- Видео 630
- Просмотров 1 369 011
Mormon Book Reviews
США
Добавлен 26 сен 2020
My name is Steven Pynakker host of Mormon Book Reviews: "Where an Evangelical Encounters the Restoration." This channel intends to be a unique place where all the expressions of the Restoration can intersect with one another. I also plan on offering my "outsider" views on related subjects. This channel will also pursue authors and other special guests to interview. This is an independent channel. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Community of Christ, Church of Jesus Christ, or any Restoration or Remnant movement or expression. "All the voices of the Restoration will be heard on Mormon Book Reviews".
Burrows Cave & Book of Mormon w/ Scott Wolter
Forensic Geologist and host of the programs America Unearthed on the @HISTORY channel and Mysteries of the Knights Templar on @GaiaVideo Scott Wolter returns to @MormonBookReviews to discuss the controverial Burrows Cave in southern Illinois with Steven Pynakker and special co-host Nehemia Gordon. Some believers in the historicity of the Book of Mormon point to the Burrows Cave discoveries as evidence that it's true. Scott had the opportunity to examine many of the items allegedly found in the cave and came to the conclusion that it was a hoax. He also describes his interactions with Russell E. Burrows (who claimed to have found the cave) throughout the years. @Nehemiaswall
#historychanne...
#historychanne...
Просмотров: 638
Видео
FAIR Mormon Early Days w/ Backyard Professor
Просмотров 1,4 тыс.7 часов назад
Evangelical Steven Pynakker and Latter Day Saint Jonathan Neville interview Kerry Shirts (aka Backyard Professor) about the early days of the apologetic organization FAIR Mormon (now known as FAIR Faithful Answers, Informed Response). Kerry was one of the founders of the organization and he provides an oral history of that time period and explains why he finally left the organization. @TheBacky...
Is Evolution Compatible with Mormon Theology? w/ Ed Goble
Просмотров 44619 часов назад
Ed Goble returns to MBR to talk with Steven Pynakker about the reception history of the Theory of Evolution in Latter Day Saint circles. Both how it was viewed by various Apostles, General Authorities, scholars, and laymen. Here is an AI Summary of the conversation: Latter Day Saint Ed Goble and Evangelical Steven Pynakker discussed the evolution of beliefs within the Latter Day Saint community...
Was Oliver Cowdery Deceptive? w/ Jonathan Neville
Просмотров 1 тыс.День назад
Jonathan Neville returns to Mormon Book Reviews to discuss with Evangelical Steven Pynakker his latest book Moroni's America: The North American Setting for The Book of Mormon 2nd Edition. Published by Byod Tuttle's Digital Legand Press. Jonathans explains why a second edition was necessary and the changes and additions made to it. We also talk about Fair Mormon, Royal Skousen, Gold Plates, Ric...
A Latter Day Thanksgiving
Просмотров 28914 дней назад
The annual Thanksgiving tradition continues! Apostle Patrick McKay Sr. returns to Mormon Book Reviews for the 4th year in a row to discuss a Latter Day Thanksgiving. He talks about the many things he is thankful for and how to do it during time of struggle. Happy Thanksgiving everyone! #thanksgiving #latterdaysaints #mormonism #churchofjesuschristoflatterdaysaints #communityofchrist #lds #mormo...
Evangelical Steven Pynakker's Appreciation of The Book of Mormon
Просмотров 37714 дней назад
Stephen Murphy host of the program Mormonism with the Murph recently sat down with Evangelical Steven Pynakker to discuss Apologetic defenses of the Book of Mormon. #josephsmith #bookofmormon #mormonhistory #churchofjesuschristoflatterdaysaints #lds #ldspodcast #scripture #holybook #stevenpynakker #mormonbookreviews #mormonismwiththemurph #stephenmurphy #evangelical #bible #christianity #commun...
Criticisms of Book of Mormon Discussed
Просмотров 53421 день назад
Stephen Murphy host of the program @mormonismwiththemurph recently sat down with Evangelical Steven Pynakker to discuss a Naturalistic view of the Book of Mormon. #josephsmith #bookofmormon #mormonhistory #churchofjesuschristoflatterdaysaints #lds #ldspodcast #scripture #holybook #stevenpynakker #mormonbookreviews #mormonismwiththemurph #stephenmurphy #evangelical #bible #christianity #communit...
How Mormonism Saved an Evangelical’s Life
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.21 день назад
Originally released April 8 2022 on John Dehlin's @mormonstories podcast this is part 5 of 5 of a converstion Steven Pynakker had with the Mormon Stories Team. This interview discussed the role that Mormonism played in saving his life. A very powerful episode and we are excited to share it with the MBR audience. #mormonstories #evangelical #johndehlin #churchofjesuschristoflatterdaysaints #morm...
Heretic Movie & Latter Day Saints
Просмотров 2,8 тыс.28 дней назад
On the latest episode of Mormon Book Reviews, Evangelical Steven Pynakker spoke with an All Star Panel to talk about the Movie "Heretic". We covered a wide range of topics: how AMAZING the sister missionaries were, Heretic as a pro-religious film, the dynamics of women in religion and power imbalances, Mormon polygamy, prayer and its transactional nature versus human connection, the value of in...
Latter Day Accountant Talks Tithing Misconceptions w/ Aaron Brewster
Просмотров 5 тыс.28 дней назад
Accountant and member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints Aaron Brewster talks about innovative approaches to Tithing! #tithing #churchofjesuschristoflatterdaysaints #mormonhistory #mormonchurch #lds #ldspodcast #evangelical #mormonbookreviews #stevenpynakker #josephsmith #doctrineandcovenants Links to support Mormon Book Reviews: Venmo Link: account.venmo.com/u/mbrven PayPal Lin...
Joseph Smith's Non-Canonized Revelations! w/ David Hocking
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.Месяц назад
Joseph Smith's Non-Canonized Revelations! w/ David Hocking
Bishop Koyle's Dream Mine & Ogden Kraut w/ Kevin Kraut
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.Месяц назад
Bishop Koyle's Dream Mine & Ogden Kraut w/ Kevin Kraut
Jacob Hansen & Steven Pynakker Have A Conversation!
Просмотров 3,6 тыс.Месяц назад
Jacob Hansen & Steven Pynakker Have A Conversation!
Brigham Young Descendent Speaks Out! w/ Kai Van Leuven
Просмотров 687Месяц назад
Brigham Young Descendent Speaks Out! w/ Kai Van Leuven
Judaism & The Restoration! w/ Rabbi Joe Charnes
Просмотров 956Месяц назад
Judaism & The Restoration! w/ Rabbi Joe Charnes
Can Interfaith Dialogue Help Humanity? w/ Kyle Reyes
Просмотров 2372 месяца назад
Can Interfaith Dialogue Help Humanity? w/ Kyle Reyes
LDS Faith Crisis Family & Relationships
Просмотров 5282 месяца назад
LDS Faith Crisis Family & Relationships
What is The Mormon Polygamy Journal All About?
Просмотров 7632 месяца назад
What is The Mormon Polygamy Journal All About?
New Book of Mormon About To be Canonized? w/ Paul Durham
Просмотров 4,7 тыс.2 месяца назад
New Book of Mormon About To be Canonized? w/ Paul Durham
LGBTQ & The Tabernacle Choir! w/ Jim Bennett
Просмотров 5 тыс.2 месяца назад
LGBTQ & The Tabernacle Choir! w/ Jim Bennett
Polygamist Shares His Faith! w/ Benjamin Shaffer
Просмотров 7402 месяца назад
Polygamist Shares His Faith! w/ Benjamin Shaffer
Paul Brothers Jacob Hansen & Mormon Apologetics!
Просмотров 4,7 тыс.3 месяца назад
Paul Brothers Jacob Hansen & Mormon Apologetics!
Evangelical Loves The Book of Mormon?!
Просмотров 6523 месяца назад
Evangelical Loves The Book of Mormon?!
Hell Fire Ted Bundy & The Jacob Hansen Debate
Просмотров 1,4 тыс.3 месяца назад
Hell Fire Ted Bundy & The Jacob Hansen Debate
Black Priesthood Ban History w/ Matthew Harris
Просмотров 6473 месяца назад
Black Priesthood Ban History w/ Matthew Harris
Joseph Smith Papers Jonathan Neville & Trent Horn
Просмотров 3 тыс.3 месяца назад
Joseph Smith Papers Jonathan Neville & Trent Horn
Rabbi Talks Book of Mormon & Evangelical Protesters! w/ Joe Charnes
Просмотров 2,9 тыс.3 месяца назад
Rabbi Talks Book of Mormon & Evangelical Protesters! w/ Joe Charnes
Jew & Evangelical Are Now LDS? w/ Jason Olson & Rusty Curtis
Просмотров 3,4 тыс.3 месяца назад
Jew & Evangelical Are Now LDS? w/ Jason Olson & Rusty Curtis
New Book of Mormon Geography Model & History of Heartlanders w/ Ed Goble
Просмотров 1,5 тыс.3 месяца назад
New Book of Mormon Geography Model & History of Heartlanders w/ Ed Goble
"The Restoration".... CLAIMED restoration
Hello from Provo.
@@alanyoung6572 Hello from Florida!
Is the guy who does The Cultural Hall a member? I thought he was, but at one time he left?! Or is this a different Cultural Hall?
First 2 years of your show everything just fell in your lap. This year it's hot coffee spilling in your lap. Again and again. 😮
Ironically I quit drinking coffee this year!
Welcome back to mama Pynakker. Praying for your continued recovery. ❤
Watched you last night and was curious, so watched you live tonight. When I watch a live, I like to come back to comment, ie feed the algorithm. Keep up your good work.
Thanks!
@ my pleasure
Thank you for this discussion. I have a strong testimony of the truthfulness of the Gospel and the Book of Mormon. Eventually all truth will be revealed (D&C 76: 5-10) Until then, we get to listen and ponder each others ideas and opinions😂
Forget Burrows Cave who is the baddie in Great Scott's Cave! I don't think I've ever seen Nehemiah speechless. in 2024 their is no solid evidence for the BOM. The aliens are here and still no sign of the Nephites. :(
Fantastic episode with Scott. I dig his History channel show
That was so very sweet, putting your mom on the show ❤
Nibley
I took a BoM class at BYU with Nibley as the instructor. He would fall asleep while teaching the class. I laugh about that here at about 60+ years later!!
BYU is the looser. Having balanced opinions is vital for a good life. BYU will lose. LGBTQIA do not harm anyone.
Like Elder Holland, I’ve been shocked by the indoctrination on LGB and gender at BYU for several years. I was so relieved when Reese was hired and hoped to see change. Thank you for bringing this good news. Your use of the term “playbook” is silly. Church leaders don’t follow each others “playbook.“ if you’re saying church leaders historically try to keep doctrine and institutions pure, then yes. Obviously. That’s literally what their job is.
Scott. An LDS Deacon is basically an altar boy. 😊 Love your work.
I think several of Wayne's collection of artifacts are forgeries as well. I've seen several of his collection and they just aren't that impressive, similar to the ones we saw here.
Rod Meldrum and Wayne also had a bit of a falling out as well. He stopped coming out to Rod's Book of Mormon Evidences Conferences a few years back.
The hand sign on Jesus and native is Ameslan for I love you. Ridiculous fakes.
Fred and Ethel Mertz
This guy at the bottom ruined the last interview… hope he doesn’t do it this time lol
I dream of being handsome like Scott when older
🇨🇭🇨🇭🇨🇭
I’m a fan of Scott.
As someone involved tangentially with the beginnings of FAIR, alt.religion.mormon, SHIELDS and the AOL CHAT rooms that all these people Kerry is referring to where they originally hung out - I +1 his opinion of Julianne - she's awesome. I didn't attend that first conference because I was in KS/MO and it was too far (I did get the published articles), but Utah was good and I made the next 10 or so conferences. We sat with John Tvedtness one day at a conference and discovered that he and my father served at the same time in the same mission - I was also there when Brent Metcalf brought his pictures of the Scrolls. Such a fun time at the very beginning of this org. A time when the Apologetics was mostly dealing with Evangelical attack, which really was a joke, it was very doctrinally based - One of the best ways I learned the gospel was reading the FARMS review of books when they dealt with arguments of Evangelicals through the BOM, Bible, etc.. It was amazing. I also recall that John Dehlin came onto the FAIR mail list early on when he describes his issues being called to be a seminary teacher, he was arguing with people like Kevin and Julianne and others about a great number of things, he was clearly upset, in his initial pissed off phase, but I remember him being extremely shallow, unable to handle arguments, dismissive of extremely capable people - An impression that I believe has shown to be very true all these years later and even when he burst onto the scenes. Here is a link to the alt.religion.mormon conversations. www.usenetarchives.com/threads.php?id=alt.religion.mormon&y=0&r=0&p=1
What kind of arguments does FAIR provide that invalidate the critics' arguments? Seems this video doesn't even go there. Just sounds like blind adherence to authority and it only supports my scepticism. Kerry, sorry, but you don't strike me as an intelligent person. You can barely string two words together. I would have thought the people behind FAIR would have at least been somewhat persuasive. Gonna have to give you a thumbs down;)
You are probably more correct than not. Oh wait, that's more than two words......Damn!
BYP’s expectation for LDS Apologetics is more in line with Hugh Nibley-who invited research and study.
I’m glad I never had a desire to go to BYU. MSN and definitely believe in vaccines.
Did j golden have stock??
I took a class on evolution at byui, I remember the packet, I wish every student would read it. I had a roommate that thought evolution was blasphemy 😂
Howdy, … days late but I wanted to say, welcome to wavelength. I think I caught that you suffer from tinnitus. If so, I wanted to send you some empathy and solidarity.
🇨🇭🇨🇭🇨🇭
Yeah, I watched this last night and I know a lot of names that Kerry shirts mentioned because I was part of FAIR oh10 years ago or so. I left because it became too cerebral for me to keep up with and there was one guy there that really insulted me verbally because of his presumptuous pompous attitude. None of the names kerry mentioned were that person. Great interview loved it !!
Great interview, loved it. Thanks for being on, Kerry! I think you and I were Facebook friends at one point. Yeah, I watched this last night and I know a lot of names that Kerry shirts mentioned because I was part of FAIR oh10 years ago or so. I left because it became too cerebral for me to keep up with and there was one guy there that really insulted me verbally because of his presumptuous pompous attitude. None of the names kerry mentioned were that person. Now I understand more fully why kerry left FAIR and the church But personally, my emphasis is on Christ and the doctrines regarding Christ taught by the church and not on the fallibility of prophets.
Very interesting. Thanks. FAIR and gospel topics essays sealed the deal for me leaving because the best answers available were not very convincing within a fundamental/orthodox viewpoint.
@@jeremiahgreen5161 🙄
I'd be interested in an example of this. I've never understood those that say... FAIR and the gospel Topics essays sealed the deal for me... I'd really appreciate it because I've not understood it to this point.
@@zionssuburb I can just speak to my experience, but I can give a few examples. (1) I read and was taught that Joseph Smith claimed that the Egyptian papyri were written "by the hand of Abraham, but critics say that this can not be the case because the papyri are not as old as Abraham. So, look this up on FAIR: "When Joseph Smith obtained the papyri in 1835, he reportedly said that "one of the rolls contained the writings of Abraham...."[3] According to Joseph's scribes, this scroll was "written" by Abraham's "own hand upon papyrus."[4] It seems reasonable to conclude that Joseph believed that Abraham himself, with pen in hand, wrote the very words that he was translating. The problem is that most modern scholars (including LDS scholars) date the papyri to a few centuries before Christ, whereas Abraham lived about two millennia before Christ. Obviously, Abraham himself could not have penned the papyri." So now the choice is that either Joseph Smith was wrong and if he was wrong about this, what else was he wrong about or that there is some other convoluted way that it was actually written by Abraham. FAIR admits that this factoid is correct. (2) I was taught (and taught as a missionary from correlated instruction material), that the Lamanites were the principle ancestors of native Americans, but a critic claims that native Americans are not descendants of people from Israel. So look that up on FAIR: "Nothing is known about the DNA of Book of Mormon peoples, and even if their genetic profile were known, there are sound scientific reasons that it might remain undetected...DNA samples taken from modern Native Americans do not match the DNA of modern inhabitants of the Middle East." So we have an admission that modern native Americans (and since they don't want to admit it either, samples from prior native American DNA where available) does not match Middle East DNA. Now the choice is that Joseph Smith was wrong about who the native Americans /Lamanites and the church and/or FAIR are trying to deny that this was ever a claim or it might still be the case and we have to change the story that the Lamanites are somewhere among the native Americans, but we don't know where and we have to try to downplay the evidence as much as possible. (3) A critic said that Joseph hid his plural marriages from Emma. Look this up on FAIR. "For example, he had been sealed to Emily and Eliza Partridge already, and Emma later had one of her periods of acceptance of plural marriage, on condition that she get to choose the wives. [2] She chose Emily and Eliza, and so they were resealed to Joseph without disclosing that they were already sealed." So again, FAIR admits that the fact is true. This again puts me in the situation where "the critic" has put forward real facts that FAIR corroborates. Most of the rest of the writing around these points try to make excuses for why we shouldn't put too much weight on these facts. But the best case for these arguments are that we either have to rethink what the church teaches or how we view Joseph Smith or the church or we have to try to downplay the evidence. Sure, many of the stories related to each topic are complicated, but most of the problematic facts presented by the critic are admitted to by FAIR and the gospel topics essays. They just want the believer to think the issues are not as important as the critic says even if the issues are real and problematic. For me, going through topic after topic, the same pattern continues that the critic's point is correct and that in order to not have that affect belief, it becomes necessary to make room for lots of times that a prophet didn't really mean what he said, or a prophet was wrong, or we have to deny scientific consensus, or the church is changing what was previously revealed doctrine. There are so many points, but for another that makes me sick reading, reading about Lowry Nelson (www.fairlatterdaysaints.org/blog/2013/12/18/mormon-fair-cast-185-race-and-the-priesthood). Sorry, long reply. This was my experience. After seeing point after point that "the critic's points" were corroborated and that the actual facts could not be denied, I couldn't believe anymore. Thus my response is that FAIR helped me get out of the church because it corroborated the problems without providing any real answers.
Abominable freemasonry dressed up as a religion 😢😢😢
Is it too controlling?
Let's take that worship a man a step farther. Jesus was a man. Is it possible that Jesus didn't have a monopoly on Christ or christedness. Is it possible that you have Christ in you, or christedness in you and that Christ or christedness have nothing to do with the man Jesus who was born in Nazaeth. Not the mythical Jesus whose birth place was changed to Bethlehem?
I've listend to several interviews with BYP and thought I knew his backstory well, but the level of detail in here about the founding of FAIR was facinating! Thanks for giving Kerry the time to share these facinating stories.
The video is just starting for my but I can say as someone who has been around the subjects there are very few better than Kerry.
This was really good. I was at that FAIR conference when Brent Metcalfe came. He showed me his high resolution photos, they were really good. That incident where FAIR kicked out Van Hale for his Book of Mormon views really rubbed me the wrong way at the time. It had to be around 2009 because I recall talking about it with Van on the way to MHA with Steve Mayfield in Sacramento, I too didn’t like FAIR so much afterwards. Van Hale had been defending the church since the early 1980s and to be disrespected like that was outrageous.
You are more concerned about curing your hurt feelings you got from being rejected. Fair Mormon does more good than damage. Fair Mormon isn’t running people out, they would have been out no matter if fair even existed.
Their pathetic attempt at responding to critics drive more people out.
@@dr33776 are you an active and believing member?
@@smuggythornton no bad reason to leave Mormonism, FAIR is the Least of these good reasons.
@@dr33776 Definitely agree with this. I went to them hoping they had solid responses that would refute critics. When the best they have is sidestepping the issues or trying to downplay contrary evidence, it shows that no one has good answers to issues "the critics" point out. The best they seem to be able to provide is comfort to those who don't want to look too closely or have already determined to believe even if it is contrary to the evidence.
@ the podcasts from Mormon Stories to Mormonish and more attempt to drive people away have driven more recently back to the church, wonderful how that works.
Also when hearing the comments you read, it’s a constant “I wouldn’t send my child to a school that..” yet 99% of college students are likely 18 when they enter & these are adults? It’s so curious to hear parents talking about these students like they’re in junior high and they can influence the principal or community council and they have a choice where they send their child. If you talk to other groups of parents about their kids and where they’re going to college it’s more like “my child is interested in a school that…or My child says they value…” so interesting to hear so many parents speaking on behalf of their adult children, as if they are in elementary school.
I love Kerry!
Me too!
Interesting that there’s more of a push now than previously. What do you think is making that push? & even for departments like chemistry, which follow a rigid curriculum & sensitive subjects don’t come up? Except evolution, but they don’t pass a letter out anymore? Curious, I know they’ve had a gymnastics coach and current track coach that are not LDS and has there been a football coach too? You mentioned LGBQ issues as one of the reasons there’s a purge. Statistically within a coach’s lifetime, they will have been fellow athletes along side LGBQ or coached LGBQ athletes so do they check Into coaches views or only professors? I’d argue a coach’s influence is greater.
Great discussion. Yep, pretty much there is a scholarly orthodoxy.
Just started reading the new Mormon challenge, it is impressive its arguments against Mormonism.
Great Job!!! Recent Mormon History is the most important era of Mormonism...
@TBYP great show, thanks for the FAIR history
My good pleasure
Soooo right that the LDS church is now playing Satan according to THEIR plan of salvation. When I was raising my kids in the church and still believed I made sure to let them know how important free agency is when their friends had control freak parents and their kids were doing things like drugs secretly. I told my kids if they made the wrong choices THEY would have to live with the consequences NOT me. 😂 The funny thing is now I'm out of the church and they are all active members-oldest son is bishop of his ward- but some of my grandkids are slowly pulling away and my kids seem to be accepting of it. 🤗The LDS church thinks the church has a covenant path that totally takes away from what Jesus accomplished on the cross. According to their preexistence Jesus said He would take care of their sins so they wouldn't be forced to live on a covenant path. 😂 That was Satan's plan. God Soooo LOVED the WORLD He sent His ONLY begotten Son to SAVE the WORLD not condemn it.❤️🥰❤️
Thanks!
Thanks for the contribution!