India Ink
India Ink
  • Видео 8
  • Просмотров 258 906
भारत की ऊंची जातियां जाति जनगणना से क्यों डरती हैं?
भारत अपने नागरिको के बारे में हर किस्म के आंकड़े जमा करता है. सिवाए उन आकड़ों के जो उसके समाज की जड़ है: जाति।
1951 तक भारत में जाति-जनगणना होती थी। फिर उन आकड़ों में ऐसा क्या निकला जो-नेहरू से लेकर मोदी तक-हर नेता इसे छुपाना चाहता है?
इस वीडियो में हम समझाते हैं कि जनगणना भारतीय राजनीति और समाज को कैसे प्रभावित करती है - और क्यों जाति जनगणना की मांग आज एक बार फिर ज़ोर पकड़ रही है।
इंडिया इंक एक सार्वजनिक इतिहास परियोजना है जो भारतीय इतिहास के जटिल विचारों को सरल बनाती है। हमारा हर दावा अकादमिक प्रकाशनों पे आधारित है। कैप्शन के नीचे आप एक एक स्त्रोत देख सकतें है। indiaink.org
Sources:
1. Barrier, N. Gerald, and Kenneth Jones, eds. “Religious Identity and the Indian Census.” In The Census in Br...
Просмотров: 8 339

Видео

Why India's Upper Caste Minority is Scared of a Caste Census
Просмотров 30 тыс.2 года назад
India collects all kinds of data on its citizens - except the one thing that defines its society: caste. Caste data was part of the Indian census till 1950. What was so scary about this data that from Nehru to Modi - so many Indian leaders have tried so hard to cover it up? In this video, we explain how the census affects Indian politics and society - and why the demand for a caste census is on...
How Brahmins and the British Created India's Hindu Majority
Просмотров 98 тыс.2 года назад
When the 19th century began, no one was sure of who or what a Hindu was. But by the end of the 20th century, it seemed like the majority of India's population was Hindu since the beginning of time. This is the story of what happened in between... If you've enjoyed our work, support us by making a small contribution: pages.razorpay.com/pl_IIHnHKVzsBbeuY/view More info on the project at indiaink....
How Indian Politics Uses Hindu vs Muslim To Cover Up Caste
Просмотров 23 тыс.3 года назад
When India was about to be partitioned, one group of Muslims was trying to stop it. Why didn't the succeed? Well, it has something to do with a political dynamic that continues till today. In our fifth and penultimate episode of Past Continuous, we explore how Hindu-Muslim politics is used to hide deeper issues. India Ink is a public history project that simplifies complicated ideas from Indian...
How British Rule Made Some Indians Crazy Rich
Просмотров 17 тыс.3 года назад
Despite colonial rule being so bad, how did so many Indians get rich in that time? The answer is that colonialism wasn't the same experience for every community in India. In the fourth of episode of Past Continuous, we talk about the incredible inequality of colonial India and how that inequality continues till today. India Ink is a public history project that simplifies complicated ideas from ...
Why India Is Independent But Its Women Are Not
Просмотров 13 тыс.3 года назад
India was made in the image of a woman. And not just any woman. A goddess who embodies India’s culture & traditions - Bharat Mata. Why then are women second class citizens in today's India? In the third of episode of Past Continuous, we explore how the history of how the "modern Indian woman" was created. India Ink is a public history project that simplifies complicated ideas from Indian histor...
The “General Category” Is India’s Greatest Scam
Просмотров 51 тыс.3 года назад
In the previous episode of Past Continuous, we looked at how India's "middle class" is actually just a tiny group of upper caste elites. (Watch here: ruclips.net/video/ONtWahr8d1A/видео.html) In this episode, we explain how this group managed to "forget" their caste while converting their traditional caste privileges into success in the modern world. And we explore how this collective "forgetti...
Does The Indian Middle Class Really Exist?
Просмотров 20 тыс.3 года назад
The great Indian middle class is a myth. What we think of as the middle class is actually a tiny elite. This is their story - from their origins in colonial India to the present day. India Ink is a public history project that simplifies complicated ideas from Indian history that are relevant to today's debates. More at indiaink.org. Sources: 1. Quote from Colver: www.livemint.com/Companies/11EC...

Комментарии

  • @vb-uc3uy
    @vb-uc3uy День назад

    good job bro u clearly debunked some ass here

  • @srinivasarao-j9l
    @srinivasarao-j9l 2 дня назад

    Great Video. The Real problem is correctly explained.

  • @Mindful_moment_mm
    @Mindful_moment_mm 3 дня назад

    Colour of hand shows they have no idea about veda and Upanishads

  • @Proudhindu5555
    @Proudhindu5555 4 дня назад

    Propaganda 🤐🤐🤮🤮🤮🤮

  • @Mrigan.
    @Mrigan. 5 дней назад

    Once again, an attempt is being made to mislead those who don't read. I urge everyone to develop your own understanding. Remember, we live in a nation where 3,000 years ago, our sages discovered the best way of living. The rest of the world is still striving to find what we have known for millennia

  • @Jojohouse2003
    @Jojohouse2003 5 дней назад

    By this logic that you are putting on so don't you think that white people also benfited a lot and coloured people get so discriminted . if wanna cry ? Its cry cry harder but question is when its gonna end your victim card its alredy 78 years have been passed. Qouta in job qouta in universites seats exams form fees were waves off . gov provinding many subsides yojanas giving you all providing free houses , food . you guys are geting hell lot of benfits but still crying. 😂😂😂

  • @gobimurugesan2411
    @gobimurugesan2411 6 дней назад

    Isn't it everyone already knows that? Modern Hinduism is just Brahminism. In my community temple we sacrifice goats and pigs. I never seen this in any big temples that's comes under Hindu temples board

  • @thedevilmaycare6579
    @thedevilmaycare6579 9 дней назад

    Utter bullshit

  • @AbhijitZimare
    @AbhijitZimare 11 дней назад

    Upper castes want to hide the fact how much they have squeezed from the average Indian so that rest of India remains in this amnesia. They are scared that we will get to know about their privilege. They will lose their arguements on reservations.

  • @AbhijitZimare
    @AbhijitZimare 11 дней назад

    I dont understand why is it so easy to emphathise for women and not for non savarn / rest of India (aka Dalits aka SC/ST/OBC) while both have faced millenia of discrimination.

  • @AbhijitZimare
    @AbhijitZimare 11 дней назад

    Bhimrao Ambedkar is the nightmare Brahmins never imagined they would have to face since it was practically impossible for a dalit to achieve education let alone surpass every known Brahmin by leaps and miles to the extent they were mere peasants in his shadows. The repercussions of his work has shaken the ego of upper castes in India and they are in complete disbelief that people who used to clean their streets are now competing shoulder to shoulder.

  • @devkant9833
    @devkant9833 11 дней назад

    All hindus are Sanatan dharma

  • @MarcoBonechi
    @MarcoBonechi 12 дней назад

    Thank you for the education

  • @yeh2011
    @yeh2011 12 дней назад

    ll what an all the properganda hindu was not invented by any one it is a way of life

  • @devamjani8041
    @devamjani8041 13 дней назад

    Using romila thapar and d n jha as your sources really exposes you 😂 They are not even taken seriously by the supreme court. Anyway, this video is PURE PROPAGANDA, probably created by a chuslim. Here's the debunking :- 1) Yeah, the word Hindu is of foreign origin, but that doesn't matter because the Indian word for Hindu is "Sanatan Dharma" 2) Sanatan Dharma or Hinduism is NOT a religion, but a philosophy and a way of life. 3) If the word Hindu didn't exist before the 19th century, then why did Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj wanted to create a Hindvi Swarajya ? Who created our 1000s of years old temples like the Kailash Temple, the Brihadeshwara Temple, etc ? 4) There is NO such thing as a caste system in Hinduism, the caste system was a british colonial imposition that was used by them to divide people. India had Verna system and it was based on occupation and people would change their verna if they changed their occupation. 5) Hinduism is largely made up of the practices and cultures of what people today call "lower castes". That is why almost ALL ST, SC communities still worship the same Gods/Godesses as they have been worahipping since thousands of years. 6) The aryan theory has now long been debunked. And it was rejected by MOST Indian scholars whether they were Brahmins or from other communities, including Golvarkar, you are misquoting him and taking him out of context. 7) So many of our great empires were founded, ruled and administered by "lower caste". Examples include the Solankis of Gujarat, the Maurya Empire, the Ahoms, etc. 8) The Brahmins were some of the MOST important people in the fight against the british and the muslim colonisers before them. They played a critical role in creating the nation and a constitution that made sure that the injustices done to "lower caste" people is accounted for and gave them reservations. All the while the muslims demanded a separate nation and declared direct action day and massacred several Hindus, most from the "lower castes" in several massacres such as the Mopla massacre, the razakar massacres, etc. 9) ALL the muslim countries where Hindus lived, such as Afghanistan, pakistan, Iran, Tajikistan, Indonesia, etc, have been wiped out, killed or exiled. They didn't see who was "lower caste" and who was "uper caste". They simply killed them all. Now, there are virtually NO Hindus in Afghanistan, pakistan, maldives, etc and only a few percentage remain in Indonesia (2%), Bangladesh (6-7%), etc. There are SO many lies in this single video that i can just keep on going. In simple words, anti Hindu, anti Brahmin, islamic jihadist propaganda detected, opinion rejected.

    • @satyamindnectar7052
      @satyamindnectar7052 11 дней назад

      1) The word Hindu is persian adaptation of the term Sindhu 2) Sanatan Dharma or Hinduism is not mere/only a Religion but also Dharma 3) The word Hindu came to existence during Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj time and it mean Indian Culture and Indian Dharma Many Mystic use the term Turk Dharma and Hindu Dharma Turk Dharma = Islam Hindu Dharma = Vedic-Brahminism and it's various sects 4) Hinduism is Varna system and it is hereditary but many Shudra warlord did convert to Kshatriya Varna through donation to Brahmin It is more of political thing or change Varna 5) Hinduism is not made practise of so called lower caste, so called lower caste were also one of the higher caste who become lower caste due to politics or due to the occupation they choose Hinduism have the concept of worship of kuldevtas 6) Aryan migration is true and not only Brahmins are aryan, many non Brahmin jaatis have more steppe/aryan ancestry than Brahmin 7) So called lower caste were shudra but became Kshatriya which show Varna system working as class system not fixed This doesn't mean they are Shudra Kingdom 8) Brahmins are not homogenous people There are good Brahmins and bad Brahmins just like we found people in every jaatis

  • @SatyaJanta
    @SatyaJanta 15 дней назад

    Talk alot without fact!

  • @syedmaricar9946
    @syedmaricar9946 16 дней назад

    All todo with dominstion of other,? No holy country or anything,its all bullshit.

  • @TingTong2568
    @TingTong2568 18 дней назад

    Not so accurate narration on how Sanatana Dharma was formed and repackaged into the "Hindu" identity.

  • @Vath098
    @Vath098 19 дней назад

    India's Hindu majority and its religious traditions was created and sustained by Rishis who got divine wisdom from gods.

  • @srkchandrala1071
    @srkchandrala1071 20 дней назад

    There were no Mahabharat and Ramayana before. The British and Brahmins invented them. So, Patent of these two puranas belongs to UK. Appropriation and Hypocrisy at an entirely different level.

    • @Bhondhu_Hiran
      @Bhondhu_Hiran 20 дней назад

      I agree with video. But this point is wrong. There is whole Spitzer manuscript from 100bce to 100 ce which mention Maharashtra parvas. There are Gupta inscription which mention Maharashtra, its characters and 100000 shloks too. That's point is wrong

  • @rudrakumar8593
    @rudrakumar8593 21 день назад

    What bull shit you are talking you are talking about , it means we Brahmin are not native of this land , you are just spreading hate against my community , no matter how many exodus we Brahmins have faced after the independence you all are just spreading heat towards us , if you are this much scholar and know about the history why don't just give the details of all the books where it was written?? Spreading hate against us is not the way to achieve success, who the fuck believe in these western theories ask the Europeans about this , at the time of partition Sindhi's Brahmin were killed and then kashmiri pandits but you all can never accept a fucking simple thing that only only britishers were the ones who introduced caste system . If you would have spend this much time towards your studies you wouldn't have open this channel . Brahmins are the native of this land and this is the only truth which you are jealous?

    • @Bhondhu_Hiran
      @Bhondhu_Hiran 20 дней назад

      Criticism is not discriminate, also the video does not calls outsiders in any sense, he quoted what British thought. Any person who calls you outsiders or anything. I will condemn them. Bcz it's irrational to thing like this. But I agree with video about formation of hindu

  • @WonderOfU24
    @WonderOfU24 21 день назад

    This video is a product that only happens when you give an illiterate convertee internet and freedom of speech 😂.

  • @AdithiaKusno
    @AdithiaKusno Месяц назад

    Can you make a film review video on Netflix's Maharaj?

  • @funboy3536
    @funboy3536 Месяц назад

    Well you should make these type of videos in hindi as well your videos are eye opener

  • @surajitpaul921
    @surajitpaul921 Месяц назад

    Caste reservation kabhi khatam nahi hoga 😅😅😅

  • @pajeetsingh
    @pajeetsingh Месяц назад

    This video is definitely shadow banned.

  • @captsudhir6084
    @captsudhir6084 Месяц назад

    By reducing a civilization of thousands of years to just 300 years of history is blatant distortion of the truth. Our ancient seers of the Vedic ages, Rama, Krishna, the Pandavas, the Cholas, The Mauryas, the Guptas as well as our Rishis including Adi Shankara were very clear of who we were. Do better

  • @mrpotatohasabanana
    @mrpotatohasabanana Месяц назад

    Doesn't explain how few muslims were able to execute millions of deaths of hindus during partition and also why they rejected to join universities to join in offices during beitish period, why they have hogh crime rate against us, plus why they choose to keep people for marriage then jobs especially women who dont even work a lot. Muslims prioritising their religion is not our mistake neither we should ignore their collective hate towards us bcz they too have internal problems.

  • @vjyfit
    @vjyfit Месяц назад

    🤔so Brahmins were like Zionist? Small group of people who with their cunning took over total control while protecting their existence 👏🏽👏🏽

  • @MoNa-km6jq
    @MoNa-km6jq Месяц назад

    The study revealed in this report is eye opening. There can't be such a huge inequality among we Indians umless the discrimination is instutionalised and practiced for centuries. In a democratic state there is no place for such inequality.

  • @supasapien
    @supasapien Месяц назад

    Great Content bro! Keep it up.

  • @SuperLalababa
    @SuperLalababa Месяц назад

    Societal reform is dependent on reservations. That's the issue. Instead it should be based on elimination of caste and reforms should be on free and better quality education.

  • @ananthapadmanabhan6340
    @ananthapadmanabhan6340 Месяц назад

    Bro speaking facts

  • @blankname5177
    @blankname5177 Месяц назад

    I am originally from Bangladesh. This is amazing video. I wonder how caste playout in Bangladesh and in West Bengal.

  • @sumitshukla1
    @sumitshukla1 Месяц назад

    🤬

  • @blankname5177
    @blankname5177 Месяц назад

    ❤❤

  • @sorenutpal6091
    @sorenutpal6091 2 месяца назад

    Great analysis. Great video

  • @penoge
    @penoge 2 месяца назад

    Nonsense! Ghandi tried to keep India undivided but Muslims and Hindus wanted separate states.

  • @reginageorgetownuni
    @reginageorgetownuni 2 месяца назад

    General includes everyone: Muslims, Christians, Brahmins, Kshatriyas, Thakurs, etc etc. Anyone who is not SC, ST, OBC Hindu, is a "General". Brahmins are 3% of the population and should not be a source of anxiety for oppressed. Rich OBCs exploit Dalits. OBCs also exploit Brahmins 😂😂😂😂

  • @reginageorgetownuni
    @reginageorgetownuni 2 месяца назад

    "General category" does not enjoy any reservation. "UR" is "Unreserved" open to every applicant. General category only have access to 50% open seats. Obc have access to 50% open seats plus 27% reserved seats. Sc have access to 50% open seats and 15% reserved seats, st have access to 50% open seats and 7.5% reserved seats. General category student does not have access to any reserved seat. If an OBC/SC/ST candidate scores very well and gets the General cutoff, he will get general open seat. Naturally open category seats will be dominated by General candidates because they know they have access to less seats, so they will work hard to achieve a high rank. Meanwhile, reserved candidates tend to be complacent in their preparation because they know they will get a seat anyway.

  • @Maddy-vx7jp
    @Maddy-vx7jp 2 месяца назад

    Then what's a vegan? This is what happens when you lack knowledge and have the audacity to make videos when you have zero knowledge about something.

  • @Deshprem25.
    @Deshprem25. 2 месяца назад

    A fish ought not to listen to a heron about their protection.. Hindu should never trust on Muslim or Christians especially in religious term.why Muslim calls non Hindu as kaffir and tortures them,,, so Hindus are reduced to average 6 % in Pakistan, Bangladesh and afganistan... Hindus are brutally tortured ,killed , forcibly converted,raped , temples demolished. Why should we trust a European Christian who ate our picking food and later treacherously ruled us. They called Indians as dogs. A Britisher or any Christian has no rights to suggest a Hindu. How only 10 thousand Britishers ruled 400 millions Indian. By devide and rule policy... At first they set a false propaganda about maratha. To devide hindu they distort our novels,holy books. Manusmriti was distorted. So many fictional stories were written about Hindu culture. They emphasized Brahmins to control the Hindu community. They demolished Gurukul system and made Hindus illiterate. Britisher collected bribery Brahmins and started distorting by mistranslating our holy shlokas of novels. Britisher imposed distorted manusmriti in Hindu community. They imposed caste system. They emphasized untouchability. When Hindus got separated and hated each other in caste wise. Their mind diverted from Britisher humiliated ruling system. Britisher accelerated the conflicts in Hindu by adding great lie ,false theory known as Aryan invasion theory and so on. When Britisher saw hindus have been separated in caste basis, Christian missionaries came and collected lower caste peoples and it was easy to convert them. Now Britisher took turn on lower caste side and blamed Brahmins. Missionaries set false propaganda that Brahmins are real suppressor. That is still going on. . Britisher destroyed hindu enterprise, foreign trading and set monopoly in trade. Britisher forcibly planted cotton and opeium to get more profit. Billions of hindus died in British made femines by not planting food grains like rice,wheat.

  • @aparichit1211
    @aparichit1211 2 месяца назад

    wtf! Are you talking about in your pathetic video. Are mentally ill or what? You are assuming things by your own and making stories. This is totaaly shit.

  • @tonyb680
    @tonyb680 2 месяца назад

    Just as you generalising the Indian people I think your own interpretation is very very generic and a simplified version. I feel like you need to read a bit more and wider than what is available to you. Constantly challenge yourself and look from the opposite perspective before you form a views. Even then be prepared to accept your opinions may change when new information comes in.

  • @hethshah3570
    @hethshah3570 2 месяца назад

    Only a idiot can make a video like this on misleading facts , scholars like kabirdas , guru nanak have wrote about hinduism existing before the british

  • @hethshah3570
    @hethshah3570 2 месяца назад

    Not all general category students are rich and brahmins , pls stop this propaganda

  • @hethshah3570
    @hethshah3570 2 месяца назад

    He shows brahmins as a oppressors all the time , i am Not a brahmin still i don't think it is great to potray a brahmins are aggressive

    • @sarthak3441
      @sarthak3441 Месяц назад

      Alright got it.... Ur a chamar

  • @hethshah3570
    @hethshah3570 2 месяца назад

    Pls report this video as discriminatory video , it does not talk about misuse of reservations by rich people

  • @sunilzizou
    @sunilzizou 2 месяца назад

    Good video exposing the graded society of our country