Видео

There needs to be an NIL policy and procedures for each conference. But they need to flexible to still alow for flexibility and growth

I don't like the bowl idea and I like a 12 team playoff. There HAS to be changes to the whole NIL/Transfer Portal problem though. A cap, one free transfer and then you sit out if you transfer again, and a commissioner or group to make sure recruiting and transfer recruiting is fair. I think after a few years teams will be a bit more balanced leading to more competitive games in the 12 team playoff. I think it would be great if conferences went back to 10-12 teams or added divisions. The large conferences with no divisions have been intriguing, but there's a handful of teams I'd like to see play every year and they aren't now.

So far i think 8 teams is better for the playoffs with The NY6 being the playoff games in a better format than 12 teams with 4 home games right before Christmas. I would keep 4 auto bids for conference champions but the first 4 seeded teams should be treated like the original playoff format where it's the 4 best teams overall. Also no bye-weeks. So my hypothetical layoff would be 1: Oregon 2: Georgia 3: Texas 4: Notre Dame 5: Clemson 6: Bosie State 7: Arizona State 8: Ohio State/Penn State Oregon v.s Ohio State would be Rose Bowl Georgia v.s Arizona State would Cotton Bowl Texas v.s Boise State is still the Fiesta Bowl and Notre Dame vs Clemson would be the Sugar Bowl

I like the idea of 6 teams especially if the G5 gets its own playoff, if not I’d go with 8 teams and have the NY6 games all be playoff games.

Before watching the video, I think that they need to make it to where you have to sit out one year after you transfer so after you transfer, you have to sit out a year before you can play Edit just watch the video and I did not know that that was actually already a thing in college football

Zomp. Also the bowl thing is really interesting, the premier league (soccer in england) do something similar where the team with the best record plays the winner of their tournament at the beginning of the following season for the community shield. It works there, I think it could work in college sports too, but the bowls will need to be heavily marketed so it feels like an important game still

Still gotta have elite talent at the skill positions. We dont recruit or retain talent enough to compete for nattys

Getting paid directly from schools would lead to the cutting of non revenue generating sports. You get only one free transfer and then every one after that cost half a season

My changes would be that NIL is given at the end of the season after bowl games and the playoffs, make the kids earn it and that keeps them from optioning out of a bowl game. #2 change I do like the one year wait for the transfer portal, but I would make it a one and done, you can only get in once, so be sure where you want to go to is really where you want to go to. #3 Coaches, if you leave to go to another team they have to sit a year too and they forfeit their salary if they leave before their contract is up.

1) Yellow 2) Relegation Division Re-Alignment: 1st, allow schools to play D1 basketball but D2 for all other sports. To qualify for D1 in all sports, a school must have athletic revenue >$28M (adjust for inflation annually). If overall athletic revenue is <$28M, D2 football. That would move around 96 football teams from FBS and FCS to D2. Next, split all the remaining D1 schools into (5) logical conferences: Big Ten (Eastern Time Zone / North), ACC (Eastern Time Zone / South), Big 12 (Central Time Zone / North), SEC (Central Time Zone / South) and PAC (Pacific, Mountain and HAS Time Zones). The top 10 teams for each logical conference based on ranking (Sagarin or Massey), compete in FBS (total of 50 FBS teams). All other teams are relegated to FCS (around 108 teams assuming IVY decides to move to D2). At the end of every season, the top FCS team from a logical conference has the option of moving up to FBS the following year. The worst FBS team from each conference moves to FCS the following year. FBS and FCS scholarships are both set at 85, so nobody loses a scholarship due to realignment. Since the schools that don't have significant revenue were forced into D2, this shouldn't be a problem. 3) Post Season: A conference championship game is added for each FCS and FBS logical conference. All FCS conference champions get automatic bids to the FCS playoffs and FBS conference champions also get automatic bids to the FBS playoffs. Each playoff consists of (8) teams. FBS still uses Rose, Orange, Sugar, Cotton, Peach and Fiesta bowls for the playoff games. FCS uses home field advantage until the championship game which is the Citrus Bowl. All other bowl games are discontinued.

All the bottom teams lost in the first round, then all the top teams lost after their byes, now all the mid teams are left. 5,6,7,8. Wtf this is madness.

Put caps on the amount of money each school can pay their players, each player can only transfer once each transfer after that, each player gets a suspension for 4 games, and portal opens after the postseason. Expand playoffs to the top 16 teams in the nation, no byes. The top team in the top 6 conferences get auto bids (so top two seeds likely play G5 teams). Also create a second bracket for the next 16 teams and do away with conference championships.

Green

Easy, make conferences regional, and each champ gets an auto bid.

Favourite colour is blue

You won’t go back to the one year sit out rules.

My favorite color is blue

I don’t agree with a G5 playoff because watching Boise State play Oregon in week 2 (they led for most of the game and lost on a last second field goal) you can’t convince me that Purdue is a team who gets to play for a more prestigious national title. If you can fix what teams move up and what teams move down I’m open to debating that but otherwise it’s a no for me

Favorite colors are cardinal and gold

A lot of people are hard on the NCAA for doing nothing but the issue is that every time they try to do something their is a lawsuit and they lose and the NCAA continually losses power every time they try to act. Has the NCAA ever won a lawsuit?

NIL fix: either do rev share or not, however, schools/collectives cannot talk about money until the player has officially signed with a team. Removes the tampering and allows players to make the best decision for them. No AP polls until week 6, and all polls must be ranked without team names/logos. Pure based on results. This removes any strength of schedule bias or conference bias. 1 free transfer and 1 coaching change transfer. Every other transfer must sit out a year. Uniform scheduling, 9 conference games + 1 P5 non-con H&H game. Removes any scheduling disparity Referees answer for calls after games like the NBA 2 minute

They need to cut the number teams from division 1. Great players are playing at small schools. Improve the on field play by consolidating the number of programs.

Sooo, we’re basically making bowl games the equivalent of NFL preseason. Got it

13:24 they should implement a G5 playoff irl. My idea is do a 4 team playoff of all the G5 Conference Champions that were left out of the playoff (this would be Ohio, Army, Jacksonville State, and Marshall). I think this has the potential to bring attention to these smaller schools and conferences that desperately need it

i agree with most of what is said here. I mostly just want bowls back. as a Badger fan they gave me something to look forward to, a goal beyond winning every week. now days it feels like unless we bring down our standards and find some local billionaires that want short term gain over long term recognition (grants and buildings) we will never get a completive top 12 spot so therefore we have nothing to play for.

Notice how the majority of bowl games are in the sun belt? That's because they are in December/January so they are vacation destinations, especially for upper midwest fanbases. If you put them in August, that kind of defeats the point. Las Vegas in December is much more attractive than Las Vegas in August.

was hoping for my sun devils to pull through

Bro Ohio state is not a Cinderella story, they’ve been the betting favorites for both their games so no they’re not upsetting teams

The BCS was a complete disaster, there a reason why we have playoffs now

Interesting stuff

Here is how you fix bowl games forever : you do like up here in Canada. Each conference champions gets into the college Football Playoff. That’s it. Everything is resolved on the field and yes you could have the SEC champion against the MAC champion in the first round. No team should be playing a meaning full game after loosing a conference championship.

I’m an OU fan. I wish we could all just go back to regional conferences and BCS polling

Arizona was so close 😭

Jesus Loves You

The reason of the transfer portal is because making it so players transferring schools and not being able to play was deemed illegal by the courts. If any student can transfer schools and take classes without the input of their previous school, then it’s illegal for it to apply differently to student athletes attempting to play. The only solution like you said is to make players employees. With employees you could enforce limited transfers and tampering. Issue with that is that then eligibility window will no longer exist. Let me explain. If you make the players employees, then let’s say a 26 year old player who is out of eligibility wants to continue playing. They NCAA will say they can not keep them as an employee because they are too old and out of eligibility. Only issue with that is Age is a protected class when it comes to employment. So the player will sue the NCAA and their “employer” for discrimination related to race. The courts will rule that you can not deny due to age, and eligibility will have to coincide with all of the other university employees which effectively have none related to age. I am not against 26-28 year old players even if they take up rosters slots that could be going to younger players. Ultimately it’ll come down to the coaches to determine whether it’s better to develop new talent or to keep an established player.

Crimson, because Roll Tide.

purple

The six team Playoff was the nail in the coffin, king shit. >Saban as commissioner, give him borderline dictatorial powers to fix the messes. He knows how to hire and delineate work to those who know more than him, he'd be great. >I'm not against the radical change with Bowls being at the beginning of the year, but people will then talk about there being literally nothing at the end of the regular season, except for the Conference Championships and Playoffs. Meaning that we're only talking about a dozen teams or so, the rest are left out to dry. I just think because of that, Bowls have to stay at the end of the season. Do more insurance policies, tie participation to NIL money, do whatever. >Six teams in the Playoffs was the obvious choice if you cared about the sport. No auto-bids, just the six best teams, and the top two get byes. First round can be a rotation of the Peach, Citrus, Cotton, and Orange Bowl, second round should *always* be the Sugar and Rose Bowls. And never give participation trophies to inferior teams because people have pity for them, like middle school girls with a stray cat. It's pathetic nonsense, and why we constantly have massive blowouts in the Playoffs over the last decade. >I don't mind the idea of leaving NIL alone and letting it sort itself out. Although, if we're going to have Saban as a commissioner, he wouldn't let that happen, nor should he. I don't even necessarily think a Salary Cap or anything of the sort is necessary though, because of the idea of the Transfer Portal requiring you to sit a year. >Forcing players to sit a year if they transfer sounds bad at first, but quickly becomes great once you realize the implications and slight tweaks you can make to ensure it's good for all. If a kid is at their school for two years and never (or barely) starts, I think allowing them to transfer without waiting is perfect. This fixes high school recruiting, it fixes tampering, it fixes maintaining your rosters, it gives kids who're honestly wasting their time a chance to leave, etc. And there are other tweaks that could be made to make it better, and give kids a better chance at not wasting their opportunity to play. >Make recruiting less of a burnout for teams. I can't fucking imagine the stress and lack of time these guys can spend with their own fucking family before NIL, nowadays it's somehow worse. The coaches know what the dates should be to make this happen, let Saban do it. >Never stifle traditions and the pageantry of college football. Even the fights and flag-planting, let it fucking happen. For fuck's sake, probably the funniest thing this season was Beamer getting trolled into oblivion and losing his mind. >Fix the rules and referees. Ban the awful referees, reduce the number you have, increase the use of technology, etc. Fix the bullshit Targeting rule and remove the automatic ejection, remove the two-minute timeout, bring back the clock stopping, actually call holding on a consistent basis, etc. Truly, God bless the fucking Texas fans who threw shit on the field against Georgia, hopefully that's the spark that gets good changes in place for next year.

Have a conference schedule of teams that went .500 the last year

Personally, I don't see how non confrence champions have a claim to a playoff spot. If you can't prove that you're the best team in your geographical region that how can you claim to be the best in the nation?

My changes would be: - Budget cap of 10 Million dollars (including scholarships and coaches) - All NIL contracts must be signed for 4 years and players have to pay back the money if the player transfers without approval of the agency - 140 teams in 10 team divisions, winner of the division makes it to the playoffs + two wildcard spots (determined by wins and point difference) - 12 game regular season (9 division, 2 opponents based on last year’s performance and one to be scheduled freely) - One streaming service to watch the games. (50 dollars a season to watch our team, 150 to watch all games) - All playoff games are on campus except the Championship game which is held at the Rose Bowl on January 1 (even when it falls on a Sunday) - If you are arrested, you are ruled ineligible for a couple of games on first offence end for a season on second offence. - The teams in Bowl games are drafted by the Bowls themselves in a Selection Show.

My favorite color is purple

I think it’d be really cool to have a G5 playoff and a P4/5 playoff. Then you could have the champions open the next year in Week 0 in neutral site. Be able to gauge the gap between the two groups. And turquoise is my favorite.

I don't like the idea of making bowls at the beginning of the year because 1 It's tradition to have them in December. 2 It gives coaches a gauge of what their roster will look like next season. 3 It means less football between Thanksgiving and the natty. 4 The lower bowl games still mean something to the fans. Winning the orange bowl against Clemson was HUGE for Tennessee. Winning the citrus bowl against Iowa was big, and it gave us confidence in Nico.

blue

Everyone wants a commissioner, but that is what the NCAA was and schools sued the shit out of it anytime anything bad happened to them so now the NCAA can’t enforce any rules because as soon as they do a school sues and wins so the punishment did nothing

Red

Restore the conferences back to 2006

Love everything except the bowl game concept. Really don’t like that.

Divide the nation into 4 geographical conferences of 36 teams, 4 divisions with 9 teams for each conference, bottom 2 teams get relegated to the lower division, top 2 get promoted, at the top division, the first place team goes to a 4 team playoff