- Видео 75
- Просмотров 270 707
Andrew Donald
Добавлен 9 июл 2011
Kingfisher Aerial Survey
Fishing boat grounded off St Andrews and rescue of crew
Grounding and rescue of two crew from a St Andrews fishing boat. Video one of two.
Просмотров: 11 791
Видео
Fishing boat wreck off St Andrews Scotland
Просмотров 231 тыс.21 час назад
Wreck of fishing boat and rescue of two crew off St Andrews, Scotland.
Linview Linford Ringwood Hampshire
Просмотров 1 тыс.10 месяцев назад
A property adjoining the open New Forest
Deansfield Close for sale
Просмотров 1223 года назад
Romsey house for sale www.bensound.com/royalty-free-music
Hazelhurst Sway
Просмотров 3244 года назад
Hazelhurst Sway New Forest National Park A small country estate with 47 acres and two cottages
Western Downland School June 2020
Просмотров 3934 года назад
Western Downland School June 2020 reopening
Women's Team Racing Championship at Spinnaker Sailing Club
Просмотров 3545 лет назад
Women's Team Racing Championship at Spinnaker Sailing Club
To be fair I suppose the coastguards are now only trained in helping illegals in rubber boats not real situations
All the oilskin coast guard types looking on an it took a couple of chaps in wellingtons to show sense an save the poor chap
Not surprising, the coastguard teams are mostly just a bunch of elderly Walter Mitty types who are just there to get photos for their socials. I know, I used to be in one. They turn up at all sorts of scenes where they are not wanted and get in the way and the one time they’re actually needed they do this, nothing. The management encourage everything other than actual sea rescue. They spend most of their time inland interfering with police searches for missing people. Should be defunded, plenty of FRS around would do a better job. .
@@Steff-l6f 100% facts. As a former coastguard I agree completely. Most of my team were elderly Walter Mittys trying to live out some fantasy they never fulfilled in their younger days. Completely unfit for purpose and routinely a hindrance to any rescue or ongoing SAR mission by other services. Embarrassing and degrading for those few coastguards who were capable and desperately trying to whip it into shape. Glad I'm no longer associated with it and it was only a matter of time until a video like this emerged. Surprised it's taken so long to be honest as buffoonery of this nature is a daily event in the CG.
Andrew Donald, where's his troosers?
Absolute shambles!
Semoga kruw kapa speed boat nya selamat semua
Наши русские 🇷🇺 мужики уже давно бы зацепили веревками судно и вытащили вместе с рыбаками.А потом выпили за спасесенных и закусили бы рыбкой !!!❤ Наши умеют всё!
Oh poor Guy;!!
Позор этим модницам в оранжевых платьях!
This was painful to watch and a disgrace for the coastguard! Seems that nobody in the coastguard was willing to get their boots wet and were quite happy to stroll around looking important and leave the real rescue to the civilians! Quite shocking.
As somebody that has lived his whole life simply using my commonsense(having to) - I find this gobsmackingly shocking - shocking as everybody present seams to lack any sort of urgency and shocked how fundamentally stupid the so called professionals appear - terrible - not even a blanket to warm this chap up - staggering ! Well done the two guys that went in to help - commendable. I think I am right in saying that the ebbing tide just might have been a factor in this successful rescue.
I've just watched this again, those official rescuers with all their safety gear and helmets just standing around while a local gets in with no safety gear at all) tries to save the guys life Its not what you wear ( although that can help)it's your attitude that's key. seems these guys couldn't give a toss. There should be a ladder there in any case.
Has anyone got an update on the lads wellbeing?
quelles bandes de nul
These Coast Guard guys should step down-they are too old for the job. What a shambles! Four of them, and not one got wet. I couldn’t believe what I was seeing-they could hardly climb on the wall and just walked back and forth. It was a total disgrace. They put members of the public in danger, leaving them to do the rescuing instead. I really hope this is followed up with an inquiry, and the four members involved should be suspended and sacked. How brave those members of the public were, going into the water and risking their own lives. This could have gone horribly wrong. Thank God everyone made it out safely
What an utter disgrace!! Bloody coastguard only startd doing something when the fire brigade turned up!! 🤣🤣That poor man almost drowned due to thier inaction and incompetance.. well done to the lads working on the dock and in the area, you did a good thing there! 2 lives saved and no further injuries.... Well done to all involved! Except those who couldnt be bothered...
So whilst I am not claiming this was perfect let's actually correct some misconceptions from the armchair comments so far and do a bit of a reality check on this incident that only lasted 16 minutes. 1) RNLI - Weren't on scene so anyone who has made that comment might as well delete their comments 2) Coastguard don't rarely get involved in migrants - thats Border Force, who are full time paid and patrol the channel ( Nor do the RNLI unless there is an immediate threat to life - again that's done by Border force cutters) 2) Coastguard are volunteer members of the public who aren't sitting around at a coastguard station waiting for a call out. If you actually watch the video properly you will see they weren't even on scene when the video started ( they arrived just as the video started) and at that point, the locals had already fished one man out - (that's the man sitting on the wall taking his wet clothes off). 3) What actually happens when the coastguard gets called in the UK...someone calls 999 ( we have no idea when that was done here and WHAT information was given). Local CG volunteers get paged, and they get little more than a couple of lines of text describing the incident - in this instance probably something along the lines of " Fishing vessel in distress off the harbour arm" because at that point they are reliant on what information is given by the first informant. If anyone has listened to a 999 call - often the information is scant. The available volunteers then leave their lives and go to the CG station and collect the kit and vehicle and then proceed to scene. I don't know how far from the CG station this incident was, but I would imagine it would take at least 20 minutes for local members of the team to get to the station, get the vehicle out and get to the incident. This whole process can take up to 45 minutes to get anyone on scene depending how far away it is. In this video ( 3 minutes into the 16 minute video) only two members of the team had just arrived at that point not enough to set up a frame or a rope rescue system , and they may not even be a rope trained anyway - they might just be search trained. Also its highly possible that neither of them were OIC trained or a team leader - they could literally have been junior members of the team fresh out of training. When they arrived on scene they rightly ( although one should have been wearing a helmet, yes) went to establish what was actually going on. 4) By the time they get to the harbour wall,other people are already down with the casualty and I would imagine the one of them on the radio was speaking with the CG control room giving them an accurate picture of the scene and requesting the required additional resources. 5) 14 minutes and 30 seconds into the 16 minute video other members of the CG team arrive, fully equipped but by that time the second man is already up on the harbour wall. They arrive with the casualty care equipment ( first aid kit, blankets etc in the big red backpack) and then the video cuts out. 6) Anyone else in the video in "Hi vis" look like local tradesmen, fisherman and builders to me not SAR professionals. The whole video is only 16 minutes long, that's a pretty quick rescue......It would take the RNLI a good 20+ minutes to get to a scene like that, a helicopter probably 20 - 30 minutes by the time its lifted and got to scene. Armchair experts - just take a moment to think what would you do if you were sitting there right now eating breakfast, getting on with your life and you get a call out text on your mobile to a rescue like that....how long would it take you to get out of your house, drive the CG rescue station, get the vehicle out, then get to scene , get kitted up ( because you aren't sitting around in your PPE at home are you, and how long when you get there would it take you to establish what actually was happening and what you need to effect a rescue....if at that point you aren't at least 10 minutes into this 16 minute video then you have the ability to control time....
Incorrect PPE worn, all Coastguards are capable of getting a drysuit on in the first instance. Unfortunately this video displays a lack of scene assessment and control. If someone is new to the role they should hold back until more experienced people are on scene to make decisions. Members of the public will look to people turning up in uniform to take control and start doing something.
@@Sailingmanuk I agree with what a lot of you have said....but from the carpark without eyes on the scene those two quite possibly don't have any idea what is actually at the incident , and I'd put a fair wager on on them having been told by the control room to get eyes on an report back - which is what the video potentially shows. My point is that everyone here is very quick to judgement without any idea of the preamble of the incident and what information was available, and until those eyes are on ( apart from the lack of a helmet on one of them), they are in the correct PPE for being on the harbour wall and the rest of the team that turned up later into the incident ( by which time the casualty was pretty much out of the water) were in drysuits - which take a good few minutes to put on as well!
@@jcmadvisors whilst there are some excellent operators in the coastguard there is a disproportionately huge number of CROs that are severely unfit, incapable, elderly and have zero rescue impetus in them. A lot of old boys (and girls) are in it for the uniform and the kudos but deliver absolutely nothing to search and rescue. I speak from first hand experience.
Горе спасатели. Уволить за профессиональную непригодность. Woe to the rescuers. Fire them for professional incompetence.
I'm glad he's ok, but the emergency service needs some training and a heavy handed review. No medical kit, you know there's hypothermia and no one thought to remove their warm jacket and get him warming as soon as they got him up the rocks? Where's the Stokes basket or a stretcher? They could have walked him to shore with four guys. Citizens did more here than anyone. Even in my small city the EMT's (on a cold water port), has more sense than these guys.
Coast guard couldn’t do anything because of health and safety
Those two Coastguards should be Fired, All the gear and no idea, a pair of Fukwits..... Everyone else who was a part of this rescue God Bless you ❤
Surprised they didn’t stop for a tea break as well ,what a shambles.
What a pathetic bunch your rescue services are. Utterly atrocious incompetence on display!
Well done for filming this,it just shows the arsoles we employ to look after us
Great stuff lads, I wasn't aware of this occurrence but I was talking to one of the crew who is a very good friend of mine and he told me all about it, he's very badly bruised and lacerated. Thanks for a great job done you locals you should all be very proud in saving my pals life.
These Coast Guard guys should step down-they are too old for the job. What a shambles! Four of them, and not one got wet. I couldn’t believe what I was seeing-they could hardly climb on the wall and just walked back and forth. It was a total disgrace. They put members of the public in danger, leaving them to do the rescuing instead. I really hope this is followed up with an inquiry, and the four members involved should be suspended and sacked. How brave those members of the public were, going into the water and risking their own lives. This could have gone horribly wrong. Thank God everyone made it out safely
Thanks for upload , very interesting rescue.
I think they must have thought he or they . There was a second man by the wall in a distressed state they gave a coat to .Should not have been out to sea.. But You cannot just let people die . The two rescuers probably had hypothermia
Rescue crew on a Sunday Walk.
Hope it went better than it looks. CG wandering about doing nothing not even a observation when they drag him over the wall. No kit or anything. Goi g to be a creative report, but learn from video.
What kind of fisherman goes fishing with no pants on , just a T shirt & socks?.... 🤔Wandering just what he was really out there doing...🤪
Dozens of people stood there watching & shouting when the bloke is in 2 foot of water,and could easily have been pulled along the way towards the beach. Or as eventually happened, someone could have gone in to help.
Why not just bring him into the shore instead of up over the wall? This was a terrible rescue.
Now that's a "Wet Willy"...🥒💦.....😏
the poor guy left hanging there naked and even when he at last got housted up nobody covered the guy up...disgracefull.
This should be aired on national tv to show the bravery of those 2 men that saved that mans life. The rescue services on that matter must question their commitment.
The situation was chaotic and disappointing, reflecting an embarrassing incompetence from the SAR officers. Well done to the locals who fearlessly risked their lives while those SAR porkers with all the kit stood by and did nothing.
worst rescue i've ever seen in my life, done more damage to that man than the sea had done. shame
My tip. If youre in the water, being knocked against the sea wall or rocks, its, feet first if possible. I canoed a lot as a younger man.
A lot of standing around by other than just a few brave souls.
I am totally at a loss on this one. Well done the man that had the cranial capacity to risk his own safety to jump down to help that guy. As for the coast guard or whoever were "so called professionals" absolutely pathetic. I am no professional but, i would have tried to pull the guy along that sea wall, to where the waves were a lot shallower....instead of what they did. A BIG THANK YOU to the man WHO JUMPED DOWN and probably saved his life, AND THE 2ND man who helped him.
Should have just stayed in the boat😂😂
Was the second fisherman unable to stand at all🤔 Was he tangled in something at the start🤔
Fukn joke St Andrews over the back full of students Fukn about no comn sence
No helicopters in Scotland?🤔🤔
what a bunch of idiots
Embarrassing but boxes ticked
Helicopter should have been called, msns been in water to long.. he’s a big heavy man exhausted hypothermia no doubt . Pure dead weight need 4 men to stretcher him on land never mind crashing waves slippery underfoot
Aye well it would appear that SAR have changed priorities when it comes to hiring in recent years, RNLI being a good example. Lots of very polite people with nice accents that have done the training and don't say nasty things like those rufty tufty ex commercials they used to hire. Funnily enough the standard of rescue has gone down the swanny and i suspect it won't be too long before some of them get themselves in trouble if what i heard from a friend that pulled an idiot out the water just south of Montrose the other week is correct. An angled pull toward to seaward slip for that bloke wouldn't have done less damage rocks wise but would have enabled the outstanding local that got in to help to reach him and get him out much easier. Great result in the end, well done to those directly involved and documenting it, this will be a good training film.
What a farce the pair of coastguard guys should have just stayed at home doing their nails . They had no interest in helping out the poor guy in the water as they didn't want to get their blue overalls wet or dirty absolutely disgusting no thought for the guy in the water as they casually stroll around doing nothing it seems to me they just want to wear the uniform to pretend they are something they certainly aren't. Leaving everything to the locals to deal with it .They should not be in that job they do not deserve it they are an embarrassment to the rescue services the real men and women who are out there saving lives daily around our waters . These 2 guys are only in the job for a uniform they should be sent packing and let real men do their jobs. Ps hats of and respect to the locals and the guy who went in the water to save the casualty