Revolutionary Roads
Revolutionary Roads
  • Видео 23
  • Просмотров 61 536
EuroNight Chopin: Warsaw to Bratislava with PKP Intercity
Since taking my first proper sleeper train earlier in the year from Moldova to Romania, I have been eager for another overnight experience on the train tracks of Europe. Join me in Warsaw as I begin my journey to Bratislava, Slovakia.
Просмотров: 85

Видео

Warsaw: Tracing Resistance to the Nazi Occupation
Просмотров 8614 дней назад
More than 80 years on, Warsaw continues to be known for two uprisings that shook the Nazi occupation. The ghetto uprising of 1943 was an attempt to make sure that the occupiers alone couldn't pick the time and location of the deaths of the Jews who still remained. The next year, the city was largely reduced to rubble after the so-called general uprising of the Home Army.
Vilnius to Warsaw by Train(s) and a Bus - LTG Link and PKP Intercity
Просмотров 14521 день назад
Join me on what I expected to be a single train from Vilnius, Lithuania to Warsaw, Poland with LTG Link. The 10 hour 29 minute journey ended up being far more interesting than I anticipated...
Vilnius: Home of the Jewish Labour Bund
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.Месяц назад
Vilnius, Lithuania is not only a stunning Baltic capital, but it was also the birthplace of European Jewish socialism and anti-Zionism in the sense that it was the city where the General Jewish Labour Bund was founded in 1897. After the European Jewish community's decimation during the Holocaust, that history was lost as the State of Israel was founded. Could things have been different? We also...
Riga: Searching for Soviet Relics
Просмотров 281Месяц назад
How much Soviet influence does Riga - the largest of the Baltic capitals - still retain more than thirty years after the dissolution of the USSR?
Enver Hoxha's Albania - 24 Hours in Tirana
Просмотров 423Месяц назад
More than thirty years after the overthrow of the People's Socialist Republic of Albania, how much history related to Enver Hoxha and the Party of Labor can still be found in Tirana? I spent 48 hours in this amazing city to trace its Hoxhaist past.
Berlin's Resting Place for Rosa Luxemburg & Socialist Leaders
Просмотров 1183 месяца назад
In the former East Berlin borough of Lichtenberg is where you can find the Zentralfriedhof Friedrichfelde, a cemetery that is the final resting place for countless iconic socialist and communist leaders. I took a visit to the cemetery to visit some of its more prominent residents.
Tallinn's Condemned and Hidden Soviet Landmarks
Просмотров 5454 месяца назад
Since its independence from the Soviet Union in 1991, Estonia has been gradually rehabilitating the combatants who fought on the side of Nazi Germany or even directly within its ranks. At the same time, the period of Soviet Estonia is referred to on equal terms with the Nazi occupation of 1941-44. I visited Tallinn, Estonia's charming capital city, to get a sense of just how far this love affai...
Killing Social Democracy: The Assassination of Olof Palme
Просмотров 4064 месяца назад
Late at night on February 28, 1986, Swedish Prime Minister Olof Palme was shot at point blank range while walking to the metro with his wife after a night out at the cinema. Just like that, Europe's last great social democratic and anti-imperialist leader was gone. Nearly four decades later, has his murder really been solved as the country's authorities claimed in 2020?
The Best Train Journey in the Balkans? - Sarajevo to Mostar
Просмотров 4835 месяцев назад
The last leg of my mini Yugo-nostalgia tour takes me from Sarajevo to Mostar on an incredible 1 hour 56 minute train journey through some of the most stunning landscapes imaginable. Before leaving Sarajevo, however, it's time to finally check out its legendary tram system.
Don't Forget Sarajevo: 40 Years Since the Winter Olympics in Yugoslavia
Просмотров 1 тыс.5 месяцев назад
Just over 40 years ago, Yugoslavia hosted the Winter Olympics. The games took place between February 8-19, 1984 in Sarajevo, the capital of the Socialist Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina. They were the first to be held in a socialist country and were considered to be a resounding success. Within eight years, the country that hosted them would be no more and Sarajevo itself would be under the ...
Riding Serbia's China-Built High Speed Rail (Belgrade-Novi Sad)
Просмотров 22 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Did you know that Serbia has a reasonably new high speed train connecting its two largest cities of Belgrade and Novi Sad? It's a project that is part of China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) that will ulimately aim to link Budapest with Athens. The future of rail transport in this part of Europe is looking promising!
Visiting Tito's Grave & Private Blue Train (Plavi Voz)
Просмотров 4,1 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Josip Broz Tito was a towering figure of the 20th century, a man whose influence is still felt and whose presence is missed across the former Yugoslavia. In Belgrade, I visited the Museum of Yugoslavia and House of Flowers where he is laid to rest. The next day, I was able to experience something life changing - being able to step aboard his private train where he wined and dined everyone from ...
Yugo-nostalgia: First Impressions of Belgrade, Serbia
Просмотров 3,3 тыс.6 месяцев назад
Join me on an adventure down Yugoslavian memory lane as we jump on a flight from Berlin to Belgrade. Flying aboard what used to be Yugoslavia's national carrier JAT, we touch down in today's Republic of Serbia looking for Titoist relics and plates of cevapcici. We round off the day of travel by checking into what used to be the most luxurious hotel in Belgrade, the Hotel Jugoslavija, only to fo...
Back in the DDR: Looking for Marx in East Berlin
Просмотров 1 тыс.6 месяцев назад
How many Marxist mosaics and murals can we find in the former East Berlin? Are there any Leninist landmarks we can uncover? This video only scrapes the surface of the socialist heritage that continues to live on in the former Soviet sector of occupation.
No Sleep on 'Sleeper' Trains? - Bucharest-Budapest-Berlin
Просмотров 4,7 тыс.6 месяцев назад
No Sleep on 'Sleeper' Trains? - Bucharest-Budapest-Berlin
14 Hours on a Soviet/GDR Sleeper - Chisinau to Bucharest
Просмотров 10 тыс.7 месяцев назад
14 Hours on a Soviet/GDR Sleeper - Chisinau to Bucharest
Back to the Soviet Future? 48 Hours in Transnistria (Pridnestrovie)
Просмотров 1,4 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Back to the Soviet Future? 48 Hours in Transnistria (Pridnestrovie)
Between the EU and Russia - 48 Hours in Chisinau, Moldova
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Between the EU and Russia - 48 Hours in Chisinau, Moldova
Berlin's Three Soviet War Memorials
Просмотров 2,4 тыс.8 месяцев назад
Berlin's Three Soviet War Memorials
The Heart of (Soviet) Central Asia - Tashkent, Uzbekistan
Просмотров 1,4 тыс.9 месяцев назад
The Heart of (Soviet) Central Asia - Tashkent, Uzbekistan
Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan is a Soviet Time Capsule
Просмотров 9109 месяцев назад
Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan is a Soviet Time Capsule
How Soviet is Almaty, Kazakhstan?
Просмотров 3,6 тыс.10 месяцев назад
How Soviet is Almaty, Kazakhstan?

Комментарии

  • @ssnydess6787
    @ssnydess6787 12 часов назад

    I visited Trep Tauer Park while the wall was still up as a US pilot/officer on a tour that ws followed by the East German secret service. You failed to mention the signifigence of the entry: the kneeling young and old Russian soldiers or the stone draped flags and how about the five fields of combined graves? Our tour guide said each of those five grave filds contained 1 million Soviet soldiers. Give us the whole story please.

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 8 часов назад

      Thanks for your comment and for the story of your visit to the GDR back in the day. Of course, there is much more that can always be said about the memorials. Perhaps I'll need to do an extended video to coincide with Victory Day sometime in the future.

  • @EasternEuropeanSurvivorBoy
    @EasternEuropeanSurvivorBoy День назад

    Hey, great content explained in a very concise manner, thank you 👍

  • @narglefargle
    @narglefargle День назад

    Ljubljana?

  • @Wizard23
    @Wizard23 День назад

    Great content! Would love more

  • @firelight-vitality
    @firelight-vitality 10 дней назад

    Meanwhile, in neighboring EU country Bulgaria, the trains look like from a 1950s Bollywood movie.

  • @kemz83
    @kemz83 13 дней назад

    Great video Marcel! Keep up the tight work brother!

  • @Kayohes505
    @Kayohes505 14 дней назад

    Always dropping knowledge! Can you recommend any books?

  • @TheBrainwashedCommie
    @TheBrainwashedCommie 18 дней назад

    I'm really confused on Alter and Ehrlich, why were they executed? Alot of the information I've dug up points to them being very In favor of the Soviet Union, Apparently in 1917 when Elrich was elected to the Executive Committee of the All Russian Workers' and Soldiers' Soviet, Stalin endorsed his speech. Then all of a sudden in 1939, the Soviets just had it in for him for no reason. Apparently he was accused of 'sabotage' against the Soviet Union. Idk just seems arbitrary.

  • @zivguymoore974
    @zivguymoore974 29 дней назад

    Funny how it aligns and makes sense when you get your sources from Communist, Jihadi and Communists. Fascist oppressive and genocidal entities who persecuted a loyal religious minority , ethnically cleansing it to its origin - the biblical historical land of Israel. If you would zoom out from your narrow minded Antisemiti point of view you will see , that the imperialist, colonialist, genocidal entitiesare the Arab Muslims, the Nazis and Soviets. of course, you don't hate jews, just those Osraeli jews who were ethnically cleansed from Arab Muslim countries, Nazi Europe, and Communist block. The ones who returned to their ancestral homeland to rebuild it, and being attacked again and again by genocidal dictatorships.

  • @zivguymoore974
    @zivguymoore974 29 дней назад

    Do your homework . You are trying to figure out history from an American progressive leftist academic point of view, which has been infected with Soviet jihadi funds. Palestina is the Roman term for Judea, following the Roman crush of the Jewish rebellion, cruisifoction of jesus, and deporting the jews globally. Jude was renamed so after the name of their enemies , the Europen invading "Plishtim" (Goliath) . Millennium before Islam. Palash=invader in Hebrew. There is no "P" in Arabic to begin with, and "Palestinian" Arab nationality is a Soviet jihadi fabrication created by the KGB in 1964 to unite the Muslims against western democracies. The so called "Palestinians " are actually Arab work migrants who invaded the future Jewish state, looking for work at Zionist investments and British investments at the future jewish state. During the past 120 years Arabs have been invading Israel to work for the jews ,hoping to gain citizenships in Israel. In the 1920s , Britain confiscated 78%of the future Jewish state and gave it to the Hashemite Saudi Beduin royalty to create Jordan. The jews were left with only 22% , Declared by the UN as the jewish state in 1947. The day after, Israel was attacked by 5 major Arab countries to ethnically cleanse the 600,000 jewish refugees who returned to their ancestral biblical homeland. The jews fought on their own and won the war. The local Arab work migrants who rejected the establishment of the jewish state fled back to their regions of origin in the Arab countries -but were thrown to refugee camps along the borders of Israel. The so called "Palestinians " are denied citizenships in Arab countries until today, fabricating a "Palestinian " muslim Arab "exile people" to incite Arabs against western democracies and win the hearts and minds of western infidels like you. Tools for a Soviet jihadi revolution in America. Look at Haj Amin al Hueini hisory, The "Palestinian " Arab fabrication has its roots in Nazi Germany. Jerusalem is not mentioned even once in the Quran but mentioned over 600 times in Torah as the capital of the Jewish people. You are a long way from home boy. Pathetic.

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 29 дней назад

      Thanks for the hearty laughs this morning. "Soviet jihadi" funds is a joke I will be taking with me, and I know my Jewish comrades will find it particularly amusing. I truly wish you well in being able to curb your racist impulses.

    • @inactive859
      @inactive859 29 дней назад

      @@RevolutionaryRoads1984 I'm a Lithuanian Jew, we are not ur ''comrade'', nor do most of us like communism - it was just as bad for us as Nazism.

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 29 дней назад

      @inactive859 Then I very clearly wasn't talking about you.

    • @inactive859
      @inactive859 29 дней назад

      @@RevolutionaryRoads1984 i mean, you are making it seem that all Lithuanian Jews were socialist (even tho it was a small minority)

    • @zivguymoore974
      @zivguymoore974 28 дней назад

      en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qatari_involvement_in_higher_education_in_the_United_States

  • @JesusVinegarJohnson
    @JesusVinegarJohnson Месяц назад

    Swan in the Daugava very wasted, many moons ago. What a time. -Jesus Vinegar Johnson

  • @ukwupdates3509
    @ukwupdates3509 Месяц назад

    Brilliant as always mate. Your knowledge is impressive, always look forward to your vids 👍

    • @zivguymoore974
      @zivguymoore974 28 дней назад

      @@ukwupdates3509 Do not be too impressed. Your Communist Antisemitic shenanigans destroy the lives of millions. ruclips.net/video/odPJdubKe0c/видео.htmlsi=-y-Af_AYCIQidqcl

  • @samkaplun
    @samkaplun Месяц назад

    I can't believe I only discovered your channel a couple months ago! I had the good fortune to go on a huge trip across southeastern Europe in May and June, and I took this train both ways. As you can imagine, the heat was even worse in June and I don't recommend taking the train towards Bucharest simply because the border crossing and wheel change happen in the middle of the night (we were awake from 3-6 AM) but it was such a cool experience. As a Western (I'm from Canada) socialist who is trying to understand the good, the bad, and the in-between of socialist states firsthand, your videos and nuanced commentary are exactly what I've been looking for. Keep up the amazing work! P.S., if you find yourself in Dubrovnik, Croatia, I strongly, strongly recommend the Red History Museum. It's fantastic.

  • @yts4106
    @yts4106 Месяц назад

    12:45 the Riga TV Tower is actually EU's tallest structure.

  • @norsegolf76
    @norsegolf76 Месяц назад

    Awesome video as always. I still can't believe you don't get more views! I was in Riga a couple of years ago, and really enjoyed the Science Academy. So run down and Soviet, and then there's the view. Not sure I found the "bus station" outside a high point, but oh well. Btw, you should go to Grūtas Park near Druskininkai in southern Lithuania. So much Sovietness in one place!

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 8 часов назад

      Please help to amplify the channel if you can. I'm not really sure what the key is to getting more views, but I do hope it can make a breakthrough in the coming year. :) Thanks for all your support and the comments!

  • @tonygarea7925
    @tonygarea7925 Месяц назад

    I am glad to have found your channel.

  • @basedcomrade1595
    @basedcomrade1595 Месяц назад

    I'm surprised at how much ex-communist stuff you can get there! Maybe when I go to Albania, I'll get that Hoxha mug or one of those caps

  • @subzero0114
    @subzero0114 Месяц назад

    Well you were one of the last guests in the hotel as it is now being demolished

  • @tonygarea7925
    @tonygarea7925 Месяц назад

    Nice song at the end. Can you link to the full version?

  • @SabrageShow
    @SabrageShow Месяц назад

    The only important thing is that you can trace the modern border of Kazakhstan since 1465 (15th century), when 2 khans Kerey and Zhanibek united different tribes and formed one state (khanate) called the Kazakh Khanate! In 15 century! And that is a fact. The Kazakhs consist and always consisted of 3 main tribes (the older in the south/southwest, the middle central/northern and the younger west/northwest). However, if you are not historians, If you are ordinary chauvinists, you can stop reading here. If you really read a lot and can tell the difference between the truth and the Soviet dumb manual, read everything down below. In the 1760s, when we weakened from constant attacks from the Dzungars (modern territory of Mongolia), we were forcibly annexed to the Russian Empire. Also in 1916-17 there were many uprisings. However, unfortunately, we lost this war, since all the opinion leaders, all literate people such as political scientists, philosophers, writers, Stalin tortured and then cruelly executed, and all their followers. Accordingly, when the Soviet power came, there were no people left who would go against the government. Mostly women and children. The Kazakhs had led a nomadic lifestyle all their lives and could always live in abundance. Each Kazakh family in those years had a fortune of several herds of cattle. But after the arrival of the Soviets, they forcibly took away everything they had and this affected every family. In those terrible times, while Hollywood was being formed in America and the "ringing 20s", more than 70% of the population died in the Kazakh steppe from an artificially created famine. The 30 that remained alive survived as best they could, ate grass, steppe mice, and there were cases of cannibalism. Horrible times that my great-grandmother told me about with tears in her eyes. And throughout the existence of the USSR, we were called the Kazakh Autonomous Soviet Republic. Our grandparents lived through hard times, Moscow used us as much as it could, 500 000 young Kazakhs gave their lives in the name of victory over Nazi Germany, and we were still called an autonomy. All the minerals were pumped out of our land for 70 years, rivers and lakes were drained (like the Aral Sea) to redirect water resources to other regions, and all this was on orders from Moscow. This is our history... In brief... Today we are experiencing a second wind, after all the troubles that happened to our grandparents. Today we are one of the fastest developing countries in the world!

  • @evgenyshipovski4059
    @evgenyshipovski4059 Месяц назад

    Great Soviet Era, all nations lived together as one

    • @neversarium
      @neversarium Месяц назад

      Except r🐖ssians who were above all

  • @endouceurendouceur318
    @endouceurendouceur318 Месяц назад

    Totally wrong ! On your screen/title you put the name of the capital of Moldova - Kishinev / in RuSSian / / wich is not correct/.This is the correct form = Kishinău/Chișinău in Romanian - our official language /. Also on the same first screen you put the Lenin monument in Tiraspol and also the RuSSian flag of mafiosi Transnistria. No problems, you can do whatever you want, but to be correct - in this case you must put there the name - Tiraspol + Lenin monument +plus Russian flag of Transnistria. Consult the wiki and you will find our Moldovan flag, the name of our capital, etc. Also, we are not in Russian speaking world/ RuSSki Mir. Yes, we have a kind of RuSSian speaking minority - 15 % only and also Gagauz-Turkish population - 5 % who enjoy speaking also Russian. The rest of the population- 80 % is Romanian/ Moldavian / speaking population. We want to escape RuSSian occupation and influence by Re-Uniting with our historical motherland- România/EU. Ready to provide you more information, if need it.

  • @Злобныйчеловек-о3р

    Thanks a lot for the video. Almaty one is the most beautiful city in the world.

  • @DamirUlovec
    @DamirUlovec 2 месяца назад

    You missed so much of Novi Sad's life and people, come back later. :)

  • @SKV-q5l
    @SKV-q5l 2 месяца назад

    At the beginning, I felt very strange that this train is not like the high-speed trains from China, and I wondered why the high-speed trains from China could be that slow. Chinese high-speed trains can reach 350 kilometers per hour, which is really impressive, but this train can only go 200 kilometers per hour, which is too slow. Then I know that this is not a Chinese train. Chinese high-speed trains will arrive soon, and then friends from Serbia and Hungary will be able to experience what a real high-speed train is like. I'm really looking forward to it!

  • @arnie4923
    @arnie4923 2 месяца назад

    OMG the video is so great. You really made a lot of research. I appreciate that a lot, because there is no much content in english about soviet heritage in Almaty. I think Almaty had one of the most unique architecture in whole of the USSR, due to the fact that this was the only big earthquake active city in the Soviet union, and also Kunaev’s dream was to make Almaty the best place, he brought a lot of projects to make Almaty such a unique city

  • @rayandanyaanime
    @rayandanyaanime 2 месяца назад

    So nice to see something positive coming from our country for a change :) The name of the train is SOKO which means 'falcon'

  • @KumarNaman
    @KumarNaman 2 месяца назад

    Thank you ❤ Great video ☭

  • @ebermtheburn
    @ebermtheburn 3 месяца назад

    One of my favorite places in Berlin!

  • @atomov
    @atomov 3 месяца назад

    Mate, thank you for this heartbreaking video. Well done!

  • @DaddlerTheDalek
    @DaddlerTheDalek 3 месяца назад

    interesting.

  • @dusanissimus
    @dusanissimus 3 месяца назад

    Fun fact: even when we still had visas to China, the fee for them was $3.

  • @hahulin7052
    @hahulin7052 3 месяца назад

    Что тебя испугало при переходе между вагонами ?😂 Ничего там страшного нет.

  • @emilkarpo
    @emilkarpo 3 месяца назад

    I'll be honest with you dumb f$ck, its a pretty normal train. I first took it from Bucharest to Kishinev back in 2013, my first international travel in 30 years. I managed it, checked my check boxes for " Soviet Trains" spend a week in Kishinev and then headed to Tiraspol. Since then I've taken that train once or twice a year until covid as a traveler including taking an apartment in Tiraspol just to relax, the same in Bucharest. Why oversell this train? Attract people that don't understand they are traveling to a very traditional Orthodox Christian part of the world.

  • @_Worldmapper_
    @_Worldmapper_ 3 месяца назад

    In your dream Uzbekistan was Timurid empire

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 3 месяца назад

      @@_Worldmapper_ Not sure what this comment means. Uzbekistan was given its current shape, structure, etc due to Soviet power. Whatever 'I dream'' is completely inconsequential. I don't dream - I deal with facts.

    • @_Worldmapper_
      @_Worldmapper_ 3 месяца назад

      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 Putin said Russia would turn to Ussr He wants to send the Army and the young generation of Central Asians to fight with Us and Nato We will never fight for you We don't need your rule We can live without you The only problem is that Russia Cancer of the World Everyone hates you because your government wants to control the world

  • @vadimusenco5829
    @vadimusenco5829 3 месяца назад

    Вот куда вы денетесь без русского языка , даже в этом поезде едущим в Румынию иностранцы говорят на русском .

  • @MrNikita
    @MrNikita 3 месяца назад

    China is collaborating on another destination to Subotica (and later to Budapest), but through Novi Sad. Here on video are swiss made stadlers and the track was built by Serbia and partially by Russian Railways

  • @simonf8902
    @simonf8902 3 месяца назад

    Back to the Cold War.

  • @boholanasvlog4185
    @boholanasvlog4185 3 месяца назад

    Thanks for this video I’m thinking of doing this in October.

  • @bluetrane8052
    @bluetrane8052 3 месяца назад

    The train is a Swiss made Stadler intercity/regional train, very good and confortable train, but by no means a high-speed train. The "reviewer" is a genuine je*k. The Chinese tourist I regularly meet on this train from Kloten Airport are all amazed on how comfy and silent this train is.Tells a lot about Chinese regional trains :)

  • @karlis_k
    @karlis_k 3 месяца назад

    Soy boy from US try to teach victims to love occupiers? I wish you to live in USSR as I do. You will cry as little girl after one week.

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 3 месяца назад

      I don't fuck with soy. It's ultimately not to my liking. You forgot to mention that I'm also Finnish. I thought you watched the episode, but evidently not. I'm going to assume you also meant that you 'lived' in the USSR and not that you currently do, as that would imply that you have a mental derangement that makes you think we are somehow at least back in the early 1990s. Speaking of which, that means you must be well into your 40s. Grow up and stop using internet language only kids understand.

    • @karlis_k
      @karlis_k 3 месяца назад

      @@RevolutionaryRoads1984 Soy boy, I am 45, so Yes I was born in USSR and my parents was “lucky” to live all USSR period. Please go to North Korea, and do not come back. You will be happy to experience real communism (cuche) as it was when Stalin rules, or go to Cuba, for authentic late USSR.

  • @joaovitorteixeirabento
    @joaovitorteixeirabento 4 месяца назад

    Yeah man, invading a sovereign country, deporting the population of two whole cities (Narva and Sillamäe), settling ethnic russians there is definately not invasion and occupation, it was not colonization, it was definately "class struggle". Come on man, not even you believe the bull**** you talk.

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 3 месяца назад

      It's not a question of what I 'believe'. It's a question of what the available historical data shows us. I'm not guided by some sort of emotional reaction. I very well could be. After all, my grandfather fought with the Finnish army and was shot in the head by a Red Army soldier during the war, just barely surviving. That's irrelevant to trying to sort truth from facts, however, about the reality of what was happening in Europe at the time. I think it's interesting that you mention 'sovereignty'. Again, there could be no real question of this among any country on the continent at the time, not with the struggle between two irreconcilable social systems (big capital never allows for sovereignty, after all), and then the advance of fascism. In terms of the deportations, that's actually one of the most illustrative ways that we can see that this was really a class-based praxis on behalf of the USSR. That being said, I don't defend the deportations. I've given expression to this in my films from Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. The repression and deportations were often crude and decided on in a very mechanical way. Crimes were committed, and the Soviet leadership was right in trying to come to terms with this in later decades. However, it's clear that the motivation was NOT racial or organsied along ethnic lines, and was rooted in a desire to continue to advance the construction of socialism. How many ethnic Russians were also swept up in this? Even in Estonia itself, we can see that almost every Russian cultural association or administration was then closed by the new Soviet administration - not because they were Russian, but because they represented a social and economic order that was being fought against. It's convenient for bourgeois historiography to try to paint the Soviet and Nazi regimes as twin dictatorships. The reality, however, is that the two could not be more diametrically opposed.

  • @mathiaslambing9112
    @mathiaslambing9112 4 месяца назад

    Some things where you were wrong or where wording was weird. 1. 1:09 When you said "Valentines day law", the Estonians fought together with the Germans, hoping that independence could be won back and that the allies would help against the USSR. (They didnt because they feared for another war) 2. 2:51 There was no such war in Estonia as in Finland or others. There was no class war or civil war, because there were very few Reds in Estonia. It was a war between the USSR and the Republic of Estonia. 3. 3:20 At first, the UK helped, because country was just 2 weeks old. And at first they didnt even want to help us. But already in spring of 1919, Estonia was self-sufficient. And the war was for independence for the Estonians. 4. 4:26 Do you really not know history? In Estonia, there were Vapsis, but they did not have any racist ideology, companies were not nationalized, etc. This was to stabilize the country and ensure nationalism. And they don't even get to power. The president did come to power, but he was authoritarian, not totalitarian. And he was not a dictator like in other European countries, but he also wanted to keep stability and the nation alive. He was not FASCIST. 5. 5:30 The way the USSR army occupied Estonia was that an agreement was made with Germany, where the USSR would take Estonia and other countries, Soviet soldiers came to Estonia, a coup d'état was made, unfair elections were organized, and then they said that Estonia voluntarily joined the Soviet Union. 6. 5:34 These Bolsheviks were themselves Russians from Russia, not Estonians, because there were very few communists or fascists. 7. 6:38 These Soviet symbols are everywhere because we have a thing called "heritage protection" that protects historical buildings like the old town. They are everywhere in Estonia. 8. 6:49 This symbol of the 1905 revolution is for those fallen civilians. 9. 8:57 This "representation of hundreds of nationalities" is greatly exaggerated. At that time there was a cruel Russification, where nationalism had nothing to do with it. 10. 9:11 How it was not an occupation. The occupation started when elections were held where the people had no business and the new puppet government announced the accession under force and pressure. Tens of thousands of people were deported, tens of thousands died. The Estonian SSR couldng decide anything, but all decisions came from Moscow. There was cultural repression, political repression, etc. 11. 10:45 Again you claim that it was a civil war. All communists in Estonia were either sent to Russia or killed by the Germans or killed by Finnish volunteers. When Soviet Russia attacked Estonia, they tried to pretend it was a civil war between whites and reds. But in reality, Russia just brutally attacked Estonia. They had no support from anywhere, and if you have something to say, please do so. 12. 12:29 This maarjamäe memorial is covered with a fence because it is dangerous to decay. Why do you think people don't go there? 13. 14:50 The sentence is one-sided by žukov

  • @ntokozosibanyoni1421
    @ntokozosibanyoni1421 4 месяца назад

    If you're an Estonian, I don't care if you're a right-wing imbecile or an apolitical liberal. Watch the Documentary "Soviet Storm" and bare witness the heroic resistance of the Soviet people, including (I would imagine) Estonian Communists who didn't collaborate with the Nazis. The workers of the world will always love the USSR.

  • @ntokozosibanyoni1421
    @ntokozosibanyoni1421 4 месяца назад

    Not surprising at all.

  • @norsegolf76
    @norsegolf76 4 месяца назад

    Once again, I can't believe these videos of yours don't have more views.... So interesting, so well made! Can't wait to see more. 👏👏

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 4 месяца назад

      Thanks! I'm sure the views will pick up gradually over the coming months and years.

  • @thomkane6787
    @thomkane6787 4 месяца назад

    It is utterly shameful how the baltic countries, Ukraine and other former soviet states/ satellite states try to re-write history solely to be as anti-socialist as possible. These countries wouldn't exist today without the Red Army and the Soviet Union

  • @narglefargle
    @narglefargle 4 месяца назад

    Good luck trying to convince your old classmates from A*******y that the British and American heads of state during WW2 were anything other than raging bigots. An honest debate could happen here, though. Who was the bigger bigot: FDR or Churchill?

    • @narglefargle
      @narglefargle 4 месяца назад

      But for real? Everyone deserves self-determination. I hope everyone in Ukraine soon enjoys a life free of worry, danger, or turmoil. I'll say the same for people who live anywhere else, like Chechnya, Kosovo, Taiwan, or Seattle.

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 4 месяца назад

      That's an interesting point about FDR. There's no doubt that his anti-Semitic views contributed to the deaths of countless Jews that could have been avoided as Holocaust rescue plans were abandoned. Not to mention the deportation policies he put into place toward Mexican Americans (we obviously have not come far on that issue in the U.S.). What else am I missing?

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 4 месяца назад

      @@narglefargle I support the inherent right of peoples to meaningful self-determination. It's interesting to see in the age of imperialism, however, that 'self-determination' is often promoted by the imperial powers for their own geo-strategic interests, to set up vassal states that are nominally 'independent' but are tied in every conceivable way to the empire. As a genuine principle, though, I agree with you. Although, I must ask: does this mean you are spearheading the creation of a Republic of Seattle? 🤣

    • @narglefargle
      @narglefargle 4 месяца назад

      @@RevolutionaryRoads1984 Only if a strong majority of all my neighbors support it. Otherwise, whatever yields the best results for everyone while doing the least harm is what I'm for, regardless of my personal preferences.

  • @Ivanisasi
    @Ivanisasi 4 месяца назад

    Certified baltic moment

  • @Richiegiboy
    @Richiegiboy 4 месяца назад

    Churchill never admired Hitler get your facts right your the one talking shit.

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 4 месяца назад

      He quite literally spoke of his admiration for Hitler, and also noted his "courage and perserverance". It's a matter of historical record.

    • @Richiegiboy
      @Richiegiboy 4 месяца назад

      Where is it find it for me and I’ll look it up .He was quoted from straight when he become leader in Germany off sorting him straight out if they had listened to people like Churchill and a few others maybe WWll could of been avoided

    • @RevolutionaryRoads1984
      @RevolutionaryRoads1984 4 месяца назад

      @@Richiegiboy There are many sources for his praise of Hitler. I will link one below. He also spoke very favourably about Mussolini as having rendered an important service to the world in the fight against communism. jacobin.com/2018/01/winston-churchill-british-empire-colonialism

    • @Richiegiboy
      @Richiegiboy 4 месяца назад

      He liked Mussolini in the EARLY days of his rule ,certainly not later on .And he was an imperialist no question about that but so was a hell of a lot of other people in those days