Видео

Thanks for your reply !

It's a paradox as the opinion changes depending on the perspective (vantage point) you approach the issue

Ask your former leader Stalin if he respected ethnicity ... I don't think so. Because of mass-deportations, Gulag's and the mandatory "Russisifaction (which = not respecting ethnic minorities). You can't compare the US with the former USSR as you do.

Ukrainian was invented in 1930's by Bolsheviks. Please learn your history.

Most everyone was bilingual. It was not US. People around the world learn multiple languages. We learned 3. Russian as the official language, language of the republic or ethnic group, depending where you lived, and a western or eastern language depending which region you lived in but German, Franch and English were in western parts and Chines and Japanese were offered in eastern parts. It was not a "typical empire" as the Bolsheviks spent 1920-1950 restoring or creating (in case of Ukraine) ethnic and cultural groups. And before you start complaining: "how dare you use creating towards Ukraine!?!" I will point you to geography and history lessons which you should have had and should have learned how 1/3 of Ukraine was actually Polish, Romanian, and Hungarian before the world wars so they had to unify unrelated ethnic groups so cresting a language and culture that incorporated everyone was necessary.

@@victoriadedicova Stalin's regime was primarily interested in mass killings and extermination of Ukrainians.

@@victoriadedicova You wrote a pointless opus. I am immune to Russian propaganda

пришло время исследовать этнические ценности и традиции, а не следовать навязанной культуре

Ethnic cleansing was common during Stalin's time, with 150,000 to 200,000 Armenians and Azerbaijanis deported from the South Caucasus, along with around 150,000 Turks, Kurds, and Hemshils. Many ethnic groups faced similar treatment, being relocated to Kazakhstan and Siberia. Who survived was submitted to "Russification"

@@GeopoliticalInsightsBR I like Brazil and Brazilians but you shouldnt talk when you have no clue of what you are saying. I was born in Russia as a German. And yes my family was moved to Kazakhstan and Siberia... but the reason wasnt because Russians had a bad day(Well you can say they had actually). It was mid WW2 and the difficult geopolitical situation right after it. You make it sound like it was done out of nothing and for fun. Especially in WW2 there was a huge problem with many different groups supporting Nazi Germany as partisan fighters. Turks for example fought for Nazi Germany as well. When you say "Ethnic cleansing" it sounds really disgusting. I lived in Brazil... talking about "ethnic cleansing". Tell me the story about south and north Brazil and how South-Brazilians look at noderstinas. Not to mention how indegenous people of the Amazonas are being dehumenized, nobody is talking about how their whole cultures are being erradicated still today. And how darker people live and being treaten in Brazil as a whole. Give me a break. Who survies Brazilian favellas can concider himself a happy person.

I`m not a Brazilian...

@@GeopoliticalInsightsBR I didnt say you exactly are. But what this channel is supposedly all about. You are either some Anglo-Saxon or some other paid actor that came out of nothing to spread some RUclips truth, tailored to the western narrative.

​@@GeopoliticalInsightsBRStalin was Georgian.

What is your point? Zelenskyy his first language is Russian, but he pledged his allegiance to Ukraine. Many Russian Ukrainians who speak Russian have done the same thing. Seeing as Russian speaking cities such as Mariupol, Bakhmut, and Avdiivka end up after a brutal siege by the terrorist state that is the Russian Federation, that doesn't suprise me one bit.

Взаимно! (из Горловки)

@@Daniel-hp3tkThe question is rather, what is your point? Because Zelensky pledged his allegiance to NATO then we need to do the same? Have you heard of the hundred thousand soldiers from the DNR/LNR who are ethnic Ukrainian (like me and probably Vlad) yet do not identify with your likes? Screw you. Talk about what you know i.e. burgers and netflix series.

@@Daniel-hp3tkплан победы твоего Зеленского - это пукать ботами типа тебя?))

@@Daniel-hp3tk Any proofs? No? Just second-hand propaganda, bot.

Ethnicity is an inborn characteristic that simply reflects a trivial expression of the phenotype of a homo sapiens that in turn represents its innate genotype. You can “identify” as whoever you want, but it won’t make you THAT. It’s just that when people, for example, try to misgender themselves, it’s much easier to see an underlying mental illness with such an obvious matter. While in regard to ethnicity, the west in particular never cared too much, hence they naturally get to confront this important aspect now.

From Rus there are many ethnicities and Russian is not the most important one :). The true RUS ethnicity is not connected with imperial concept of ruski MIR cause it is much older than Russia concept.

@@robertsiwek7503 well yea, but it is more comfortable to call the ethnic slavs (the actual ethnicity) as Russians, because some people just use this word to address ethnic slavs. For example, my rather pro Ukrainian friend who is from Ukraine with his family living and born in Germany also says sentences like "All Russians love Barbecue" by that he is including himself in this concept of "Russians". Not meaning people from the Russian Federation. But yea, strictly speaking its not "right"

@@Sluchayniy (well okey, but for that example we dont just identify as that, my parents still kept their soviet-Russian passports, so we are not just theoretical Russians, but Russians with heritage from not exactly the area from inside the Russian Federation). Ethnicity wasnt the right thing for this, but I just meant all ethnic Slavs with this. But those slavs first got their national identity from the Kievan Rus' as far as I know 😇

@@michaelst9575 calling all Slavs Russians is a simple ignorance, no matter how you put it

but our 'friends' across the 'Red Square' think otherwise... If you speak Russian you ought to be Russian (or part of the Russian Federation)

@@GeopoliticalInsightsBR at least they are aware there's more languages, unlike the US lmao

@@GeopoliticalInsightsBR Not true. An invention of Gringoland interventionists to cause division between brothers. The opposite is true. For the ukranazis, if you do not speak Ukranian you are not Ukranian. For Biden, if you do not buy in dollars, you are not human.

Well, why do you use a south American word?

Youre both.

Learn to prompt your AI. You absolutely missed that there are actually 3 factors that are assigned to people of former USSR. They are Ethnicity (which you seem to just glazed over, and, no, ethnicity is not just language, it is specific culture and traditions, song, dance, art, stories), Nationality (location where they were born), and language. FYI Russian was a national language for everyone so everyone learned it for ease and mobility and national languages were learned in the region. Ethnic languages were also taught in regions. It was part of the Bolsheviks plight to stay in power to make sure all ethnicities and nationalities spoke their own language besides Russian. And in case where ethnic language did not exist, like Ukrainian which as a mesh of Polish, Romanian, Turkish, and old Ukrainian due to their territories actually belonging to those countries not long before, a new language was created. In the case of modern Ukrainian, it was a blend of all those languages and Russian.

Did you delete my comment?

@@jjamespacbell and make it all work in time