Видео

I like how you also make Mrs Kim a better person. I don’t find Mrs Kim’s treatment of lane on the show cute or quirky. In fact I found it abusive at times

My question is…why did Palladino HATE Lane? Lol

Im glad you kept Gil lol

THIS IS SO GOOD

It's his sled 🛷

this video was confusing there was so much going on maybe its just me but your voice doesn't stand out from the background music and its distracting, good analysis tho

Henry would have been really good too. Both are so much better than the way it turned out.

I Love this! And i agree with a comment that was posted, that though we all hate when they change actors and we Love the original Dave, I’d rather them swap characters and continue Dave’s relationship soooooo much better, and it would be worth it to carry on this version you’ve created!!!!!

The editing and plotting is so good

This is amazing!! Keep up the good work!! the editing was so fun to watch.

I would loveee to see this. you came up with such an interesting storyline that's still true to the essence of the original series. i would love to see this play out in the current age and what type of shenanigans would ensue. seriously great work also with the editing (pleasee consider doing a part two)

this is crazy editing wow

I started crying when Mrs. Kim frantically reached out to Lane with the band she missed reviewing, a schedule of bands she should see, and ideas for publications to reach out to. Just started crying and couldn’t stop😭😭😭😭😂 Your Lane and Dave rewrite will forever be canon for me now and I honestly care less if she married her high school bf than that she actually got a job in the industry. It also creates a really really interesting parallel with Rory’s pursuit of journalism-it adds a new dimension to their friendship and would have sparked so many discussions about how they are/not similar as journalists, different reasons to pursue a career, and different ways to go about it. It would have added this whole new dimension to “female role model for girls,” which is so much of what the show felt like to a lot of us, at least until whenever Rory went off the rails. Like: it’s awesome if you love books and go to Yale but you don’t have to (and you don’t even have to have your first choice career) to *do something* and have an awesome life. I think the problem would have been writing your version so Lane was *willing* to get an actual job in the industry, since her initial attitude was kind of purist/go for broke/play or nothing. Anyway, thanks for this. It was the catharsis I didn’t know I needed. Justice for Lane! AND Mrs. Kim!

People focus on Dave and rightfully so but I LOVE the idea of her and Henry running into each other again at some point!

omg i’m SO happy your video appeared on my feed, loved your alternatives for Lane, the first one with Dave was my favorite and now that’ll be how it ended for her on my mind, THANK YOU, this was HEALING 😭😭🙏🩵🩵✨

i love your editing and this video!! justice for lane fr. i refuse to go along with the shitty ending the writers gave her

The carrying cactus part is realistic as you can bring plants through tsa

this is such a fantastic video! i really want to point out the editing - the sound effects and visuals are so simple and charming but i can tell you put a lot of thought into it!! and the storyline you wrote for lane and dave is so lovely, i feel like it filled a gap in my heart that was left bc of lane's treatment in canon

Lane & Dave was perfect for each other imo & the writers did Lane so dirty & hated how they did her (i dont really like zach either). This might be off topic maybe not but I also don't like how once a character did the deed they immediately get punished for it in some way besides Rory (which i just now noticed that Rory didn't have anything wrong when she did what i mean by that is when Lane had s3x immediately got pregnant same with Sookie, Paris didn't get accepted into college after she did it & thinking that's the reason she didn't get it which isn't the case). I don't want Lane to be together period so im not for that storyline.

i relate to the feeling of insecurity and thinking there is a right way to watch movies. being on the film analysis side of youtube and having letterboxd catalyses that feeling for sure. similarly to you i decided it’s okay to not see what other people see in art in general. it’s okay and only natural for everyone to be impacted differently. it makes me appreciate others takes that much more. when it comes to past lives i am in the camp of people who didn’t really get much out of it. i wasn‘t moved by nora and haesung‘s relationship whatsoever. i wasn’t convinced there was anything special between them. i felt a lack of depth in their shared experiences. arthur as a character also rubbed me the wrong way. he is married to nora for i don’t know how many years and yet it seemed like her meeting haesung was the first time arthur thought about her diasporic identity? there were many projections on her. arthur wanting to be enriched by her perspective shaped by her korean-american identity feels almost exploitative? he doesn’t want to know about her experience for the sake of knowing her but to make use out of it? it most definitely read as self-serving to me too. but i have yet to put what exactly makes him icky to me into words… thanks for another great video with your nuanced insights and beautiful editing 🌷

I love, love, love this editing ❤

Any rewrite is better than the original. For more rewrites 🎉🎉🎉 Edit: Your rewrites are very well put together, by the way 🌟🌟

After seeing Rory story ending in the time jump, the show loves to push the theme of full circle and repeating cycles. So, I wonder if they chose that for Lane lamely.

I'm wondering if the actor who played Dave is disappointed or if he feels guilty for what happened to Lane bcs of his leaving 😂

its not even that i dont like zack its just that hes soooo plain and unambitious.

Imo, the show has a bias towards the small town life or Stars Hollow in particular. That's why Rory ends up back there in the revival and is the real reason why Lane couldn't leave. The writers seem to want to show that sure, you could dream big and have ideals, but you're probably going to end up right where you started. Or maybe that's just my pessimistic read on the narrative.

they did her so dirty in every sense, like we all know zach and her don´t match at all... but at least they could´ve made a deeper slowburn connection to makes us at little bit more convinced on them or something. she should have either be single thriving within life with dreams and so , reconnected with henry cho or keep dave rygalski character bur recasting it .

I feel like what they did to lane is exactly what they ended up doing to sookie , get em married n prego , n appear whenever Lorelei's n rory's arc needs them to , of if they a need short episode side story

If Dave couldn't come back I wish Lane had ended up with Brian instead. They had much better chemistry and he was so sweet to her

It will forever upset me that they didn’t just recast Dave. Adam Brody is adorable and was perfect for the role, but there are plenty of adorkable dudes out there who could have been cast for the role. Stubbornly sticking to Adam and then destroying the OG vision for his character was dumb as hell.

THIS WAS SO COOL! From the concept to the execution, you did it flawlessly. Thank you <3 I would really want a "Why is Logan the best boyfriend" video, if that is possible someday :)

Your editing is fantastic! Great video. 🙂 I also like your alternative ending. It gives a more inspirational story to Lane.

I love all three storylines for Lane here. I really wish she and Dave would’ve ended up together. Hated her and Zach together. Hated the pregnancy immediately after their first time. I know with Dave it would’ve been better for both of them.

Your Dave storyline>>>

This is SO much better I want a reshoot!

I found the costume choices for Lane especially later in the series awful! Same awful sweaters. She’s supposed to be a rocker. Just doesn’t fit.

I miss Dave so much

The storyline with zack made no sense at all, but i really liked the way her relationship with her mom developed through out the process with her getting married and pregnant. It was so interesting to see how her mom also hides her life from her own mom who is buddhist. I liked how mrs kim tries to support lane throughout the pregnancy and after and i thought it was interesting how figuring out how to be a mom, lane kind of gets closer tu her mom and we can see how much she appreciates her. Eventhough she wants to raise her children differntly, she realises that her mom made a lot of sacrifices for her and wants to do the same thing

Your animations for this audio are just soooooo goooood 😮😮😮😮

As a key friend of Rory's growing up they should have integrated her more into the plot later in the show, it feels like they forgot about her. In the end I think Lane was more respectable than Rory anyway considering how she turned out and the more Rory socialised with Logan and more upper class crowds the more I felt she lost touch with her roots in Stars Hollow, which is probably why their friendship didn't develop much further

But the entire point of the show is “where you lead I will follow.” That the apple doesn’t fall too far from the tree. Lane’s story is a mother-daughter story. Just like Lorelei and Rory.

This is wonderful! Instant sub

I doubt Lane would have been a young mom.

This video is amazing! Love the graphics! Love the alternative storyline with Dave!! Well done!!!

Oh my God I absolutely adore this. Why wasn’t this real?

I honestly think Lane could’ve been single and travelled around as a substitute drummer until she does something else. I like the idea of the blog or her being in artist development. I think once Dave left the show that was a perfect time to have Lane go and explore the world and grow as a person outside of a romantic relationship or her relationship with her mom. She deserved to live her rock and roll dreams outside stars hollow.

They did her sooo dirty. I was DEVISTATED when she got pregnant

I’ve been saying this!! ❤

If they had to pick another love interest for Lane, Brian would have been a better choice. He was respectful to her mum, interested in her culture, considerate, wrote a song for her, and bass and drums are just a good combo. He's not an obvious pick for Lane but that only makes it more interesting. I think he was written off as a viable love interest because he's nerdy and Lane was stuck with an absolute loser when she had a great alternative right in front of her.

I'm just gonna go ahead and pretend that the: Lane + Dave living happily ever after and having successful music careers storyline really happened... I think that's what I've been doing subconsciously this whole time anyway 😅.