- Видео 5
- Просмотров 3 251
Canon Club
Добавлен 10 окт 2024
The Canon Club is a show about the Western canon: the great cultural inheritance we're handed, across music, art, and literature.
It was born of a blog by Ed West, in which he pined for a return to the amateur schools of art and literary appreciation that were so famous in pre-WWI Vienna. An era when people took seriously their commitment to appreciating the art that had come before them: from Beowulf to The Divine Comedy, from Goya to Beethoven, from Brahms to Ibsen.
This podcast is that latter-day Viennese salon. After all, the Western canon is everyone's birthright, even if most of us feel under-educated in it. Paul and Ed have set out to reclaim it for themselves, and thereby transmit it to a wider audience.
Ed West is a prominent British journalist, and the author of the wildly popular Wrong Side of History Substack.
Paul Morland is a nationally-renowned expert in demographics, and the author of several books.
It was born of a blog by Ed West, in which he pined for a return to the amateur schools of art and literary appreciation that were so famous in pre-WWI Vienna. An era when people took seriously their commitment to appreciating the art that had come before them: from Beowulf to The Divine Comedy, from Goya to Beethoven, from Brahms to Ibsen.
This podcast is that latter-day Viennese salon. After all, the Western canon is everyone's birthright, even if most of us feel under-educated in it. Paul and Ed have set out to reclaim it for themselves, and thereby transmit it to a wider audience.
Ed West is a prominent British journalist, and the author of the wildly popular Wrong Side of History Substack.
Paul Morland is a nationally-renowned expert in demographics, and the author of several books.
Canon Club: How The Romanesque Emerged From Medieval Property Speculators
This week, Paul and Ed discuss the emergence of a style of building which represents the birth of the western architecture, namely the Romanesque. Across Europe there remain thousands of buildings which are still categorised are Romanesque, but what does the term mean, where does it come from and what defines building of this kind? To help us find out we are joined by John McNeill, an Oxford expert and prolific writer on the subject.
***
The Canon Club is a show about the Western canon: the great cultural inheritance we're handed, across music, art, and literature.
It was born of a blog by Ed West, in which he pined for a return to the schools of art and literary appreciation that were so ...
***
The Canon Club is a show about the Western canon: the great cultural inheritance we're handed, across music, art, and literature.
It was born of a blog by Ed West, in which he pined for a return to the schools of art and literary appreciation that were so ...
Просмотров: 210
Видео
The Canon Club: Was Anna Karenina inspired by a railway station?
Просмотров 17214 дней назад
The novel Anna Karenina was published by Count Leo Tolstoy in 1878. It tells the story of an adulterous affair between Anna, a respectably married upper-class woman, and a young army officer, Count Vronsky. Anna, torn between duty and passion, cannot resist the latter and is drawn to her destruction. It is also the story of Count Levin, a character in no small part based on Tolstoy himself, str...
Canon Club: Why was Anton Bruckner obsessed with young women?
Просмотров 745Месяц назад
Anton Bruckner was born in 1824 in Ansfelden near Linz in Upper Austria, the eldest of eleven children born to a schoolmaster. He became a teacher then was appointed an organist, eventually moving to Vienna. Bruckner was a late developer as a composer, lacking confidence in his abilities. After various early efforts including two preparatory symphonies he wrote nine fully recognised symphonies,...
The Canon Club: Is Macbeth The Same Person As His Wife?
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.Месяц назад
Macbeth is one of Shakespeare’s later and darkest tragedies. Set in eleventh-century Scotland, it tells the story of how Macbeth, triumphant and promoted by the King after triumph in battle, has his future Kingship foretold by three witches and is moved, with the encouragement of his wife, to murder the king and take the throne. Macbeth and his wife are consumed by guilt and madness. Macbeth co...
The Canon Club: Why Did Caravaggio Kill A Man?
Просмотров 5802 месяца назад
Paul Morland and Ed West are trying to get to grips with the Western canon. Like most of us, they feel under-read and incompetent in the presence of the great Western artistic inheritance. The stuff that shaped our civilisation. From Thomas Mann's Death In Venice, to Tolstoy's Anna Karenina. From Macbeth to A Doll's House, Goya to Goethe, Canterbury Tales to The Ring Cycle. It's a world we ofte...
Great stuff as ever.
Great discussion (though who’s the guy in the picture? Not Bruckner.) I hope no listeners will even contemplate listening to those appalling attempts to complete the Ninth.
I enjoyed yours too. So hard to convey in words what the music conveys.
Bruckner is underexposed.
38:50 Shakespeare's characters seldom if ever seek salvation?! Try actually reading the plays rather than quote scholars who are either anti-Christian or so Christian that Shakespeare is not moralistically Christian enough for them. Academic Agent/Neema Parvini does not know Shakespeare; he rehashes the opinions of some bad scholars about Shakespeare. King Lear is constantly "looking up". He asks the gods for help, and to forgive him. As for Hamlet, salvation (of himself and others) is one of his major preoccupations. Of course Macbeth . Othello asks Desdemona to confess her sins to God before she dies, for her salvation; and to be careful not to lie. Does that sound like a man that cares not about salvation? Both Macbeth and Othello care about salvation but they feel doomed because they can't stop doing what they know is a sin. Obviously villains aren't going to stop being villains and ask God for salvation, because they're villains. This doesn't mean that Shakespeare is "pre-Christian" writer concerned only with nature! I suggest Neema Parvini buys a Shakespeare Concordance and looks up 'salvation' and other words related to the concept. Study the primary texts for a change.
40:16 Nonsense. Shakespeare is full of Christian allusions, ideas, world-views, experiences, archetypes. Shakespeare is said to have about two thousand Biblical allusions. Five times as many as Marlowe. Of course the likes of the awful Harold Bloom will downplay Christianity as much as possible (as will anti-Christian quoters of Harold Bloom types like Neema Parvini). They are not intellectually honest enough to say what is *there*: instead they see what they want to see.
This is making my nerdy heart gush!
AI shite
Scorsese directing Viggo Mortensen as Carravagio in a TV show based on this book would be amazing.
I saw a rendition of MacBeth at The Disney Theater in LA, as an Opera, and it struck me that the witches could also be seen psychologically as Lady Macbeth and Macbeth’s paranoid psyche… run amuck driving them as if they had no real free will of their own… driven by power, greed, standing and collusion. It was astounding!
Or maybe they're just witches.
@ awe…maybe…I like that too of course, but you weren’t there
@Joe-os3vp awe …yes, I thought about that too as I sat there…in the theater watching it myself with so many others that were lucky enough to be there that night….
@dianawitty9628 You couldn't have paid me to be there. American productions of Shakespeare are bad enough, but in a Disney building ... in LA ... in opera form? No way. Not on your Nellie. The only way that could be worse is for a hut-dwelling D.E.I ex-academic conman to come on and quote a Freudian analysis of the play.
31:02 "Muckbeth and Muckduff?" First time I've "hyurd" them pronounced like that.
AA truly in his element.
@@jankymcjangles3817 Grifting is his element. He's admitted that he doesn't like or read Shakespeare, or indeed any fiction.
Fantastic overview of Macbeth and Shakespeare. Wonderfully detailed.
Not really. He just summed up a list of bad opinions of 20th century Marxist/Freudian academics. If you think this is detailed then the Penguin Shakespeare footnotes will blow your mind.
@Joe-os3vp blimey, I was just leaving a positive comment for something I enjoyed.
@@Sparkx100 And I was just leaving a negative comment for some awful, pretentious, textually incorrect and unoriginal Shakespeare commentary from a Ronald McDonald-funded, Stalin-loving, disgraced academic.
Subbed
Nice to hear AA with Uncle Ed, even if it's the "erm, erm, erm" AA.
He has a habit of this when on others podcasts. Much prefers his cave in Wales going solo.
It's always the erm erm Neema. Plus all the "y'know", "does that make any sense?", "kinda like", etc. Fills up the time between paraphrasing American academics.
This is really good.