Видео

Since she was doing the other adlibs, I assume it was also hers

There are certain parts where it’s clearly not Tzuyu, such as the ad-libs "Ey" and "Lalala," particularly noticeable during the chorus. All of the adlibs sound like they were done by one person.

@@AnDistribution the "no way" and the "lalalalala" sound like tzuyu to me. Plus how can you say that they don't but they assign the "hey" to her?

@@simoneromano6147 The "Hey" is louder than the other adlibs. It's possible that it's Tzuyu layered with Sophiya. Sophiya is just really active in this song it even sounds similar to her background vocals here.

Tzuyu got adlibs in a few songs like catch a wave, polish, etc.

Wow, really?

he probably uses the dolby atmos stems and extracted the vocals using any other vocal separators e.g Audacity

They still sound like Chaeyoung to me.

@@CorrectLineDistribution of course sounds like Chae, but the accent not from her, for me is Melanie.

@@idk-nn5tf It can't be different since it the same voice. It could only be either the 2 for both adlib

@@AnDistribution ohh

@@Wish011 It'll possibly be the last in the album

I think the "uh" do sounds like Chae but the "yeah" kinda doesn't

I agree, with his filters both of them are pretty Chae to me

The uh always sounds like chae to me but the yeah not sure

I'm still thinking if I'm gonna do SSD, not sure about DCMA cause I never liked that song 😩

@@AnDistribution awwww I hope u can make them both for the sake of the album. But if u really don't want, I respect ur decision

​@@AnDistributiondo not FINISH DCMA it will be a gift for me if you dont🥰

@@idk-nn5tf I'll ignore it for a day 👀

@@AnDistribution im confuseddd i would love to see dcma and ssd, does this mean you’re making them or not?

@@Kpop_Thinghz Other than the "yeah yeah" there's no other mistake, is it?

@@AnDistribution Yes , in DDP All the ohh are momo

​@@AnDistribution Checking the distribution OMT i think Its all right 🤦🤦🤦 My bad

Not even close to Momo imo

@@Oliver-uz1fsThen Who's LD is the most accurate? I think almost all LD channels count that adlib as Momo

​@@user-xt1yw6lt8f It's defo Dahyun

@@AnDistribution Then DDP's LD is the most accurate?

@@user-xt1yw6lt8f I think so, but they did make a mistake labeling the "yeah yeah" cause it doesn't sound like Momo

no one asked

@@redloona1085 and no one asked for your comment as well

@@redloona1085There’s literally no point to be rude and toxic

Me with Chae in remember when we were kids

Wait have they sung this live?

"Cause I need you~ hey~ hey"

@@lukec2129 I have all audio of Elley's bg vocals, harmonies and ad-libs and she doesn't have any layer on that part

@@AnDistribution i just mean she could be mixed with her in the lead vocals for some reason bc they dont particularly sound 100% like a member

@@lukec2129 drive.google.com/file/d/1F549rVcbsVCvAwyLYSTdnA_ECjfe4pqw/view?usp=drivesdk You can listen to Elley's all vocals here

It doesn't even sound like her

Actually i agree with that too.

I mean the fact that Chae only had a verse while everyone else has either two lines or in SaMoTzu case, one line and something else, and Dahyun a line and a repeated line in the post chorus, considering how often DaChae get paired together, it just made sense to the post chorus to be supposedly Chae, turns out is no one in twice for some reason

Also this video proofs better as well how in studio is Nayeon too ruclips.net/video/U1RUQozXQcw/видео.htmlsi=MCasgkCDFw83CFCi

@@Oliver-uz1fs Yes it would make sense structurally, however is still pointless to assume cause Twice's all lines parts are rarely sung by any other member with the exception of Nahyo, it's mostly the background vocalist, unfortunately though 😑

No, that's clear all Chae

​@@snsdgivemetwicetogfriendfr9137 is a joke

Thankfully Sophiya isn't anywhere to be found in LF, is Yeonseo

Could be a lot of reasons maybe the girls don't have time to record all the layers of a song, maybe twice is not commited in terms fo recording but rather choose to put more time in the performance, maybe with a group so experimented it could be difficult to get some members do some things, maybe it's producers choice maybe they like the vibe given by the bg vocalists

Also i wanted to point out that a lot of RUclips song production creators and analysts of recording love to analyse twice songs, you can find a lot of people who really like to analyze twice music but since late 2017 twice barely records bg vocals, most of the times are the bg vocalists doing those beautiful harmonies and things, i'm not saying anything but i find really interesting that people is interested so much in a group who barely have participation in the recording (excluding they are songwriters) I want to clarify it's not bad to participate less in the recording production, at the end of the day they record the main vocals who everyone love it

She is the credited background vocalist for this song (According to the Album Credits)

The 10th member

The One More Time thing isn't 100% confirmed tho

​@@corneiz_bp_tw8240But in fact is like that , everyone saw It and all the line diatributions are taking chae first

@@Kpop_Thinghz all of that is based off of ONE vocal analysis video from a channel who already questioned Dahyun's lines before

@@corneiz_bp_tw8240 Just because some questionable lines happen to involve Dahyun it doesn't take away credibility, most of those times it also affects JeongMiTzu

You're taking line distributions way too serious, also is not like Chaeyoung herself pointed to the producer with a gun and told them to not include Dahyun in the brige on purpouse, let's add to the fact that it just makes it even the grouping of MoSaChae and JeongMiDah to have the repeated chorus and a extra line

I agree, it's definitely Dahyun or Chae

But sophia did this in Brave too, I'm confused😂

@@Nahyo.Sophiya sounds a lot like them that’s why we tend to hear DubChaeng

@@kpopythings614fr, here sounds clearly Sophia than in other filters from others videos

@@DDP121 yes it’s definitely Sophiya

Take care of yourself, hopefully you're feeling better

​@@Oliver-uz1fs Thank u, I am feeling better now 🥰

​@@AnDistribution at least Chae slngs it in the live version

@@zuleta333nobody sing it in live, Dahyun lipsync in all choruses, Chaeyoung only lipsync in the last chorus and for the choreography Dahyun is center in 1st and 2nd choruses and Sana is the center in the last.

@@DDP121 my life is a lie 😭