Видео

Arafat turned down Bill Clintons peace plan

I definitely agree with Khalidi about the Hegelian angle. The modern world is a world of nationalism and the I/P conflict is a reflection of this. Moses Hess, the first proto-zionist (and arch frienemy of Karl Marx) was a major young hegelian thinker.

Beautiful documentary. I LOVE the Palestinians so much. In fact, I’ve become obsessed with their inner and outer beauty. I am so concerned about their safety. have something controversial to say. At this point- a geno-side is taking place. Israel and American are much too powerful, and Hamas and PLO don’t seem to have negotiating room against such evil empires. Wouldn’t it be okay to encourage the Palestinians to reconsider leaving occupied Palestinian? Why do I say this? Well, in the late 1600’s, my ancestors were expelled from Scotland by a rival clan from England after a hard battle, called border clan battles. My ancestors fled to Ireland and then America. Now, I’m a descendant and myself and my Mother and Grandfather have done well for ourselves. We are happy. I’m in America and I’ve met Palestinian refugees here who also are happy. Yes they long for their homeland, as refugees. But their children and grandchildren and great grandchildren will be successful here. I know we shouldn’t encourage refugees to leave their homeland. But imo, Israel politicians are a special breed of evil, akin to Nazis. They wield enormous power over the world as we can see. I don’t believe Palestinians and their supporters can overcome this evil. At the peril of the babies and children, this fight is happening. Do they still want to keep resisting even if they are all exterminated? Drawing the parallel between my ancestors who fled Scotland and the current Palestinians resisting against their colonizers, wouldn’t the Palestinians be more successful if they fled and rooted elsewhere, as sad as that would be?

The truth will eventually overcome the lies you spread, beginning with the fiction of the so called Palestinian people

Where are I get this song?

Disgusting how these people try to paint hateful bigots and terrorist supporters as peaceful and loving

Great poem. But clearly an Arab poem because they lost Islamic rule and privilege. It also displays THEIR entitlement to THEIR land, erasing everyone else. That is the legacy of colonial occupation for 900 years during which because of Islamic rule Arabs had higher social status in what was an aparthied rule by a State that commited massive genocidal attrocities during this very time period. Jerusalem ethnicities were quartered in separate districts and had separate rules and taxes. Now that was an apartheid state. But by the 1940's Jews were the majority over Arabs in Jerusalem, Ottoman Emire was falling. Arabs from elsewhere started to immigrate to Jerusalem in fear of losing Islamic control as the Turks increasingly needed European support and losing their grip over occupied lands.

Wait now. You are talking like only ethnic Arabs are pre Israel Palestinians. This is not true. Everyone in Palestine was a Palestinian all ethnic peoples there were Palestinians including Jews. 100 percent . Arabs were the majority but by 1948, they were not or at least less than 85 percent.

Was it called Palestine, and did it have boundaries? Was it on any Ottoman maps? You didn't say if your map denotes Palestine? The place name Palestine did not refer to Arabs. It referred to the Holy Land, for centuries. It referred to the land of the Jews , Samaritans, ancient and new. Not to Arab Palestine. It was not an official territory under Ottoman rule.

AJ+ offers remarkably brilliant investigative reporting; it is compelling, comprehensive and compassionate. The journalism here is that which is absent in so many western journalist franchises and thankfully, you educate. In the United States, nearly all but Democracy Now just pander propaganda.

CPS--maybe stop by your comments section every so often and delete misinformation and hate speech. I tried to take the trash out, but who am I, but a mere civilian with a RUclips account, sweeping up and paramecium and misc. ignorant gunk.

hello dear.. I am RUclips marketing, SEO & Facebook marketing expert.. Do you need any service. & grow your channel.Want to grow your channel?

Glorifying the murder of innocent people 'used as art'. wtf

Jew hating scum.

Well said. I am a Palestinian historian, speaker, and lecturer of Afro-Arab heritage with West and North African ancestry. This summarizes my history and area of study perfectly. My research is in African-American and Muslim history.❤

Thank you all for sharing, your work. ❤️🙏🏻✌🏻🇵🇸🇮🇱🌎🌍🌏💙💛🌻🇺🇦🇷🇺🇸🇸🇸🇩✌🏻

Fishman …. Is grossly inaccurate More like a lier

I really wonder why Said’s critically important relationship with the hugely influential musician and conductor Daniel Barenboim wasn’t mentioned, as really the only relationship he had which was directly addressing the issue of getting young Israeli and Arab musicians together to form the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, an organization Barenboim continued to be closely associated with until his recent illness. And through which they wished to show young Arabs and Jews that they could cooperate and work together to make music, in order to show that they were more alike than unlike. As a musician myself, I became aware of Said through that relationship, which I thought was incredibly important and provocative in the best way possible, except that Barenboim has been virulently attacked by very influential Israeli politicians. This didn’t stop him, because he knew he and Said were correct. How could this be completely ignored in this remembrance??

ألله مام الميرووووو الاعزمة والافخمة والدلوعة سوو ماتش سقلت موهبتي واثرتني باني اجد نفسي مع مين رفاقي واتعلم من حدارة ورؤساء اميركا وهوشي منه وتولستوي والمهاتما (غاندي) محرر الهند!!!!!! والامبراتور الفرنسي العزيم ( نابليون بونابارت)

ألله مام الميرووووو الاعزمة والافخمة والدلوعة سوو ماتش خليلية ويتعشا الهولي خلايلة.......

ألله مام الميرووووو الاعزمة والافخمة والدلوعة سوو ماتش خليلية ويتعشا الهولي خلايلة....... ( اهل الجمال والشقف والازكية وماشيين عالشرع)

Love u Dana from Amman

Andalusia and Israel are two territories taken back from Muslims. Islam thinks it's supreme among the world’s religions and Jews are not equal to Muslims under Islamic law. And yet they now have self determination, autonomy and control in their ancient homeland, a homeland once ruled by Muslims. 😂😂😂

There Will be MIROOOO JASSER ( BIRZEIT ANGEL) THE PALESTINIAN AMERICAN 2 BE as Head of STATE of Palestine 🇵🇸

I've never heard anyone deny the fact that a territory exists called Palestine. That's certainly not an argument I've ever heard from, really anyone. I've heard arguments that the name was forced upon the land by Romans, which is true I think. I've heard arguments that "Palestinian" was never an ethnicity. Certainly people lived in Palestine and knew the name of the place they lived. But Palestine was considered part of greater Syria and the communities were not considered separate ethnicities. No different than the people of Damascus being any less or more Syrian than the people of Homs. Separate regional communities of Greater Syria, which Palestine was a part of. But that doesn't make the people living in Palestine a different ethnicity than those living in the rest of Syria. So I'm not sure it's getting to the root of the dispute really. At least, this spends a lot of time trying to prove something that no one is denying. This isn't like the Kurds, or Druze, separate ethnic identities living in lands with a different identity. That was never the case for Palestinians. Samaritans were always Samaritans living in Palestine. Their ancestral homeland. Their ethnic identity was specifically situated within the TERRITORY called Palestine at that time. As is the Jewish identity. But they both had names for that land that predated "Palestine", not even connected to the construct of Palestine the Romans created. Being proud of a place doesn't make the people living in that place an entirely different ethnicity either. People can be proud of their city, trying to bring people to their city. People consider themselves New Yorkers, but NY is in America, so they are Americans. If NYC broke away from the rest of the US, they would have to either choose to become citizens of that new NYC national identity, or remain American and move elsewhere. The NY Times is called the NY Times. The NY Post is called the NY Post. The Washington Post is called the Washington Post...... they are all American. Does that somehow prove New Yorkers are a completely separate identity than the rest of Americans? People from all over the US work at the NY Times.... not just from NY. They are all American first before New Yorkers or Washingtonians. How do I know that? Because New Yorkers regularly move to other places in the US and people from all over the US move to NY. Long time New Yorkers, who's ancestors have lived their for generations, might consider themselves New Yorkers, but are still American. NY isn't a completely separate ethnic or national identity and neither was Palestine in the context of Greater Syria and the Ottoman Empire.

It seems very interesting. I'm going to buy it.

محلاكو، ومحلا البيت، بحبكو اشتقتلكو❤️

Free Palestine

Wonderful panel! Thanks for the organizers and the speakers.

Why don't you display the screen so that we may see what he is trying to show us ?

🇵🇸✌️

Thank you for posting this, and good luck with all your efforts.

Thank you!

I think it’s mind boggling that Israel can occupy 3+ MILLION people for decades, terrorize them and make their lives hell and they just get away with it ! Why in the year 2021 are Palestinians basically still crying out for their basic human rights ? The people of Gaza are literally in a open air prison for years and that’s scary! Israel needs to be held accountable it’s been too long. They hide behind this smoking mirrors of “antisemitism” , they just use that as a excuse to continue their reign of terror. Theres nothing Jewish about Zionism. Bottom line.

With US supporting Israel unfortunately nothing will change

Thank you Professor Khalidi, and congratulations too for being the first Edward Said Professor at Coulumbia.

Hello

Let’s convince UNESCO. Jordan has another monument. It will be as important as Petra or even more. There are interesting ruins and reliefs on the Black Desert, dated 8,500 years old. They can only be seen from planes, drones, satellites and helicopters. Archaeologists don't exactly know nowadays what they represent. These ruins really represent embryos of several species in different stages of development and will be able to shed light on the origin of the human being and our planet. When it will be officially confirmed by biologists, this discovery will be a delight for the eyes, shed light to the origin of humanity. Activate the subtitles in English: ruclips.net/video/rikVfTbX2Mo/видео.html It contains the documentation with the Jordanian authorities about this scientific and archaeological discovery

T H A N K Y O U !

These people get compensated for land they never owned. Outrageous.

excellent presentation ..particularly by Claus Kress

The interview starts at 07:00

Thank you.

Why is the focus so much on Palestine with other areas? When we supposedly solved the Jew problem with Hitler, we focused on wiping out Nazis rule. If you want to give any attention to the Palestinian cause, you need to address Zionist (Hitler minus 1) rule over the Palestinians.

interesting stuff. great work Mohanad