Gabriel Gatica
Gabriel Gatica
  • Видео 1
  • Просмотров 25 898
[REUPLOAD] [NOTHING FROM THIS VIDEO IS BY ME] Rewriting the Entire Star Wars Prequel Trilogy
This video was made by Cardinal West and reuploaded by me.
Cardinal West channel link:
ruclips.net/channel/UCC2_pJ7v2O7nEaBEmL9XeYg
Original description:
I must say this is here sooner than I expected.
If you would like to see more content from me in the future (and have the means to do so), I would be most appreciative if you supported me on Patreon - every little bit helps:
www.patreon.com/cardinalwest
If you enjoyed this video, you may also like some of my recent work:
The Animal ‘Game of Thrones’ You (Probably) Never Knew About - The Animals of Farthing Wood:
ruclips.net/video/B_lbofTRG7g/видео.html
I Recut The Hobbit Trilogy into One Movie (And You Can Watch It):
ruclips.net/video/XB6h9uCAZmI...
Просмотров: 25 906

Видео

Комментарии

  • @anjetto1
    @anjetto1 7 дней назад

    Greedy bankers would NEVER try to overthrow democracy.... Also, crazy call with the whole "brexit was good" take

  • @kudosbudo
    @kudosbudo 8 дней назад

    5:19 this scene is a crime, the reason being there is a really good fight scene in there marred by maybe two section. its easily one of the best fight scenes for its visuals but it has a major flaw in the intro and a missing knife in the end which ruin it. everything else in between is amazingly shot, spaced edited and cut together. im a snob for fight scenes though, grew up on jacky chan so most 0f the other star wars fights scenes dont hold up in terms of grabbing my eyeballs haha. the prequel scenes are often boring.

    • @kudosbudo
      @kudosbudo 8 дней назад

      oh no is every cut away gonna be sequel hate? oh well another mauler wannabe...im out.

  • @superslimjim6483
    @superslimjim6483 Месяц назад

    So you are telling me Anakin lived at the Lars homestead his entire life, and when he was Vader he never once returned? Plot hole.

  • @clonetrooper2003
    @clonetrooper2003 Месяц назад

    Alright…….even i gotta admit……this was good

  • @BruceParker-nc6of
    @BruceParker-nc6of Месяц назад

    Palpy didn't say "Do it!!!"

  • @chiara_pros1297
    @chiara_pros1297 Месяц назад

    I'm not convinced about Anakin being a moisture farmer, i feel like having him being a scavenger would be more in line with his skills in engineering

  • @ethangonzalez8904
    @ethangonzalez8904 5 месяцев назад

    Can you imagine if the Inquisitorious was originally founded by the Jedi to look for the Dark Lord of the Sith? The Empire then continues the institution as an arm of their covert "Dark Jedi," aka inquisitors

  • @jessiehubick961
    @jessiehubick961 5 месяцев назад

    Incredible. Thank you.

  • @daytimefern8895
    @daytimefern8895 6 месяцев назад

    The second movie he barly changed anything

  • @CTSmerv
    @CTSmerv 6 месяцев назад

    My first only criticism is still having Anakin be the one to build C3P0. My impressions of him as a character was that C3P0 had always been a standard protocol droid for the elite. It would possibly be better to have him originally belonging to Bale Organa, and later Leia. That way, his adventures start later, possibly with Leia, giving his pessimism to adventure more weight from episode 4 and on. It would also better close the plothole of why he doesn't recognize the Lars farm or Tatooine at all (unless youd plan on having his memory wiped).

  • @RobertDownySenior
    @RobertDownySenior 7 месяцев назад

    33:32 I left off here

  • @RobertDownySenior
    @RobertDownySenior 7 месяцев назад

    Here 21:00

  • @notapplicable1296
    @notapplicable1296 8 месяцев назад

    1:30:00

  • @sadclownjoin5021
    @sadclownjoin5021 8 месяцев назад

    Good shit dude

  • @forcecaptainoverlordsuprem2964
    @forcecaptainoverlordsuprem2964 8 месяцев назад

    Honestly I feel like he barely changed revenge of the sith

  • @EllyJelly23.
    @EllyJelly23. 9 месяцев назад

    watched this video through out the whole day. very great

  • @CC-ww8zg
    @CC-ww8zg 9 месяцев назад

    WOW! Amazing video. I'm going to go rewatch it rn 10/10

  • @gabrielhbosse6030
    @gabrielhbosse6030 9 месяцев назад

    How long is the time gap between this version of Episode 1 and Episode 2

    • @clonetrooper2003
      @clonetrooper2003 9 месяцев назад

      Probably a few years

    • @PiotrekDuncan7885
      @PiotrekDuncan7885 9 месяцев назад

      I think three to five years. think it would be best for Anakin to start his adventure at the age of 15/16.

    • @Perke2King
      @Perke2King 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@PiotrekDuncan7885I say three years.

    • @Perke2King
      @Perke2King 8 месяцев назад

      ​​@@PiotrekDuncan7885Anakin is 15 in Episode 1, 18 in Episode 2, and 23 in Episode 3. Obi-Wan Kenobi is 25 to 33 years old in Episode 1 to 3. Padme is the same age as Anakin.

    • @ayaankhan-eh1xy
      @ayaankhan-eh1xy 2 месяца назад

      @@Perke2King I think Padme is a year younger like she was in Episode 1 of George

  • @beefmalone
    @beefmalone 9 месяцев назад

    This was going well until the battle between Yoda and Palpatine. No reason to take his Force Lightning power away and have him lose because of weakness. I'd prefer him to only get beat through some type of cheating or underhanded means. Anyway, good job overall.

  • @PiotrekDuncan7885
    @PiotrekDuncan7885 10 месяцев назад

    This is, in my opinion, the best remake of the prequels I've ever seen. it perfectly shows that the script of these films was not bad at all, it just needed proper processing. Nevertheless, I think that a few minor modifications could be useful. For example: - the thread of the conflict between the Trade Federation and Naboo could be a cover for the real goal of taking over scientific secrets regarding cloning. It could be established that Naboo Scientists are working with the Kaminoans in the development of the Cloning process, and Palpatine and the Federation are interested in learning these secrets. - This would give us better motivation to set off on a rescue mission with a small team instead of waiting for the republic to act. It would also allow us to better announce the topic of clones that will be introduced later in the film. - Separatists should also use a clone army. This would provide a better basis for calling this conflict the Clone Wars. I'm guessing that Lukas introduced an army of robots so that the main characters wouldn't look like mass murderers (possibly he didn't want a repeat of the dispute over the morality of Luke's destruction of the Death Star), but it can be solved in a simple way. Separatist clones are not sentient entities, but merely zombie-style empty shells controlled by those parasitic worms that we saw in the Star Wars the Clone Wars animation. They could have been specially cloned from some predatory animals.I was thinking about something like Terror Troopers from Star Wars The Force Unleashed II. - I would remove the plot of Count Dooku as a Sith Lord. If Dooku was just a former Jedi forced to make a pact with the Devil, not willingly but out of necessity, aware that if he refused, Palpatine would replace him with his loyal servant and ruin the hopes of the separatists for a better future. This would help build a more ambiguous antagonist and introduce more gray morality. it would also have one more positive. without any extensive contact with the topic of the Sith, Anakin could definitely look more favorably on cooperation with Palpatine because, knowing the image of the Sith from the Jedi teachings, he would have less reason to question the nature and intentions of the Chancellor. In such a situation, it would be enough to establish that Palpatine has his agents on the Confederate council to guard Dooku and when he, Grievous and the rest of the most important Confederate leaders die on Mustafar, one of the council members who was not there will order the surrender of the separatists. -I would divide the roles of the assassin sent against Padme and the DNA donor/trainer for the republic's army. It seems weak to me that Obi Wan comes to Kamino for a simple inspection of the army and, coincidentally, a person hired to assassinate an important senator of the Republic is working on its formation, and he is also present at the moment. I would suggest that Jango fett was a mercenary employed by Palpatine and I would entrust the investigation and subsequent tracking down to Maca Windu. In this way, he could be given a larger role in the story and the basis for the antagonism between Windu and Anakin could be built, which would later translate into their behavior in Episode 3. However, Obi wan, instead of Yoda, could appear at the head of the Clone Army. - While I consider getting rid of the chosen one's theme to be a bonus - Lucas never delved into this topic and it caused quite a stir. So depriving Anakin of his past as a slave is already a disadvantage. This could be resolved by establishing that Anakin's father died saving his son from slavers and replacing the desert people with a criminal cartel that kidnapped Anakin's mother in order to force the Larses to pay off their debts. In this way, it would preserve the element of young Skywalker's difficult childhood and establish his resentment towards the half-witness of the crime, making his support for Palpatine's authoritarian solutions more understandable. - the last change is that I would suggest that the person who would convince the Jedi council to accept Anakin for training would be Dooku. His sympathy for the young Padawan in his first months of training would have given Skywalker more conflict when Dooku was beheaded. From such smaller modifications *the introduction of the character of Owen Lars as a member of the crew of a Republic ship that was supposed to take the Jedi to Naboo could have been good. He could help our heroes escape from Naboo and later take part in a rescue mission. In Episode 3 he could be one of the pilots fighting on Corusant. This would allow Anakin to be removed from Tatooine, making hiding Luke there more meaningful. It would also allow for expanding the world presented (privately I would suggest Nal Huta or Dantooine) * Anakin should have built R2D2 while C3PO should have been Bail Organa's droid from the beginning. *This is more of a personal suggestion than a necessary change, but I like the idea of Anakin's mother being a healer/herbalist who may have knowledge of the Force in a different way than the Jedi. It would be interesting that local residents might perceive her as a witch because of her practices. In such a scenario, the circumstances in which Qoigon decides to accept Anakin as a shocker for training may have been based on the fear that his mother's insufficient knowledge of the Force combined with Anakin's great potential would create a dangerous combination. He might even see his mother's practices as potentially leading him to the dark side. I always liked the origins of the Skywalker family more than the chosen one. Ok, that was a long ride. Gabriel Gatica, you don't have to follow my suggestions. I know this video is by Cardinal West. I just wanted to present my point of view on some threads and create a potential discussion point.

    • @puterboy2
      @puterboy2 5 месяцев назад

      And I would have Owen and Beru be Anakin’s brother and sister in law.

  • @ryanelliott71698
    @ryanelliott71698 10 месяцев назад

    Honestly “the chosen one” is so pointless you could literally remove it with “Anakin is strong with the force” and nothing changes.

    • @Deity_devil
      @Deity_devil 10 месяцев назад

      Took that from the gold man

    • @ryanelliott71698
      @ryanelliott71698 10 месяцев назад

      @@Deity_devil lol yeah pretty much, it’s a good point nevertheless

    • @ontasbulent5709
      @ontasbulent5709 10 месяцев назад

      Well him being the chosen one adds pressure to Anakin and it gives him in his eyes entitelment like being on the council or gaining the powers to save Padme. While him being the chosen one is also the reason Qui Gon takes him in or why Palpatine has a interest in him. Its not pointless

    • @santiagobanosflores7069
      @santiagobanosflores7069 9 месяцев назад

      @@ontasbulent5709 The way the "Chosen One" concept is handled makes it pointless, because you can just as easily say that Palpatine wanted Anakin because "he is strong with the Force". The idea of Anakin being destined to destroy the Sith isn't even relevant until the ROTS, but you can easily still have that movie function with that aspect of the prophecy. All that's special about him is that he has the highest midichlorian count, which can easily still be enough for Qui-Gon to take him, but even then, the relevance of midichlorians is being increasingly rendered meaningless when compared to characters from Legends or the way Disney is handling the Force in recent shows such as Ahsoka. If you want Anakin to truly embody the idea of the "Chosen One", then at least make him unique, and different from everyone else, eg in terms of power progression to make him a true anomaly among the ranks of the Jedi. I mean, he literally was made BY the Force, but nothing about his powers ever truly represent that, and I can certainly think of at least 1 way to try to remedy that. At the end of the day, he's just some guy who could be a bit above the average Jedi. Nothing Chosen One-y about that.

    • @oilybat3269
      @oilybat3269 9 месяцев назад

      I like the stakes that it adds.

  • @thesteveruss
    @thesteveruss 10 месяцев назад

    There are only 3 SW movies. ❤

  • @davidmr11able
    @davidmr11able 10 месяцев назад

    😂😂😂😂

  • @gabrielhbosse6030
    @gabrielhbosse6030 11 месяцев назад

    In my rewrite i mixed the kashyyyk moments with the utapau plot so it would be much simpler but utapau would have a cameo during order 66

    • @RobertDownySenior
      @RobertDownySenior Месяц назад

      So is general grievous on kashyyk?

    • @gabrielhbosse6030
      @gabrielhbosse6030 Месяц назад

      @@RobertDownySenior only in my rewrite

    • @RobertDownySenior
      @RobertDownySenior Месяц назад

      @@gabrielhbosse6030 so would Obi-Wan go with Yoda then

    • @gabrielhbosse6030
      @gabrielhbosse6030 Месяц назад

      @RandomResearch57 yes along with mace, kit, saesee, luminara, eath koth, quilan vos, anakin would have the same role like in the original movie and duel would take place in a republic dreadnought called the PRIDE OF THE CORE.

    • @RobertDownySenior
      @RobertDownySenior Месяц назад

      @@gabrielhbosse6030 that sounds epic wait so who will fight palpatine

  • @FarmorP0nd13
    @FarmorP0nd13 11 месяцев назад

    OMG thank you I used to watch this vid all the time

  • @gabrielgatica2216
    @gabrielgatica2216 Год назад

    [READ THE TITLE BEFORE COMMENTING] For those of you who wonder why my reuploads of ApplePie's videos about FNaF are gone: I deleted those reuploads, and apart from deleting those videos because their presence in my channel resulted in FNaF appearing in my recommendations more often, there's another far bigger reason. Those videos didn't explain how not answering who bite victim is or why his story mattered to the rest of the series has led to FNaF lore discourse becoming worse. Scott's lack of an answer has led to the community not knowing whether Golden Freddy, a character who was in the series since the first game, was possessed by the fifth missing child, the bite victim, or both, yet her videos just ignore that problem with the statement of bite victim's story having no effect on the lore and presenting Michael being the bite victim as if it's the only common argument for bite victim's story being important (Despite how that hypothetical doesn't make sense either). From now on, i'm only gonna reupload a previously deleted video that talks about how FNaF has bad storytelling if it actually has put a lot of focus on that issue.

  • @Deity_devil
    @Deity_devil Год назад

    Didn’t the original one get takedown?

  • @TheTokkin
    @TheTokkin Год назад

    It's a pretty good rewrite, but I think the trade federation conflict is still so boring that it needs to be fleshed out better. It needs to be a better part of the overall story.

    • @vanillabryce2965
      @vanillabryce2965 Год назад

      Here is one good way to fix it: There are scientists on Naboo who have perfected a cloning formula and the trade federation wants to steal it for themselves and that’s what sets the conflict in motion and it’s further expanded upon in the sequel with the kaminoans

    • @clonetrooper2003
      @clonetrooper2003 Год назад

      I still wished it fitted with the eu

  • @vanillabryce2965
    @vanillabryce2965 Год назад

    Kathleen came and copywright claimed the og video?

    • @gabrielgatica2216
      @gabrielgatica2216 Год назад

      Considering Cardinal West mentioned that his old videos got copyright striked, maybe.

  • @oVoxxy
    @oVoxxy Год назад

    Thank you god tier man