?
I try to avoid telling people what they should do. Not always great at that though. I am letting people know that they have a natural tendency to push the weight up and forward on the x step and that will keep them from bracing. There are ways to avoid that. The easiest way is to either use a launch step or a tiny x step that lets the weight fall forward to the plant. However, there are some other methods out there as well.
@@jon51901 and when you say xstep, you mean pushing from the left leg that crosses behind in RHBH? Just trying to make it clear in my mind. But regardless, I truly think you’re on to something!
@@anthonygames4451 Yes. The step before the plant, where the left foot crosses behind the right is the x step.
I went back and looked at some of my form videos and I could instantly see how I don't transfer my weight very efficiently. Excited to take some more footage and make some adjustments! Great Video
Sounds good. Have fun experimenting.
I feel like Simon's horizontal movement is derived from being a 360 full distance thrower. Wiggins does the same.
Maybe so!
You really have a gift of being able to explain whats going on with these movements. Thanks for taking the time to make this video.
Thanks!
Are you sure?
Are you asking if I am sure that this is what the majority of people struggle with in the runup?
@@jon51901 haha
Wow. Very in depth analysis of the front foot plant. I'm certainly not doing it like Calvin! I've never thought of the X-step foot as a sort of "passing through without disturbing the weight getting to the plant foot" process. I was so into pushing off with the left foot because I thought it would push me into the brace, but all it did was mess up my shoulder turn and the planting of my front foot(I'm not Ezra). So push off with the right foot and concentrate on getting back onto the right foot(plant foot) without intentionally bouncing back up on the left (X-step foot). Thanks for studying the backhand with the photoshop markers for comparison. Can you help us with the Forehand?
I can help with the forehand. I'm fairly busy, so it might not be soonish. In the meantime check out Caroline Henderson's forehand video. It is very good.
Yes the advice to use the x-stepping foot very lightly as a guide toward the brace is excellent! I have also seen many players zigzag on the tee because of the x step, and this advice prevents that as well.
Jonathan: Very good video. She is strong.