Видео

once the russians stole the gold, the war sort of 'fizzled out'

You spoke so fast there is no difference between normal and 00.75 speed 😂. Great video I am rewatching now 😂😂😂

10 out of ten

Living in Barcelona since 2013, and then visiting again last month, reinforced my perception of the failure of Barcelonian socialism. The people there are very arrogant. They have a horrific sense of entitlement to anything free and generally speaking they are lazy and uncreative. They protest for more free time and they do nothing with that free time to better themselves or their community. The banks are atrocious and will outright steal your money, regardless of your rights that money and amount of documentation. The socialism of Barcelona has made me antisocialist, even though I was probably a socialist for most of my life. Liberals tend to be unorganized and undisciplined and this this tends to make them ineffective. So their ideas tend to be short-lived, begging the question about the value of those ideas if they cannot be actualized and maintained. Now in 2024 citizens of Barcelona are actively protesting against their own tourism industry, which again speaks to their arrogance and entitlement because they don’t really have any other major source of income other than tourism basically strangling their own economy, but they feel entitled to do so. my perception of socialism and the extent to which it can be attributed to Marx is that it has no goal other than freedom for no purpose. People want more free time and they want more money and they want to be part owners of the businesses, but they have no idea how to run a business they have no goal of doing anything with the money once they have it and they have no idea of actually improving their societies or themselves.

I am sorry to say that history only very rarely provides a clear cut division between hero and villain. In the Spanish Civil was this is particularly the case. On the one hand was a horribly disorganised Republic defined by ferocious anti-Catholicism, inter Party conflict between Socialists, Marxists, Anarchists and Soviet Communists, and the sadistic presence of the Soviet secret Police. On the other was a brutal Fascistic-military dictatorship headed by Franco, one defined by the systematic use of torture and mass murder. Neither side is at all appealing or very heroic.

Mother anarchy loves her sons🚩🏴☠️🏴‍☠️💀💣

"he fancies himself as a mix of both lenin and makhno" that is INSANE😭😭

Napoleon and Hitler started their invasion in late June way too late to avoid General Winter.

The Russian offensives of 1914 were aimed to help saving Paris and the Western front - which they did. That main reason why they ended up disastrously is that they started without proper preparation, even before the Russian Army was fully mobilized. This is an important point unfortunately omitted in the video.

Los revolucionarios eran los anarquistas

Russia expected to and planned to replace it's standing Army of 4 to 5 million soldiers every 4 to 6 months during a high intensity conflict and do it more then once!

It was this blitzkrieg was meant to last a few hours, not a few years!

High mate,I'd like to say i enjoyed the vidio learn't some more of the battle my late father william forrester served with the 2/1st battlion infantry 16th brigade of the 6th division AIF in that battle he never said any thing other then they were the first one's into battle never spoke another word about it to any of us six kids he took it to the grave it must have been frightening bayonets draw tanks blasting away machine guns blurring "I think i know why he said nothing".

The Warsaw uprising was a perfect situation for the Soviet Union. Both Polish Patriots and Nazis died fighting and basically did the Soviets work for them.

Not a good sign that every source is broken or gone

❤

Hey very good video and analysis about Makhno.

Nazi Germany had help from Croatians ,Bulgarian ,and French soldiers and still lost 😞

One Russian soldier said when they invaded Germany all houses were full of food so why come to Russia to loot we had nothing like Germany True statement

Russia were fighting two fronts with Japan so Hitler taught it will be easy but he was wrong

Hitler big mistake he broke the agreement with Russia by invading Russia and Russia joining with the eagle and the lion Thank God 🙏

It just baffles me how everyone goes to war for Poland, yet Soviet Russia not only invaded Poland with Germany, and actually ended the war not to give Poland political sovereignty until the 1990’s. 😂

When was this film made, like 2014/15? There is no mention of the full scale invasion by russia. Also, right wing nationalists are NOT dominating the political landscape of Ukraine today. And that figure Mosgovoi has been dead since 2015, presumably killed by his russian overlords he must have gotten in the way of.

As a middle aged African military history Geek, nothing exasperates me more than this almost fanatic drooling over the German military of WW2 especially by white young men and boys. Trust me, I get it, its efficiency and appearance of strength is intoxicating, even for me who is black and easily a target for this ideology. I'm glad someone is at least trying to tell these kids how evil these people were...

Hey, very good video, thank you! I'm a history student and i wanted to write a paper exactly on this subject but at the end I feared that by not knowing Ukrainian or Russian I wouldn't be able to gather enough information, so I made a kind of mix with its legacy in Ukraine, in France (I'm french) and around the world, it was very interesting and thankfully my professor who is Ukrainian said my work is good so lol we should never stop talking about Anarchism in Ukraine 🇺🇦🖤❤️

СЛАВА УКРАЇНІ!

Am a big fan man, keep it up

These mutinies were totally justified.

These narrators need to learn that constant speaking is not very attractive. Can’t even take one breath, this guy. Not to mention that the video doesn’t even go with this narration. They did absolutely nothing to line it up. What trash!

🖤🏴🏴

I can happily now x say that Pan Europe is now permanently damaged

the speed in wich the red army transformed is absolutely incredible already in 1944 they were doing their own blitzkrieg against the germans. the french newspaper reported in 1944 that the wehrmacht is an obselite army

nazi invasion was doomed from the start.Hitler had no chanzse against stalin. if d d day didn't happen stalin would had controlled all of Europe not just half

Army Group Center Was Stripped of All it's Tank Groups and Best Unit's and was a Secondary Unit at Best! And a Piss Poorly Skeleton of It's FormerSelf!

Russia was too big, Germany was too small. Unless Moscow was captured within 3-4 months (and the Soviet Government fell and sued for peace), the Germans faced a multi-year war, and Germany would lose. By mid-June 1942, Russia achieved superiority over Germany (in all areas-men aircraft, tanks, artillery and resources); and Germany's fate was sealed.

it's not true, the height of sabotage was doubled in 1943 and early 1944. Oh and btw mate... we are not in the 50s no one believe in the myth you've mention, it's pretty much in our knowledge to underate the French resistance, which is sad considering the thousands who died on the field;

My grandfather died Stalingrad Don river 1943

I think taking Moscow was the only way for Germany to win. They cannot win a war with the Soviets on the field due to the extreme imbalance in numbers, no matter how many encirclements they pull off. So it had to end symbolically by taking the capital. At least then in the eyes of the international audience, the Germans had won.

This is a great video, thank you! I think the example of the Spanish Civil War is one of the most important for any Marxist to learn from.

when children get smacked back into reality.

Oh, God, please! The black and red piece of crap is Petlyura's flag- not Makhno. Nestor hated Petlyura's guts and that goddamned menstrual rag.

I think the comment by Stalin that "Hitler would never attempt such a risky adventure". Goes a long way to explaining the early successes of the the Wehrmacht and the earlier 'bloodless' political victory in Czech and Austrian annexations. His and the western democracies to understand that Hitler was not just an old style "realpolitic" statesman in new clothes. But was a 'True Believer' and actually meant to do everything he said in his speeches, the Western democracies thought,(as they had seen many times before) that the insane things he said were just bombastic rabble rousing. No one,(before seeing Treblinka and Auschwitz) would credit such an inhuman vision of world domination.

Happy Operation Barbarossa day! And Napoleon’s invasion of Russia day!

The,endofnazipower,andnazioppression.

Am waiting for your next video

Fantastic channel.

I never knew the Caucasus Mountains oil supply was different and needed to be treated before use. That explains a lot, thank you.

Very underrated.

Ill also add that I am a ML who agrees that spain is a good example of the failures of the USSR and stalin and a mistake that was not in line with ML principles. Spain was consciously organizing already and the infighting between the left groups harmed the building of socialism

Good video. Really shows how crippled the American left us because of the tiny number of us, we refuse to unite on any level. Also far too much emphasis on action, when understanding theory is just as important but lacking in many leftists in US, so their actions aren't effective and only drain revolutionary vigor.