Видео

No way <3 1: No ancient culture heals, we look historically, Jesus said: your faith has healed you. 2: How can a psychiatrist heal you when he doesn't touch you? IT IS NOT SCIENCE, HOW CAN WE TALK ABOUT MEDICAL SCIENCE!

It all goes back to trauma. We are traumatized, often before we realize, and subconsciously traumatize others, partially due to our own previous trauma, trying to make the best of bad situations, and subsequently, causing far more damage than we could ever possibly know.

My disco.fort is concous sometimes.

Hannah Arendts stupid explanation of Eichmann

As one who is a "none", I have trouble not considering all organized religions to be cults. Probably not strictly correct by definition, but that is my view.

Or any extramism- racial, ideological (Nazism, Marxism) environmental. Where do we draw the line? Should Greenpeace sabotage human activity for profit, if the environment is saved for future generations? Old growth forest radicals who drive ceramic spikes into tree trunks so chain saws cannot cut them down? Hi ow far sghould radicals go to save rainforests, indiginous peoples from being taken advsntage of? Was Michaelangelo was monomaniacal in spending weeks constantly with minimal sleep. Was he an extremist, or is gathering a following necessary for that category? So, extremism has its role for good, as well as bad.

Excellent and valuable thank you

Well according to the Progressive Democrats. Have total faith in our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ of Nazareth make us extremests.

In short, I ❤ this channel! Very beneficial

When your parents lost material goods and you create a whole philosophy based on the narcissistic resentment. Holocaust is an epitome of Anglo-Saxon racism. Funny that the chosen ones twisted their minds to blend with them and project this inherently common superiority concept onto the world. Read Torah, time will come and the whole world will be your slaves. But wait, they all will WANT to be your slaves 😂😂😂😂

It's not unity, it's exclusive, fascist, se xist, racist, take no prisoners codependency.

Answered many doubts and posed solution to many issues, thank you

Nice one. Anything on the hypothesis that there is an epigenetic component? Cults often protein-starve their members, and there may be _in utero_ effects from hormones the mothers transmit via the placenta.

Obviously this is directly relevant to the current political situation in the United States. Lies and misinformation from the right are accomplishing the same thing among a portion of the population here that they accomplished in Nazi Germany almost a century ago. No deep-seated intelligence, only malicious cunning…

An Extremist is someone who won't shut up and won't change the subject.

Atheist dogma is: That God/ Jesus/ Bible/ Satan/ sin are myths. That Christians are deluded fools. This is working on the latter premise.

I believe in God and Christ but I'll admit that there's a subconscious discomfort I feel sometimes with fellow believers

The shrinks Call hearse people to accept a non-curable diagnosis. That’s the evil of psychiatry and labels and stillness of the cars back from Matic events in our lives that have never been rude. If we look at juniors psychology, we would really understand this a big Pharma loves to get there the chips in there and kill people and torture them. I’m a victim of psychiatry I became a grand Ricky master and I have no use for the industry. I know there’s a lot of things that work and at the methodology of learning holistic practices.

Are you shrink lol

Dark ages region to darkagemedicine it crime on humanity

no mail account no male account takes All every time i need a black provider if you buy the cyclothymia

Interesting …a neurological explanation, sounds like the brain hard wired for extremism of all varieties, great, hopefully a treatment

The mind is not generated in the brain but by a persons spirit. Therefore extremism depends on what spirit is doing the driving.

Interesting, interesting, interesting! Our pastor, John MacArthur, lit up the internet a few months ago by making his assertion that there is no such thing as mental illness. Wow! And he used many of the same arguments presented in this video. I’m glad and it is educating to see this is nothing new. I even think he must have used Thomas Szasz as a source for his view.

It doesn't imply still that the brain produces consciousness because the brain is insufficient to explain consciousness

I was always amazed at how some religious people can be perfectly rational in everyday life while totally irrational when it came to accepting some of the beliefs of their faith.

Lovely lecture! Thank you 🙏

🕊️🕯️🌳🤍🕊️ Thank you Thank you. Brilliant breakdown. 🕊️🤍🌳🕯️🕊️

This verifies what Eric Hoffer wrote over 60 years ago.

This was good and I agree. There is a potentiality of consciousness which must pre-exist the hard problem of consciousness. A young baby has emotional experiences (yet still not conscious I would argue), which appear to be, according to Northoff, the basis on which consciousness is truly born.

Adherence to the system is the worst form of extremism..by faaar. THEIR self righteousnes n arrogant pridefilled ignorance blames ALL not with them, their philosophies n denial of God..THAT is mankinds problem. 💣⌛⚖️👌😏✌️

Good stuff here

I am so glad I am no longer a Christian. Christianity is nothing but a cult

Thank you. 🙏

Nice intellectual effort!

Speaking from the point of evolution, these parts of brain developed in order for us to survive better?

This is so important and I'm glad that such people like Szasz existed. I hope his work will be valued more and more in the future. I also think that the medical community is aware of this but societies do still operate on power and coercion, so they just shrug their shoulders?

An interesting perspective; a video well worth watching. ... I think it offers an seriously over optimistic view of psychoanalysis. This is the last topic in the video. The idea on offer here is that psychoanalysis, (communication) i.e., talking, can reverse errant and harmful misinterpretations of one's environment is anything other than weak tea in terms of a remedy. Take the case of PTSD. This coming from the "shell shock" of WWI, progressing to the "battle fatigue" of WWII, and arriving at PTSD during the war in Viet Nam. The artillery shells launched on the trenches of WWI were physical realizations of the enemy's message of, "I aim (literally aim) to kill you." Even without suffering bodily injury, the shell shocked soldier developed extreme psychological distress and serious bodily dysfunction, not from the shell but from the message of the shell. The shell simply being words by other means. However, deep physiological changes occurs within the brain. These changes have to be reversed, and talk has little chance to reach such deeply embedded and strongly held hypotheses the victim holds about the dangers in his environment. Adding drugs that affect neurotransmitters attests to this and makes therapeutic sense. Unfortunately, they have little understanding of what is treatable (a small amount) and what the approach cannot change. The Free energy Principle offers the notion of "hard priors," beliefs that are virtually impervious to change. For example, the phenomenal experience of the color red. Can psychoanalysis, even with neurotransmitter medication, change a person into perceiving red objects as blue? I posit we are a long, long way, from the possibility of doing that, if it turns out we can do that at all. This is where clinical practice is a problem, offering hope where there is none. And, all too often, in their ignorance and zeal, harming the patient. One good example is pursuing conversion therapy for gender identity patients.

“Abby Normal brain.”

Thank you 🙏 ❤😊

Thank you for this video. I wanted a coherent depiction of faith that I couldn't put into words. This gives a basis to think and materialize what appears as chaotic random.

Freeing people from the brutal and highly suggestive label that disempowers their own role in their psychological well being is the epitome of true empathy.

To address your question, I would like to offer the following thoughts from recent publications: As we recently proposed (Northoff and Scalabrini, 2021), the aim of a neuropsychodynamic informed psychotherapeutic process is to (i) to reverse maladaptive topographic-dynamic reorganization of brain and (ii) to establish a more adaptive and stable temporo-spatial nestedness of brain and self thereby re-establishing a proper nested hierarchy of self. This process might serve to re-establish the subjective sense of integrity, coherence, and continuity of self over time and space, “the capacity to feel like one self while being many” (Bromberg, 1996, p. 166). Consequently, healing the self and re-establishing the sense of self-continuity beyond the dissociation, conceptualized in terms of lack of integration and synchronization between the different layers of the self (Scalabrini et al., 2020), may primarily require one to re-establish or re-organize the topography and dynamic of the nested hierarchy of self and its brain through spatial and synchronic means. Thus, the therapist needs to synchronize (virtually or symbolically) her/his larger (spatial-topographic and temporal-dynamic) scales of her/his nested hierarchy of self to the more restricted of his/her patient self. These intersubjective synchrony require an authentic response finely matched to the momentary local situation to provide the client with the opportunity to intra-subjectively integrate and nest her/his own more restricted spatiotemporal scales into the larger ones of her/his therapist. This mechanism involves the intricate process of aligning the different aspects of intrasubjective and intersubjective synchronization within intero-exteroceptive and extero-proprioceptive self of both the psychotherapist and the patient. Every individual possesses an intrinsic rhythm, such as our heartbeat or breathing pattern, that is shaped by the relational alignment with the world since infancy (Trevarthen, 1993; Trevarthen & Aitken, 2001; Atzil et al., 2018, Feldman, 2007). This synchronization process can lead to entrainment, a concept referring to how we adjust to match each other's rhythmic patterns (Hall, 1983). This tendency to synchronization holds a crucial relevance in the development of the self, considering the importance of its relational dynamics with other selves (Atzil et al., 2018) that stems from mother-infant interactions (Feldman, 2007; Mucci & Scalabrini, 2021; Scalabrini, et al., 2018, 2022). In this context, psychotherapy and the psychotherapist act as facilitators in triggering a re-organization at the neuronal and psychological-emotional level in the patient through the regulation of the space and time of the therapeutic interpersonal relationship. The patient's altered emotional states are nurtured by a rhythmic oscillation between different degrees of intersubjective synchronization with the therapist. This dynamic allows for the reorganization of these emotions within a safe interpersonal temporal and spatial framework, offering a renewed perspective on the physical sensations associated with the intero-exteroceptive self. Furthermore, it reaches beyond a technical, neutral response and becomes a specific fit to a specific situation. These moments have been lived through together. That, in turn, will create the basis of a “psycho-physiological secure baseline” (refer to Northoff, 2016; Northoff et al., 2022; Scalabrini et al., 2022) to maintain a continuous and temporally extended and integrated sense of self and sense of relatedness that will allow the client to process the traumatic input relationships in a non-threatening and non-disrupting way for her/his own self way without becoming fragmented or dissociated. This result in a re-organization of the border between order and chaos, of coherence and complexity. The therapist and the patient have created an expanded intersubjective field that opens up new possibilities of ways of being with one another. We propose to use temporo-spatial coordinates in the psychotherapeutic setting to work within the transference-countertransference matrix of the therapist-patient dyad. Working through synchrony, space, self-relatedness, and affective regulation might provide a more comprehensive, basic, and extensive operating field that also embeds and contains affective, social, cognitive functions within a larger more comprehensive context. This process aims to shape the temporal dynamic flow of the patient’s neural and psychic activities to re-organize the traumatized self and consequently change the patient’s baseline organization of the self and its spontaneous psychic and neuronal activities (Northoff and Panksepp, 2008; Scalabrini et al., 2018, 2022; Mucci, 2021a,b; Northoff et al., 2022). From • Scalabrini, A., Mucci, C., & Northoff, G. (2022). The nested hierarchy of self and its trauma: In search for a synchronic dynamic and topographical re-organization. Frontiers in human neuroscience, 16, 980353. • Lucherini Angeletti, L., Scalabrini, A., Galassi, F., Northoff, G. (2024). The Relational Self in Psychotherapy: Intersubjective and Intrasubjective Synchrony in Interpersonal Space. In Shapiro, Y. (eds). Psychodynamic Psychotherapy: A Global Perspective (In press), Nova Science. Andrea Scalabrini, Lorenzo Lucherini Angeletti & Georg Northoff

Its a very grey area you can't just say its real or not, black and white, like the poeple it affects it depends on each individual case. Admittedly some people will use it as a scam but others are genuinely suffering because society expects too much from them.

Where did he get paper to write a book 9 days after "liberation?" He starts his book with an admission, "THIS BOOK DOES NOT claim to be an account of facts and events...."

17:50 should be "unconditional positive regard."

It's a kind of stupidity.

No medical science! 100 %!!!

100% agree with this. I think mental illness is a perfectly normal and expected reaction to trauma caused by parents and other narcissists, and stress cause by a society run by narcissists. I have seen the effects of childhood trauma on my siblings from by two narcissistic parents. I was the oldest of six and escaped with a pleaser, fixer mentality. I married a narcissist. That was my suffering but my other siblings had it much worse. The youngest two in particular - one who was utterly neglected as a child was bi polar and died last year aged 45 and the other is an alcoholic, borderline and has had a hard time all her life. ALL mental issues are caused by environment. No one will ever persuade me otherwise.

Hypothesis, not theory. This just makes willfully ignorant people say ignorant things. Sorry but it's real.