- Видео 2
- Просмотров 306 245
Jean Rohrer
Добавлен 29 сен 2011
Court reporter versus digital recording or voice recognition.
Why court reporters cannot be replaced with digital recordings or voice recognition. How the court reporting machine works. Why an "old fashioned" court reporter instead of electronic recording.
Просмотров: 37 730
Видео
Court Reporting How it Works
Просмотров 269 тыс.12 лет назад
How the court reporting machine, stenotype, stenograph machine works, that the court reporter, stenographer, uses.
Hey Jean. This is Sandra. I've been trying to reach you.
Explained well Pamela in Detroit 2024
This reminds me of the Matrix when they are looking at the code on the screen and somehow they can see what's happening in the Matrix.
Oh, girl. You make this look SOOO much easier than it is. That 30+ years of experience shows through. Impressive in both action and content. I started learning 40 years ago when it was still the paper tape machine but pregnancy interrupted that. Now, I'm trying again at almost 70, as a bucket list item. LOL!
Hi Chapped. Thank you for your comment. Do you live in Florida? There is plenty of freelance work here. The average age of a stenographer is 61, so you're a spring chicken!
As somebody who does sound in the video. Yes cut corners will just throw a microphone and a camera on it we're done and then you have the camera on the other side of the room and the microphone on the floor. I think there's a place for both as back ups but nobody would want to pay double. The number of scenarios and times I've heard somebody say or act like oh yeah you have a stereo you know how to do sound.....
I think courtrooms are designed to massage the egos of judges and attorneys. They are not designed for good audio or video recording. There is lots of wood and metal, the placement of the participants doesn't work well. When we get more interested in properly recording what happens in a courtroom, then we should see more justice. More and more, our justice system is being exposed as a joke.
dislike for the dead cat (kidding) like
Hahahaha, the Super Bowel party! We've all been there.
LOL
I find this fascinating. I think you are a magician 😊
Lol
Oi Teachers leave them KINGDOM KIDS ALONE!!! 🐍🦎🎅 🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥🦥 You can have the Nazis and punish them Nazis and their familys they are ALL WICKED LIKE THEIR ANCESTORS AND THEIR NEXT GENERATION IS SHOWING CLEARLY NAZIS CAN NOT COPE WITH THD PRESSURE THEY ARE UNDER TO TAKE THE DRUGS WORLD GOVERNMENT GAVE THEM TO TAKE TO ACCOMPLISH WORLD MISSION!!! NAZIS YOU WILL BE PUNISHED FOR EVERYTHING YOUR ANCESTORS DONE. 👩⚖️🧑⚖️👨⚖️ 👸🤴🦁
Humans.. you have to OUTSMART, OUTWIT AND OUT PLAY!!!🦁🤴👸👨⚖️🧑⚖️👩⚖️🥇👍 their🦎🐍🎅🧙🧙♀️ Systems y'all are in. Activate your Yhwh DNA easy as. Faith in ACTION 🌬️🏰 Fruits of the Holy Spirit 🕊️ TRUTH bring the (wicked🐍🦎🎅and their Lies) into the LIGHT🕯️ so it loses its POWER!!! Life Instructions. Bible. Prayer. Faith in Action.
👍👸🤴👑👋🤣 I'm the typist for GODS KINGDOM COURT 👩⚖️🧑⚖️👨⚖️🦁🤴👸👑🏰🌬️
I’ve worked with steno writers, mask writers, and pitman writers. They were all amazing reporters. Voice reporters work with CAT software and have the same training as steno writers. Don’t forget, closed captioners can’t ask the speakers to repeat and slow down; it has its challenges. I’d be afraid to closed captioning, not having the ability to ask a speaker to slow down or repeat something. Voice recognition has improved a lot overtime. I’m a steno writer and I believe that VR will put all forms of court reporting out of work one day. Just my opinion
When do you think VR will take over? How far from now?
I think it will be a slow process and happen little by little. Maybe ten years.
Why not just record,,?
Court Reporter versus digital recording or voice recognition - see this video.
this should be universal keyboard system. why it isn't?
you mean a QWERTY keyboard? You could not keep up.
@@CourtReporting3 you can't even talk! are you alcoholic?
Wow, that's amazing 👍🏽
Thank you!
Holy crap. Court would be all done and I'd still be figuring out how to turn the machine on. 😳
HAHAHA
I was trying to learn but I'm sorry I hear alot of chewing
Sorry about that. This video was originally supposed to be a practice!
What is being chewed in her mouth in this video is distracting and makes it hard to listen.
None of this makes any sense? Why was this bizarre alphabet adopted??
TK for the D sound, really? None of it makes sense.
Why is she wearing those things on her hands
Just to cover my hands so you don't have to see them.
I just can’t believe that people can do this. People speak so quickly sometimes. Starting sentences, stopping, starting again. Another person talks at the same time or close to that. You also have to indicate _who_ is saying what. Multiple attorneys, the judge, the witness, clerk too, maybe. I just don’t understand how you can keep up with everything and type it out accurately. Yet those of you that do it are remarkably accurate. Mind blown🤯
Yes, it can be very difficult!
15:08…..she’s so right! There’s no room in the courthouse to cut corners. When there are plenty of people who have studied this AWESOME work and people like her who want to report it correctly. Like she said there was someone who was very soft spoken and had an accent and what if someone went to prison for life because something wasn’t recorded properly in court and no one could agree on what was said and trying to cut corners and use technology instead of PEOPLE…..like we should….messed it all up Too many people have lost employment due to technology….and she clearly show us that voice recognition is the best route in the court system!! Siri can’t understand everything….PERIOD
Great video and very informative. Wondered how those work. This is more like playing an instrument than just simple typing. How do mistakes get corrected? Especially if you have to keep up with what is said. I imagine they just get fixed later by the reporter in a review process after the talking is done/during breaks/etc..
In depositions there is an errata sheet attached to the end of the transcript. The witness has the opportunity to correct or change anything they wish to.
Wow!! There is so much to learn!!
Whitchcraft, no other explanation
Many years of blood, sweat and tears.
Wow, this is fascinating, Thank you. So complex, you're very clever xxx
My head hurts just thinking about it. Truly impressive.
Thank you!
This show was interesting and entertaining to watch. This show brought to me a closeup view of a stenotype machine. As a keyboard specialist who is able to work on any machine with a typewriter-like keyboard, your show fulfilled my curiosities about the stenotype keyboard. I definitely agree with you no matter how computers and electronic technology may advance, a person cannot be replaced by those things and objects. No matter what the critics may tell you, without a person to man the machine, it will just not work, period.
Well said!
@@CourtReporting3 Thank you for tapping or typing to me. I wish you "Happy Keyboarding!"
I love the hand covers. Where did you get those?
I found them on ebay. They're like gloves.
I'm curious, what college courses would somebody have to study in order to become a court typist?
There are court reporting online schools. We are in high demand, so I highly recommend learning the skill! As far as college courses, I'm not sure what to tell you. The larger your vocabulary, the better. It takes tons of determination to obtain the skill. You must be highly dependable and organized.
Maaaad respect! Never knew this was so complicated, yet seems so simple as you are writing.
Thank you so much. 33 years of blood, sweat and tears.
Wow!! Pamela in Detroit
can you still type on a normal keyboard? or do you have to use your steno keyboard
I can still type on a normal keyboard. The keyboards are so different I don't get them confused.
Why dont they just record the session and assign someone after the session is finished?
Sometimes they do, but the transcript is not as accurate. When someone does not speak up or speak clearly, a reporter can ask them to repeat. If someone does not speak up or speak clearly on a digital recording, the record is lost forever.
Wow your finger Movement, very smooth. Pamela in Detroit
Thank you!
I was impressed before, now I am even more impressed. The level of dedication to master this is equivalent to learning a musical instrument. Respect!
Thank you!
There are some jobs that are just not made for everyone. I'm so confused. She lost me at hello. lol
LOL!
So you convert spoken english (including probably regional accents and english-second-language accents) to steino "code", to very specific button presses, to high-legalise written English. With very little error. AT NORMAL AND QUICK TALKING SPEEDS. You really cannot possibly understand how impressive and mind-blowing this is to me at this very moment. Like, how do you even realize you're capable of such a talent?!
Thank you so much for your comment. I went to court reporting school right out of high school and frankly had no idea how difficult court reporting is. There is a 90 percent drop-out rate in school. Somehow I had the dedication it requires. Honestly, I have zero talent for this. It's just been 33 years of blood, sweat and tears.
It's years of school and exams
Thank you for all that you do, and helping to provide a fair trial for people.
Aww. So Sweet. Thank you.
Thank you for what you do and for giving us a peek at your profession and livelihood! I appreciate it, sincerely! It was very informative and I have an all new appreciation for court reporters and transcriptionists.
My pleasure.
This is a great video, but using Siri as an example for Speech Recognition software is just misleading. Siri is not "voice recognition". Siri is looking for specific commands, and is not designed to transcribe audio. A specifically tailored piece of machine learning software to be used in a courtroom is drastically different, and very powerful. I have nothing but respect for court reporters, and I do not want "robots" as it were to replace their jobs. However, stating that it will never happen is just false. I work in film, and we are capable of mass transcribing hours of film very quickly using a technology similar to what I mentioned above, with a <1% error rate. Now, I'm an outsider looking in - like I said, I work in film, not court reporting. However, I do believe that it will be possible to replace court reporters with voice recognition in the very near future.
Side note: I do believe that there are applications where it is better to have a human do it, again, not arguing against it - I think court reporters should still be doing this.
Thank you for your input.
"we are capable of mass transcribing hours of film very quickly using a technology similar to what I mentioned above, with a <1% error rate. " That might work with the speakers on the screen, I guess it would be called "Closed Captioning". What the legal field needs is speaker diarization, where the speakers are identified and what they say is segmented. Whatever you are using in film does not do that. The technology is getting closer but we aren't there yet. Additionally that "<1% error rate" still has to be accounted for and corrected. This isn't entertainment, it's court proceedings that have a huge impact on peoples' lives.
Interesting, thank you for the video.
Glad you liked it!
Thank you for your service.
Much appreciated
Can you recommend a program that teaches this?
I have met and I really like Mark Kislingbury as a human being but I honestly have zero experience with court reporting schools. I wish I could be of more help.
I thought they use a normal keyboard. This is very impressive.
Thank you.
sus
Not sure what SUS is. LOL
This is so mesmerizing to watch. Stenographers are under appreciated!
Thank you!
Honestly, watching the demo at the end truly makes it look like a super power. I have no doubt it comes from years of training and then years of experience, but she made it look so effortless.
Yes, that's 30 years of blood, sweat and tears. But thank you!
@@CourtReporting3 Even with the fact its less inputs to input the words. The fact that someone of that age and female can translate stimuli to input so many dynamic combinations that quickly and accurately makes me feel even worse that in esports and gaming older people and females are treated as if they are less capable or not capable at all. Still really nice to see though. Its something to share with people as an example.
I definitely appreciate more the skill of court reporters now that I have been proofreading for them. It's amazing what you all do.
Now i can die peacefully. I saw steno engine for both gherkin and butterstick keyboards. But wondered how does it look in real life not on paper.
Wow. Never heard of gherkin or butterstick. I better add those words to my database!