- Видео 1
- Просмотров 889 646
Yubby Smith
Добавлен 28 май 2020
To Singapore, with Love (星国恋）full movie - banned in Singapore
"To Singapore, with Love (星国恋）was banned in Singapore for "undermining national security" in 2014.
From the film's website www.tosingaporewithlove.com:
Singapore political exiles, some of whom have not been home for 50 years, talk about the City of their dreams.
Director Tan Pin Pin 陈彬彬 attends a funeral in the hills of southern Thailand, a family reunion in Malaysia and goes for a drive through the English countryside, searching the world for the displaced souls of Singapore: different generations of Singaporean political exiles who have not been able to come home. Some have not returned for 50 years. They are now in their 60′s to 80′s. Some were activists, student leaders, others were car...
From the film's website www.tosingaporewithlove.com:
Singapore political exiles, some of whom have not been home for 50 years, talk about the City of their dreams.
Director Tan Pin Pin 陈彬彬 attends a funeral in the hills of southern Thailand, a family reunion in Malaysia and goes for a drive through the English countryside, searching the world for the displaced souls of Singapore: different generations of Singaporean political exiles who have not been able to come home. Some have not returned for 50 years. They are now in their 60′s to 80′s. Some were activists, student leaders, others were car...
Просмотров: 889 658
Why is it banned in sg tho?
"suspected" of being a communist. literally called comrade in his obituary lol good thing this trash"documentary" is banned
why is this banned in singapore?
These people were supported by Chinese Communist Party, and believed in Mao's radical ideology. They were trying to subvert Singapore government. If they have won, Singapore people would have been miserable, similar to North Korea people is going thru. Letting them return to Singapore probably is OK, but let's not forget the history. I am from Mainland China btw.
Tan Pin Pin really made one of the best documentaries in terms of Singapore's shady political history, I hope that all those who are still stuck overseas due to the autocratic government back then are brought home as soon as possible.
They should be allowed to return.
12JUN2024.....👍👍👍👍👍
to this day there are still 60% sheeple who do not know the dark underbelly and history of the PAP and continue to be pro-oppression by voting them in...
#LKY did not like communists !!
Obviously things never change and they are still talking about detention without trials ... The same problem cause the source of trouble maker still there. Lying, cheating, murdering ...
detention without trials violates rule of law, every accused deserves right to fair trial
Very moving, it should be made known to the rest of the world the other side of the self-imposed Utopian best in the world facade
😢❤
This is a great and moving documentary of regular people, who decided to take a stand in what they believed in for the country they love. Their are many stories like this one but are censored by those in power. This happening right now throughout Latin America by foreign dictators supported by US corporations. (Noam Chomsky)
31st June, there is no such date
她們能為了看不見、摸不著的信念付出了所有，因為她們對他人有大愛。
共產主義是人類有史以來最大的邪惡！ Communism is the biggest evil in human history ever!
Thank u to this wonderful doctor for helping the Palestinian people we thank her so much and will never forget
So, Lee is 11-12 with Soeharto
Very touching story indeed! Wish everyone in this world will be more broad minded, forgive and tolerate each other. As Lao Tse said: behave like sea, stay low (humble) and embrace every streams and rivers.
England is the worst place for Asians😂. The royal family hates Asians
Lee Kuan Yew banned the study of Chinese History and Languge in Singapore in 1970-90s.
I came here because CNA, since a lot of people commenting "Singapore Exile." And it's very interesting.
The Singapore leaders who made decision to force these ppl into exile has mistaken themselves as the "emperors" of Singapore. In their eyes, there can only be one version of Singapore and if your narrative is not within that version, then you are the enemy of the state.
Absolute power corrupts absolutely!
I didn't know there's a book about my uncle, Chin Peng. Must get a copy.
You mean the Secretary General Chin Peng of MCA?
@@felisalpha1534 I don't think he's ever associated with MCA. He's always been with CPM.
@@pt4822 Sorry typo. CPM. What I meant was "He's your uncle" ?
2nd time watching time, while the poor palestinians are being bombed yet again, immense respect for the lady surgeon. the world is not fair.
lets be real, ur life is much better out of SG
0:49 0:49 0:50
After watching your RUclips I feel sad for you and families for not able to come back. Singapore as a Singaporean. In those days government are very dictator and very scare of penetration from external forces destroying the country. I hope the future leadership will be transformed to be Democratic party and country...let's pray your wish is granted GBU
why didn't include amos yee
A good documentary. But i really hate it when the people kept saying "democracy", which is very much a western imperial term today. The west always use the pretext of "democracy" to invade, regime-change countries. It is always "democracy" vs "autocracy". There are no real democracies in this world, including the western countries.
Monopoly Power worked in Cambodia...so others are No Exception ....
I am a Malaysian Chinese. It's a big surprise for me that the government of such a modern and developed country, Singapore, still fear of allowing all these patriotic anak2 Singapura for returning to their motherland, even it's already more than half century!
LKY sacrificed his life to build up Singapore. Without doubt he was sincere and dedicated in his mission. Could those opposition leaders achieve what LKY achieved? Or were they merely doing their job of opposing for the sake of opposing, obstructing LKY's vision? To criticize is easy but to deliver takes more than sweat and tears.
you should remember that LKY was a opposition leader as well. so are you doubting LKY's vision when he was the opposition?
The deserted Chinese orphans , the Chinese Government also Taiwanese Government do not care them, they just used them!
It’s time to go forward with reconciliation. So many years has passed. This is a very painful chapter within our nation that we made to preserve our way of life. Thus, I believe that we should open the way to reconciliation.
God Bless those Singaporeans who wernt Sheep and Robots.Will there Stories remain in the Hearts of their Children and the Books they have written to Reveal the True Struggle of the History of Singapore.
in 1965, population of spore was 1.5 million. LKY needed to solve education, defence, housing, employemt, Infrastructure problem. Freedom and democracy couldn't solve these problem. Today, all the above had been solved, how many people will fight for freedom and democracy, (western style?) if 60 to 80% of population voted for PAP for the passed 50's years, don't these people don't like freedom and Democracy? my personal point of view: LKY and PAP had done a good job. I would't mind sacrifice couple of dozen people if I need to take care of 5 million people's livelihood. when a few poeple killed, It is a tragic. when a few hundred thousand people killed, it is just a figure! ---- Joseph Vissarionovich Stalin
The same as now in Taiwan 2023 ..
How come there are so many money laundering activities in a squeaky clean place?
Lots of cover Up ..
CIA demanded Singapore stop accepting US $ remittances from Cambodia... during early 2000 ..
This is totally unfounded. You should know that rioting is an offence.
I wished all exile in every country to return to the land of their birth. Leave politic in parliament. Its just a job. You go home as normal ppl to your family. Nobody should be exile b'cos of political reason. At the end of the day how rich or how poor; whichever party you believe in their ideology & voted for; what position or a beggar like Lazarus & the rich man all will die & return to the dust & you cannot bring your riches, political party & position with you. You are dust & nothing! Your eternity is define by God; heaven or hell; all your hidden secret will all be exposed. Live right, do good & walk humbly with the Lord. Owe no man anything but to love him; everything else you will be accountable to God. No religion? There is the law of God & heaven. So who will win?
Man: I think they would come and detained me in 2 weeks. Woman: I better marry you then, so I can visit you in prison. If that's not love I don't know what is. 4:39
PAP is the saviour of Singapore.Jai Shree Ram 🙏🙏🙏
😞😓😞😣😖😤😤😤😤
Why are the British always involved in making life miserable for others?
Long live Palestine!
Hmmm...interesting.
The thing is, if Singapore allow such a great length of freedom when it comes to speech, it won’t be able to evolve into such a powerhouse country
回来吧。时代已经不同了。
Freedom does not mean good in managing a country. Look at the US and what the freedom they preach got them into
I’m not a Singaporean, but I found this documentary an interesting one. One moment I found particularly heartwarming was 21:21 where the man speaks about children. The way his face lights up with his smile is just wonderful