Видео

What’s up with the angry Christian in the audience who claims he’s found God?

'God revealed himself to me' - so why is that anyone else's problem? Why is it his responsibility to project his believe on others? The EGO! The MANIA!

No. I don't like this episode at all. Before mid point, we have an audience member claiming that a god had spoken to him! We should have asked that guy questions! Instead, they let it go. Horrible.

All life forms are biological and our planet allows all life forms to be born live and die in our planet itself. No heaven or hell can outside of our planet.

How many of you would subscribe to removing the free exercise clause in the Constitution? If I can exercise my religion, and not bother you; why do you care? I’m a Catholic and don’t bother anyone about what they believe. I’m part of the leave me alone party

Gore Vidal was amazing ..he lives on in his works

Each human plays a role in each imagination

Is there a full video for this show?

Bear in mind that the "God" toward which Vidal is an atheist is the Christian concept of God, or more precisely yet, the generally accepted and promulgated concept, and that's a product of political processes...a false/human-created "God"...an idol, like one of Bacon's. I think he'd agree there may be a real God but what the real God is like, who knows?

Oh my god,how great this man was;and stupid Americans did not know him...

If God talked to you, then more than likely, you are insane.

Do a good have pray to God

Do a good have pray to God

Why good people go to hell

There is no God existence at all

I like the books of his I have read, I like him ok here... The 1950's Eugenics stuff he was promoting was pretty insane though.

Any religion that tells you your suffering on this earth will be rewarded in heaven isn't a religion, it's a death cult.

5:00 The British man saying that "they were all Christians!": I wish that Vidal had retorted, "The 'They're ALL True Scotsmen' Fallacy!"

From what we have observed and from what we know we exist in a natural universe, not a magical one. RIP Mr Vidal

What was the name of the show? What does it mean to be "battling for atheism"? Why should anyone contend for atheism? Are ALL the members featured here dead now? Hey, saw your write-up, mind if I weigh in? (If you wish to engage, feel free to pick just one topic from the 1-2-3 you see below that corresponds to your own list.) 1. So you believe that "live and let live" is the standard all men ought to abide by then? Why are YOU an atheist? Top 3 reasons maybe? 2. Who would you consider a few heavyweights in the atheists camp today and why? What is "poetic" about the atheists position? Didn't an atheist write a book about, supposedly, consciousness being an illusion? If stardust is all we are, why should anyone care? 3. But is it possible for the atheist to make a positive, scientific, evidence based case FOR their own naturalistic position? Why should anyone be an atheist? What do you mean by "the dignity she deserves"? It sounds like you're assuming things that, I don't see how mindless atoms could account for. You're making value judgments here, correct? Well, based upon whose or what >>immaterial<< standard? Okay, I'm done! Just thought you might want some action on a decade old post. 😁

What does he mean by "good behavior"? Seems to me he's assuming a standard of some kind. But then, how can atoms produce immaterial standards of behavior that somehow comport with reality-that larger clumps of atoms are somehow obligated to abide by? Is that just his imagination running while or did he have a rational and/or scientific reason for believing that?

02:29 What an insufferable, boastful know nothing.

Gore is wrong.

Brilliant conversation

On Vidal's final remark, I would say that the notion of 'a good human being', cosy as it seems, is entirely vacuous if it is not grounded in something solid. Christ seems to be the obvious archetype here.

i voted for Ronald Reagan in 1980 and 1984 and i voted for the right candidate . Reagan was the greatest President we ever had . Put that into your pipe and smoke it , Mr . Vidal .

Gore is right.

of course Vidal was correct...al religion does and has ever does is divide people....but being a good human being requires no hate and that is why believers wont accept it

Take A Moment Hi, Jester Moon The Wizard of Silly After 28yrs in the RAF. Killing for the government in the repair and maintaining of 'The Lawnmower of Death'. Now 64, I live in Calgary Alberta with 24/7 mental health issues. 40yrs + I have been diagnosed with PTSD. A new perspective. Life is odd that way. Mysterious eh I am still in my foxhole. No gods required or seen Stay Happy Stay Safe Safe Free

IDIOTS

I'm non-religious and I can fully understand the notion that some ideas of some religions can provide comfort, reassurance, solace, etc. I get that. I just don't think there's any reason to think any of those notions exist independently of human minds. I'm far more convinced of the validity and existence of concepts emerging from centuries of iterative advances in science than any religious ideas. The audience member who asserted that a God exists because of some personal experience is typical of the sort of reasoning that is common to faith-based ideas and utterly absent from scientific ideas. we can be fooled and for ideas to rise above the improbable and into a realm where we can not only start to increase our understanding we must be able to separate any idea from an individuals subjective experience, to describe that thing, to have it be something concrete enough to reproduce and hopefully be specific enough to falsify.

Timothy 2 1 You may be quite sure that in the last days there will be some difficult times. 2 People will be self-centred and avaricious, boastful, arrogant and rude; disobedient to their parents, ungrateful, irreligious; 3 heartless and intractable; they will be slanderers, profligates, savages and enemies of everything that is good; 4 they will be treacherous and reckless and demented by pride, preferring their own pleasure to God. 5 They will keep up the outward appearance of religion but will have rejected the inner power of it. Keep away from people like that.

We don’t dance when our loved ones go away, we dance when they return.

“I wouldn’t be able to supply proof I love my husband.” Oh I don’t know about that; it seems your actions would supply a hell of a lot of evidence on that question

Clown

I always loved the part where he said "she's not being a good Christian. She's being a good human being".

The sight of the smug smarmy 'Reverend' is the only argument needed against Christianity.

Christianity is so simplistic and reactionary it's laughable that anyone claiming to be serious, believes a word of it. For me their constant claims of belief, prove the opposite. Nobody screams and shouts about anything they really believe in, they take it as read. That's impossible for Christians because they all know it's rubbish. Their obvious and total insecurity, when claiming to be in possession of the true word of their omnipotent God, says everything.

Vidal was a real bastard

Wish they hadn't cut to the audience with the proselytizing howler monkey. Killed the flow

There are millions who believe in Trump.

Xtians and other believers constantly demand that we "respect" their beliefs. There is no reason why anyone should respect a belief of any kind.

At 5:09, the always unanswered after life question has always interested me. If there’s some sort of afterlife, do you remain what you are at that moment for eternity? Do a new born dies and forever is a new born? Die at 100 and you remain 100? Do you revert to the best version of yourself? What do the religious think happens? Seems to me that after an eternity has passed and you were in some energy/spirit state, you will have been everywhere in the universe, seen everything, learned everything, and basically become a god. Then what? I think an actual end is better.

Melvyn Bragg deserves the credit for acknowledging that the millenium was about Christianity. He was the only media person who did that

2:05 Joy Behar had to apologize for saying what this guy has shown.

The capabilities of our brains that we can do many things but yet the stupidity of man to deny his maker is astounding

6:26 when it comes to this woman’s argument, I would say that this actually only prevents people from accepting that their relatives are gone and devalues their relationships to a degree in this life. For example if you don’t believe that there is an afterlife and believe this is all you get, you do indeed have an incentive at the very least to make sure that your relationships with relatives and friends are good so you don’t regret anything when they pass. If you do believe however, a person could just say “well I didn’t resolve x with them but when I see them again in heaven then we’ll have the opportunity to make amends”. You will still treasure the memories you had with them but you won’t as much as someone who doesn’t believe in an afterlife who believes all they truly have left are memories. It actually more serves to prevent yourself from truly accepting that they are gone and moving on with your life. Certainly I wouldn’t be able to accept it if I did believe because I know for sure that I’ll see them again. What would be the point if I believe that I will indeed “see” them again? No lessons would be learned because I wouldn’t have any actual reason to do so.

God help us all. Christ is at the center of us all.

God is a personal God, He doesnt appeal to everyone the same ways. there certain things which happens to a persons heart and mind once they truly experience God. They become more devoted, mentality changes and spirituality becomes a part of them. Its not just a fleeting feeling. Jesus Christ is the way, the truth and the life. God is someone Who comes to those who seek after him. Its not fair for you to expect God to appeal to you and communicate with you, when you couldnt care less about Him. In natural senses imagine calling someone who never picks up the phone, and talking well about someone who backstabs you consistently. Would it be fair to expect them to love and support you. Of course not. Think logically sir.

This is a good program me myself I don't believe on the imaginary man I don't think I'm a stupid enough to believe this kind of negatives therefore this was a scheme to control and power and they still praying on people