Видео

I’m back again after one year 😊 for refresher…..

Good images...topography

My hypothesis is Jesus is Aretas IV's son, and you enlightened me by explaining the divinized Dionysus and Isis depictions, Dr. Graf! Southern Peraea being Nabataean is also new to me. So, Pheroras and his doulē might resemble a certain doulē in gLuke. I wrote a platinum post for Dr. Bart Ehrman on my hypothesis that Jesus is the son of Aretas IV in the ancestor cult of Obodas Theos -- because how else can you be the son of a handmaid to a Lord (via Ketubot 3b) when the only prefect/hegemon is to the SE? I think Phasaelis is Jesus' reborn "Queen of South" and don't know why scholars don't think Jesus wouldn't be picking a side, Josephus links her to John the Baptist. Jesus' parables about the Kingdom of Heaven would be lowkey about Petra and Nabataea then, and he could be the successor influencer that got Herod Phillip's troops to flip to the Nabataean side. I also think there's other tells of Arab association, like "wineskins" instead of amphorae, the unguanterium, eating common meals in groups of 13 like Strabo discusses, Jesus drinking from multiple cups, John's camel-hair coat. The Herods as patrilineally Idumean isn't accepted by the LINEAGE-PHILES and eh they just don't follow Tribe of Judah traditions right, lol, this is why replacing them with ethnically Jewish Agrippa (a whole 1/4) solves the civil unrest. I think Nabataeans are Nabonidus' dynasty when he abdicates to Arabia after establishing the trade route, and this dynasty name would be naturally dropped when it is superceded by Jesus achieving the status of Great King under the title of Malichus II in the southern camp, and perhaps Manu as the Immanuel name minus its theophoric elements in the northern camp. 106 CE Nabataeans thus may have an orderly re-home-basing to Abgarid Osroene with merchant bases from Puteoli to the 7 churches of Asia, and noted by the new excavation of the underground city at Midyat, where they could have transitioned agriculturalists to value-added products production. My credentials: I found my name in a Christian reincarnation book as the sister to the author of Luke-Acts and started researching in the Great Reset 😊

Martin Laura Robinson Amy Martinez Mark

Perez Helen Smith Nancy Hernandez Eric

Subbed...

Just subscribed! Do you know how to reach Shimon?

Amazing

Blah blah blah fucking shit do something else

This is SO fascinating. Eric Cline is the best. I feel so fortunate to be able to benefit from Eric's vast studies.

By, "Biblical Era," I assume they just mean Bronze Age or earlier ? This seems like just tired another attempt, heavy handed and massively contrived to establish some sort of historic and cultural continuity with the Jewish state of Judea, (which was destroyed by Hadrian,) and so on and the modern state of Israel created a political fiction convenience after WW II and which has existed for less than a century. I take it all with a pinch of salt.

This is a 'site' with serious question marks. It has all the hallmarks and efficacy of a stage managed production. Academic scholars with decades of financial support speaks volumes in this day and age. This site, like Giza and Gobekli Tepe, should be viewed for what they are - simply tourist attractions.

What I find facinating, apart from the archeology, is the fact that the Westerners got dreadfully sick with Malaria but not the Egyptian workers. I live in South Africa and I lost a very healthy cousin to Malaria. Scientists tried to eradicate Malaria in Africa but the virus simply mutated and still lives.

What exactly does domestication mean? It seems like we can't do those things today, much of them. Just breeding and interbreeding and we come up with all this? Cmon.

Thank you very much for your hard work. Can you help with the underwater arch. Picture and these big questions of before the flood. How megalith construction was occuring. Naztec Lines, etc. Also help with getting America and Europe behind the ridiculous flat earth thing. Which was meant as quack news. Even the Native Americans new the earth was round. We have to teach this correctly. Also, to think that Africans or anyone with black skin would not have made wealth by using gorillas and evolution publicly is lame. In fact it was probably very important for some, with crowds drawn in.

Dressing the stage for tomorrow.

Cline sure likes to hear himself talk......

Thank you for this history. It's very interesting.

A brief observation about the telegram codes. While these enabled secrecy from casual readers (though anyone with a copy of the published Code-book could have decoded the messages), their main function was to reduce costs. International telegrams were very expensive, and charged more for words of more than 5 letters. Each 5-letter code group stood for a longer word, or sentence, or date, etc., so a message of, say, 30 5-letter code groups would be charged for 30 (short) words, but might encode a message of several hundred words. Such codes were widely used in international commerce: some companies issued their own code-books, or special supplements to published codes, with codings for their own products.

Israeli war of independence?

Excellent ! My best regards from Brazil 🇧🇷

Nicely researched presentation as far as it goes. However, according to David Rohl it is wrong to equate Egypt's Shoshenk as the same as the Biblical Shishak. They are different pharaohs. Rohl in his documentaries convincingly explains why conventional pharaonic chronology has a missing 300 year gap and many pharaohs are completely mis-dated and are, in fact, much older. Consequently, a lot of Biblical dating is wrong and confusing. You would do well to stop re-gurgitating discredited conventional 19th Century dating and apply your knowledge to answering the blatant discrepancies that Rohl has uncovered. Otherwise, you are just another academic nit-wit living in a pleasant ivory-tower making a pretense of furthering Biblical research, but actually contributing nothing.

Shimon Gibson rocks!

In many markets in the south-west of Saudi Arabia (Jizan and surrounding area) they sell woven straw baskets of many different styles. The finest (and most expensive) woven baskets are known locally as “Jewish baskets”. Apparently these fine baskets had been produced by local Jewish tribes who had lived in the surrounding area. I could never find out anything definitive about such tribes or when they were producing such baskets. (I was told that these “Jewish baskets” were now provided by local families - presumably now non-Jewish families.

brilliant talk!

Excellent, thank you.

Very, very interesting presentation. Wish other people on the zoom knew how to mute themselves though, the distractions are absolutely MADDENING

*Pompeii @8:38

I was thinking about buying a book on this subject maybe this will do

Oh wow! My next door neighbor 3000 years ago.

That Fatimad jewelry is beautiful. The artist who made it should be proud of his work

Thank you for sharing….. I always enjoy mr. David Hendin’s insight into Jewish coins.

Better than agatha Christie!

History and Archaeology, are working hand in hand when you face ancient history

Notes to self for future reference: LMLK ostracon at 12:34 & excavator autographs at 14:22.

Note to self for future reference: LMLK x4L handle at 18:47.

For my own reference, Wendy Slaninka (granddaughter of James & Marjorie Starkey by their daughter Mary) comments at 47:14 & 1:05:58.

Education will soon be a hobby not a means to get a decent job..

Started in Babylon..

Har Meggido!

Assalamualaikum ! My name is Muhammad Abdullah Khan Barakzai ! I'm from Pakistan ! But my family come to Afghanistan city name Kandahar 300+ Year ago and Tel kedesh 2000 Year ago ! Barakzai tribe of Pathan and Barakzai meaning is son of Barak ! Barak son of Abinoam ! And Abinoam belong to Naphtali Tribe and Barak mother belong to Benjamin Tribe. My name is Abdullah and Abdullah name meaning is Man of God ! And Israel Name meaning is Man of God ! We believe Tel kedesh is ower home land and we will return one day and According to Wikipedia Barak was a ruler of Ancient Israel. As military commander in the biblical Book of Judges, Barak, with Deborah, from the Tribe of Ephraim, the prophet and fourth Judge of pre-monarchic Israel, defeated the Canaanite armies led by Sisera and Barakzai also military commanders of Nadar Shah and also ruled of modern Afghanistan . Give me your comments Brother

Yonatan’s argument seems water tight. All except for a purely artificial academic distinction between intellectual and cultural history in his conclusion. Maintaining that distinction makes sense for his initial data driven research but in the conclusion it seems to make ZERO sense that the Torah or scrolls of the Hebrew Bible could have existed in their present form before the Hasmonean period. No one would write an expensive scroll, like say the contents of Leviticus at a time prior to it being taken up for observance in the Hasmonean period. He should be more brave and at the very least assert the likelihood that the Hebrew Bible scrolls came into their final form, in the period he asserts practising Judaism emerged. There is no need to maintain this distinction in his conclusion. The social history of the Hebrew Bible itself is non existent without a thriving cultural application at some level. Granted that many parts of its content existed in differing forms much earlier. The final observant parts were surely not in their known form until then.

A very enjoyable presentation. Thank you for sharing.