Видео

Thomas: Classic Edward: Classic Henry: *CLASSIC* Gordon: Both James: HiT Percy: Both (Slightly leaning towards Classic) Toby: *CLASSIC* Emily: *HiT*

This is a rather mediocre ranking and one biased of an overrated sing along, sadly.

No, they're not bad, stfu

Ngl the point switching sound effect in Gordon’s hit theme is addictive

Aw hell naw. Grown ass man making this.

Hit era music isn't bad, but I dont remember it at all, unlike the classic series where almost every song seems to be distinct and very memorable.

Emily's S7 theme is fine, but I've got a lot more nostalgia for Emily's 8-12 theme. It generally feels a lot more focused. 8-12 FEELS like Emily, y'know?

I'll always have a preference for Edward's classic theme. He's always been one of my most favourite characters, and classic era treats him so greatly. But the HiT theme for Edward is definitely one I enjoy more than most HiT music

Who the fudge made the hit era music

14:35 I don’t think I’ve *EVER* heard this song before this video! It’s so good!

This video is so well made. It was a pleasure watching it. 😊

Also is the island song emotional?

Why is it because of the owl?

The reason why Thomas’ theme in the classic era is because in season 3 - 7 they used different instruments compared to season 1 and 2

While I do prefer the classic themes, my favourite theme ever is Percy’s Hit theme

James has grumpy theme and a happy theme

I love James's theme song in the series 1 episode James and the troublesome trucks.

To me I prefer Gordon’s hit era theme more than his classic theme. It sounds more grand.

Jamie Turner as Thomas Ringo Starr as Edward, Henry, Trucks and Narrator George Carlin as Percy Ken Friedel as The Fat Controller Willie Rushton as Duck, Donald, Douglas, and Guard Michael Angelis as Gordon, James, and The Spiteful Brake Van

I Guess it depends on which era of Thomas you grew up I'm from the classic seasons 1-5 and all the classic music I just happened to see this video while I was listening to the Viaduct theme from season 2 but the hit music is fine just not my happy place.

You can just tell Robert had a good time composing for the HiT Era, Was just trying things to see what stuck, Which is debatable at times, Nonetheless, Nostalgia hits like a truck

Twight is more powerful then straight she was holding back

Thomas and Friends HiT themes are not that bad. It’s just the classic model series ones that hit hard

hit entertainment had a strange obsession with brass music

I’m down for either theme, in my opinion, James’ hit theme is better than his original one

I really love seasons 8-12 Thomas’ theme❤️

Well you deserve a sub and I think some people should encorperate some of Robert's music into there own compositions.

Yes

I really like Mike and Junior's music and it's memorable. When Robert Hartshorne took over his music is fine, and he has good character themes which I do like, but they are a hit and miss.

My favourite theme of the HiT era was Thomas' Branchline theme and is the one that gets stuck in my head the most. Not as catchy and bouncy as the original, but it gives me a happy feeling and is still quite a nice simple tune I also love Gordon's HiT era theme as it works really well in the context of Gordon. May not be the best theme out there, but it definitely sounds very big, very grand and very proud. Much like Gordon!

hit era music aint bad but it does not match classic series

most HiT era themes, ESPECIALLY emily and edaward's themes are sooo under rated

some of the lower placements are questionable, but most the A-S tear is fab

Not at all

I wonder if the newer characters should have Classic Themes.

I honestly like the hit era themes better but classic themes are as good as the hit era themes

please im BEGGING make more power and abilities analysis videos!!!

Henrys theme hits hard as hell in the original seasons (specifically season one and two)

My guess is that Mike & Junior's themes are more popular to recreate because the instruments (Jupiter/Proteus) are readily available on top of being more recognizable and nostalgic.

I remember watching this about a year and a half ago, but I haven’t watched it since until now.

I love how James' Hit theme starts with a fart

Please just as you highlighted starlight glimmers powers in a video, could you also do twilight sparkles.

I personally liked hearthshorne's music, but the classic themes tend to be more varied and come out on top.

For me, I would never call the Hit era music bad, I just prefer the classic ones

The Island Song feels like an 80s power ballad

16:34 you thought you were slick, eh?💀

I personally think The Island Song should have been #1

14:48 James had 2 variations, yes, but It was his triumphant theme and jazzy theme. The variation of James's theme you mentioned second was the same one as the first you mentioned. James's jazzy theme was more upbeat.

5:19 i recently rewatched the great discovery and was literally just thinking this!! definitely my favorite use of thomas’ hit theme in the series by a mile, it feels so triumphant and fits the scene perfectly (edit) 17:36 I’VE ALSO ALWAYS THOUGHT THIS EXACT SAME THING!!!!!

thats james classic traveling theme not his main theme